Andrew Tate Is Proof That the Whole Economy Is a Scam

Online misogynist Andrew Tate doesn’t pretend that life under capitalism isn’t a scam. He readily acknowledges that it is, with success coming through coercion, exploitation, and predation — and he wants you to get in on the hustle with him.

Andrew Tate. (Wikimedia Commons)

Residency in a Romanian jail cell on suspicion of human trafficking, rape, and money laundering, has not, it seems, reduced the popularity of the self-proclaimed “Top G,” kickboxer, professional misogynist, and grifter extraordinaire Andrew Tate. For a brief period in 2022 Tate was the most Googled man on the planet; he continues to drive internet traffic and rack up billions of TikTok followers. Now in prison awaiting trial, his influence over young boys in his native United Kingdom has not diminished. There, reports of teachers complaining about the juvenile sexism inspired by his ceaseless stream of social media soundbites have become ubiquitous.

Momentarily, the Tate saga seemed over after major social medial firms “canceled” him.  But something strange happened — the Tate machine proved too big to fail. Spurned by the social media establishment and the media, he managed to expand his influence and presence despite only posting his content directly on Rumble and other right-wing “alternative” social media platforms.

On the dark corners of the internet, Tate managed to speak directly to an audience of boys and young men. His “expulsion” from social media only served to increase his appeal among his target demographics. According to one study, 74 percent of British males between ages eighteen and twenty-four had consumed some sort of Tate content; substantially more boys have heard of Tate than of UK prime minister Rishi Sunak, a perhaps unsurprising fact given the relatively short shelf life of recent PMs. Teachers are reporting that Tate’s influence is directly changing the behavior of boys, who have taken to asking their instructors “what color is your Bugatti?” as well as parroting Tate’s sexist routines to girls and women.

What Tate offers is a way to hack the system, to make the scams work for you. Why believe anything else in a world in which the charisma-free, sweatpants-wearing Sam Bankman-Fried is able to con his way into a fortune?

What makes Tate more than a particularly unpleasant creature is his widespread appeal. Unlike, say, Elon Musk — a repellent figure for very different reasons — he does not even claim to owe his fame to his ability to actually produce anything. Predation, exploitation, and relentless clout chasing are the tools with which he has won fame and fortune. He is a symptom of a new brand of capitalism unincumbered by any illusions about progress. For Tate and his followers, the whole system is a scam and the only way to succeed is by pushing others down and clawing your way to the top.

Tate is the most toxic and popular figure to surface from the swamp of the so-called manosphere, which includes the likes of the steroid-enhanced, raw offal–chowing Liver King, and Gonzalo Lira, the pickup-artist-turned-geopolitical-“expert” living in Ukraine.

Tate and the Matrix

Tate’s entire persona is based on what an insecure adolescent boy imagines to be success in today’s world. His view of what counts as a marker of success — waving a sword around, smoking a cigar and posing next to his supercars — is unaspiringly crude. (Lil Wayne’s adage that “Real Gs move in silence like lasagna” is not one embraced by Tate.) Tate’s grift is to use this image to market an unoriginal synthesis of outrageous misogyny packaged with pseudo-spiritual wisdom to hawk his various obvious scams.

We are, according to Tate, living in what he calls “the Matrix.” The economy: a scam; the media: a scam; politicians: also a scam. So, too, is the traditional nine-to-five job. Modern dating is a feminist scam. Education a total scam. What Tate offers is a way to hack the system, to make the scams work for you. Why believe anything else in a world in which the charisma-free, sweatpants-wearing Sam Bankman-Fried is able to con his way into a fortune? Underlying this worldview is a kind of egalitarianism: shouldn’t the common man, too, have a chance to get in on the hustle?

Tate also owes his success to the skill with which he has navigated the attention economy and understood the moral outlook that underlies it. According to this worldview, his money, his cars, and his poisoned relationships with women are all evidence of his virtue. Tate sits atop the pyramid scheme of the scam economy because he is most deserving, and he is most deserving because he has done so well for himself. Unsurprisingly, he has a rags-to-riches fable of making money through a camgirl empire hat he has all but confessed was reliant on human trafficking.

Sadly, Tate is not the originator of the hustler gospel he evangelizes. A decade of slow growth following the financial crisis made possible the hustler economy of precarious gig work that was billed as empowerment, but that in fact was merely a way of subsidizing the incomes of the poor. Today, “hustling” has become thoroughly egalitarian. From Amazon drop shipping to crypto day-trading, anyone can get in on the action.

