St. Antonio and the Scholastics: Medieval Monks as Economists

When enumerating the images associated with capitalism, one such impression is of wealthy merchants exploiting the poor. Similarly, when moneylending is mentioned, visions of miserly Ebenezer Scrooge spring to mind. Yet surprisingly, the first thinker to produce a systematic treatise on what is today called the Science of Economics, and among the first to argue that earning profit and charging interest is not sinful, was Renaissance-era Dominican monk St. Antonio of Florence.1 

Contrary to modern notions of what it means to be a capitalist or a socialist, St. Antonio was a social economist who cared deeply for people. He realized that if unfair monopolies controlled by the rich were removed, free markets would give hard-working citizens the chance to improve their lives. In essence, he envisioned the system that, over 300 years later, would enable the United States of America to create the world’s largest middle class.

St. Antonio (1389–1459) was born Antonio Pierozzi in Florence. At age 16, he was admitted to the Dominican Order, ultimately serving as Archbishop of Florence from 1446 until his death. During this era, Florence was ruled by Cosimo de’ Medici and was one of the richest cities on Earth.2 Many economists regard Florence as the birthplace of capitalism, owing to its urbanization, industrialization, trade networks, and sizable banking sector.

St. Antonio was a member of the Scholastics, a philosophical tradition largely led by Catholic monks from Italy and Spain. From around 1150 to 1450, the Scholastics utilized a mix of Catholic, Jewish and Islamic religious principles combined with Aristotelian philosophy to conduct economic thought experiments3. The thinking of St. Antonio and similar philosophers, like St. Thomas Aquinas, was ahead of its time and broke with long-held traditions and beliefs.  

Early Christian scholars discouraged entrepreneurship because profit-seeking necessarily led to avarice. St. Antonio agreed that traders and entrepreneurs may be led to sin, but so could other professions.4 St. Antonio argued that, from a position of Christian faith, the acquisition of wealth was not intrinsically sinful so long as the money was earned honestly and not spent sinfully. To determine what constituted the honest acquisition of wealth, St. Antonio referred to the Ten Commandments and the Canonical law. Along with the Bible, he cited these two documents because they were the most widely accepted standards of morality. It was a sin to lie, steal, or cheat, and therefore contracts had to be legally enforced by the government. This would encourage people to invest money, he wrote. No one would invest in a business if they thought their investment could be stolen. What’s more, he regarded contract enforcement as one of the few areas where the government should involve itself in the economy. 

In 1776 Adam Smith, the father of modern economics, published An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, a work that changed the course of history. In it, Smith stated that the economy would work most efficiently if the government limited itself to protecting national borders, keeping public order, and upholding property rights. This is exactly what St. Antonio had outlined in his great work of 1477, Summa Theologica Moralis. 

Profits could be earned, in St. Antonio’s reckoning, if they were moderate and used to support families or help the poor5. His idea of moderate profits was that a “just price” should be charged for goods and services. But unlike modern socialists, who believe the government should decide what the just price is, St. Antonio regarded the just price as being whatever buyers and sellers arrive on without coercion. In effect, he was describing a free market where buyers and sellers are free to do business with whomever they choose.

One of his most innovative concepts was his theory of the economy as a system. Today, we call this the circular flow. In a simple yet brilliant observation, St. Antonio realized that there were two major players in the economy: firms and households. The former produces products and services, while the latter consumes them. This much had been known for centuries, but St. Antonio took this idea a step further by completing the circular flow. He recognized that firms bought inputs and raw materials to make goods and services, and that one of those inputs was labor, which is purchased from households. 

In the circular flow model, a worker receives a wage which is then used to buy groceries and clothing. The worker sells their labor to the firm, and the firm buys the labor to make goods and services, which the firm sells. The worker then receives a payment for selling their labor and uses that payment to buy other goods and services. This cycle repeats countless times per day across the world every day of human existence. This is our economy. 

