At Least 16 Dead after 6.8 Magnitude Earthquake

At least sixteen fatalities have been reported following a 6.8 magnitude earthquake that struck the southern region of Ecuador on Saturday.

The quake was located near the town of Baláo and had a depth of 65 km (about 41 miles), according to the United States Geological Survey. News of 381 injuries was reported by the General Secretariat of Communication of the Presidency of Ecuador.

In the province of El Oro, 11 deaths occurred, and one in the province of Azuay was caused by a wall falling onto a car. Three more in El Oro were due to a security camera tower collapsing. Those injured were taken to hospitals for treatment, but no further details were provided.

The USGS gave the tremor an “orange alert,” indicating a potential for “significant casualties” and possible “disaster” in the area. Some in the port city of Guayaquil felt very strong tremors.

Reports of structural damage to buildings in Cuenca, a major city listed in the UN’s world heritage sites, were confirmed by Ecuavisa, a news affiliate.

The National Weather Service did not issue a tsunami warning for the region. Airports in Guayaquil and Cuenca remain open and accessible.

Fresh shooting attack in Huwara: 2 Israelis wounded, 1 seriously

The assailant fled the scene. A suspect was arrested shortly afterwards.

By World Israel News Staff

Two people were injured in a shooting incident Sunday afternoon in Hawara, Samaria.

A terrorist opened fire at a passing Israeli vehicle and fled the scene. One of the victims, a man, suffered a serious head injury and was treated by Magen David Adom EMTs before being transferred to Beilinson Hospital

The lightly injured victims, reportedly in shock, managed to call for help.

Israeli security forces scanning the area of ​​the incident found a Carlo submachine gun – the kind manufactured in Palestinian-administered areas – that was left at the scene.

This is a developing story.

The post Fresh shooting attack in Huwara: 2 Israelis wounded, 1 seriously appeared first on World Israel News.

GROWING TIES: Muslim-majority country’s new envoy ‘proud’ to serve in Israel

Mukhtar Mammadov, Ambassador Designate of Republic of Azerbaijan to Israel, talks about the upcoming opening of the Azeri embassy in Tel Aviv.

The post GROWING TIES: Muslim-majority country’s new envoy ‘proud’ to serve in Israel appeared first on World Israel News.

Twenty Years Ago, the Iraq War Changed Everything — and Taught Elites Nothing

The ripple effects of the disastrous Iraq invasion still course through the Middle East and domestic US politics decades later. Yet there’s little evidence those in power have learned anything from it.

President George W. Bush with Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, Vice President Dick Cheney, and Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice after a meeting about the Iraq War in the White House in Washington, DC, January 5, 2006. (Brooks Kraft LLC / Corbis via Getty Images)

The first thing to remember about the Iraq War is that it was only meant to be the beginning.

You don’t have to take the word of former general Wesley Clark, a man who once nearly started World War III, and his claim that there existed a secret memo outlining plans for war on “seven countries in five years,” starting with Iraq and ending with Iran. The Bush administration’s own behavior, rhetoric, and later admissions made it abundantly clear that this was the idea.

Of course, George W. Bush’s invasion fell to shambles so quickly that he never had the chance to put this plan into action. Rather than being the starting gun for a series of US wars in the Middle East, the attack on Iraq instead became merely the signature disaster of the Bush presidency and — at least until recently — the entire twenty-first century, a Vietnam-like black hole insatiably pulling human lives, neighboring countries, and trillions of dollars into its death vortex.

For Iraqis, the war was a cruel and lasting generational cataclysm that killed hundreds of thousands and displaced millions, with parts of the country toxic to their inhabitants years after the war was nominally over thanks to US use of depleted uranium. The considerable US costs — including more than four thousand dead soldiers and nearly $3 trillion set aflame — pale in comparison. Yet even so, this week has been replete with US retrospectives on the war and what it means. Why, twenty years on, does the Iraq War still hold the place it does in our consciousness?

After all, the US invasion of Afghanistan — the other Vietnam-esque quagmire Bush dragged the country into, in this era of supersize wars — lasted far longer. And Iraq was by no means the last US-led regime-change war, with Obama condemning Libya to still-ongoing bedlam with his 2011 ouster of Muammar Gaddafi. What Bush and his underlings did in Iraq is hardly unique in the scope of US history, let alone just this century.

And yet there is something distinct about Iraq.