In a world in which self-exploitation has been universalized and critiques of capitalism are rarely advanced, Tate has been able to claim the mantle of an Übermensch — “the top G” — whose success can only be the result of his unique skills. As one British teacher stated, “He is brainwashing a generation of boys, and it’s very frightening.” She added, “They seem to think he is right. He’s right because he’s rich.” Clout makes right.

Unsurprisingly, Tate’s entire story is a scam too. According to Tate, he was born to a legendary African-American chess master and a British catering assistant, and grew up on a council estate in Luton, one of South East England’s least inspiring cities. Rising from the gloom of Luton, through the power of will, Tate was able to become a four-time world kickboxing champion. He eventually retired from the sport when he decided that it was not going to make him rich or bring him the celebrity status he so clearly desired (Tate was infamously kicked out of the UK edition of Big Brother in 2016).

Working with his brother he finally found a profession equal to his talent: the camgirl industry. Fleeing legal troubles, or “seeking freedom” in his own words, he moved to Romania and built an empire worth millions. Armed with the keys to success, Tate then proceeded to use his immense wealth to try to save young men from the Matrix (and increase his own net worth), leading him to international fame and fortune. For his efforts, Tate was punished and imprisoned by the Matrix.

In a development that nobody could have possibly predicted, the Hustler’s University itself was a scam.

In reality, Tate was only a kickboxing champion in a second-rate promotion. He was a failed reality-TV celebrity who had tried for years on various shows to gain public attention before he was kicked out of Big Brother following his arrest for rape allegations. He has publicly documented his desperate desire for clout from the beginning. An early Tate series on YouTube, “the Hateful Tates,” is one of the most bizarre and hilarious records of male insecurity ever posted on the internet. While he did end up making decent money from his stock of camgirl girlfriends, this was in his own words “a total scam” based on tricking desperate men out of their money by selling sob stories.

Fortune secured, true fame was somewhat harder to come by. To realize his dream, Tate embarked on a shameless campaign to ingratiate himself with the most odious representatives of the modern right. He infiltrated the alt-right media ecosphere, aided by a legion of media grifters from Alex Jones up to Donald Trump Jr; in the UK, he opted for his fellow Lutonite Tommy Robinson, disgraced founder of the far-right English Defence League, and Nigel Farage, architect of the Brexit campaign’s right wing.

He then proceeded to “hack” the second generation of visual-based social media by mixing short TikTok clips of his decadent lifestyle with utterly outrageous statements, followed by more reasoned, mature, and cerebral monologues in which he justified his wealth. The secret to his web omnipresence was also a scam.

What made Tate’s assault on two fronts possible was the unique post-pandemic climate. This provided Tate with an ideal target audience for his grift: the pandemic experience created insecure, lonely, and alienated young men, who rightly felt that everything is a scam but were quick to latch on to a personification of success rather than a real community or sense of meaning. This was in large part because Tate’s ideology doesn’t require them to engage in self-reflection or to challenge the dominant values of capitalist society.

The Hustler’s University

Tate’s most successful product was himself. He managed to transform his identity into a get-rich-quick marketing scam known to the world as “Hustler’s University.” This institute of higher learning promised to sell young men tried and tested methods to make money for a mere $49.99 a month. Hustler’s University eventually ended up with something approaching 150,000 students at its peak before Tate shut it down after his “cancelation.” It has since reopened with the new name of “The Real World.”

In a development that nobody could have possibly predicted, the Hustler’s University itself was a scam. Once students signed up, members were informed that they could make money by recruiting more members through sharing viral Tate content on social media with links to said higher education institution. Enrollees would receive 50 percent of the tuition of each member recruited. This pyramid-scheme university was not entirely devoid of academic rigor. Tate offered students a “PHD (Pimping Hoes Degree),” a course in which he basically confesses to being a human trafficker and webcam pimp, as well as more mundane courses on crypto or Amazon drop shipping.

As recorded in a recent Vice documentary, if you were ready to pay $5,000 you could join his secret society “The War Room,” where you can impress Tate by volunteering to be beaten to a pulp by a professional mixed martial arts fighter. This secret society includes such esteemed gentlemen as his court wizard/hypnotist Iggy Semmelweis and other cronies such as the so-called Alpha Wolf and a mysterious Australian ex-intelligence officer who goes by the moniker “Sartorial Shooter.”

