Tax the Rich, Because Inequality Is Bad for All of Us

Economic inequality undermines democracy, hastens environmental destruction, fosters anxiety, and erodes social trust. We can start to solve these problems by taxing the rich, as progressives and socialists in New York State are now proposing.

A homeless person is seen near a subway station in New York City. (Tayfun Coskun / Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

Inequality is hazardous to your physical and mental health, your community life, and your budget. Wherever you are in the status hierarchy — top, bottom, or middle — it takes its toll on you. And while it is inevitable under capitalism, its effects can be accentuated or mitigated by public policies.

One key policy mechanism to address inequality is taxing the rich. And one place that would benefit from taxing the rich is New York. New York City is the capital of the world financial system, and New York State is the most unequal state in the nation: 1 percent of households take home 31 percent of all income in the state, whereas the top 1 percent of households nationally capture 21 percent of all income. That is because the very wealthy in the state are exceptionally wealthy. While the top 1 percent in the United States has an average annual income of $1.3 million, New York’s top 1 percent makes $2.2 million.

The Invest in Our New York (IONY) coalition — made up of New York City Democratic Socialists of America (NYC-DSA), the Working Families Party (WFP), New York Communities for Change, and local community and political organizations across the state — is proposing to challenge this obscene inequality by raising taxes on the superrich and investing in housing, public transportation, education, and the environment.

Taxing the rich would allow us to publicly fund these desperately needed goods and services. But it has another benefit: it would chip away at the corrosive effects of inequality in our lives. Such inequality has massive impacts across our society, including in some surprising areas you might assume have little to do with the rising concentration of wealth. The effort to raise taxes on the wealthy in New York will not erase these social problems, but it can address some of inequality’s worst impacts.

Inequality Is Out of Control

Inequality has escalated out of control in the United States since the 1970s, as an increasing share of national income has gone to corporations in the form of profits. The numbers are familiar to us by this point but they bear repeating: CEO pay in the three hundred fifty largest US corporations increased by 1,460 percent between 1978 and 2021, while the average worker’s pay grew during the same period by only 18.1 percent. In 2021, the average CEO was paid 399 times as much as the average worker (compared to 59.1 times as much in 1959).

The already rich are walking away with most of the gains of our growing economy. In the boom following the financial crisis of 2007–8, the top 1 percent in New York State took 51.4 percent of the income gains between 2009 and 2015, and the rise in the number of billionaires since the pandemic shows that the trend has continued. At the same time, many working people are not seeing their pay keep up with inflation.

Meanwhile the tax structure has grown more regressive: Congress reduced the top federal income tax bracket from 94 percent in 1945 to 35 percent in 2012; it stands at 37 percent today. The wealthy, moreover, have access to a combination of legal, illegal, and questionably legal dodges that make massive tax evasion possible. In 2021, the Treasury Department estimated that the top 1 percent of taxpayers were underpaying by more than $160 billion.

In the wake of Occupy Wall Street in 2011 and Bernie Sanders’s two presidential campaigns, mainstream politicians have paid more attention to inequality, including President Joe Biden. The budget presented by the Biden administration to Congress in March calls for significant increases in the corporate tax and in income and capital gains taxes for wealthy taxpayers (though the proposal is unlikely to survive the Republican-majority House of Representatives and the narrowly Democratic-controlled Senate).

The Social Costs of Inequality

Inequality has corrosive effects in almost every area of social and political life, even in societies where everyone enjoys relative prosperity. Conversely, societies of relative equality enjoy many advantages: greater political democracy, less crime, better public health, and less stress and anxiety. These costs and benefits affect the whole population, not only the worst off — rich people in more equal societies reap these social gains too.

The benefits of greater equality derive from social cohesion. When cooperation rather than competition prevails in a society, individuals are more likely to believe that they owe solidarity to others and are themselves entitled to solidarity. Mutual solidarity underlies policies that both ameliorate social conditions and prevent deterioration.

