US State Department report on human-rights practices devotes 24,000 words to Israel

It also singles out certain countries and their behavior, including egregious antisemitism, anti-Israel hatred and Holocaust denial in Iran.

By JNS Staff

The U.S. State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor released the 2022 edition of its annual Country Reports on Human Rights Practices on Monday. The reports “cover internationally recognized individual, civil, political and worker rights, as set forth in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and other international agreements,” stated Foggy Bottom.

“The report embodies the importance of human rights for American diplomacy and for our vision of an open, free, prosperous and secure world,” Antony Blinken, U.S. secretary of state, said in a press conference on Monday. “Human rights are universal. They aren’t defined by any one country, philosophy or region. They apply to everyone, everywhere.”

The report makes clear that there was a “backsliding in human rights conditions—the closing of civic space, disrespect for fundamental human dignity” in 2022, according to Blinken, who said the report does not aim to lecture nor shame.

“Rather, it is to provide a resource for those individuals working around the world to safeguard and uphold human dignity when it’s under threat in so many ways,” he said. “And while this report looks outward to countries around the world, we know the United States faces its own set of challenges on human rights.

In his remarks, Blinken singled out the “appalling and ongoing abuses” of the Iranian regime, the Taliban’s “relentless” discrimination against women and girls in Afghanistan, the erosion of human rights in Burma, “genocide and crimes against humanity against Uyghurs” in China, as well as offenses in Cuba, Nicaragua and Ethiopia. He addressed “calculated and deliberate” offenses in Ethiopia at some length.

‘We’re not pulling our punches with anyone’

One of three questions from reports who were present focused on Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Israel.

“What would your response be to those that would say despite the contents of the report and despite all of the work that goes into it, that the issues that are flagged are not sufficiently influencing policymaking, especially when it comes to countries where it is harder for the United States to have those tough discussions on human rights, like Egypt and Saudi Arabia and Israel?” the reporter asked.

The report devotes nearly 23,992 words—about 50 pages, single-spaced, in a standard word processing format—to Israel, West Bank and Gaza.

“We have those tough discussions across the board with friends, adversaries, competitors alike,” said the secretary of state. “We’re not pulling our punches with anyone. We call things as we see them. Sometimes, we do it more publicly; sometimes, we do it more privately.”

Among other things, the report notes of Israel that Israeli Security Agency forces, which fall under the Israel Defense Forces and operate in the West Bank, were the subject of reports of abuses. It added that there were “significant human rights issues,” including “credible” reports of “unlawful or arbitrary killings,” “arbitrary or unjust detention, including of Palestinians in Israel and the occupied territories” and “punishment of family members for alleged offenses by a relative.”

Of Iran, the report noted that “according to media reports, officials and media propagated conspiracy theories blaming Jews and Israel for the spread of COVID-19. According to NGO reports, school textbooks contained content that incited hatred against Jews as part of the state curricula for history, religion and social studies.”

It added that the approximately 9,000 Jews who live in Iran, according to the Tehran Jewish Committee, “were reportedly subjected to government restrictions and discrimination. Government officials, including the supreme leader, president and other top officials, routinely engaged in egregious antisemitic rhetoric and Holocaust denial and distortion.”

“In January, Iran was the only country to object to a U.N. resolution condemning denial and distortion of the Holocaust,” it added.

“Supreme Leader [Ali] Khameini’s social media accounts repeatedly contained antisemitic attacks and tropes. State-run media routinely claimed ‘Zionists’ influenced Western nations on topics affecting Iran and blamed ‘Zionists,’ among others, for widespread protests following the death of Mahsa Amini in September.  The Jewish community in Tehran warned persons on Telegram not to visit synagogues during the high holidays ‘due to the dangerous situation.’”

The post US State Department report on human-rights practices devotes 24,000 words to Israel appeared first on World Israel News.

Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad representatives speak at University of Cape Town

South African Zionist Federation spokesperson Rolene Marks said that the event was “shameless” and promoted extremism.