Lemons to Lemonade

Maybe it’s the extraordinary cynicism of the administration’s push for war, which involved not just “co-opting” global sympathy for the United States, as UK prime minister Tony Blair urged Bush to do the day after September 11, but manipulating ordinary Americans’ pain and anger over the attacks to create the consensus for an entirely unrelated war neocons had long slavered over.

Bush’s former counterterrorism advisor Richard Clarke and others memorably alleged that the then president almost immediately demanded aides find some connection to Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein in the attacks. Plenty of documents — like a top secret directive Bush signed six days later ordering the Pentagon to start war planning for Iraq — made it just as clear that he was determined from the start to take out Hussein no matter what.

Plenty of documents made it clear that Bush was determined from the start to take out Hussein no matter what.

Likewise, it took only hours after the 9/11 attacks for Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld to ask the vice chair of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and others if there was information “good enough [to] hit” Hussein at the same time as Osama bin Laden, and to order the Pentagon’s top lawyer to get “additional support” for the “connection w/ UBL [Osama bin Laden].” Two whole months before September 11, Rumsfeld had produced a memo suggesting a “more robust policy” against Hussein on the basis of “the danger of an increasingly bold and nuclear-armed Saddam in the near-future,” and claiming that his ouster would create “a much-improved position in the region” for the United States and “enhance US credibility and influence.”

Thanks to the slew of paperwork unlocked by the UK’s Iraq Inquiry, we can today read almost in real time as US and British officials schemed over a “clever strategy” for how to most effectively sell and justify an attack on Iraq to a largely reluctant world. Sending weapons inspectors into Iraq, they made clear, was merely a tool in this campaign. As Secretary of State Colin Powell explained to UK prime minister Tony Blair, the “over-riding objective is the removal of Saddam,” and if the dictator avoided the trap by allowing inspectors in, they would simply “find a new demand to justify military action.”

Misinformation From the Mainstream

All of this was bad enough. But as Powell’s words suggest, the administration’s determination to drag the country into war also involved a breathtaking and ferocious campaign of fearmongering, omissions, half-truths, and outright lies, all propagated at the highest levels.

Bush officials were ubiquitous on TV making the case for war, sometimes citing the very same dubious information they’d anonymously fed to the press as independent confirmation of the claims they were making. Internal dissent was ruthlessly ignored and suppressed, as when undercover CIA officer Valerie Plame was publicly outed to get back at her husband for disputing officials’ lies. Powell himself drew on the considerable esteem in which US liberals and foreign publics held him to make a pivotal pro-war case at the United Nations that he privately derided as “bullshit.”

We’ve arguably never seen this level of misinformation campaign in US politics, before or since. So relentless was the administration’s campaign of deceit that on the eve of the war, nearly two-thirds of the US public thought Hussein had played a role in the September 11 attacks, and upward of 90 percent believed that he had weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) or was developing them. The Trump administration’s comparatively lackluster and unsuccessful attempts to create a groundswell of support for regime change in countries like Cuba and Venezuela are a testament to how sophisticated this operation was.

We’ve arguably never seen this level of misinformation campaign in US politics, before or since.

None of it could have succeeded without the mainstream press. Long before the words “social” and “media” became a single noun, this avalanche of powerfully effective fake news emanated from the most establishment of establishment news outlets and no small number of liberal columnists, to the point that you can literally count the number of journalists who questioned the administration’s case on one hand. It took only two days after the 9/11 attacks for a reporter to bring up the nonexistent links between Hussein and bin Laden to Powell, and for the Wall Street Journal to cite “experts” that Iraq was “most likely to have helped” bin Laden. An exhaustive analysis of two weeks of coverage in the lead-up to the war by Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting found that 222 of the 297 current and retired officials that networks overwhelmingly relied on as guests were associated with governments backing the war, and that a mere four were critical of the invasion.

This all came with a stifling and aggressively censorious pro-war climate that makes the last few years’ worth of complaints about cancel culture look quaint. What little dissent from the official line existed was swiftly stamped out, with reporters and media personalities losing their jobs or outright ordered not to be critical of the war effort, while those with even an inkling of questioning the administration were scurrilously labeled as anti-American or pro-Hussein. Antiwar protesters were derided or cast as suspect. Even voices on the Left weren’t immune to this jingoistic fervor.

The media’s conduct didn’t get much better once the war began. The Iraq War continued, if not perfected, the art of “embedded journalism,” sidestepping the grave error officials had made in Vietnam, when they’d allowed reporters the leeway to honestly and independently tell the public what was happening on the battlefield.