While Tate was making money hand over fist through Hustler’s University, he was also trying to spread his own new-age-meets-dumb-rocks-misogyny worldview. For Tate, the Western world is utterly corrupt, destroyed by feminism and the Matrix. To this self-help guru, clout cargo cult leader, and troll, the West’s moral and economic decline is evidenced in the realities of harsh taxation, increasing authoritarianism, violence, and the climate of growing fear and alienation. Tate’s most recent marketing move was publicly converting to Islam in order to smooth his relocation to Dubai and also extend his reach to the legion of lonely young men in the Islamic world. He praises Islam as an alternative to the “cucked” religions of the West.

For Tate, the Western world has been deceiving women into abandoning their biologically determined role. “Women are programmable, women are blank slates, they are either programmed by you or society,” Tate proclaims. That men and their views about the world might also be shaped by society is a nuance he seems incapable of grasping.

Another Tate lowlight was urging women to take responsibility for being raped:

If you go out. Meet a guy. Take his drinks all night. Go to his apartment drunk. Start to kiss him. Then he grabs your tits. Not harassment. If I left a million dollars outside my front door — when it got stolen people would say “Why was it there? Irresponsible.” Take some personal responsibility. This zero-blame game is damaging to the female cause as a whole. Protect yourselves.

This misogyny is essential to Tate’s worldview and no doubt tied to some daddy issues. To him, femininity represents the opposite of individual freedom because women are a commodity one attains through building power; their autonomy is a direct threat to this reactionary vision of freedom.

Tate Atop the Scam Economy

This new scam economy is as obvious as it is widespread, from crypto to sports betting and the legion of tech firms that are worth billions despite never making a cent in profit. These are all made possible by the influx of cheap money and low interest rates since the Great Recession. A subway ride in New York or London introduces one, via ads, to a satanic menagerie of new startups. Each one touts the opportunity to rent out your bed or buy twee fair-trade dick pills. None of this is connected in any sense to a progressive vision of capitalism as a system capable of increasing productivity by creating laborsaving technology or producing actual things. Peddled instead is the indebted, alienated consumption of anxious lonely subjects.

However, this stage of the scam economy is coming to an end: inflation, high interest rates, supply chain issues, and the energy crisis are reshaping the global economy.

He had found a successful scam and convinced himself by virtue of its success that he was the smartest guy in the world, and went around shouting from the rooftops.

Tate is a creature born out of the ashes of a dying economy. Unlike, say, Bankman-Fried, he is an open scammer; he promised to teach his fans how to escape and avoid financial hardship by scamming in pursuit of freedom. The Tate cult is a world of something far worse than YouTubers: streamers, guys who make their money sitting on their computer playing games and responding to things to satisfy the innate desire for friendship and community that so many alienated, lonely young people have and lack in real life, indeed for a generation coming of age online during a pandemic.

Tate’s Downfall

Now Tate sits in Romanian jail awaiting charges, which by most reports will be extremely serious. The irony is that he boasted for years that he moved to Romania because of its reputation for corruption and loose attitude to law enforcement. Following several rape and assault allegations in the UK, he stated in one video that this was “probably forty percent of the reason” he moved there, adding, “I’m not a rapist, but I like the idea of just being able to do what I want. I like being free.”

Tate’s wish to share with the world how successful he was, was also the root of his own downfall. He had found a successful scam and convinced himself by virtue of its success that he was the smartest guy in the world, and went around shouting from the rooftops. The problem is that the Romanian authorities he lambasted as corrupt started paying attention and looked into the scams he just had to tell everyone about.

For his followers, Tate’s camp tweets content supposedly from their imprisoned leader, in which he describes the rats and roaches he faces in his cell and compares himself to Nelson Mandela and Martin Luther King, targeted by the authorities for speaking truth to power. Already, his legal defense team has claimed that he was “just playing a character.”

Regardless of Tate’s fate, it seems likely that the brand of grifting along with the perverse ideology that he has championed will be with us for some time. It is predicated ultimately on a vision of capitalism completely devoid of the idea of progress. Absent any hope for the future, what will become increasingly common is an intensification of the rat race and the justification of this war of all against all through an appeal to old and new forms of barbarism.

Unipolar Hegemony Is in Its “Death Throes”: American Conservative’s George D. O’Neill Jr.

