For Great Power Competition, America Can Learn from William Pitt, The Elder

In the mid-1700s, the British Empire was at an inflection point. The nation had just fought two wars without a clear strategy. The War of Jenkin’s Ear bled into the War of Austrian Succession and accomplished little to improve the lives of British citizens or grow the empire. The population had become sick of adventurism abroad and ushered in a class of isolationist and pacifist politicians. Prime Minister Walpole, who oversaw a myopic foreign policy for nearly two decades, was followed by a series of Prime Ministers who either dispatched troops only under haphazard circumstances or avoided wars altogether. This reluctance to confront Britain’s enemies in a deliberate manner ceded power to her adversaries and ultimately encouraged a system of anti-British alliances in the lead-up to the first true world war, the Seven Years’ War.   

William Pitt the Elder rose to prominence through his opposition to Walpole and the corrupt, erudite politicians running the empire. Pitt became known as “the great commoner” for his reluctance to use titles and his opposition to bribery. But Pitt’s most relevant contribution for modern policymakers was his reforging of Britain’s foreign policy. He championed British exceptionalism and advocated for aggressive actions against her adversaries. He funded allies on the continent to keep Britain’s adversaries bogged down in costly land wars and strategically maximized the use of naval and amphibious operations abroad to assert influence and control, growing the empire and establishing British dominance of the seas for nearly two hundred years. Roughly 260 years later, as America sits at a similar inflection point in an era of great power competition, policymakers have much to learn from the methods of one of Great Britain’s most successful statesmen. 

In 1756, after nearly a decade of serving as the Paymaster of Forces and fighting against the pacifists in his own party, William Pitt became the leader of the House of Commons. He was swept into office after a series of British defeats at the hands of France. The British navy’s retreat at the Battle of Minorca and subsequent loss of the island to France caused rioting in London. Shortly after, the French captured Madras from the British East India Company, gaining control of most of southern India. By 1757 Pitt pushed his nation to adopt a new strategy of occupying French forces in Central Europe by subsidizing an ally on the continent. As Prussia’s Fredrick the Great went to war with all three of Britain’s adversaries, funded by British pounds, the return on investment became clear. With French and Spanish troops diverted, the British navy began a series of operations to increase British influence and control abroad. 

Throughout 1758, Britain conducted raids and landings around the globe, striking strategic locations in Africa, India, Southeast Asia, and the Americas. In Canada, then controlled by France, the British navy sailed down the Saint Lawrence River and deployed amphibious forces to scale the cliffs outside Quebec City, successfully capturing it. The force moved on to Montreal and then Fort Niagara while a separate force moved up the Ohio River Valley, utilizing local militias and colonists, retaking Fort Duquesne (establishing what would eventually become Pittsburgh). While hundreds of thousands of French soldiers fought in Germany, a small contingent of 3,200 British regulars, supported and sustained by the British navy, began recapturing outposts across India. British raids then captured Havana and Manila, which were later traded for Florida.  

By the end of the Seven Years’ War in 1763, Britain had become the dominant power in North America and South Asia. The strategic investment in Prussia had successfully weakened France and Spain’s ability to project power abroad. Pitt would later say of his strategy, “Canada was won on the banks of the Rhine.” His aggressive foreign policy, successful financing of allies, and strategic use of naval engagements and amphibious landings established the greatest empire the world had ever seen. As a testament to his achievement, his longtime adversary, former Prime Minister Walpole, said Pitt, “exceedingly altered the appearance of our fortune. He warded off the evil hour that seemed approaching, he infused vigor into our arms, he taught the nation to speak again as England used to speak to foreign powers.” 

In a piece of lasting advice to Britain several years before his death in 1778, Pitt urged the government to accept the demands of the American colonies and keep them in the empire. He proposed the Provincial Act in 1775 to recognize the Continental Congress and warned that the colonies could never be conquered. Pitt’s understanding and appreciation for British exceptionalism apparently extended across the Atlantic to America.  

America, like Britain in the 18th century, is facing increased calls for isolation and pacifism as the nation recovers from two wars that often lacked a coherent strategy. Just as in the 18th century, there is a war in Europe involving a major adversary. The prescriptions of William Pitt to invest in allies, rebuild and revitalize the navy, and ensure the strategic capability to land military forces around the globe may be exactly what’s needed to reinvigorate the sentiment of exceptionalism in our nation. 