Cable networks covered the campaign less like the brutal assault it was and more like the Super Bowl. In one infamous incident shortly after the invasion, CNN and other networks broadcast footage every four to seven minutes of a throng of Iraqis cheering as they toppled a statue of Hussein. The reality was that the square was nearly empty, that the small crowd was largely reporters and US marines, and that the Iraqi who sledgehammered the statue later regretted it, having become a refugee in the post-invasion chaos and now fantasizing about killing Bush and Blair with his bare hands.

Cable networks covered the campaign less like the brutal assault it was and more like the Super Bowl.

No matter. Media coverage of the war soon dropped off, and the US public was led to believe the war was won and done, a belief soon tested by the outbreak of civil war in Iraq, the steady stream of body bags coming home from Iraq, and the failure of any WMDs to materialize.

It’s no coincidence that Americans’ trust in the media dipped in 2004, as the mission in Iraq started to look more and more distinctly unaccomplished. That trust has only deteriorated ever since. The press has never really recovered, a state of affairs helped along by a widespread refusal to self-reflect on this failure, much less accept responsibility for it. The years since have instead set off a desperate search for scapegoats, be it Donald Trump or social media.

A Spreading Cancer

But as the war’s fallout stretched far into this century, collapsing faith in the press would prove to be only one facet of its political cost. A slow-twisting dagger in the side of the Bush presidency for the rest of his two terms, the war would go on to both make and break politicians, helping account for the rise of Barack Obama (and, stunningly, Donald Trump), and contributing to the shocking defeats of Jeb Bush and Hillary Clinton. Meanwhile, it’s hard to find a young leftist today in the United States (and beyond) for whom the invasion wasn’t one of their formative, radicalizing experiences.

The unambiguous catastrophe that the war became set off a genuine shift in US public opinion more generally, as Washington politicians succeeded in somehow getting more Americans killed than had died in the terrorist attack that was supposed to have justified the war. Public sentiment soon lurched away from the hawkish view that had prevailed since the Reagan era, and toward less military adventurism, more restraint, and an emphasis on securing prosperity at home. Even if US elites today remain slow to catch up to the rest of the country, this public shift has inflicted real political costs on those running against it, enough that the war’s architects are still whining today that the resulting “Iraq syndrome” has stopped them from getting all the wars they’ve wanted in the intervening years.

Beyond domestic politics, the reputational damage the war inflicted on the United States globally was immense.

Beyond domestic politics, the reputational damage the war inflicted on the United States globally was immense. Washington had been enjoying the “unipolar moment” for barely more than a decade when Bush invaded Iraq, triggering unprecedented global opposition, while running roughshod over international law, multilateralism, and the “norms” in which US officials now unconvincingly drape themselves.

If the United States was the undisputed global power, it had suddenly revealed itself as a profoundly erratic, irresponsible, and dangerous one. Iraq to this day remains a sticking point for a Global South unwilling to align with the United States over the invasion of Ukraine, and is no minor cause of the United States’ potential displacement in the region by what US officials see as their leading rival, China.

Geopolitical blowback for US elites continued in the form of strengthening Washington’s other major adversary in the region, Iran — which used the ensuing power vacuum to boost its influence in Iraq, whose Shia majority was no longer held down by the dictatorial, Sunni hand of Hussein. When Trump very nearly started a war with Iran by assassinating Qassem Soleimani in 2020, it was as the powerful Iranian general was heading to Baghdad, a common practice for the man who used the Bush-created void in Iraq to extend his government’s military and political sway inside of Iran’s former foe. Even on the foreign policy establishment’s own narrow, power-seeking terms, in other words, the invasion was one big case of Washington elites shooting themselves in the foot.

The chaos that defined Iraq only metastasized in the years that followed, in large part due to the administration’s arrogance and laziness. Not caring to properly understand the country it was occupying, the Bush administration blundered forward against official advice with its policy of “de-Ba’athification” and disbanding of the Iraqi military. This contributed to the creation of an army of bitter Iraqis who wound up helping to form ISIS — which cut a swath of terror and death across not just Iraq but also Syria, and which necessitated yet more US troop deployments, foreign occupations, and endless wars in the region that persist today.

Sold as an action to fight terrorism, the invasion of Iraq was instead terrorism’s greatest gift.