By Dion J. Pierre, The Algemeiner

Representatives of Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) addressed students at University of Cape Town (UCT) via video message during an “Israeli Apartheid Week 2023” event held on Monday by the Palestine Solidarity Forum (PSF).

Images of the event, as well as advertisements for it, were obtained by The Algemeiner. PIJ representative Nasser Abu Sharif and Hamas representative Khaled Qadomi, both of whom represent their organizations in Iran, gave remarks via video, according to a flyer for the event. The student group also displayed the flags of Hamas and Hezbollah in the room where the event took place.

University of Cape Town has been asked to comment on this story. It will be updated accordingly.

On Monday, the South African Zionist Federation (SAZF) spokesperson Rolene Marks told The Algemeiner that the event was “shameless” and promoted extremism.

“Our universities should be places of rational debate and inclusive engagement, not hostile environments which encourage the dissemination of propaganda from extremist organizations such as Hamas,” Marks said. “Places of learning in South Africa must be clear on the dangers of incitement hosting speakers who would call for the discrimination, annihilation, and destruction of Jewish people, as a result of their race.”

Marks added that SAZF “condemns the PSF for encouraging the discriminatory, racist, and extremist political ideologies of Hamas and the oppressive regime of Iran on South African campuses” and called on the university to join it.

PSF has previously conducted anti-Zionist activity on campus. In 2019, it worked with the Boycott, Sanctions, Divestment–South African Coalition (SABDS) to cancel presentations by two Israeli professors at an academic conference co-hosted by the University of California-Berkeley and UCT.

In a statement posted on Twitter, PSF said it also sent UCT and the Berkeley Center an ultimatum calling for the professors to “clarify … their position on Palestine,” or otherwise for the conference to rescind the scholars’ invitations and invite Palestinian academics.

Please share and make this trend. We cannot let the #UCTLawConference have Israeli academics in attendance while their government commits apartheid and terrorism in #Palestine. The hypocrisy of @fabacademic and @UCT_news is unacceptable. #decolonization #IsraeliApartheid pic.twitter.com/Dk2S1zmq2h

— UCTPSF (@UCTPSF1) July 13, 2021

Past efforts to boycott ties to Israeli academics at the University of Cape Town have been strongly opposed. In November 2019, 68 percent of the 363 members of the UCT Senate voted down a resolution proposing that the school “not enter any formal relationships with Israeli academic institutions operating in the Occupied Palestinian Territories as well as other Israeli academic institutions enabling gross human rights violations in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.”

Two years prior, a petition calling on the school to “stand against” a boycott of Israel drew over 69,00 signatures, arguing that boycotts violate principles of academic freedom and freedom of speech.

The post Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad representatives speak at University of Cape Town appeared first on World Israel News.

Democratic senator takes Biden administration to task over backlog at US embassy in Israel

Senator demands State Department end lengthy delays at U.S. embassy in Israel, noting massive delays ahead of Passover holiday.

By World Israel News Staff

A Democratic senator is demanding that the Biden administration improve service at the U.S. embassy in Israel, ending the lengthy delays that have made it difficult for Americans living in Israel to receive basic services, including passport renewal and certification of births abroad.

Richard Blumenthal, the senior U.S. Senator for Connecticut, publicly chided the State Department, penning an open letter to Secretary of State Antony Blinken, demanding he rectify the situation at the U.S. embassy in Israel ahead of the Passover holiday.

“U.S. citizens in Israel are encountering inexplicable difficulties obtaining passports,” Blumenthal tweeted over the weekend. “These seemingly unnecessary obstacles are deeply frustrating before the Passover holiday. I am demanding that the State Department end these delays.”

Americans living in Israel have reported severe difficulties in obtaining appointments at the embassy in recent weeks, and in some cases, even refusal by embassy officials to serve those who had made appointments, citing recent changes to the embassy’s rules.

The delays have raised concerns among Americans living in Israel ahead of the Passover festival, which begins on April 5th, that citizens who need to obtain passports – especially for newborn children – will be unable to join relatives in the United States for the holiday.