The post For Great Power Competition, America Can Learn from William Pitt, The Elder appeared first on Providence.

Integralism, Christian and Islamic

There’s a new phenomenon in Iran: young men and women posting videos of themselves flipping the turbans off clerics’ heads. Their parents and grandparents, too old to do it themselves, proudly share these videos in person and on social media. In similar fashion, a few years ago an audio clip went viral in Iran: a father recorded his son, maybe not even a teenager, asking to go to mosque. The father wouldn’t let him, responding “go drink alcohol instead.” A nation that wished for the integration of mosque and state four decades ago got its wish and has come to hate it.

Iran is not an Islamic society anymore. Octogenarians who performed their religious duties for decades are embracing atheism, and Islam is the fastest-shrinking religion. Underground churches are instead popping up, mostly due to the attraction of “the West” and anything associated with it. People are calling themselves Zoroastrian, not because they believe in it but to disassociate themselves from Islam and instead embrace the one Persian religion. It’s less an expression of religiosity as much as an embrace of national heritage. But, according to the only public opinion survey available, nones—atheists, agnostics, spiritual, and irreligious—now form a plurality at 44 percent. Shi’ites, once the predominant majority, stand at 32 percent. Mosques are the emptiest since modern Iran embraced political Islam. In sum, the Iranian national character has ceased to be Islamic.

This turn against religion isn’t merely personal, but also political. Two in three Iranians reject religion as a basis for law in any form. But perhaps most telling is Iranians’ attitudes toward political figures, the most popular of whom today is Reza Shah, founder of the Pahlavi dynasty, who brought enormous progress to Iran while also brutally cracking down on the clergy—Iranians believe with good reason, that, in this case, correlation is causation. Once condemned for banning the hijab in public, he is now the most celebrated Iranian since Cyrus the Great. While the 1979 revolutionaries were grieved by Reza Shah’s assault on public Islam, the 2022 revolutionaries chant: “Reza Shah, may your soul be happy!”

The reaction against Islam has also turned Iranians away from what American conservatives call family values. The fertility rate is 1.7, below replacement. Fewer people are getting married each day. Instead of traditional religion, the growing nihilism among younger Iranians has made pagan ideals popular. Just for a couple of examples, orgiastic sex parties are popular, and the public attitude toward out-of-wedlock birth is in transition from openness to celebration, both expressions of “the Western openness” of Iranian minds. 

In sum, trends American conservatives worry about as signs of a declining civilization are being embraced by increasingly secular Iran as a demonstration of their “open-mindedness” against “rotten” religious mentality. The logic is as follows: whatever Islam stands for is bad, and so the opposite must be good. The integration of Islam and government has meant that Iranians associate the religion with totalitarianism. They don’t just see Islam in its political form as problematic, but rather Islam in itself.

The Roman Catholic integralist movement in the United States must be careful about what it seeks. Is it sheer power or a religious revival? If the latter, particularly given that a leading member of this movement, Sohrab Ahmari, is a fellow émigré from Iran, the integralists would be wise to consider the Iranian nation as a cautionary tale.

The integralists are correct to say that religion is an important ingredient for a well-functioning society. Indeed, many of America’s contemporary problems are partially the result of the decline in religious practice. The hope for religious revival is a noble one, but using the heavy hand of the state is the best way to accelerate, not reverse, current trends toward secularism. In Iran, religion became the ideology of a failing and oppressive state. Therefore, Iranians want to punish the mosque because it is a symbol of tyranny.

The late Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks articulated why politics and religion cannot be integrated: in politics, compromise is a necessity, while in religion it’s a sin. The integration of politics and religion in Iran has led to absolutism in government and compromises in the mosque, making the former tyrannical and the latter corrupt and hypocritical, ultimately making both unpopular and unjust. Religious people believe that their religion is incorruptible because it is divine, yet everyone can agree that the clergy are not because they are men and flawed. This tale is hardly exclusive to Iran or Islam; indeed, little differentiates it from the fall of L’Ancien Régime and the rise of laïcité in France.

Some degree of interaction between religion and politics is not only inevitable but also desirable. Every political question is inherently an ethical one. Therefore, the formation of a moral citizenry, most commonly done through religion, is a necessary feature of a functioning democracy. But, as Greek philosophers taught us, moderation is a virtue. Too much religion in politics becomes repulsive and leads to a society that blames religion for the shortcomings of the state and adopts nihilism to punish the clergy.