Sold as an action to fight terrorism, the invasion of Iraq was instead terrorism’s greatest gift. Meanwhile, twenty years later, US soldiers are still in Iraq, more than a decade after the official withdrawal.

Miles to Go

It’s still an open question how much elites have really learned from Iraq, and how much has really changed.

No subsequent administration has had the appetite for more ground invasions that cost US lives and money, including Trump’s administration, which preferred to try regime change in countries like Venezuela using economic warfare and local proxies. But as Trump’s four years showed, whether in Venezuela or Cuba, regime change and military adventurism are still at the top of the menu for US foreign policy.

Leaders continue to try their hand at Bush’s folly, even as Iraq should’ve beaten into the heads of everyone alive that the ability to militarily subdue a country isn’t the same as winning a war, and how quickly and easily things spiral out of one’s control when a leader is violently toppled. Obama blasted Bush while repeating his policy in Libya with similarly horrendous results and intensifying similar efforts in Syria. Commentators and officials today talk with breathtaking glibness about regime change as a solution to Russian aggression. And of course, it’s not just US leaders: Russian president Vladimir Putin’s disastrous invasion of Ukraine has followed Bush’s playbook almost to a T, from faulty intelligence and expectations of being greeted as a liberator to poor war planning and empowering local extremists.

Leaders continue to try their hand at Bush’s folly, even as Iraq should’ve beaten into the heads of everyone alive that the ability to militarily subdue a country isn’t the same as winning a war.

The architects and major backers of the war, meanwhile, have suffered no consequences, moving on to plum positions in US intellectual circles and policy making. Bush is now a beloved elder statesman who has dipped his toe back into politics. John Bolton is now running for the GOP nomination after a stint as national security advisor to another Republican president. Propagandists for the war — whether David Frum, Nicole Wallace, or Ari Fleischer — populate the nation’s media platforms. Some, like Bill Kristol, who led the call to Bush to invade “even if evidence does not link Iraq directly to the [September 11] attack,” are now influential in liberal circles. Dick Cheney’s advisor as he engineered the war is now a top state department official shaping US involvement in the Ukraine war. The leading Democratic architect of the invasion is the president.

Maybe Iraq’s lasting legacy is the psychic break it triggered for Americans at the height of post–Cold War supremacy — a violent, ongoing reminder that those who rise to the top of US media and political institutions may not in fact be all that bright, or all that good, fueling the signature cynicism and rage of the era we’re living through. As for the lessons it holds about the limits of US military power and the perils of seeking hegemony at all costs, it looks like those are yet to be learned. But it’s not too late.

Netanyahu touts elimination of ‘dozens’ of Arab terrorists, vows crackdown on anti-judicial reform ‘anarchy’

Following apparent assassination of senior terrorist in Syria,  Netanyahu vows continued crackdown on terror – and on anti-judicial reform protests that spread ‘anarchy.’

By World Israel News Staff

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed his government will take a tough stance on terrorists, and that the police will crackdown on critics of the judicial reform plan whose protests promote “anarchy.”

Speaking at the start of the government’s weekly Cabinet meeting Sunday, Netanyahu laid out the agenda for the government, highlighting efforts to build an international coalition to bar Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons, the recent spate of Arab terror attacks, and lawlessness at some anti-judicial reform protests.

“Today, I will discuss our three struggles: Against the Iranian nuclear program, against terrorism and against anarchy. First, the diplomatic struggle. The Government of Israel is continuing the struggle against the Iranian nuclear program.”

“Last week I met with German Chancellor Olaf Scholz. I stood together with the Chancellor on the platform in Berlin from which Jews were sent to the death camps.”

“As opposed to the past, today when we face the extremist regime in Tehran, which seeks to obliterate us from the face of the earth, we do everything necessary to defend ourselves. Like I say to world leaders and as I told Chancellor Scholz, the Jewish state will not allow another Holocaust.”

The prime minister alluded to last week’s bombing attack at the Megiddo Junction in northern Israel which left one man seriously wounded.

Netanyahu touted the “dozens of terrorists” eliminated by Israeli security forces in recent weeks, and vowed authorities would bring terrorists “everywhere” to justice

“Our forces are active around the clock in order to settle accounts with the terrorists and thwart terrorist infrastructure. Dozens of terrorists have been eliminated in the past month; many others have been arrested.”

“Whoever tries to harm Israeli citizens will pay the price. We will find the terrorists and the architects of terrorism everywhere.”