“I write today with serious concerns over the apparent difficult U.S. citizens in Israel are having with obtaining appointments for passports and Consular Reports of Birth Abroad,” Blumenthal wrote to Blinken.

“These seemingly unnecessary, aggravating delays and obstacles have been particularly frustrating in advance of the upcoming Passover holiday, which is a time when U.S. citizens living in Israel often seek to travel home.”

“I am also concerned that these issues are not only affecting the U.S. Embassy in Israel and that U.S. citizens living abroad elsewhere may also be experiencing difficult in making timely appointments to obtain passports, particularly for newborn children.”

“I understand that the U.S. Embassy in Israel announced a new appointment system in early February with the goal of reducing the number of fraudulently obtained appointments. I also understand that, on March 10, the Embassy announced further changes to the new system that seemingly prevents those seeking new passports from traveling to the United States for Passover due to unknown delays.”

“The inability for U.S. citizens to schedule timely appointments and acquire a passport is simply unacceptable when people have a need for travel.”

The post Democratic senator takes Biden administration to task over backlog at US embassy in Israel appeared first on World Israel News.

SMOTRICH: Israel must explain its position to the world

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who made waves Sunday by telling a French audience that there is no such thing as a Palestinian nation, told i24News that Israel is “not doing enough” to fight terror, that it would be suicidal to establish a “terrorist state” in Judea and Samaria, and that the more Israel explains its position to the world, the more support it will get.

The post SMOTRICH: Israel must explain its position to the world appeared first on World Israel News.

WATCH: Why Trump is ‘very anxious’ about possible indictment

President Donald Trump is preparing for a possible indictment from Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg.

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis slammed Bragg on Monday when asked about the potential indictment of the former president, Fox News reported.

“The Manhattan district attorney is a Soros-funded prosecutor, and so he, like other Soros-funded prosecutors, they weaponize their office to impose a political agenda on society at the expense of the rule of law and public safety,” DeSantis said.

The post WATCH: Why Trump is ‘very anxious’ about possible indictment appeared first on World Israel News.

The protest movement can’t unravel the thread of Israel’s unique tapestry – opinion

According to a recent Direct Polls survey, the civil “unrest” is populated mainly by silver-haired boomers. You know, the ones who think they’re at Woodstock or something.

Ruthie Blum, JNS

Anybody who lives in and loves Israel is aware of its miraculously beautiful mosaic of inherent paradoxes. It’s Middle Eastern, yet Western; war-torn, yet peace-obsessed; provincial, yet cosmopolitan; frenetic, yet relaxed.

It’s religious, yet secular; conservative, yet woke; judgmental, yet empathic; marriage-oriented, yet a singles’ magnet. And it’s a bureaucratic hell, while also an entrepreneurship heaven.

Aside from all of the above, the tiny state—still young at its soon-to-be 75th birthday—is a major player on the world stage. This is both good and bad news for the Jews.

On the one hand, it means that we managed to return to our ancient homeland and make the literal and figurative desert bloom. On the other, such a miraculous success story, against all odds and surrounding enemies, comes with a price.

Indeed, as is the case with many blessings, this one often feels like a curse. The weight of responsibility—the burden of serving as a “light unto the nations”—is only part of it.

Perhaps a greater difficulty for a once-scattered nation demonized and slaughtered in the Diaspora is the realization that the “ingathering of exiles” didn’t put an end to envy-sparked antisemitism. On the contrary, what the late historian Robert Wistrich called the “longest hatred” was simply transferred to the Jewish nation-state under the cloak of “legitimate criticism.”

“Dear God, I know, I know, we are the chosen people, but once in a while, can’t you choose someone else?” cries Tevye in “Fiddler on the Roof.”

It’s not for nothing that this tragically funny line resonates with most of the tribe. Memorialized by Israeli actor Chaim Topol, whose stage-and-screen portrayal of Sholom Aleichem’s character earned him international accolades, it sums up our collective gripe in a nutshell.

