Emmanuel Macron Is Using the 2024 Olympics to Make France a Surveillance State

A new security law from Emmanuel Macron’s government will roll out an AI-based biometric categorization system. The law is billed as a measure for the 2024 Paris Olympics — but also allows a vast expansion of intrusive surveillance.

LE ROVE, FRANCE – 2021/02/02: Surveillance cameras in Le Rove, France.
More and more French municipalities are using surveillance cameras to monitor motorists. (Photo by Gerard Bottino/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)

Guillermo Federico Ibarrola was waiting for a train in the Buenos Aires metro when he was picked up by two police officers, booked and detained for six days. Ibarrola hadn’t committed a crime, nor was he a witness to one. Rather, Ibarrola was the unfortunate victim of a glitch in the city’s newfangled, artificial intelligence–based facial recognition system, installed citywide in 2019 and now covering 75 percent of the Argentinian capital.

Even some years after such biometric systems were developed, most European capitals haven’t followed Argentina’s example. But now, this could change. As large swaths of France take to the streets in protest against a proposed rise in the pension age, the National Assembly has been quietly pushing forward a bill related to the upcoming 2024 Olympics that privacy experts say will drastically increase the state’s policing and surveillance capacities.

The so-called Olympics and Paralympics law is being fast-tracked through Parliament after being proposed by Emmanuel Macron’s ruling Renaissance party (formerly En Marche!) last December. If adopted, it will pave the way for the installation of a controversial, if “experimental” according to its proponents, AI-based biometric categorization system aimed at detecting “predetermined events,” such as crowd movements, terrorist attacks, or acts of violence. In short, the bill is named after the Olympics, but it’s about much more.

“The government’s intention through the bill is to increase the social acceptability in France of generalized surveillance,” Elisa Martin, a deputy from the left-wing New Ecological and Social Popular Union (NUPES) coalition, told Jacobin.

An “Experimental” System

At the heart of the controversy surrounding the proposed Olympics and Paralympics bill is Article 7. This article states that “images collected by means of video protection systems,” including surveillance cameras around stadiums, metros, and other areas, “may be subject to processing, including through an artificial intelligence system.”

The proposed AI-based system is “experimental,” the authors write, and was initially planned to last through June 2025 — well beyond the Olympic Games, which are slated for August 2024. (This was later amended to last through the end of December 2024.) According to the authors of the law, the system would not include facial or biometric identification, but rather would use AI to identify “atypical” or “risky” behavior, such as standing in place for long periods of time or loud voices.

Privacy advocates say that while these systems are billed as not including facial recognition, for all intents and purposes they can be used in the same way.

The bill is named after the Olympics, but it’s about much more.

“There’s a whole range of things you can do with that data,” including grouping people together by hair or skin color, recognizing emotions and making inferences about behavior based on these categories, Daniel Leufer, a senior policy analyst at Access Now, told me. “You’re capturing people’s behavior, the way they walk, the way that they’re shouting. The types of data that you’re gathering or processing about people will allow for them to be identified.”

In recent weeks, civil society groups have joined the chorus of mostly left-wing politicians opposing the law. On March 7, thirty-eight organizations, including Access Now, Amnesty International, and AlgorithmWatch, a Berlin-based AI watchdog group, signed an open letter asking for Article 7 to be removed from the law.

Katia Roux, who heads advocacy at Amnesty International France, told Jacobin that the law, in addition to infringing on antidiscrimination and privacy standards, “can have an extremely dissuasive effect on the freedom of expression, the freedom of peaceful assembly.” “When we know we’re being surveilled, or when we think we’re under surveillance obviously we don’t act the same way,” she said. “There can be a form of self-censorship.”

That the system would be deployed in Saint-Denis, the largely minority, working-class suburb north of Paris where much of the Olympics infrastructure is being built, she added, only adds to the potential for misuse.

Martin, from NUPES, noted that Article 7 is not the only concerning element of the Olympics and Paralympics law. It also includes US Transportation Security Administration (TSA)–style body scanners at the entrance to stadiums and the deployment of tens of thousands of police during the upcoming Games.