Netanyahu’s comments came just hours after the Islamic Jihad terrorist group claimed that a senior member of its military wing had been shot and killed by Israeli agents in Syria.

Amid ongoing protests, including rallies Saturday night that descended into violence, Netanyahu warned that the movement against the judicial overhaul plan is spreading “anarchy.”

“We will not accept anarchy. There are those who are calling for the blocking of highways, for refusal, for blood in the streets, and to attack public figures. We will not accept this. We will not accept violence – by any side.”

I expect the Inspector General and the police to enforce the law, to prevent violence and the blocking of roads, and to allow the daily life of the citizens of the country.”

“I expect the Shin Bet and the State Attorney’s Office to take determined action against those who incite to murder ministers and MKs, and the Prime Minister and his family, without turning a blind eye, without cutting slack and without cutting corners. I expect the IDF Chief-of-Staff and the heads of the security services to vigorously fight against refusal to serve. There is no place for refusal to serve in the public discourse. A state that values life cannot tolerate such phenomena and we will not tolerate them.”

“Instead of incitement and calls to anarchy, instead of the awareness engineering by the propaganda channels, there needs to be a genuine, substantive and fair discussion of the judicial reform. The foundation of democracy is the balance between the three authorities: The legislative, the executive and the judicial. This balance has been overturned in Israel in recent decades in a way that has not happened in any democracy in the world.”

The post Netanyahu touts elimination of ‘dozens’ of Arab terrorists, vows crackdown on anti-judicial reform ‘anarchy’ appeared first on World Israel News.

Protester arrested for vandalizing Modi’in home of Israeli justice minister

The suspect, a resident of the city in his 60s, allegedly spray-painted “Enemy of the People” on a wall outside Justice Minister Yariv Levin’s residence.

By JNS

A man was arrested on Saturday for vandalizing a wall outside Israeli Justice Minister Yariv Levin’s home in Modi’in on Thursday.

The man, a resident of the city in his 60s, had spray-painted “the enemy of the people” on the wall, in the context of the judicial reform plan being spearheaded by Levin.

Separately on Saturday, a man was arrested for threatening Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in a video posted to social media.

On Saturday evening, Israelis took to the streets to protest the judicial reforms for the 11th straight week.

“Next week, Israel’s government intends to pass the dictatorship and religious coercion law. Every citizen must come out and take a stand in these fateful moments of the State of Israel. Together, hundreds of thousands will save Israeli democracy,” protest organizers said in a statement.

They vowed to escalate demonstrations if the coalition does not halt the legislative process associated with the reforms, declaring this coming Thursday a “National Day of Paralysis.”

Anti-reform protesters last week blocked roads, the Haifa port and Ben-Gurion Airport, and destroyed property on a day of ‘escalating resistance.’

Netanyahu has repeatedly called on the opposition to engage in negotiations without preconditions, overtures that have been summarily rejected.

The Israeli premier reiterated last Sunday that he had been elected to pursue change and accused the opposition of trying to overthrow his government.

“Only four months ago, we held elections. The government I head received a clear mandate from the citizens of Israel. The fact that for two whole months, our repeated calls for dialogue received no response from the opposition proves that what interests the opposition is not the judicial reforms, but the creation of anarchy and the overthrow of the elected government,” he said.

“It is impossible to be in favor of the success of the Israeli economy and to encourage the flight of funds from Israel. It is impossible to be in favor of the rule of law and to encourage violations of the law. It is impossible to be in favor of the security of the state and to encourage insubordination that would collapse the security of the state,” said the premier.

“There is no conditional Zionism,” he added.

The post Protester arrested for vandalizing Modi’in home of Israeli justice minister appeared first on World Israel News.

Let’s Talk About the COVID-19 Lab Leak Theory

Whether COVID emerged from nature or from a laboratory leak is a legitimate debate. We still don’t have all the answers, but how that discussion was stifled bodes poorly for scientific inquiry.

Security personnel stand guard outside the Wuhan Institute of Virology as members of the World Health Organization team investigating the origins of COVID-19 visit. February 3, 2021. (Hector Retamal / AFP via Getty Images)

The following is a preview from the spring edition of Jacobin, “Conspiracy.” You can subscribe today for a year of our print edition (digital access included) for just $10.