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Unipolar Hegemony Is in Its “Death Throes”: American Conservative’s George D. O’Neill Jr. appeared first on Global Research.

Socialism Is All About Expanding Freedom

Libertarians and conservatives talk a lot about freedom, but the most important kind of freedom is freedom from domination — and if you take that seriously, you should oppose capitalism.

The men and women who built the trade union movement and fought to end child labor and institute an eight-hour day understood they were fighting for a profoundly important kind of human freedom. (Claude Gabriel / Unsplash)

In my last article for Jacobin, I praised “the republican theory of freedom” — the idea that the most important kind of freedom is freedom from domination.

Some might wonder why I think it’s important for the Left talk about freedom in the first place. We see “freedom” invoked to defend everything from the right of corner gun shops to sell AR-15s without background checks to the right of chemical plants to dump toxic waste in rivers. Shouldn’t we instead ground our politics in alternative values like equality or the alleviation of suffering?

These other values are important. Equality matters both in itself and because genuine freedom is impossible amid massive inequality. Reducing suffering is a valiant aim too. But it would be a huge mistake to cede “freedom” to the defenders of the capitalist status quo.

The drive to overcome unjust relations of domination has always been at the center of the Left’s project.

Conservatives, Libertarians, and Freedom

Conservatives love to talk about freedom. Donald Trump just announced a proposal to charter “freedom cities” on federally owned land. His likely rival for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination, Florida governor Ron DeSantis, recently published a book called The Courage to Be Free.

Progressives pushing back against this rhetoric often point to the Right’s inconsistencies and hypocrisies. What about the freedom of pregnant women to decide what happens in their own bodies? What about the freedoms of gay and trans people?

This is all true and important. But none of it quite reaches the nub of the issue.

After all, if the only problem with mainstream conservatives’ invocation of freedom is that it’s full of blind spots, what should we say about those few relatively principled libertarians who do come down on the right side of many of these battles? While some libertarians are antiabortion, for example, the ones who aren’t describe their worldview as “pro-choice on everything.”

The libertarian conception of freedom is “noninterference” — an idea pithily summarized in the title of Matt Kibbe’s 2014 “libertarian manifesto” Don’t Hurt People and Don’t Take Their Stuff. When DeSantis wants to lock up a Floridian who smokes a joint in her backyard, he’s going against the first half of that title. And when leftists advocate nationalizing private corporations — or even raising taxes to pay for Medicare for All — they’re going against the second half.

One easy way to rebut the Don’t Hurt People and Don’t Take Their Stuff worldview is simply to emphasize the importance of competing values. If you think that people struggling with suicidal depression or addiction to hard drugs sometimes need to be saved from themselves, for instance, or that mass shootings are an unacceptable price to pay for “gun freedom,” you’re going to reject at least the most extreme form of libertarianism. But that’s consistent with thinking freedom is very important — and that “freedom” means what libertarians think it means. So even if you support gun control or want the legal system to push heroin addicts into rehab, you might value “freedom” too much to want to take away Amazon from Jeff Bezos and run it as a public utility.

A deeper problem with freedom as noninterference — or at least with the claim that economic redistribution violates this view of freedom — is that every time you recognize a property right to “stuff,” you’re actually carving out an exception to the “don’t hurt people” part. If you don’t believe me, try to board a privately owned train without a ticket and see what happens.

Libertarians sometimes attempt to get around this problem by appealing to the “non-aggression principle,” which says that hurting people or taking their stuff is only bad if you’re the one initiating the use of force. It’s fine to defend people or their property with the use of force.

But the problem here is with the concept of “your” property. Does this mean the property that’s legally yours? If so, taxation and even nationalization of private companies is just fine! If Congress passes a law to nationalize Amazon, then the company is no longer legally Bezos’s property. On the other hand, if “your” property means the property you’re morally entitled to, then objecting to ethical arguments for redistribution on the grounds that it undercuts your freedom against interference with “your” property is just arguing in a circle.

Whether we’re talking about socialist proposals like nationalizing Amazon or daily capitalist realities like a landlord calling the police to kick squatters out of an unoccupied building, all possible distributions of scarce resources are enforced by some sort of coercion. The question in dispute is never coercion versus no coercion. It is, always and everywhere, which distribution to coercively enforce.

Negative Freedom, Positive Freedom, and Freedom From Domination

If you were nodding along to that last argument, you might think “freedom” can’t tell us much about how resources should be distributed. And it can’t — if freedom means noninterference. But is that the only important kind of freedom, or even the kind that matters most?