The proposed law, she added, is one of several laws and directives passed in recent months that aim to criminalize dissent in France, including a directive passed by the Interior Ministry that greatly expands the scope of misdemeanor fines. “Who is this aimed at? It’s aimed at poor people, it’s aimed at activists,” she said. “It’s part of a civil liberty-threatening continuum that’s being slowly and steadily reinforced.”

Surveillance Shock Doctrine

This wouldn’t be the first time the Olympics are used to push through extensive security measures, Jules Boykoff, the author of the book Power Games: A Political History of the Olympics, told me.

“When it comes to policing and the Olympics, local and national police forces in the host city and country use the Olympics like their own private cash machine, getting all the funding, special weapons and even laws that it would be very difficult to get during normal political times,” Boykoff told Jacobin. “And so, what we’re seeing transpire in Paris is what we see transpire in numerous cities.”

The 2004 Summer Olympics in Athens were a case in point.

In France, activists worry that the ‘state of exception’ created by the Olympics will lead to a long-term build-up of surveillance technology.

Throughout those Games — the first to take place after 9/11 — a large blimp fitted with cameras surveilled Athens. Seventy-thousand police and military forces marauded the streets. In computer centers hidden from public view, security agents monitored thousands of surveillance cameras that had been set up to identify “suspicious behavior.”

The security was so intensive that one Greek scholar referred to that year’s Olympics as a “super-panopticon,” in reference to a nineteenth-century prison design that allowed one guard to simultaneously monitor all of a penitentiary’s inmates without them being able to tell if they’re being watched.

Rio de Janeiro and Tokyo, other host cities, saw similarly expansive security measures passed, Boykoff writes in Power Games.

In France, activists worry that the “state of exception” created by the Olympics will lead to a long-term buildup of surveillance technology, much as it did in Greece — which is currently in the midst of a spying scandal nicknamed Predator-gate, brought about by allegations that the ruling party used a spyware tool called Predator to spy on journalists and politicians.

“The Olympics are an accelerator of surveillance,” “Alouette,” a privacy activist at La Quadrature du Net, a digital rights group, who preferred to remain anonymous for security reasons, told Jacobin. “For the security industry, especially the French industry, they are a huge opportunity.” French, and international, surveillance companies “really see the Olympic Games as a security showcase that allows them to show off their know-how,” she added.

While it’s unclear which company would provide the technology for AI-based surveillance for the Olympics, one company, the Israeli firm BriefCam, already deploys video surveillance technologies in more than two hundred municipalities across France, La Quadrature has noted.

To Boykoff, the idea of using the Olympics to push through these types of measures is common because of the popular nature of the Games. “You get people kind of used to it in that happy face, celebration capitalism environment of the Olympics, and then that new technology that was injected during the Games in that state of exception becomes the norm for policing moving forward.”

A European Precedent

The French law also comes as the European Union is preparing to pass an AI Act that would regulate artificial intelligence. This legislation, proposed in April 2021, could be adopted as soon as next month, and would place significant restrictions on algorithmic video surveillance.

According to Roux, the passage of the Olympic law would position France as Europe’s “champion of surveillance” and could be used as a way to hack at the AI bill from below, weakening future surveillance legislation in the EU.

“The precedent that it creates and the signal it sends to member states is extremely dangerous,” she said.

Other security experts, meanwhile, questioned the effectiveness of algorithmic surveillance.

“You have an inherent problem if you’re using machine learning to predict rare events,” Leufer said. “If that’s what you’re doing with your system, that should be a red flag already. That’s precisely the type of thing that machine learning is not good at. The less data you have on the type of thing that you’re trying to predict, the worse the system is going to be at it.”

U.S. Drone Forced Down in Black Sea Was Gathering Intelligence for Ukrainian Forces. Scott Ritter

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …

The post U.S. Drone Forced Down in Black Sea Was Gathering Intelligence for Ukrainian Forces. Scott Ritter appeared first on Global Research.