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, social media platforms began to flag, downgrade, or remove a range of posts that these companies said were spreading misinformation about the virus. Facebook’s list of COVID-related content that is subject to removal for violating its community standards is very long, from claims that the illness can be cured by herbal remedies to posts that say the vaccines contain microchips or are ineffective. In February 2021, the firm expanded its list to include any posts making claims that the virus was man-made or does not have a natural origin. Google likewise altered its auto-complete capability so that anyone typing in “coronavirus lab leak” or similar phrasing would not see their search query autofilled, whether via the search engine directly or its subsidiary YouTube, so as to not lead “people down pathways that we would find to be not authoritative information.”

This policing of what is acceptable and unacceptable to say was not limited to social media. Following accusations from the likes of Republican senator Tom Cotton in February 2020, as well as President Donald Trump’s predilection for calling COVID-19 “kung flu” and the “China virus,” an open letter from twenty-seven high-profile public health scientists was published in the Lancet, the prestigious British medical publication, denouncing the “rumours and misinformation” about the origin of the virus. “We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin,” they wrote. Researchers from multiple countries who had performed genomic analysis of SARS-CoV-2, they said, “overwhelmingly conclude that this coronavirus originated in wildlife.”

The signatories further attempted to demonstrate this overwhelming scientific consensus by stating that the presidents of the US National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine and “the scientific communities they represent” had written a letter to the White House confirming the virus’s bat-derived origin, and that the director-general of the World Health Organization had issued a call to “promote scientific evidence and unity over misinformation and conjecture.” The authors of the letter said that suggesting anything other than a natural origin of the disease did nothing “but create fear, rumours, and prejudice” and that, contrary to this, they were standing in solidarity with the science and health professionals of China.

Those who accepted the natural origin story were on the side of the scientific consensus, like those who accepted natural selection against creationism, and anyone who suggested otherwise was not just a conspiracist, like those who believe NASA faked the moon landing, but was a racist conspiracist to boot.

The Two Theories

In a hyperpolarized media environment, because it was the likes of Tom Cotton and Donald Trump who had hinted at a lab leak, any discussion that this might be a hypothesis worth testing became verboten for much of the press. Even the New York Times dismissed the claim as a “fringe theory,” and the Washington Post categorized it as a “conspiracy theory.” And so when the liberal media refused, for the most part, to consider the question, the always inflammatory right-wing media was more than happy to oblige, with all its predilection for exaggeration and hate. Thus, out of fear that even objective investigation of the lab leak question would result in prejudice, prejudice was what resulted.

Assessment of the validity of a scientific statement had retreated from its dependence on empirical evidence. Validity was now assessed instead based on who was making the statement. Argument from evidence had been replaced with argument from authority. It does not matter what your telescope says, Galileo, for it is the Church that decrees Jupiter can have no moons.

But then, in late February 2023, the Wall Street Journal reported that the US Department of Energy had concluded the most likely origin of the COVID-19 pandemic was indeed a laboratory leak. Such resolutions, albeit made with “low confidence,” parallel those reached by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), the latter’s with “moderate confidence.” Four other intelligence agencies and the National Intelligence Council still believe the virus spilled over from an infected animal — a zoonotic transmission — also with low confidence. The Central Intelligence Agency is undecided. That is, all the agencies concerned have low or moderate confidence, or are sitting on the fence, and no one has high confidence in either hypothesis.

Because the Department of Energy and the FBI are both operating under the direction of a Democratic president this time, it has become permissible to consider the lab leak hypothesis without being accused of racism or conspiracism. It is not that any new evidence has been presented, but who is presenting the evidence has changed. And so, despite the thawing of the discourse, this is not yet an improvement with respect to science.

To be clear, no agency believes the pandemic was the result of a bioweapons program. Instead, any leak could have been the result of an accident at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which is located near where the outbreak first occurred and which studies coronaviruses. Such an accident could have occurred in any number of ways. Perhaps it was from “gain-of-function” research — genetically altering a pathogen to better understand it and try to predict its “next move” evolutionarily, thus developing a vaccine or other response before that move happens. Figures such as Republican Rand Paul have criticized gain-of-function research as “fooling with Mother Nature,” and liberals like economist Jeffrey Sachs and political comedian Jon Stewart have been no less anxious about “mad scientists” who know not what they have wrought. But perhaps gain-of-function research had nothing to do with the leak. Perhaps biosecurity measures were not sufficient or failed, and such an altered virus escaped. The original SARS virus, which first emerged in 2002, has escaped from extremely secure labs a total of six times. Or perhaps it could have been as simple as a researcher becoming infected while collecting virus samples from a bat cave.