Inequality inhibits democracy by financing capitalists’ campaign contributions, lobbying, and control of the media, giving them the power to impose policies that favor their interests at the expense of others. The Supreme Court’s 2013 Citizens United decision allows corporations to make unlimited campaign contributions. They can support lobbyists in Washington and in state capitals, working day in and day out, maintaining continuous personal contacts, providing information, incentives, and pressure to persuade legislators and regulators to support their interests. Their think tanks promote junk science, attack environmental regulation, and hamstring responses to climate change.

Inequality also exacerbates social and public health problems: not only are these greater in unequal societies, but they are greater in every group within the socioeconomic status order in such societies. In societies of greater inequality, social problems affect people across the class spectrum more heavily than in less unequal societies. High-income people in societies of greater inequality are more likely to suffer problems ranging from cardiovascular diseases to asthma to crime than high-income people in more equal societies. The same goes for those of medium income and, of course, for those of lower income.

More unequal societies rarely provide universal support mechanisms. Private provision of basic necessities inevitably means that support will be inadequate for the poorest and least-protected segments of the population. This harms them, but it also harms everyone else, as the COVID-19 pandemic showed clearly. Universal provision, as exists in all the advanced countries of the world except the United States, provides better care at lower cost than our system.

Conspicuous consumption becomes more important to our standing in an unequal society. But spending on goods purchased to symbolize superior status can crowd out spending on goods that would enhance welfare. Important among such underproduced “goods” is leisure. Workers in more equal societies have shorter work hours, more holidays, and longer vacations. The average worker in the United States works at least 20 percent more hours annually than workers in Germany or Sweden, for example.

Inequality has corrosive effects in almost every area of social and political life, even in societies where everyone enjoys relative prosperity.

Excessive consumption of goods used by the superrich and the nearly superrich to display their wealth raises the cost of living for everyone, because the price of high-end goods affects the costs of midscale and cheaper goods. Consider real estate: the $150 million price of condos on 57th Street in Manhattan cascades downward to the rest of the market, raising the price of housing for the moderately wealthy, the middle class, and the poor, and consigning tens of thousands to living on the street.

Inequality in the real estate market intersects with inequality in education. The irrational, decentralized financing of education in the United States creates extreme variability in the perceived quality of schools, which drives up suburban real estate prices as families choose to live in communities with schools that will put their kids on track to get into a university that will in turn prepare them for a high-paying career. Again, the high prices cascade their way down through the housing market, raising prices for everyone.

Unequal societies also suffer greater environmental degradation. Capitalism exploits the environment as it exploits workers; rapacious resource extraction and planned obsolescence of goods to be discarded as waste fatten profits that feed the hyperconsumption of the rich. On a world scale, the consumption of the richest 10 percent of the population is responsible for 50 percent of carbon emissions. High-inequality areas, moreover, devote fewer resources to environmental protection, because the rich resist taxation and can choose locations or insulate themselves from harmful environmental conditions.

While the excessive consumption of the rich makes them the worst polluters by far, mass consumption contributes too. The capitalist economy raises demands for its products through fast fashion, product obsolescence, and similar devices to promote consumption for its own sake.

Finally, people living in societies of relative equality are happier. Released from the stresses of insecure access to basic needs (for some) and status competition (for others), they can better enjoy life. According to international surveys, the happiest countries in the world are the five Scandinavian countries, which have among the most equal distributions of wealth and income among industrial nations.

We Need to Tax the Rich

The Tax the Rich campaign proposes to increase revenues by $20 billion. A corporate income tax increase was enacted in response to IONY’s 2021 Tax the Rich campaign, raising the corporate tax from 6.5 percent to 7.25 percent for corporations making over $5 billion per year and a smaller increase on the next tier of corporations. The current campaign seeks to make that increase permanent.