Fact Check: Member of House of Lords Uses Mainstream Media to Claim That “Antivaxxers are a global menace who must be defeated”; So Why Did the Triple+ Vaccinated Account for 92% of All COVID Deaths in 2022? And Why Are Mortality Rates Per 100k Lowest Among the Unvaccinated (Antivaxxers)?

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …

The post Fact Check: Member of House of Lords Uses Mainstream Media to Claim That “Antivaxxers are a global menace who must be defeated”; So Why Did the Triple+ Vaccinated Account for 92% of All COVID Deaths in 2022? And Why Are Mortality Rates Per 100k Lowest Among the Unvaccinated (Antivaxxers)? appeared first on Global Research.

From Balloons to AUKUS: The War Drive Against China

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …

The post From Balloons to AUKUS: The War Drive Against China appeared first on Global Research.

Temple Mount rioters and TikTok terror: Israeli police gearing up for Ramadan

The Jerusalem police are “working hand-in-hand” with the IDF and Israeli security agencies to prevent violence and terror during the upcoming Ramadan holiday.

By Lauren Marcus, World Israel News

Jerusalem police units are working “hand-in-hand” with Israel’s security agencies and the military to ensure safety and public order in Jerusalem during the upcoming Ramadan holiday, which will see a major influx in visitors to the city, officials told World Israel News.

During a media conference, senior Israeli police officials said that they are bolstering the number of police officers on patrol near the Old City, at Damascus Gate, and the seam line between east and west Jerusalem.

Border Police officers and military troops will provide reinforcements on the ground, the officials said, with the goal of “increasing operational readiness.”

Jerusalem police officers have undergone “cultural sensitivity training” for best practices on interacting with Muslim pilgrims to Jerusalem, many of whom are expected to visit the city from Palestinian Authority-controlled areas in Judea and Samaria.

“We also have Arab Muslim and Arab Christian police officers in our ranks who are going to help us during” the Ramadan and Easter holiday periods, the official said.

The TikTok terror phenomenon, in which Arab youth attack Jews and spread incendiary posts on the social media network, is a particular focus for the police this year.

“During Ramadan, there are those who spread inflammatory material and disinformation, with the goal of taking advantage of innocent young people” and influencing them to carry out attacks, the official said.

“We have formed a special unit that monitors social media incitement and terror,” he explained, emphasizing that the police would “deal uncompromisingly with lawbreakers and troublemakers who will use the holiday to harm public security.”

The Israeli police will be working closely with the Waqf – the Jordanian entity that serves as the Islamic custodian of the Temple Mount – on logistical issues such as water and food delivery for worshippers at the site who are breaking their fasts, along with garbage disposal.

Because the Passover holiday will overlap with Ramadan this year, some have predicted tensions as Jewish visitors tour the Temple Mount, which is the holiest site in Judaism.

Muslim authorities have long held that the mere presence of Jewish visitors at the compound is inherently provocative and could spark clashes during Ramadan.

There “will be no change to the status quo on the Temple Mount,” which sees Jews barred from openly praying at the site and restricted to visits during specific hours, the official said.

The representative stressed that the Israeli police “do not want to” maintain a presence on the Temple Mount and will only enter the compound should rioters begin endangering public security.

The post Temple Mount rioters and TikTok terror: Israeli police gearing up for Ramadan appeared first on World Israel News.

MKs celebrate final passage of law repealing disengagement from northern Samaria

Repeal of the same law for Gush Katif is next, they say, in order to correct the “historical injustice” of forcibly evacuating thousands of Jews from their homes in 2005. 

By Batya Jerenberg, World Israel News  

Right-wing MKs celebrated Monday night’s final passage of the bill repealing the Disengagement Law for northern Samaria, saying it should lead to the eventual return to the major area forcibly evacuated in 2005 as well – Gush Katif in the Gaza Strip.

Otzma Yehudit party MK Limor Son Har-Melech, who introduced the bill with the Likud’s Yuli Edelstein, touched on both issues in her Knesset speech after the vote, which passed 31 to 18.