Regardless of how a leak happened, if it did happen, the rationale for such a hypothesis rests on three observations: on the fact that researchers have tested tens of thousands of wildlife samples without finding the virus in any animal other than humans; on the proximity of the Wuhan Institute of Virology to the outbreak; and on intelligence that three researchers from that institute became so ill they were admitted to the hospital in November 2019, around the time of the outbreak.

But there is no smoking gun. No one is very confident at all that a lab leak was the origin of the COVID-19 pandemic. They just think it is slightly more likely.

The rationale for the alternative, natural origin hypothesis is that zoonotic origin is how all other novel infectious diseases have emerged; that the outbreak region does have a thriving wildlife trade that pushes its merchants and suppliers into close contact with animals known to be reservoirs of coronaviruses; and that China appears to have been as taken by surprise by the outbreak as anyone else.

Again, the partisans of natural origin also have low confidence in this hypothesis. They just think theirs is the one that is slightly more likely.

To be fair, something of a thaw had begun in 2021, when the FBI first made noises about a lab leak and when, around the same time, another group of high-profile scientists, including key figures in the world of virology, published their own open letter, this time in the journal Science, arguing that both the lab leak and the zoonotic spillover hypotheses were viable. But it was the Department of Energy reveal in late February that has opened the floodgates.

Defending the Scientific Revolution

Science is not a battle of partisan authorities. It is a battle of evidence. What distinguishes the Scientific Revolution from all other ways of knowing that came before, all other facts about the world that had previously been discovered, was the deceptively simple but radical epistemological break that is the scientific method. An observation about the world prompts a hypothesis — a possible explanation of why something is the way it is — which is followed by a test of that hypothesis, which in turn prompts more observations, and then more hypotheses and more tests of those hypotheses. All that matters is evidence. It matters not who is making the hypothesis, performing the test, or doing the observing.

Prior to the Scientific Revolution, evidence was secondary to the authority of who was making a truth claim. But because the predictive power of the scientific method is vastly superior to superstition or tradition, there is a tendency sometimes for scientists to be wielded as a new authority, or for scientists to treat themselves that way.

The Scientific Revolution, and the Enlightenment of which it was a part, came about at the time they did because of the great, centuries-long antiauthoritarian tumult that stretched from the Reformation through to the American and French revolutions. The scientific method necessarily depends upon an egalitarian foundation for a rejection of the belief that any bishop or lord, pope or king is better than anyone else — that anyone at all knows better than anyone else by dint of who they are.

Today the mask debate, like the lab leak debate, as well as debates over school closures, lockdowns, and vaccines, is settled in the minds of too many people on the basis of whether they view the given partisans of a position as good people, and not on the evidence provided.

Pandemic policy is too important to return to a pre-Galilean assessment of truth based on an appeal to authority. So let journalists, social media firms, public officials, and scientists expunge from our vocabularies the unscientific phrases “scientists say” and “science denial.” Let us instead re-embrace the motto of the oldest scientific body in the world, Britain’s Royal Society, “Nullius in verba,” which can be roughly translated from Latin as “Take nobody’s word for it.”

Antisemitism on campus: Students rewarded for attending hateful anti-Israel events at NY college

Brooklyn community college offers extra credit for students who participate in one-sided, biased anti-Israel events; Advocacy group says Jewish students no longer feel safe on campus.

By World Israel News Staff

Students at a community college in New York city are offered extra credit for participating in anti-Israel, antisemitic events on campus that present a one-sided version of the Israeli-Arab conflict, says a watchdog group.

S.A.F.E. CUNY, an NGO that “advocates for Zionist Jews systematically discriminated against and excluded” at CUNY, expressed concern last week about an exhibit approved by senior administrators at Borough of Manhattan Community College (BMCC-CUNY).

The exhibit, which was displayed in a “highly-trafficked, public area,” expressed sympathy with “Intifada (a call to murder Israeli Jews),” S.A.F.E. CUNY wrote on its Twitter account.

BREAKING: Yesterday, we were tipped off to a truly horrifying, deeply antisemitic CUNY-sponsored display posted by @bmcc_cuny administrators in a highly-trafficked, public area. We share images here.