A second revenue bill would equalize the tax rate on employment earnings and capital gains. Presently, at both state and federal levels, when an owner of a security sells it at a profit, the gain is considered taxable income, but it is taxed at a lower rate than earnings from labor. In other words, you pay lower taxes on the money you make by sitting at home watching your assets grow than by actually working. The IONY proposal would tax capital gains at the same rate as other income.

The campaign is also about how the increased revenue should be spent. Revenue sources are not legally designated for particular expenditures. But Tax the Rich calls for increases in spending in a number of specific areas. The Build Public Renewables Act would enable the New York Power Authority to build renewable energy plants. Spending on public transportation would fund freezing of Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) fares at $2.75, more frequent bus service, and the phasing in of fare-free buses. On the housing front, vouchers would provide rental subsidies for New Yorkers who are homeless or at risk of homelessness, while the good cause eviction rule would give renters the right to renew a lease and enable them to fight unconscionable rent hikes.

These programs strike a balance among meeting the urgent needs of the most desperate New Yorkers (the homeless), serving the interests of middle- and working-class people whose budgets are squeezed by rising prices (housing security for renters and the MTA fare freeze), and keeping the planet healthy (public renewable power and the buildup of public transportation).

Taxing the rich in New York will not magically transform the state into a paradise of equality. IONY’s proposal would make only a small dent in inequality and a small contribution to solving associated problems. Though New York is the most unequal state in the United States, achieving a more equal distribution would still leave vast landscapes of inequality throughout the country. Tax reform at the federal level, where the greatest tax burden falls, is needed to seriously attack inequality.

A second limitation is that equalizing incomes through taxation merely treats a symptom of the problem of inequality, rather than its source in the capitalist system that determines and allocates rewards. Fundamental change would require democratizing ownership and control of the economy, rather than leaving decisions about investment, production, and incomes to private, for-profit corporations.

Still, taxing the rich along the lines proposed by IONY would not only begin the badly needed task of redistributing wealth, but it would also educate the public about the need to reverse our current course of mounting inequality. If we can enact this legislation, much of New York might start to look very different.

WATCH: ‘Netanyahu needs to lead solution to judicial reform conflict’ – but what about gag order?

World Likud Chairman and former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations Danny Danon tells Israel National News that the Israeli prime minister must lead the solution the the judicial reform conflict, although Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara has forbidden the Israeli leader from speaking publicly on the issue.

“I’m not making this up. I’ve been given a gag order. After all, who am I? I’m just the Prime Minister of Israel. What have I got to say about this thing that is gripping the nation? It is patently ridiculous,” Benjamin Netanyahu told the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations in Jerusalem last month.

The post WATCH: ‘Netanyahu needs to lead solution to judicial reform conflict’ – but what about gag order? appeared first on World Israel News.

4 Israelis regain sight, thanks to corneas donated by family of young terror victims

“We wish for the donors to see the world’s goodness and joy, as our sweet Hallel and Yagel saw it,” the bereaved parents said.

By World Israel News Staff

The corneas of 22-year-old Hillel Menachem Yaniv and 19-year-old Yagel Yaakov Yaniv, who were shot to death last month in Samaria by terrorists from the nearby Palestinian village of Huwara, were given to four patients awaiting donation.

The bereaved parents announced the donation shortly after the attack. The procedure, carried out at Beilinson Hospital in Petah Tikvah, was a success, and all four recipients have regained their sight,, according to a press release.

“Corneal transplantation is a medical operation that brings together a world of bereavement and loss on the one hand, and the excitement and joy of the recipients with restoring vision on the other. This is one of the moments that instills in all of us a sense of unity, kindness, and unconditional giving,” said Beilinson’s director of the Ophthalmology Department, Prof. Irit Behar.

“The righteous decision of the family at the precise moment of their tragedy is extremely moving,” she added.

The recipients had been waiting for a transplant for over a year. Their eyesight has been restored, “thanks to the Yaniv family,” whose “sons’ legacy continues to live on through the lives they have impacted.”