“This is a day of endless joy over the historical correction we made here in the Knesset,” said the MK, who experienced the Disengagement personally, having been forced out of her home in Homesh, one of the four northern Samarian villages destroyed by Ariel Sharon’s government.

“After 18 years of deportation, destruction and persecution of anyone who wanted to return to the territory of the settlements that were evacuated and correct the injustice, today, the Knesset of Israel declares with a clear majority that the deportation and the law that constituted a disgrace to the people of Israel and trampled underfoot thousands of pioneering citizens are a thing of the past.”

She not only called for the immediate re-establishment of Homesh, Sa-Nur, Ganim and Kadim, but for the government to come up with a settlement plan “for the other vast areas of northern Samaria,” in order to “ensure Jewish control of this land.”

This would not be enough, however, she added.

“I say here today with a clear voice: Our vision is the complete cancellation of the Disengagement Law and the return to all the settlements that were evacuated and destroyed,” including the 22 that were destroyed in Gush Katif in the Gaza Strip

“This is an inseparable part of the Land of Israel, the land of our birth, and we have the right and duty to settle there,” she said.

Edelstein, who was one of only a few MKs who consistently voted against the forced expulsion of over 8,000 Jews from their homes in 2005, posted a statement to social media saying in part, “The State of Israel tonight began its recovery process from the deportation disaster. This is the first and significant step towards a real repair and establishment of Israel in the territories of the homeland that belong to it.

“We shouted, we warned, and despite the political threats we received at that time, we voted against the Disengagement. We failed, but not without a struggle,” he added. “We gave up territories – we received missiles; now we will get life!”

Edelstein, who is chairman of the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, also brushed aside a comment made by U.S. Ambassador Tom Nides to The Jerusalem Post ahead of the vote, saying that the Biden administration was not happy with the law.

“We have been very clear we oppose the bill,” Nides said, noting that the Disengagement had been part of an understanding reached between then-prime minister Ariel Sharon and president George Bush.

Edelstein commented that “the ambassador has my personal phone number and he never bothered to call because it is not an issue of major interest to anyone…not a single American official has spoken to any single Israeli official on that matter.”

The post MKs celebrate final passage of law repealing disengagement from northern Samaria appeared first on World Israel News.

Lebanese roadside bomber didn’t use tunnel: IDF

Israeli security officials won’t say how Lebanese terrorist entered Israel undetected, but confirm that he did not use a cross-border tunnel.

By Adina Katz, World Israel News

A terrorist who planted a roadside bomb in northern Israel that seriously wounded a motorist did not enter Israel from Lebanon via a tunnel, the Israel Defense Forces confirmed in a statement on Monday.

The Israeli military did not provide details as to how the man had slipped across the border without being detected by security forces.

“The IDF continues to study and investigate the incident in order to draw the necessary operational conclusions,” the army said.

In recent months, Israel has seen an uptick in deadly terror attacks, but the incident last week was unusual because it involved cross-border infiltration.

A relatively unknown terror organization, which is affiliated with the Lebanon-based Hezbollah terror group, took credit for the attack.

However, Israeli government officials have remained tight-lipped regarding whether they believe the small splinter organization was behind the sophisticated act, or if the terrorist had been acting directly on behalf of Hezbollah.

It’s unclear exactly when and where the perpetrator crossed the border from southern Lebanon into Israel, but Hebrew language media reports have indicated that the man may have spent several days in Israel before planting the explosive.

The bomb was detonated near Megiddo Junction, some 40 miles south of the border and around 20 kilometers south of Haifa, the largest city in northern Israel.

The terrorist, who has not been named by Israeli authorities, was shot dead by IDF special forces while attempting to return to Lebanon.

The man was reportedly armed with a rifle and wearing an explosive belt.

Residents of Israel’s northern border communities have long complained of the serious security risks posed by gaps in the border fence.

Some said that migrant workers wandering into Israel from Lebanon was not an unusual occurrence, and demonstrated that infiltration is relatively easy.

The post Lebanese roadside bomber didn’t use tunnel: IDF appeared first on World Israel News.