Once St. Antonio completed the circle, he realized that if firms could set the price at which they sold goods and services, workers should be able to set the price at which they sold their labor. But, even more forward thinking, he believed that unions and syndicates, which forced employers to pay a certain wage, distort markets. He advocated for a free market for labor, just as there was a free market for shoes, bread or any other product. This way, workers who were more productive could command higher wages and thus get richer. It would be centuries until the circular flow diagram entered the lexicon of economics. 

St. Antonio’s philosophy regarding lending is a classic example of his melding of Christian ideals with economics. Early Christian and Islamic scholars believed that the charging of interest was prohibited by the Bible, specifically Deuteronomy 23:20. The Scholastics, however, also understood that compensation and profit were at the core of commerce. As for profit, the reason a worker does one job over another is so they can earn more. The reason a firm specializes in one product over another is so it can earn more by selling it. And that “more” is the profit. 

Consequently, if it is permissible in Christian ethics to earn a profit from working or to sell a product at profit, why would it be immoral to earn a profit on money? And here is where St. Antonio derived a whole slew of innovative economic concepts. He recognized that someone lending money had to be compensated for the risk. He also recognized that the lender has a choice, in a free market, to do what they wish with their money. Because they will invest their money into the most profitable activities, interest on a loan must be enough to compensate the lender for the next best use of his money. If you could invest your money for a 3% return or loan it out, you would have to charge at least 3% interest to compensate for the opportunity cost incurred. To this day, the concepts of opportunity cost and the time value of money are at the foundation of our modern economy. 

Today, we see a world where many wish to forget the wisdom of the past. In abandoning religious morality, they believe they will find more happiness or, in the case of socialism, more equitable outcomes. But it was by maintaining our moral values, rooted in scripture, that a system of guaranteed rights and laws which made America one of the richest and freest societies ever was established. 

When Adam Smith wrote The Wealth of Nations in 1776 and America’s Founding Fathers signed the Declaration of Independence, human beings lived in a world of limited upward mobility. Yet despite Smith’s reputation as the first expositor of economic freedom, capitalism’s theoretical underpinnings were first articulated hundreds of years earlier by St. Antonio and the Scholastics; it was these Renaissance scholars who recognized that the amelioration of poverty and creation of a fairer society could be accomplished through free markets. Though capitalism’s rise was not immediate, by the end of the 19th century, nations like the United States were so far ahead that there could be no contest. St. Antonio has been proven right beyond any shadow of a doubt.

(1)  Alexandrin, G., & Poulatis, S. S. (2001). “Social Economist: St Antonino, Bishop of Florence, 13841459.” International Journal of Social Economics, 28(5/6/7), 561–576. https://doi.org/10.1108/03068290110360830

(2)  Brown, J. A. (2019). St Antonin of Florence on Justice in Buying and Selling: Introduction, Critical Edition, and Translation [Doctoral dissertation, Centre for Medieval Studies, University of Toronto]. Toronto. 

(3) Langholm, O. (1998). The Legacy of Scholasticism in Economic Thought. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511528491

(4) Rothbard, M. N. (1975). “San Bernardino of Siena: Economics and the Entrepreneur.” Journal of Christian Reconstruction Symposium on Christian Economics, Vol. 2 (1).

(5) Caferro, W. (2020, April 30). “Premodern European capitalism, Christianity, and Florence.” Business History Review, Vol. 94, 39–72. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007680520000045

The post St. Antonio and the Scholastics: Medieval Monks as Economists appeared first on Providence.

Christian Realism as a Remedy for Polarization

Though nations are never completely inwardly harmonious, tensions over COVID-19, religious liberty, abortion, racism, climate change and refugees are increasingly tearing at the fabric of Western societies. Polarization can occur within families, among colleagues, across political and social movements as well as religious groups and within companies and organizations. Not only do politicians seem at a loss for how to address the problem, but the rhetoric they sometimes employ tends to make matters even worse. Within the resulting us-versus-them mentality, contradictions are sharpened, and the extremes become completely alienated from one another.