For 22 years, I grew up in a place where religion was corrosive; where stupidity and religion, rotten minds and piety, had a direct relationship. It took almost a decade of observing religious practice in the United States to realize that religion is not intrinsically malformative, and that piety and enlightenment can coexist. Even so, though I have changed my position and become pro-religiosity, the scars of those 22 years have made me irredeemably irreligious. I don’t wish this curse upon my fellow Americans and will never understand why the integralists seem to.

The post Integralism, Christian and Islamic appeared first on Providence.

A War of War Crimes

As we approach the first anniversary of Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine, one of G.K. Chesterton’s most profound observations keeps coming to mind: “The true soldier,” Chesterton explained, “fights not because he hates what is in front of him, but because he loves what is behind him.” Against all odds, a people’s army of students and soldiers, farmers and techies, shopkeepers and artists, young women and old men has beaten back, ground down, outwitted, outmaneuvered and outfought Putin’s invasion force—in large part because they love their families, their fellow Ukrainians, their freedom and their homeland.

But in the dark shadows of what Putin’s army has done in Ukraine, the Ukrainian people can be forgiven if they are motivated not just by love of their country and their countrymen, but also by a deep and righteous hatred for their enemy.

The World’s Largest Crime Scene
In every way, Putin has perpetrated a conflict characterized by war crimes against Ukraine. Ukrainian investigators and international observers report that the Russian Federation and its military, security forces, intelligence agencies, and military contractors have committed at least 58,000 war crimes in Ukraine. That number grows by the hour.

The first of these war crimes, it must not be forgotten, is the very way the war started: Both the 2014 assault on Crimea and the 2022 full-scale invasion of the whole of Ukraine constitute a war of aggression by the Russian Federation against Ukraine, a sovereign independent country that had neither attacked nor threatened Russia. However, this is quite literally only the beginning of Putin’s war of war crimes.

Much of the immorality Putin and his invasion forces have committed against Ukraine is too gruesome to describe in this space. But here’s the PG-13 version of Russia’s atrocities in Ukraine: targeting and destroying hospitals, including maternity hospitals; targeting and destroying civilian population centers; targeting civilian energy, food and water supplies; damaging or destroying 93 schools and some 270 places of worship; torturing and massacring civilians; engaging in mass-looting of Ukrainian property and Ukrainian cultural artifacts; abducting Ukrainian children and placing them in Russian homes in order to forcibly Russify them and thus serve Putin’s larger goal of erasing Ukraine; imprisoning Ukrainian civilians in “filtration camps;” forcibly transferring as many as 1.6 million Ukrainian civilians to Russia; attempting through deportations and disappearances “to change the demographic makeup of parts of Ukraine,” according to a State Department report; desecrating and mutilating dead combatants; conducting a campaign of mass-rapes and employing sexual violence as part of their “military strategy,” in the words of a UN official.

The U.S. Helsinki Commission (an OSCE-linked body comprised of members of Congress and executive-branch appointees) reports that Russia’s military has “decimated hospitals, schools and apartment buildings, including a theater in Mariupol where hundreds of children were sheltering and the Kramatorsk rail station where thousands were waiting to escape the Russian onslaught.” 

Historians and humanitarian-law experts who spoke to the commission in November “unanimously agreed” that “Russia’s invasion of Ukraine meets the definition of the term genocide as defined by the Genocide Convention”—namely the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.” According to the commission: “Rarely has genocidal intent and pattern of action been so clearly telegraphed and demonstrated for the world to see.”

Secretary of State Antony Blinken labels Putin’s war of war crimes “a deliberate campaign to kill, to torture, to rape, to commit atrocities” and the U.S. is not alone in these grim conclusions. Pointing to “torture,” “unlawful confinement,” “executions,” and “sexual and gender-based violence” against girls as young as four and women as old as 82, a special UN commission definitively concludes that “war crimes have been committed in Ukraine.”

Karim Khan, chief prosecutor for the International Criminal Court (ICC), describes the whole of Ukraine as “a crime scene.” Spurred by 43 member states, the ICC dispatched investigators to Ukraine and has begun assembling the evidence and infrastructure necessary for the largest war crimes trial since Nuremberg. (Toward that end, Ukraine has identified some 600 Russian political officials and military commanders for the prosecution of war crimes.)