Sadly, Topol died earlier this month at his home in Tel Aviv at the age of 87. Despite the political rift and mass demonstrations going on there and in other Israeli cities, prominent figures across the spectrum paid tribute to the award-winning actor.

The outpouring of appreciation was for more than his illustrious career, however. Through his performances as Tevye, the quintessential “Sabra,” who was born in Mandatory Palestine some 12 years before the establishment of the state, represented a merging of Jewish cultures—a thread connecting the tapestry of the “Old Country” to the new.

Today’s protesters against the government in Jerusalem are threatening to unravel that thread. Claims by the movement’s leaders about rescuing Israeli democracy from imminent demise are false.

The root of their rebellion really lies in an aversion to the right-wing-religious coalition and its leader, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Their placards, slogans, chants and epithets make this abundantly clear.

Unfortunately, the campaign has had an effect on many well-intentioned members of society whose familiarity with the reforms is as minimal as their concern (or gullibility) is genuine. Nor do these fellow travelers seem to grasp that nothing short of a coup will satisfy the forces trying to bring down Netanyahu and his partners.

This is precisely why the architects of the endeavor are accusing the democratically elected powers-that-be of staging one. It’s a neat trick of projection, reminiscent of Soviet-inspired Palestinian propaganda, a key element of which is charging Israel with its own crimes. Oh, and enlisting support from the international community by inverting victim and perpetrator.

Observers at home and abroad of the current crisis fear—or hope—that Israel is headed for a full-fledged civil war. Hearing members of Israel’s military and other security forces join the fray by announcing their refusal to fulfill their duties causes them to consider this a real possibility; watching thousands of Israelis march to the beat of former prime ministers and defense officials calling on foreign governments to censure Netanyahu will do that.

What the ill-wishers purposely obfuscate, and the pearl-clutchers don’t take into account, is the way in which average citizens are going about their daily lives behind the lens of TV news cameras. This is certainly true of citizens who have little interest in and no clue about how the branches of government operate. But even activists are hard to discern at supermarket check-out lines and bus stops.

Hungry and thirsty from all that demonstrating

On Thursday night, for instance, as the so-called “Day of Resistance” came to a close, every trendy restaurant, bar and nightclub in the White City was packed to the brim with millennials eating, drinking and making merry. When I pointed this out to a friend, she quipped: “All that demonstrating must have made them hungry and thirsty.”

It’s unclear, though, whether this particular crowd—munching happily on shrimp and pork—had taken part in the protests at all. In fact, according to a recent Direct Polls survey, the civil “unrest” is populated mainly by silver-haired boomers. You know, the ones who think they’re at Woodstock or something.

In a lopsided debate (what else is new?) with two left-wingers, I cited this example of the “life goes on” resilience that’s characteristic of Israelis in the face of adversity. Their response was that the people I was referring to won’t be able to be out enjoying themselves, and certainly not in non-kosher establishments, if the government clips the wings of the Supreme Court.

Sigh.

“Ok,” I said. “So, you and the rest of the protesters can try to change the situation during the next elections.”

Their humorless answer was hilarious. If the judicial reforms proceed, they argued, elections will be banned.

It was a ludicrous pronouncement that Opposition leader Yair Lapid had made several days earlier. It’s baseless hype that he and the pundits parroting him know to be nonsense.

Despite the damage they’re doing to Israel’s standing and security, the one thing they won’t be able to shake is the underlying health of a society that cares deeply about preserving Judaism, Zionism and—yes—popular culture. Faith in this unique blend, which the over-reaching judiciary has been attempting to dilute, is what the majority reasserted at the ballot box on Nov. 1.

Voters must not be bullied into forgetting it. It’s no accident, after all, that Israel just ranked No. 4 in the UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network report on world happiness.

Ruthie Blum is a Tel Aviv-based columnist and commentator. She writes and lectures on Israeli politics and culture, as well as on U.S.-Israel relations. The winner of the Louis Rappaport award for excellence in commentary, she is the author of the book “To Hell in a Handbasket: Carter, Obama, and the ‘Arab Spring.’ ”

The post The protest movement can’t unravel the thread of Israel’s unique tapestry – opinion appeared first on World Israel News.