While polarization is hard to combat, it would be wrong to see it as fate. If anything, societies seem to be in need for more fundamental guidance when trying to confront polarization. Could Christian realism offer a remedy? We do not pretend that Christian realism prescribes direct measures for tackling polarization. Still, we suggest that Reinhold Niebuhr’s thought and life story embodies a fundamental approach that can help us address the issue sensibly. Concretely, we propose the following ten Niebuhrian imperatives.1

1. Combine idealism with realism

It was important to Niebuhr to ground his ideals for a good society in the practical: “For every tree is known by its fruit.” You can dream up all kinds of ideas, but you will also have to demonstrate that they are applicable to the world as it is today. “One of the most prolific sources of self-deception,” Niebuhr argued, was “the proclamation of great ideals and principles without any reference to their relation to the issues of the day.”2 To proclaim from one’s ivory tower what society should look like was not Niebuhr’s style. He wanted to make ideals concrete for the daily reality of people, whether they worked for Henry Ford or as soldiers. Niebuhr stretches a long rope between his high, sometimes heavenly, ideals and earthly, brutal and broken everyday reality. On the one hand, he dares to say that the sacrificial love of Christ is the example for all of us, but he also dares to connect it with the question: should we use nuclear weapons in international conflicts? Such statements did not always help his popularity, but for Niebuhr popularity was no criterion for the correctness of his views.

Many contemporary debates also involve conflicting high ideals. High ideals are good, but they ultimately must be tested for their practical effect. As soon as that happens, these ideals must become concrete and practical, which often reveals existing contradictions as not nearly so hard or absolute. People may well have more in common than they thought.

2. Beware of ideological blindness

Niebuhr lived in a time dominated by ideologies like fascism, communism and liberalism. Recognizing the negative consequences of the rise of the automotive industry under Henry Ford early in his pastoral career in Detroit, Niebuhr also became aware of the ideological blindness that can accompany free-market thinking. He later saw that blindness also reflected in communism. Ideological blindness occurs when people have come to “believe” in their own social and political views so strongly that they must realize them at all costs. They place their entire heart and soul into trying to realize their ideology in the here and now. In these polarized and heated discussions, people can become blinded by their own ideological “correctness.” It is important that people are aware of their capacity for self-deception as they pursue their ideals.

3. Be self-critical

This is partly related to the previous imperative. After all, how can you be sure that you are not ideologically blind yourself? An essential characteristic of ideology is blindness to your own blindness. By reading Karl Marx and other “masters of suspicion,” Niebuhr learned to approach good intentions with healthy mistrust. Niebuhr was acutely aware that his own thoughts and actions could be the product of the social privilege he enjoyed or the interests he sought to defend. Being self-critical was his way of coping with this problem. For him, self-criticism was also the hallmark of true religion. A worldview or religion which lacks self-criticism is intrinsically dangerous because it threatens to devolve into an ideology; an ideology being a closed system of assumptions that cannot be altered in accordance with changing facts on the ground. Thus, for Niebuhr, humility was indispensable for the sake of self-criticism. 

Niebuhr was not only critical of his own thinking, but also of America and its self-image. Time and again, he held up the mirror to his own nation: in all their philosophical pursuits, they all too easily believed that they were on the right side of history, no longer recognizing their own foibles. Niebuhr considered it his task to keep pointing this out; to keep on “speaking truth to power.” Niebuhr was aware that human reason can easily be the vehicle for the passions and the will. In other words, one can argue a case very rationally while what ultimately determines one’s conclusion is not rational itself. If people were more self-critical, they would not so easy demonize others. Indeed, they would be more prone to recognize flaws in themselves if they allowed others to hold up the critical mirror.