EU bodies are pushing for an international tribunal to investigate, prosecute and punish Russian war crimes. Citing “escalating acts of terror against Ukrainian civilians,” “deliberate attacks and atrocities committed by Russian forces and their proxies against civilians in Ukraine,” “the destruction of civilian infrastructure,” and “other serious violations of international and humanitarian law,” the European Parliament recently declared Putin’s Russia a state sponsor of terrorism. 

Soldier and Sword
Chesterton’s insights about the “true soldier”—the noble warrior who loves what’s behind him so much that he will risk and sacrifice his own life, who fights for a just cause in a just manner, who believes that right makes might—can also be applied to Putin’s army of criminals, albeit in the opposite manner. 

Putin has propagandized his subjects and soldiers into hating and dehumanizing what’s in front of them—the Ukrainian people—by pushing the lie that Ukraine is “not a real country,” that Ukraine was “entirely created by Russia,” that Ukraine is governed by “a gang of drug addicts and neo-Nazis.” The irony—obvious to everyone outside the propagandists defending Putin’s war of extermination and annihilation—is that by concocting phantom enemies, revising and rewriting history, trying to rebuild a dead empire, waging a war of aggression, and engaging in genocide, Putin is the one who’s imitating the Nazis. Putin, like the Nazi high command, knows it’s easier for soldiers to destroy what they’ve been taught to believe is not human and not real.

This is the sort of thinking, the sort of worldview, the sort of behavior that people of faith and goodwill must hate. Some may gasp at such a notion and counter that “Hatred cannot be righteous.” Yet the psalmist (“I behold the treacherous and loathe them”) and Solomon (“The fear of the Lord is to hate evil”) suggest it can. Paul’s letter to the Romans literally instructs us to “hate what is evil.” And it pays to recall that, in this same letter, Paul reminds all those with ears to hear that governing authorities bear the sword “to execute wrath on him who practices evil.”

Putin’s motivations, means, methods, and ends in Ukraine are evil. Ukraine’s response is right and righteous. Of course, the Ukrainian people and their political leaders must guard against allowing their righteous rage—their hatred for Putin’s evil—to devolve into the very same sort of ends-justify-the-means mindlessness that would dehumanize the Russian people. Given what Putin’s army has done, that will take enormous moral and political will—and perhaps generations.

For now, the United States and its allies should send the Ukrainians everything they need to clear a pathway to their vision of postwar peace and secure what they define as victory, everything they need to protect their innocents and liberate their blood-soaked land, everything they need to clear their skies and open their ports, everything they need to defeat the evil thrust upon them.

The post A War of War Crimes appeared first on Providence.

HR 1009: Subordinating Military Power to Politics

Representative Jerry McNerney (D-CA-9) has brought before the House a resolution (H.Res.1009) “regarding the consideration of ‘Just War’ principles prior to any vote with respect to a declaration of war or an authorization of the use of military force.” The mere act of advancing the resolution for House consideration speaks to the importance of just war thinking and moral use of force as an instrument of politics. The resolution does two things: it reminds us of the subordination of the use of force to politics assumed by the just war tradition, and it resurrects the practice of explicit dialogue by states around the principles of the just use of force. 

The central insight of the just war tradition concerns the relationship of politics to force. To remain a moral endeavor of peace-making, war must remain subordinate to politics, and thereby to policy. Even when a war proceeds from a just cause – that is, to resist some severe harm one party brings upon another – the violence and brutality of war are difficult to contain. War has a brutal logic: once undertaken, its momentum presses toward expansion. The initiating cause gets lost in the sentiments associated with death and destruction, in the investment of blood and material resources, and in the propaganda necessary to inspire a population to its successful waging.  Not for nothing did Augustine lament his incapacity to describe the evils and miseries of war in book nineteen, chapter seven, of The City of God. He thought only a senseless man could regard war without “anguish of soul.” Such a man, Augustine wrote, “thinks himself happy only because he has lost all human feeling.” (City of God, XIX, 7)

The undeniable horrors of war can only be chosen in the name of the common good, the constant goal of good politics. Thus, Carl von Clausewitz, the great Prussian military thinker, argues that “war is not merely a political act but a real political instrument, a continuation of political intercourse, a carrying out of the same by other means.” Sometimes misunderstood as a justification for mindless war-making, von Clausewitz intends instead by this to make at least two points: first, to show the necessary continuity of politics and war, which is merely the former’s instrument; second, to thereby emphasize the necessary subordination of the instrument to the consistent and continuous goals of politics. Keeping war and politics together provides the best possibility of deescalating war and of constructing a more durable peace at the cessation of violence. The subordination of the use of force to politics is foundational to the just war approach. 