Right-Wing Provocateurs Are Trying to Drag Australia Into War With China

Paul Keating’s fiery attacks on the AUKUS nuclear-powered submarine deal last week drew attention to Australia’s uncritical support for the US in its China containment policy. This drive for war has been years in the making.

Australian prime minister Anthony Albanese (L), US president Joe Biden (C), and British prime minister Rishi Sunak (R) hold a press conference after a trilateral meeting during the AUKUS summit on March 13, 2023 in San Diego, California. (Leon Neal / Getty Images)

Australian politics is often misleadingly described as “rancorous.” To be sure, there is no lack of ill will among the Australian political elite. But there is a near-complete absence of genuine political debate.

High-profile fights are usually either cheap point-scoring in the lead-up to elections or intraparty power grabs. On the key issues the two major parties are usually in agreement, and the media generally toes the line. The situation has been no different throughout the discussions on the AUKUS nuclear-powered submarine deal with the United States and Britain.

But the bipartisan consensus found itself caught in flagrante last week when the deal’s details were announced in San Diego. Former Labor prime minister Paul Keating, in an AUKUS-centered interview at the National Press Club, attacked his own party for entering into the deal. A head-kicker from the right-wing faction of his party, famous for slinging insults, Keating lambasted the Australian government, opposition, spy agencies, and media for adopting a policy of military containment against China. AUKUS, he argued, wastes money, peels away Australia’s sovereignty, and needlessly provokes its largest trading partner.

The effect was immediate. As the media outlets that Keating mentioned personally admonished him for being old and mean, some tentative voices from across the political spectrum began to publicly question the political, military, and economic wisdom of the AUKUS deal.

Keating’s intervention exposed some of the fault lines and tensions of Australian elite politics in the twenty-first century. It’s worth examining exactly what he accused the political establishment of, what he left out, and what any revived culture of debate needs to include if the drive to war is to be stopped.

Thucydides’s Troll

Keating has been making a version of his Press Club argument for many years now. In broad terms, the argument goes that the rise of China as a genuine economic rival took the United States by surprise. Due to a too-large sense of itself, and unable to ideologically reconcile the prospect of a multipolar world, the United States now insists on trying to maintain strategic hegemony in the Asia-Pacific region. This will not work, because the People’s Republic of China will not accept it anymore. Asia is where Australia’s economic security lies, Keating argues, and the rise of China means prosperity for the nation. Rather than attempting to prop up the Americans’ doomed endeavor, Australia should encourage them to adapt to the new reality.

This is unlikely, however, as Australia has “screwed into place the last shackle in the long chain which the Americans have laid out to contain China,” he said. It’s a handcuff tying Australia to US imperial policy for the foreseeable future, with potentially deadly consequences.

The Press Club interview threw some behind-the-scenes scandal into the mix. Australia’s foreign policy, Keating claimed, has been commandeered by “a pro-American cell,” and the government now “dances to the tune” of spy agency “provocateurs.” Not only is this extremely dangerous, he argued, but completely undemocratic. As Keating put it,

We are in the ambit of the US strategic command system. We’ve turned the place out. We don’t run the place anymore.

Cheerleading all this, he added, are pro-US media organizations like the Nine Entertainment group, Sky News, and the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) think tank.

“We’ve Turned the Place Out”

Keating argues that the AUKUS deal is just the latest step in “turning the place out.” But the previous steps require some explanation.

Australia entered into the Australia, New Zealand, and United States Security Treaty (ANZUS) in 1951 as a junior partner to the United States. It was required to back US Cold War military operations when ordered to, and in the late 1960s was compelled to host a US military surveillance facility (Pine Gap) that directs spy satellites flying over China. For its enthusiasm, Australia was rewarded by not being allowed to join high-level strategy discussions, and was privately mocked and derided by US ambassadors.

Even when prime ministers fully support the existing military alliance, the United States will brook no unpredictability.