“I’m so emotional. This was beyond my expectations. What a strong family. I am so looking forward to meeting them – just to hug them,” said 68-year-old Ziona Salzberg, one of the recipients.

“When this terrible incident happened, I looked at the TV and saw their beautiful, big blue eyes. I did not imagine even in my wildest dreams that I would get to see again thanks to them. I appreciate them and this noble act so much,” said recipient Ron Carmeli, 66.

“We were excited to receive the announcement about Hallel and Yagel’s cornea transplant this morning. We wish for the donors to see the world’s goodness and joy, as our sweet Hallel and Yagel saw it. Their good and beautiful eyes will continue to illuminate our world through these dear messengers, and we are filled with satisfaction that even after their death they were able to do good to others,” the bereaved parents said in a statement.

Hillel was studying in a joint army-biblical studies program known as Hesder and had recently completed his military service in the Navy. Yagel, a Hesder student, was set to enlist in a combat role.

The post 4 Israelis regain sight, thanks to corneas donated by family of young terror victims appeared first on World Israel News.

Zebra Attacks Man Nearly Dismembering His Arm, “I think he tore my arm off”

Ohio deputies responded to a call on Sunday evening in Circleville, OH. Ronald Clifton, 72 had just been severely attacked by a zebra.

When Clifton called 911 and reported the zebra attack, the dispatcher sounded shocked and asked Clifton to confirm that he was attacked by a zebra, to which he replied, “Oh hell yes.”

The zebra nearly dismembered Clifton’s arm. He told the dispatcher, “I think he tore my arm off…send a chopper.”

When officers arrived, they found Clifton lying on the ground, and his arm was bleeding below the elbow. A tourniquet was applied just below the shoulder, and two deputies managed to help the man get to an ambulance.

While one of the deputies tended to Clifton, the other reported that one of the workers on the property had instructed him to put down the zebra if necessary.

Moments later, it appeared the zebra was aggressive and, as captured on body camera footage, had taken steps to approach the deputy. As a warning and to protect himself, the officer shouted at the animal three times, but it did not back away.

In self-defense, the officer aimed a 12-gauge shotgun at the animal’s head and fired a slug.

The zebra was a male and had been defending the nearby five to six females. Clifton was taken to Grant Hospital, where he was treated for his injuries.

Police bust Arab weapons traffickers in Israeli cities, Judea and Samaria; 31 arrested

More than 400 policemen raided homes and other locations in eastern Jerusalem, Lod, Samaria and the Binyamin area.

By Pesach Benson, TPS

Israeli Police busted an arms trafficking network, arresting 25 weapons dealers in raids in Israel and Judea and Samaria on Tuesday morning.

During the course of an eight-month investigation, an undercover agent made dozens of transactions in which 31 weapons were purchased with matching ammunition. The weapons included 22 pistols of various types, nine M-16 assault rifles and three spray grenades, some of which are suspected to have been smuggled outside the borders of Israel.

Some of the assault rifles were converted from “airsoft” or BB guns into standard weapons capable of killing.

More than 400 policemen raided homes and other locations in eastern Jerusalem, Lod, Samaria and the Binyamin area. Among the detainees was a woman who used her Israeli citizenship to transport dealers and illegal immigrants in her car. Police seized weapon parts and three vehicles.

A number of drug dealers in Israel and the Palestinian Authority were also arrested.

Police Commissioner Kobi Shabtai said in a statement, “Many human lives were saved thanks to this action, as those weapons could have ended up in the wrong hands. We will continue to act against those criminals who deal in illegal weapons, some of which are used for serious crime and some of which leaks out and is used for terrorist activities.”

The post Police bust Arab weapons traffickers in Israeli cities, Judea and Samaria; 31 arrested appeared first on World Israel News.

Former Arafat aide and oldest Palestinian prisoner released from Israeli jail

Fuad Shubaki was sentenced for his role in attempting to smuggle weapons from Iran to the Gaza Strip.