One way of pushing back against an excessive emphasis on “negative” liberty is to play up “positive” liberty. Maybe a drug addict, for example, isn’t truly free — you can’t be the master of your own destiny if you’re enslaved to your addiction.

The classic objection to this idea comes from philosopher Isaiah Berlin, who conceded that coercing someone for their own good might in some cases be justified, but who still thought it was absurd to say that

if it is my good, then I am not being coerced, for I have willed it, whether I know this or not, and am free (or “truly” free) even when my poor earthly body and foolish mind bitterly reject it, and struggle against those who seek however benevolently to impose it.

Fair enough. But the dichotomy between “negative” freedom from interference and “positive” freedom to act on your “real” underlying interests doesn’t exhaust the possibilities. “Republican” theorists — as in ancient Greek and Roman republics — emphasized freedom from domination, and argued that this was a more fundamental kind of freedom than freedom from interference.

Think about the most extreme form of nonfreedom, slavery. A slave who’s whipped every day is certainly less lucky than one whose master hardly ever strikes him. His body is interfered with less. But is he more free? Proponents of republicanism would say no, because in each case the slave is at the mercy of the master and the same underlying relationship of domination persists.

Of course, ancient republican philosophers had no objection to slavery. They just wanted a class of citizens to be free from the whims of any emperor or oligarch. But in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, abolitionists, labor organizers, and socialists advocated a society in which everyone would be robustly free from domination. Even the elimination of extreme unfreedom through the Union’s victory in the Civil War wasn’t enough to satisfy these radicals, who saw disturbing patterns of domination in Northern industrial capitalism: “Emancipation may have eliminated chattel slavery, but, as eight-hour campaigner Ira Steward once put it, the creation of this new form of economic dependence meant ‘something of slavery still remains . . . something of freedom is yet to come.’”

Under capitalism, the vast majority of people who are directly involved in the economy don’t own what Marxists call “the means of production.” They don’t own factories, for example, or book-packaging warehouses or grocery stores, and they can’t afford to buy any of these things. So they have no realistic option except to rent themselves out for eight hours a day — and it’s only eight hours due to the efforts of people like Steward — to people who do own them.

There’s a profound power imbalance in this relationship. Many workplaces are run as petty dictatorships where the boss can tell workers when they have to smile, when they are or aren’t allowed to talk to each other, and when they can and can’t go to the bathroom. In the vast majority of cases — exceptions include workers with rare and highly valued skills, and periods of especially low unemployment — it’s much easier for a company to replace a worker than for the worker to replace her livelihood. She has to fret about her boss’s opinion of her in a way that he doesn’t. Even if he is a benevolent boss, she is still subject to his whims.

To be sure, there’s a sense in which absolute nondomination is impossible. Humans are socially interconnected, and therefore inescapably dependent on each other’s whims to some extent. We rely on each other to meet our most basic needs — very few of us, for instance, are in a position to grow all our own food. And while human institutions can provide an important degree of stability, legal and political institutions rise and fall over the course of history. Any rights that you have in a given system could be taken away in some unlikely but theoretically possible scenario in the future. We could achieve workers’ control of the means of production and then lose it in a counterrevolution.

But arguing that this means spreading economic power far more evenly wouldn’t be a deeply meaningful extension of freedom from domination is a little bit like saying that someone who lives in a compound surrounded by a high wall and armed guards doesn’t count as “really” safe because they could be taken out by assassins with sufficiently advanced military hardware. Absolute freedom, like absolute safety, is impossible — but that doesn’t make humanly achievable degrees of freedom or safety unimportant.

US Hegemony and Its Perils: Loosing the Trust of the Global South, China “Takes the Gloves Off”, Antiwar Forces Mobilize

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post US Hegemony and Its Perils: Loosing the Trust of the Global South, China “Takes the Gloves Off”, Antiwar Forces Mobilize appeared first on Global Research.

Father Arrested After Shooting at Naked Man Found in Daughter’s Bed

This week, a 44-year-old man, David Victor Miller, was apprehended after shooting a naked man that ended up in his daughter’s bed. He was charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and shooting into an occupied dwelling.

According to authorities, the arrest was made at his Cape Coral, Florida home following an incident where the man fired multiple shots at a naked man he discovered sleeping in his teen daughter’s bed after a night of heavy drinking.