4. Acknowledge the presence of evil in yourself as well as in others

Niebuhr was, more than anyone else, aware of the human propensity for evil. At the same time, he also had high expectations for man’s creative potential. He only noticed his idealism and attempts to understand social issues were insufficient if he did not simultaneously consider the view that evil is ingrained in man. This Christian notion was the great equalizer for him. The fact that all have the capacity for great evil as well as good ensures none can be considered morally elevated; doing so could already be a sign or cause of evil. If you consider yourself better than those you disagree with, evil is already creeping in. That in the end we all inevitably get our hands dirty by doing more or less evil should make us humble in the face of the evil other people do or cause. This does not equate to morally equivocating, but rather that we should always judge others with our own fallenness in mind.

5. Dare to distinguish between greater and lesser evil

Niebuhr warned against issuing moral judgments from comfortable, safe positions where the consequences of those judgments are ultimately only theoretical, not material, for the judgers.  All difficult choices between good and evil are not black or white. Human beings are actually constantly concerned with how to avoid evil by choosing the lesser of two evils. This necessitates action over inaction when acting will lead to failure but inaction will lead to yet even worse tragedy. Niebuhr offers tools for those situations by distinguishing between the bad and the worse. For example, how can the idea of forgiveness and grace provide room for action when it inevitably involves failure? And are there not degrees of wrong behavior? An opponent is not necessarily the ultimate evil, although they can certainly act morally wrongly.

6. Recognize elements of truth in the views of others

For Niebuhr, it was paramount that most of the people he disagreed with represented at least some truth. For him, this was related to the idea that his interlocutors had something to say as fellow human beings. This made Niebuhr not only open and curious toward others, but also involved. This way he could disagree with pacifists yet give them credit for the elements of truth in their position. A possible consequence of Niebuhr’s openness was that, in many areas, his thinking is a synthesis of the thoughts of others. Since he also dealt with many subjects, there is something of interest in Niebuhr for everyone. Admittedly, the disadvantage of this is that very different people have considered him one of their own: conservatives, Christian socialists or Christian revolutionaries and liberals. Yet, recognizing elements of truth in the positions of others is something that can help counter polarization.

7. Acknowledge the complexity and mystery of human nature

Niebuhr has become known, among other things, for his anthropology, which he elaborated in the two volumes of The Nature and Destiny of Man. His view of humanity goes far beyond the simple statement that “most people are good,” as Dutch author Rutger Bregman argues in his bestseller Humankind: A Hopeful History.3 Niebuhr’s image of human beings is rich because of the way he values humans; that is why his vision of humanity is broadly appealing. On the one hand, he recognizes that humans can rise to great heights in their strivings and creativity. On the other, he shows how much evil man is capable of and can surrender to. The creative and destructive tendencies of people both have a place in Niebuhr’s thinking; they are often intertwined and human motives are therefore mixed. This saves Niebuhr from one-sided assumptions about human behavior and superficial explanations of social issues. Human beings are complex, which is why social issues and their solutions are too. Even a little of this thinking makes all too superficial schemes and interpretations of social issues impossible. The acknowledgment of this fact also helps to prevent a polarized worldview.

8. Avoid moralism

Recognizing the irony of history, as well as the complexities of evil and of human nature, Niebuhr was critical of attitudes of “moralism.” Moralism is lecturing others on the basis of an imagined superiority, which differs from making a moral judgment as such. The latter was precisely what Niebuhr tried to do. He wanted to discern what was at stake and sometimes felt he had to voice a strong opinion on political matters or even condemn certain policies. However, because he knew how complex evil was and what his own part in it could be, reacting moralistically was out of the question for him. A good recent example of this is how Barack Obama, when still a presidential candidate, reacted to radical statements by his former pastor Jeremiah Wright: “That anger is not always productive; indeed, all too often it distracts attention from solving real problems; it keeps us from squarely facing our own complicity within the African-American community in our condition. (..) We can dismiss Reverend Wright as a crank or a demagogue. (…) We would be making the same mistake that Reverend Wright made in his offending sermons about America – to simplify and stereotype and amplify the negative to the point that it distorts reality.”4 In polarized debates, moralism can be an obstacle, because it suggests that one side should be allowed to condemn the other side based on its own moral superiority.