War as a means or instrument pursuing the “continuation of political intercourse” keeps war tethered to the political goals that obtained before and after the instruments were swapped out. That those ends – say, order, justice, stability – could be and perhaps usually are pursued by other means suggests that their pursuit even by the instrument of war ought to keep war from pursuing its own totalizing logic. War is not normally necessary for the pursuit of these political goals. Generally other means, for instance, negotiation, compromise, diplomacy, suffice in their pursuit. 

Tying war to the activities associated with political goals keeps politicians attentive to the broadest horizon of concerns informing particular policy choices. Among other things, the fuller political horizon keeps the broader international repercussions of particular policies in front of decision-makers. Connecting war to politics invites them to reflect on the political goals sought by their adversaries, to investigate them as rational choices in terms of those goals. War disposes adversaries to consider the opposing party irrational and even “mad.” We saw this during the war on terror, and we’re seeing it again in the ease with which pundits attribute madness to Putin’s policies (a phenomenon that has occurred in the media since 2008; recently a columnist called his actions “more taxi driver than head of state”). The accusation of an adversary’s irrationality presupposes no connection between the use of force and any political goals; terrorists, for instance, are “irrational” because they don’t act, according to this accusation, like normal political agents. They are motivated merely by hatred or desire for destruction; their violence has no constructive purpose. Because their acts have no purpose, terrorists are not susceptible to alternative political appeals and must be eradicated. So goes the detachment of political thinking from the use of force leads inexorably to the escalation of violence. The sound instinct of H.Res. 1009 is to reattach political thinking to the use of force.

By inviting the House to consider the principles of just war analysis prior to authorizing a use of force, H.Res. 1009 reintroduces an age-old practice of political and moral deliberation around justifying force. Nearly 500 years ago, in 1550-1551, King Charles I of Spain convened a conversation between philosophers and theologians to discuss the morality of Spain’s engagement with the indigenous peoples of the newly-discovered Americas. As the Harvard historian Lewis Hanke argued in All Mankind is One, King Charles I actually directed Spain to halt military operations until the conversation had concluded and a judgment made. The famed Dominican theologian Bartolome de Las Casas argued the case for the humanity of the Indians, their just possession of their lands, and their right to self-rule against Juan Gines Sepulveda, the Renaissance humanist and scholar of Aristotle. Sepulveda argued the indigenous peoples were like Aristotle’s “natural slaves” and thus by right subject to the rule of the Spaniards. The Spaniards could by force dispossess and rule over them.

That argument was effectively an argument about the justification of force used by Spain against the indigenous peoples. Las Casas argued that the indigenous peoples by right had just claims to their property and had political legitimacy. They could not be justly attacked by the Spaniards without some legitimizing cause. In much of his argument, he followed and adapted just war analysis: built into the justification of force is the limitation of force. Force can be justified, but not always, and not without limit on its use. In the Spanish case against the Indians, Las Casas argued the Spaniards had no right. 

We know the history of the Spanish conquest: the moral judgments of a conversation in Spain had little effect. As Francisco de Vitoria (an influence on Las Casas) wrote, kings are pragmatists who think “from hand to mouth.” Nonetheless, the long-term influence of this sort of political reflection on the use of force impacted our conceptions of sovereignty, international law, and the laws of warfare. Las Casas’ argument against Sepulveda happened only because King Charles I asked for reflection on the rights of the Spanish crown in the Americas. Though ineffective in stopping the conquest, the argument reverberated throughout the globe and down to us today. 

We can be grateful for Congressman McNerney reminding us that force serves politics and not the other way around.

The post HR 1009: Subordinating Military Power to Politics appeared first on Providence.