The statement from the police department stated that Mr. Miller had a married couple renting a room from him. Miller explained that one of his roommates was found nude in his daughter’s bedroom. When officers arrived at the scene, they were able to escort both of the man’s roommates out of the bedroom.

Investigations revealed that the two victims were a married couple renting a room in Miller’s home and were living with his wife and daughter. Additionally, officers reported that shell casings and bullet holes were found in the bedroom door.

Miller said that he and the two victims had been drinking heavily that night, and the naked man told police that he had gotten out of his bed in the middle of the night to use the restroom and mistakenly went into the teenage girl’s bedroom afterward.

The girl woke up and then alerted her father, and the naked man’s spouse woke him up and shouted that he was in the wrong room. Miller then went to the man’s bedroom and began pounding on the door and threatened to kill him before shooting his gun 3-4 times outside the bedroom door.

The girl did not allege that a crime happened to her during the incident.

Miller was arrested without incident and taken to Lee County Jail, held until his arraignment on April 10.

Where Should Palestinians Search for Justice?

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …

The post Where Should Palestinians Search for Justice? appeared first on Global Research.

Predictions for 2023? Annus Horribilis with Some Surprising Upsides

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Predictions for 2023? Annus Horribilis with Some Surprising Upsides appeared first on Global Research.

Rail-Lobbyist-Turned-Senator John Thune Is Set to Block New Railroad Safety Measures

Sen. John Thune, a former railroad lobbyist, is positioning himself to help kill rail safety legislation meant to prevent disasters like the recent East Palestine derailment. It’s one of many examples of the rail industry’s “revolving door” in Washington, DC.

Former railroad lobbyist Sen. John Thune is once again going to bat for the industry, positioning himself as a key obstacle to the most substantial rail safety initiative considered by Congress in years. (Senator John Thune / Twitter)

In 2004, a registered lobbyist for a railroad corporation got himself elected to the US Senate, and then he promptly helped his former client become eligible for billions in cheap federal loans in the wake of the company’s hazmat train derailment. The same Republican lawmaker later spearheaded the effort to repeal a major rail safety rule while becoming one of the Senate’s top recipients of campaign cash from the industry.

Now, Sen. John Thune (R-SD) is once again going to bat for the industry, positioning himself as a key obstacle to the most substantial rail safety initiative considered by Congress in years.

Thune, the second-highest-ranking Republican in the upper chamber, has been critical of the bipartisan push for quick and expansive legislation in the wake of the East Palestine, Ohio, train derailment that has rocked national politics.

“We’ll take a look at what’s being proposed, but an immediate quick response heavy on regulation needs to be thoughtful and targeted,” Thune told the Hill, echoing his earlier comments to CNN insisting that lawmakers should wait to “get the facts, and then figure out what, if anything, needs to be changed.”

Thune’s efforts to slow the measure are being boosted by the rail industry’s advocacy group, which previously gave him an award when he helped kill a train brake rule, and which now employs his former legislative staffer as its top lobbyist.

Thune embodies the railroad industry’s power in Washington, which extends beyond the Senate.

In the House, the new Republican chairman of the transportation committee is the chamber’s top recipient of the industry’s campaign cash. The industry also employs more than two hundred lobbyists who have previously served in the federal government. Meanwhile, Norfolk Southern’s general counsel — who has pressed for federal safety waivers — is a former executive director of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), which is currently investigating the company.

All of that influence is bolstered by the rail industry’s PR operation to fight regulations, as well as $14 million in federal campaign donations in the past two election cycles.

With Norfolk Southern CEO Alan Shaw set to testify before a Senate committee Thursday, here is a review of the biggest obstacles to a congressional and regulatory crackdown on the rail industry’s safety practices.

A Landmark Initiative, but One With Loopholes

Last week, a bipartisan group of US senators proposed the Railway Safety Act, which limits train lengths, requires two-person crews on freight trains, strengthens transparency requirements for hazmat trains, sets standards for infrastructure maintenance, and increases the maximum fines for safety violations.

It’s an unusual piece of federal legislation because it is opposed by a major industry but still has some chance of passing a divided Congress with bipartisan support.

On the Senate side, at least three Republicans are backing the legislation — senators Josh Hawley (MO), Marco Rubio (FL), and J. D. Vance (OH) — suggesting that it may be able to reach the nine Republican votes needed to overcome a filibuster, assuming all fifty-one Senate Democrats support it.

Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY) pledged last week that he would move quickly on the legislation, saying that the bill was “precisely the kind of proposal we need to see in Congress“ and that he would do “whatever I can” to pass the bill.

Still, major rail unions are pushing for a stronger bill, warning that in its current form, the legislation grants broad discretion to the transportation secretary to write safety rules, rather than spelling out regulatory specifics.

“You can run a freight train through the loopholes,” said Eddie Hall, national president of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen, the largest rail union, about the bill’s two-person crew provision.

For years, rail unions have been pushing back against the industry’s desire to run trains with one-man crews. While the legislation requires two-person crews on many freight trains, it includes carve-outs for short-distance trains as well as the potential for waivers.

A two-person crew rule proposed last year by Secretary Pete Buttigieg’s Department of Transportation would similarly allow railroads to seek exemptions.

The Lobbyist in Senator’s Clothing

Even in its current form, the proposed Railway Safety Act will have to overcome significant legislative obstacles. Thune, in particular, could pose a problem.

“We’ll take a look at what’s being proposed, but an immediate quick response heavy on regulation needs to be thoughtful and targeted,” Thune told the Hill on Monday.

Thune sits on the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee and is the second-most-senior Republican after Texas senator Ted Cruz. (Cruz has said he supports “congressional inquiry” into the East Palestine derailment but has not commented on the legislation.)

Thune served as the railroad director of South Dakota from 1991 to 1993, before getting elected to Congress. For some of his time in the House, Thune sat on the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee.

He retired in 2003 after a failed Senate run and quickly became a lobbyist for the Dakota, Minnesota and Eastern (DM&E) Railroad, which he had previously regulated as a state official. He continued lobbying for the company — which is now a subsidiary of the Canadian Pacific Railway — during his successful Senate campaign in 2004.

As part of his advocacy work for the railroad, Thune helped the company procure a $230 million loan from the Federal Railroad Administration. Upon joining the Senate in 2005, Thune attempted to help the company obtain a $2.3 billion federal loan it was seeking to expand coal freight operations.

That year, Thune convinced his colleagues to expand the loan pool for railroads from $3.5 billion to $35 billion — and increase the pool for small railroads from $1 billion to $7 billion — making his former client far more likely to win its loan.

The Thune provision allows the Dakota, Minnesota and Eastern Railroad and the Iowa, Chicago and Eastern Railroad to apply for a loan package totaling $2.5 billion to build or rehabilitate over 1,300 miles of rail, the majority of which would be spent in South Dakota,

his office said in a press release after the bill passed. “If approved, the loan would finance South Dakota’s largest railroad infrastructure program.”

A fellow senator called Thune’s loan pool expansion “the most despicable special-interest deal I’ve ever seen in all my 30 years in government.”

Ultimately, Thune’s former client was rejected for the loan, after intense scrutiny of Thune’s lobbying background for the railroad company and opposition from a hospital along the proposed route due to DM&E’s record of hazmat train derailments. Had DM&E obtained the loan, it would have been the largest private loan guarantee in US history.

In 2015, Thune reprised his advocacy for the rail industry, leading an effort to repeal an Obama administration regulation requiring improved, electronic braking systems on some hazmat trains. The following year, he received the first-ever “Railroad Achievement Award” presented by the Association of American Railroads, the industry’s main lobbying group.

Thune is the third-largest recipient of cash from the railroad industry in the Senate and raked in nearly $70,000 in the past election cycle alone.

Meanwhile, the highest-ranking Republican in the Senate, minority leader Mitch McConnell (KY), has not said whether he will back the legislation. McConnell’s wife, Elaine Chao, served as transportation secretary during the Trump administration and repealed numerous rail safety rules.

House Chairman Is Top Recipient of Rail Industry Cash

Even if the Railway Safety Act makes its way through the Senate, there are also substantial barriers to passage in the House, where Republicans hold a majority and have been raking in railroad cash.

The legislation could face its first major roadblock in the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee. Chairman Rep. Sam Graves (R-MO) was the top recipient of railroad industry campaign cash in Congress last election cycle and has been a longtime enemy of efforts to regulate his donors.

Graves has held his solidly red seat since 2001, and he easily won his most recent election last fall with 70 percent of the vote. Even so, the railroad executives and their political action committees poured $107,000 into his campaign coffers last cycle.