By JNS

A former aide to Yasser Arafat and the oldest Palestinian prisoner in an Israeli jail was released on Monday after serving 17 years for arms smuggling, according to local media reports.

Fuad Shubaki, 83, was released from Ashkelon prison and was being transferred to Palestinian Authority-controlled Ramallah beyond the Green Line, said the reports.

Shubaki, a senior member of PA chief Mahmoud Abbas’s ruling Fatah faction, was sentenced for his role in attempting to smuggle weapons from Iran to the Gaza Strip aboard the Karine A.

The ship, seized by Israeli forces in 2002, was carrying 50 tons of weapons, including Katyusha rockets and anti-tank missiles, supplied by Iran and its Lebanon-based terror proxy Hezbollah.

Shubaki dealt with financial affairs for then-Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat and was convicted of purchasing the weapons through a foreign agent.

He was first detained by Palestinian security forces in 2002 and held in Jericho under U.S. and British supervision.

In 2006, the prison was raided by Israeli forces and Shubaki was taken to Israel, where he was tried in a military court and sentenced to two decades in jail.

His sentence was later reduced to 17 years.

The post Former Arafat aide and oldest Palestinian prisoner released from Israeli jail appeared first on World Israel News.

Selected Articles: China’s Initiative: Iran and Saudi Arabia Are Back on the Diplomatic Track. Ending the Atrocious War in Yemen?

China’s Initiative: Iran and Saudi Arabia Are Back on the Diplomatic Track. Ending the Atrocious War in Yemen?

By Peter Koenig, March 13, 2023

The Sunni Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the Shia Republic of Iran have agreed – …

The post Selected Articles: China’s Initiative: Iran and Saudi Arabia Are Back on the Diplomatic Track. Ending the Atrocious War in Yemen? appeared first on Global Research.

28-Year-Old Musician Dies After Collapsing on Stage

South Africa was rocked with tragedy this weekend when 28-year-old rapper and singer Costa Titch, known by his real name Constantinos Tsobanoglu, suddenly passed away. He had recently taken the stage at a popular music festival just hours before collapsing on stage. The footage went viral of the rapper falling over, gesturing for help, and then briefly standing up before falling again.

His family did not immediately disclose the cause of his death in their statement confirming the tragedy on his Instagram page. They expressed their devastation at the same festival he performed at, Ulta South Africa. They described Costa Titch as “a talented rapper, dancer, singer, songwriter, collaborator, and friend.”

Costa Titch, originally from South Africa, was an upcoming star of the amapiano genre, a subgenre of house music, characterized by deep house, wide percussive basslines and soulful piano melodies. His rap style seamlessly blended South African culture, style, and language into the popular trap music genre. One of his most successful singles, “Big Flexa,” saw major success on TikTok and won him fans across Africa. It was even remixed with help from Senegalese-American artist Akon.

South African music stars have been left reeling, with many paying tribute to Costa Titch’s life and impressive legacy. According to his family’s statement, they greatly appreciate the emergency responders and all those on the scene in his last hours. The rapper may be gone, but his spirit and style live on in the memories of his many fans.

Are China’s Resurgent Economic Cooperatives Preparation for Invading Taiwan?

A ghost that Chinese people are both familiar with and fearful of—a state-controlled supply and marketing system— has recently returned to the forefront of their minds. On Oct. 23, 2022, one day after the closing of the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) 20th National Congress, China’s central authorities announced the 2023 civil service exams, where the All-China Federation of Supply and Marketing Cooperatives is planning to significantly expand by recruiting more young people. 

In November 1949, after finally cementing control of China after decades of civil war, the CCP set up the Central Cooperative Administration, followed by the founding of the All-China Federation of Cooperatives in July 1950, which included production cooperatives, credit unions, and the resurgent subject of Chinese anxiety: Supply and Marketing Cooperatives (SMCs).