9. Communicate in a language comprehensible to others

Niebuhr was a theologian and philosopher. Still, with his analyses, he has managed to appeal to a wide audience to this day. This is partly because Niebuhr succeeded, as Habermas calls it, in meeting the “translation requirement.”5 This means that you make an effort to convert your ideas into words and ideas that are understandable to other persons and perhaps even convincing to them. Niebuhr was really successful in this regard. Although he was a theologian, there were also many non-Christians who were attracted by his ideas, calling themselves “atheists for Niebuhr.” If you do not communicate in a way that is understandable to others, you will stay in your own bubble, without being able to reach the other person – which is precisely what reinforces polarization.

10. Be open to the possibility of having to adjust your opinions

In his reflections, Niebuhr focused on everyday reality without making his thinking dependent on it. He considered it essential to examine his own stance and viewpoints. Do they match with reality? Do they lead to a better world? If not, their assumptions may not be correct. At the same time, he also dared to come up with ideas based on Scripture and the Christian tradition, because they contain eternal truths about mankind, history, and ethics. Examining ideas because the empirical reality “contradicts” you is not only something that scholars are trained to do, but also something that ordinary people, believers or non-believers, should practice. Otherwise, one becomes dogmatic and rigid, while changing one’s viewpoint when the facts give rise to it is essential to reduce polarization.

Taken together, these ten Niebuhrian imperatives are immensely valuable for combatting polarization in our societies. They help us develop openness and curiosity towards those other people who may not be the opponents they were initially perceived as. At the same time, they help us cultivate the critical edge needed to make distinctions between what’s really valuable and what’s not, between what is to be defended, tolerated and resisted. In all, they represent the practical wisdom Niebuhr cherished so highly.

[1] This article is a slightly adapted translated version of one section of the authors’ introduction to the book Jeremy L. Sabella, Hoop in tijden van verdeeldheid. Het levensverhaal van Reinhold Niebuhr en zijn lessen voor de wereld (Hope in Times of Division: The Life Story of Reinhold Niebuhr and His Lessons for the World.) Introduced and translated into Dutch by Simon Polinder and Menno R. Kamminga (Almere: Parthenon 2022).

[2] D.R. Davies, Reinhold Niebuhr: Prophet from America (London: James Clarke & Co, 1948),21.

[3] Rutger Bregman, Humankind: A Hopeful History (New York/Boston/London: Little, Brown and Co, 2020).

[4] Barack Obama, “A More Perfect Union,” March 18th, 2008, https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=88478467&t=1645787394342.

[5] Jürgen Habermas, “Religion in the Public Sphere,” European Journal of Philosophy 14 (2006) 1: 10-16.

The post Christian Realism as a Remedy for Polarization appeared first on Providence.

All 5 aboard Care Flight plane killed in Nevada crash

Five people are dead, including a patient and medical personnel, after a Care Flight plane crashed late Friday in Nevada. The incident occurred at approximately 9:15 p.m. when the Lyon County Dispatch Center began receiving multiple calls regarding a possible plane crash near Stagecoach, Nevada — about 45 miles east of Reno, according to a statement from the Lyon County Sheriff’s Office. Care Flight, a service of REMSA Health, headquartered in Reno, Nevada and Guardian Flight, headquartered in

Measles outbreak that sickened 85 children declared over in Ohio

The measles outbreak in central Ohio that left 85 children infected has officially been declared over, Columbus Public Health announced Thursday. “CPH has received the last pending test result, which was negative for suspected measles cases,” the agency tweeted. “We have surpassed 42 days, or two incubation periods, since the last rash onset, which fits the CDC’s definition of the end of an outbreak.”