In July 2021, Graves sent a letter to the Surface Transportation Board — the other federal agency that regulates railroads — warning that Biden’s recent executive order calling for a “whole-of-government approach” to address antitrust issues could “decrease the freight railroads’ efficiency or limit their ability to reinvest in their infrastructure.”

Speaking on Fox News about the East Palestine derailment on February 16, Graves noted that the federal government’s “accident investigation continues, so instead of speculating about all the potential factors, I want to fully understand the facts involved. When we have the facts, Congress can consider what next steps may be necessary.”

The Rail Safety Act could also run into trouble in the House Transportation Subcommittee on Railroads, Pipelines, and Hazardous Materials. Subcommittee chair Rep. Troy Nehls (R-TX), told Politico about the proposed legislation, “The rail industry has a very high success rate of moving hazardous material — to the point of 99-percent-plus. Let’s not have more burdensome regulations and all this other stuff.”

A $54 Million Lobbying War Chest

Nehls’s defense of the rail industry was a near word-for-word recitation of rhetoric from the railroad industry’s lobbying group, the Association of American Railroads, which has been touting its “99.9 percent” success rate in the wake of the East Palestine derailment, including in recent Politico advertisements.

The Association of American Railroads brought in $55 million in revenue in 2020, according to the group’s most recent tax filings, the majority of which came from membership dues. Members include the major class I freight railroads, some smaller railroads, and Amtrak.

In the wake of the new Senate rail legislation, the Association of American Railroads has similarly argued that policymakers should wait to issue new safety rules until the government has completed its investigation into the East Palestine derailment.

The organization’s top lobbyist is a former staffer for Thune, and its president and CEO was previously a staffer on the Senate Transportation Committee.

There are currently 265 people registered to lobby the federal government on behalf of the railroad industry, 208 of whom previously held jobs in the federal government according to data from OpenSecrets. The rail industry as a whole spent $25 million directly lobbying the federal government in 2022.

Norfolk Southern Employs a Former NTSB Official

Railroads like Norfolk Southern have one other way to potentially avoid new safety crackdowns: by being granted regulatory waivers.

The Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) has authority to allow rail companies to bypass any safety rule, regulation, or order “upon a finding that doing so is ‘in the public interest and consistent with railroad safety.’” The Senate legislation’s two-person crew provision explicitly gives the Transportation Secretary the authority to grant such waivers for trains to operate with fewer than two people.

Norfolk Southern’s current point person for requesting waivers from safety rules and regulations is especially well positioned for the role, since he was formerly acting executive director and managing director of the NTSB.

Thomas Zoeller, Norfolk Southern’s current general counsel for markets and regulation, served in executive roles including acting executive director of the NTSB when the board recommended that the Obama administration expand the definition of high-hazard flammable trains (HHFT) to include flammable gases like those on board the train that derailed in East Palestine.

Before heading Norfolk Southern’s legal department, he made a brief stop at the US Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board, where he was senior policy advisor and acting general counsel, according to his LinkedIn Profile.

In his capacity at Norfolk Southern, Zoeller sought a waiver in March 2021 to exempt Norfolk Southern from manual track geometry inspection requirements, insisting an automated inspection system was sufficient. Automated track inspections is something the Association of American Railroads, the top lobbying group for rail companies, has been pushing for as it expedites the required inspection process and ultimately reduces staffing demand.

The FRA denied the request, citing the Brotherhood of Maintenance of Way Employes Division/IBT (BMWED), which argued that if the waiver was granted it would “adversely affect railroad safety.”

Zoeller’s transition from the public sector to private industry is one of many examples of regulators going through the revolving door to corporations they formerly helped regulate.

“Intimate knowledge of bureaucratic intricacies includes knowing how to exploit the process,” said Dylan Gyauch-Lewis, a researcher with the Revolving Door Project. “Former regulators know the chokepoints in the regulatory process and seek to use those bottlenecks to block or delay regulation,” he told us.

That makes Zoeller well positioned to help his rail employer skirt potential safety rules.

“Zoeller, coming from the NTSB, will know exactly how to skirt the boundaries of laws and regulations and can leverage his personal ties to regulators to try and get Norfolk Southern out of trouble,” Gyauch-Lewis said.

You can subscribe to David Sirota’s investigative journalism project, the Lever, here.

Zelensky Admits He Never Intended to Implement Minsk Agreements

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Zelensky Admits He Never Intended to Implement Minsk Agreements appeared first on Global Research.