New Documentary Captures Greek Resistance to Nazis and Holocaust in WWII 

“I’m a Greek but it seems I’m kind of different from my fellow countrymen. Most of the people in my family have uncommon names that don’t really sound Greek like Rachel, Daniel, and Nissim. Till the 1940s, these names were not uncommon in my country. But while I was growing up, they were. My grandfather had an uncommon name, as well: Leon. I never met him. Mom describes him as adorable, charming, and funny. His life was just as uncommon…”  

This is the introduction to the ground-breaking documentary film “My People” by Anna Rezan, whose grandfather Leon was arrested by German Nazi occupiers in Athens during WWII. Rezan’s Jewish great-grandmother, Rachel, was deported and lost her life in Auschwitz.  

“My People” relates the stories of Greek-Jewish victims and survivors of the Holocaust, as well as the heroic resistance of the Greeks against the Nazis. The film is the “brainchild” of Rezan, whose mother is a Greek Jew and father a Greek Christian. Rezan, 30, wrote, produced, directed, and narrated the film mainly by herself. She dedicated 7 years to thoroughly researching the history of the Holocaust, Greece’s resistance against the Nazi occupation, and her own Jewish-Greek family origins in making this documentary.  

The multi-talented Rezan, known well as an actress, filmmaker, and musician with a fashion model background, began the project alongside cinematographer Zafeiris Haitidis, completing it in 2022. It was co-produced by Academy Award-winning Mitchell Block and multi-Academy Award-winning Kim Magnusson. John and Jason Filippidis, Eleni Purgioti and Pantelis Kodogiannis serve as Executive Producers.

Rezan first went to Auschwitz to find out more about her Jewish family roots and about the story of her great-grandmother who was killed in Auschwitz. During her voyage, she learned about the history of the Jews of Greece — a history that she recounts in her breathtaking documentary.  

The film sheds light on the largely unknown resistance of Greece against the Nazis. It includes the moral courage of the Greek Orthodox Church, its clergy, the Greek Christian civilians, and the Greek guerrilla fighters across the country that helped save thousands of Greek Jews. This Greek resistance was instrumental in the defeat of Nazi Germany and her allies and the ending of WWII. See the official trailer here. 

Rezan describes in the documentary how Greece was targeted by Italy and Germany during WWII: 

“On October 28, 1940, the Italian government led by fascist Benito Mussolini gave an ultimatum to Greece allowing the Axis forces to enter and occupy the country. The Prime Minister of Greece, Ioannis Metaxas, simply responded “oxi”, meaning “no” in Greek.  In response, the Italians, aided by Albania, attacked Greece.”

Alongside the Greek military approximately 13,000 Jews, including Rezan’s grandfather Lian, fought in the Greek-Italian war. 

“Although the Greeks were poorly equipped, they fought heroically, and forced the invaders to retreat… Up until then, it was the Axis powers’ most significant defeat.” 

This highly important historical fact will now become better known because of this heartwarming piece of cinema. 

“Following desperate pleas from Mussolini’s government for help, Nazi Germany invaded Greece on April 6, 1941. Despite the Greeks’ valiant resistance, the country was overrun by the Nazis.” 

During the Nazi occupation of Greece, Rezan narrates, “Jews were forced by the Nazis to submit ‘wealth declarations’ and to wear the yellow star. They were also prohibited from practicing their professions in German-occupied areas.” 

“On March 15, 1943, the nightmare of the Jewish community unfolded as the Nazis implemented the final solution,” Rezan relates. Trains started deporting Greek Jews to Auschwitz. 

One of the most significant aspects of this history is the unique role the Greek Orthodox Church played in its resistance to the Nazis. As the cruelty of the Nazis increased, so did the courageous resistance of the Greek Orthodox Church. Archbishop Damaskinos, the archbishop of Athens and of Greece, issued a letter of protest to the German Nazis. This was signed in Athens by the Archbishop himself and 27 other prominent Greek leaders. The letter, which protested against the persecution of Jews by the Nazis, reads in part as follows: 

“Our Holy Religion does not recognize superior or inferior qualities based on race or religion… Our common fate, both in days of glory and in periods of national misfortune, forged inseparable bonds between all Greek citizens… 

The International Raoul Wallenberg Foundation has said: “There is no similar document of protest of the Nazis that has come to light.”

The Nazis’ plans were countered by strong local resistance as well. Rezan gives further examples: 

“The police chief of Athens, Angelos Evert, issued thousands of false identity papers to desperate Jews. Rezan’s grandfather Leon was one of them…”

“Hundreds of Greek Orthodox priests and civilians were deported to the death camps for having helped Jews.” 