Any time an Australian leader has even hinted at developing a degree of independence, the United States has stepped in. Gough Whitlam — who visited China as leader of the opposition in 1971 and established diplomatic relations with the People’s Republic instantly upon becoming prime minister in 1972 — was deemed a security risk to Australia and removed from office. Apart from his criticisms of US involvement in Vietnam, his main crimes were threatening to expose CIA operations in Pine Gap.

Even when prime ministers fully support the existing military alliance, the United States will brook no unpredictability. The United States also had former prime minister Kevin Rudd removed from office, despite him encouraging the country to use force against China and its own acknowledgement that he was not a “panda hugger.” His independent diplomatic efforts in the Asia-Pacific simply did not tie in smoothly enough with the Obama administration’s “pivot to Asia.” As Wikileaks files revealed, a group of Labor Party “faceless men” reporting to the US embassy conspired to remove him from office. His US-approved replacement, Julia Gillard, soon stood next to Obama and announced that US troops would be stationed in Darwin.

As a former CIA agent who helped establish Pine Gap explained in the 1970s, “so long as Australians keep electing the right people then there’ll be a stable relationship between the two countries.” Sovereignty this is not.

With Friends Like These . . .

Keating used the catchall term “provocateurs” to describe the voices pushing AUKUS. It’s worth breaking down who he means, and what role they’re playing.

The most familiar to ordinary people will be the powerful media figures preparing the ground for war. The Nine Entertainment group, and the Sydney Morning Herald in particular, came under fire from Keating for a recent hysterical campaign. The Murdoch media empire also falls squarely into this camp. Commentators from Sky News and the Australian rant and rail about China on a daily basis, and the Murdoch family just unveiled a new center for its seventy-five-year-old American Australian Association in New York City. The association’s sole function is to promote the military alliance.

Less well known is the right-wing think tank ASPI. This was founded in 2001 by the Australian Department of Defence, in order to shore up support for the various military misadventures into which the United States would soon drag Australia. ASPI is consistently anti-China, but this can sometimes come back to bite it. In 2017–18, an anti–Chinese influence witch hunt saw fifteen politicians (who were not connected with China) expelled from parliament. Soon after, ASPI lobbied for the Foreign Influence Transparency Scheme Act in an effort to counter “foreign influence” in Australian politics. After the legislation passed, however, it exposed that ASPI itself was foreign funded — by the US State Department, Japan, Taiwan, Lockheed Martin, and other multinational weapons companies. ASPI now campaigns against the scheme’s “country agnosticism” — arguing that only Chinese influence should be mandatorily reported.

Also drumming for war is the group of ex-military and intelligence personnel now serving in the Australian Parliament and other positions of power.

Also drumming for war is the group of ex-military and intelligence personnel now serving in the Australian Parliament and other positions of power. Keating singled out elite society figure and Office of National Intelligence director-general Andrew Shearer, but there are others that might be mentioned, including MPs Peter Khalil and Andrew Hastie, Senator Jim Molan (until his recent death), and Governor-General David Hurley — all of whom forged their careers in the forever wars. With the exception of Hurley, whose role requires extra diplomacy, they are deliberately provocative. Hastie and Khalil have publicly compared China to the Nazis. All argue that the United States should defend its domination of Asia.

Beyond just being inflammatory, their argument is quite weird. Shearer has called the idea of independent foreign policy a “vacuous slogan,” and said that

The national interest is our lodestar when it comes to weighing closer co-operation with our allies. But neither should we allow ourselves to be intimidated into compromising our fundamental national security choices or values through the threat of economic payback.

Similarly, Molan criticized those who highlight China’s economic boon to Australia, arguing that “the markets make us prosperous but they’ll never make us secure.” The US containment strategy, therefore, must be supported, even though

We could be dumped by the US. . . . in my view we will get very little help should there be a significant war because their hands will be full. . . . if we look at the last time we faced similar challenges, Prime Minister Churchill was more than happy to sacrifice Australia. The imperial strategy that we were subservient to was a farce.