At the time, the SMCs, which ostensibly required farmers to buy shares and promised dividends, were in fact a copy of Soviet cooperatives. It was a transitional stage in preparation for an economy modeled on collective ownership—the collective farm, known in China as the people’s commune. Over time, the SMC system was further transformed from collective ownership to state ownership. The supply and marketing agency operated the centralized purchasing and marketing system.

In China’s reform and opening-up era, the SMCs faded amid market-oriented reforms. Toward the end of Hu Jintao’s rule in 2012, the SMC had basically shrunk to a symbolic agricultural service organization.

However, after Xi Jinping took power, the SMC began gradually returning to the forefront. SMCs have since flourished throughout the country, though without much fanfare until recently.  The Chinese people can only hope the new SMC system has learned from the experience of cooperatives in foreign countries and will not regress to the failed model of the Maoist planned economy.

In particular, Chinese scholars view Japanese agricultural cooperatives (JACs) favorably.  They are impressed by their tough attitude towards the Japanese government and insistence on defending the interests of farmers as expressed, for example, through the anti-TPP rally led by the JACs. However, most are unaware that JACs were once a war tool of the militarist Empire of Japan.  

JACs were established and supported by the Japanese government in the early 20th century. Then, when Japan became involved in WWII, the militarist government mobilized and forced all farmers to join JACs to contribute food and war materials to the state. At the time, JACs acted as an agency of the Japanese state.  Fortunately, following Japan’s democratization after WWII, JACs gained independence and became a powerful advocacy group on behalf of agricultural interests.

Xi’s CCP has demonstrated increasingly alarming militaristic tendencies in both domestic and foreign policy. Under such circumstances, will China’s SMCs follow the example of JACs as a war tool under Imperial Japan? The following signs are worth noting.

Since 2012 when SMCs began their revival under Xi, and especially since 2018 when they reappeared in the news after many years, they have quietly regained coverage of 95% of the countryside.

In June 2021, “Regulations on Supply and Marketing Cooperatives” were included in the “State Council’s 2021 Legislative Work Plan.” In November 2021, the CCP accelerated the reconstruction of SMCs. In October 2022, it announced that more than 1,300 grassroots SMC agencies had been restored in Hubei Province, covering all of the province’s townships and tallying over 450,000 employees.

There are now many SMC propaganda posters not only in townships but also in major cities like Beijing, a startling flashback to the China of half a century ago. It’s foreseeable that, after full coverage of the countryside, SMCs will spread even faster in the cities.

Many believe that Xi’s revival of SMCs is the result of China’s failure to integrate into the international community. It’s also thought that China’s decoupling from the United States is a foregone conclusion and that China must return to a planned economy and impose material controls to prevent social collapse.

However, a review of the re-emergence of the SMC reveals that the agency’s resurgence was determined long before the arrival of external pressures like the U.S.-China trade war, the Hong Kong democracy movement, the pandemic, the potential food crisis, and U.S.-China technological decoupling. Rather, every time external pressures emerge, the growth of the SMC accelerates.

One logical inference is that the resurgence of the SMC is meant to serve both a long-term and an emergency function. In the long term, it will help the government transition the economy to a greater degree of state control in times of peace to secure the “Chinese path to modernization,” i.e., achieving China’s modernization under the condition of two securities—Xi’s grip on power and the CCP’s rule. And, in the case of emergency, when extraordinary circumstances such as pandemics, wars, international sanctions and embargoes are encountered, the corresponding emergency measures will be activated.

Xi Jinping’s ambition to unify Taiwan—by force, if necessary—is undoubted. And his re-crowning at the 20th National Congress has made him ever more confident and determined. The Civilian-Military Fusion Committee and the reforms in the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) in the past few years have been very important measures in preparing for war. There is a Chinese saying, “Before the troops move, food and provisions go first.” Once the CCP starts to carry out war-ready reforms for the whole society, such as the restoration of SMCs, the world should be on high alert that China is gearing up to launch a military invasion of Taiwan.

The post Are China’s Resurgent Economic Cooperatives Preparation for Invading Taiwan? appeared first on Providence.