In addition to sympathizing with Intifada (a call to murder Israeli Jews),… https://t.co/cwJMBfVnuj pic.twitter.com/1FWMfyEmNa

— SAFE CUNY (@SAFECUNY) March 16, 2023

“Among the falsehoods and tropes leveled at Jews and Israel: 1) That Israel “targeted” journalist Shireen Abu Akleh for murder; 2) that Israel is guilty of ‘ethnic cleansing’; 3) that Israel is a settler-colonial state; and more,” the group continued.

Dr. Jenna Hirsch, Associate Professor of Mathematics at CUNY- BMCC, told United with Israel that she was stunned the clearly biased exhibit had been approved by administrators.

VIDEO of the antisemitic display that now adorns @bmcc_cuny‘s hallways, sponsored by BMCC. Thank you to the courageous person who provided this to us. You can really get a sense of how prominent it is. pic.twitter.com/D16OzOVvH2

— SAFE CUNY (@SAFECUNY) March 16, 2023

“I went inside and a girl behind the desk told me that they indeed sanctioned the exhibit under the auspices of the director of the program. I didn’t believe her, so I asked her again – ‘Are you sure the director knows about this exhibit and allowed the students to put it up?’ She assured me they did.”

Notably, the exhibit is part of an ongoing series of events disseminating anti-Israel and antisemitic propaganda, which was organized by CUNY-BMCC’s Social Justice and Equity Center director, Nadia Saleh.

“The students are actually offered official credit, which will appear on their BMCC transcript for participating in these anti-Israel events!” Dr. Avraham Goldstein, Assistant Professor of Mathematics at CUNY- BMCC, told United With Israel.

“S.A.F.E. CUNY should bring to the public attention that as a result of these systematic anti-Israel activities, visibly Jewish students and faculty, and especially Orthodox Jews and Israelis and Zionist Jews, no longer feel safe on campus,” Goldstein continued.

“We believe that the rise of the antisemitic assaults and attacks on the CUNY campuses in the recent year or two (as admitted even by the top CUNY officials themselves) is caused by this anti-Israel hysteria promoted by BMCC Social Justice & Equity Centers and their systemic campaigns of hate and libeling.”

Goldstein encouraged donors to reconsider giving funds to the school until “the situation is straightened out,” and encouraged S.A.F.E. CUNY to examine any legal actions at their disposal.

The post Antisemitism on campus: Students rewarded for attending hateful anti-Israel events at NY college appeared first on World Israel News.

Nearly three in four Palestinians back Huwara terror attack—poll

For the first time since the establishment of the P.A., a majority (52%) of Palestinians now support its dissolution, according to the Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research.

By JNS

Seventy-one percent of Palestinians support the terrorist murder of two Israeli Jews in Huwara, Samaria, on Feb. 26, according to a public opinion poll conducted earlier this month. Only 21% of those surveyed were against the attack and similar armed attacks.

Brothers Hallel Yaniv, 21, and Yagel Yaniv, 19, were shot by a Palestinian terrorist as they sat in traffic in the Arab village.

The poll, conducted by The Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research in partnership with the Ramallah office of the German think tank Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, shows a general hardening of attitudes in the Palestinian Authority population, with growing support for terrorism in the conflict with Israel.

For the first time since the establishment of the Palestinian Authority, a majority (52%) now support its dissolution, while just 42% say the continuation of the PA is in the interest of the Palestinian people.

For the study, 1,200 adults were interviewed in person at 120 randomly selected locations in the Gaza Strip and Judea and Samaria between March 8-11, 2023, according to PCPSR. The margin of error is 3%.

“Public evaluation of internal conditions points to a greater deterioration in the standing of the P.A. and a significant loss of trust in it,” PCPSR said in a press release.

“Findings show a rise in the belief that the P.A. is now a burden on the Palestinian people and for the first time in our polls, a majority supports the dissolution of the PA and views its collapse as an interest for the Palestinian people. In fact, a majority thinks that the continued existence of the PA serves the interests of Israel and that its dissolution or collapse would strengthen Palestinian armed groups.”

Only 27% of Palestinians support the concept of the two-state solution while 71% oppose the concept.

Seventy-three percent opposed and only 21% supported Palestinian attendance at last month’s security summit in Aqaba, Jordan, in an effort to stop the escalation of the armed conflict in Judea and Samaria.

A second regional security summit discussing security coordination between Israel and the P.A. ahead of Ramadan was scheduled for Sunday in the Egyptian Red Sea resort town of Sharm el-Sheikh.

The post Nearly three in four Palestinians back Huwara terror attack—poll appeared first on World Israel News.