They seem to be arguing that Australia must help the United States contain China even though the economic consequences could be dire, and the United States will probably not help Australia militarily in return. It’s hard to see what could go wrong.

These provocateurs also claim or imply that prominent sectors of Australian society — certain big businesses, universities, and some politicians — have been bought by China and are acting as either useful idiots or an actual fifth column. This accusation is no doubt what rankled Keating so badly. It hits him on two aspects of his legacy.

Firstly, it implies that he is actually in the employ of the Chinese state (he isn’t). Secondly, it suggests that his privatizations of the 1990s were a mistake. China outright owns or co-owns every major privatized port in Australia, and dominates Asian sea routes through its Ocean Alliance consortium. The provocateurs suggest that China will take advantage of this during a military confrontation.

Having Their Cake and Eating It Too

Despite veiled allusions to treachery, big business has been polite about AUKUS. A quick glance at Australia’s rich list makes it clear that most won big during the resource boom sparked by China’s industrialization in the 2000s, or are benefiting from China’s tech expansion. But they never let crises go to waste, and are hedging on future conflict with China.

Metals industry billionaire Andrew Forrest might have begged the hawks not to “poke China in the eye,” but he’s also eyeing the AUKUS submarine shipbuilding contracts, and setting up a nice little shipping empire to potentially profit from conflict in the region. The richest Australian, Gina Rinehart, who does a roaring trade with China, has pitched mining as crucial for defense. She’s also taken up some of the war hawks’ less antagonistic talking points, such as self-sufficiency in medicines. But hers is a far more complimentary kind of alarmism, claiming that

China is led by terribly intelligent people and they do see things at a further distance and more in the future than what we do.

The only top billionaire to openly side with the provocateurs is Visy’s Anthony Pratt. He cofounded Murdoch’s new anti-China center in New York last week, and reaffirmed his view that “Australia’s relationship with America is our most important, and it’s never been stronger or closer thanks to organizations like this.” Pratt’s open ANZUS patriotism, however, can be easily explained by his multibillion dollar manufacturing interests in the United States, and doesn’t speak to any wider mood among the top tier of society.

It’s important to note that for all the hype around the rise of China, the Australian economy is still deliberately intertwined with that of the United States.

It’s also important to note that for all the hype around the rise of China, the Australian economy is still deliberately intertwined with that of the United States. Total US investment in Australia is around $1 trillion, and most companies on the Australian stock exchange are dominated by US capital. For all the hawks’ talk of self-sufficiency, the US–Australia relationship keeps the junior partner from developing its manufacturing, and reliant on the importation of advanced goods such as medical instruments and civil engineering machinery from the United States.

The Last Shackle

Keating, despite his neoliberal credentials, has now positioned himself to the radical side of the Labor leadership. He has acerbically painted himself as a skillful freethinker (“I had Clinton playing the saxophone and Jiang Zemin doing karaoke”) and current prime minister Anthony Albanese as a craven sycophant (“at the kabuki show in San Diego there’s three leaders standing there but only one is paying: our bloke!”).

But in expressing his contempt for the so-called representatives of the Labor left, he admitted that as prime minister in the 1990s, he dutifully carried out US demands, saying that,

I’ve fought the left most of my life, mostly on behalf of the United States. . . . what Albanese and [Minister of Foreign Affairs Penny] Wong have done essentially is accommodated the strategic wishes of the United States uncritically. . . . We were like Bolsheviks compared to them.

It is indeed a sad indictment of the state of public debate that it took an establishment figure like Keating to provoke the barest of antiwar discussions. It’s now the job of the Left to turn this momentum into something bigger.

Consultancies Have Been the Handmaidens of Neoliberalism

During the most recent French general election, a Senate commission’s conservative president and communist rapporteur jointly attacked the “influence of consultancies on public policy” in President Emmanuel Macron’s government. That morning, as Macron was meeting voters, one yelled “McKinsey” at him until being escorted away. At the time I was in a provincial Auvergnat town, […]