The documentary tells the stories of Greek Jews not as only victims but also as resistance fighters. For instance, the ranks of the Ethnikós Dimokratikós Ellinikós Sýndesmos, or National Republican Greek League (EDES), and the Ethnikó Apeleftherotikó Métopo, or National Liberation Front (EAM), who fought against Nazi occupiers included many Greek Jews.  

Various stories from Greece will fascinate the spectators.

“In the port city of Volos, the birthplace of Rezan’s family, the EDES and EAM protected the Jewish community…”

The courageous resistance of the Greek island of Crete was also extraordinary.

“Crete was vital to Hitler’s plan to take over north Africa. Germany attacked Crete by an airborne assault,” Rezan reports in the film. 

 The documentary features interviews with survivors and eyewitnesses of the Holocaust at Auschwitz and during the Nazi occupation of Greece.  

A Greek Jewish Holocaust survivor Rezan interviewed said:  

“At Auschwitz there was a children’s hall called ‘Kinder’. They [Nazis] were obsessed with identical twins. They took identical twins and opened their scalps to examine their differences. One went crazy. They cut the penis off of another. So the victim could never have children. They experimented on children. None of them [children] returned.” 

Rezan then recounts another case of brave resistance to Nazis in Greece: 

“Meanwhile in the island of Zakynthos, bishop Chrysostomos and the island’s mayor, Loukas Karrer, were commanded by Nazis to surrender a list of the Jews living on the island. They defiantly responded with two names: their own.”

The Holocaust survivors that Rezan interviewed discussed not only the persecution and torture they and other prisoners were subjected to, but also the rebuilding of their lives after liberation. Also, one of the incidents the documentary reveals is the courageous, self-sacrificial revolt of a group of Greek-Jewish prisoners at Auschwitz.  

“Meeting these survivors was a life altering experience. They represent happy endings in real life. They are the epitome of courage,” Rezan said in an interview with the author of this piece.

 “‘Love brings love, and it is the greatest power of all’ is my motto and they are the first three words of the name of my film production company. The message in my motto has been an absolute inspiration to me. Hopefully, it can inspire others, as well. These resilient people decided to continue their lives, get married, have families, and be grateful for what they still had in their lives. They are real-life superheroes.

“Even though the Holocaust survivors experienced terrible traumas and horrific, atrocious situations, the ability to transform this experience into something positive and powerful is so impressive. It becomes a universal message that empowers the audience to believe in love and life.” 

Rezan stated how excited she is that the film competed at the Vail Film Festival, which is a favorite of hers. 

“We had our world premiere in LA and the next stop was Chicago. We won the “Audience Award” following our premiere in New York which was hosted by the Hellenic Film Society. We also had our New Jersey premiere hosted by AHEPA (American Hellenic Educational Progressive Association) and various other locations. Our international premiere will happen soon at the Thessaloniki Documentary Festival (TDF) in Greece. We would like to have an Israeli premiere as well. 

“The film is a love letter to Greece with universal messages. I hope that ‘My People’ will become available globally soon,” Rezan added. 

Already this new film, “My People”, is a classic, and it should be shown at schools, universities, film festivals, and other venues across the world. 

“My People” is described as “a hymn to love and courage as it is discovered by a young woman in her quest to uncover her Greek Jewish family’s history.” This documentary is undoubtedly one of the most significant depictions of the Holocaust ever made. It is awe-inspiring to view, particularly on International Holocaust Remembrance Day. It is a reminder of how one can remain courageous and stand against evil even when plunged into the bleak darkness of its abyss.

The post New Documentary Captures Greek Resistance to Nazis and Holocaust in WWII  appeared first on Providence.

A New Peace Conference at Torgau

The need for an international peace conference at Torgau, in Germany, is more urgent than before. As we enter the first winter war, the protracted Kremlin assault on Ukraine has had worldwide impact. Africans are suffering from the loss of Ukrainian grain. Europeans are feeling the loss of access to Russian oil and gas. For the rest of us, inflation is an onerous burden on working families in every developed nation. But why Torgau? 

The Soviet Red Army met U.S. troops there in January 1945. Their “closing the ring” marked a brief but important collaboration of the USSR with the Western Allies. Both sides hoped for a new spring of peace. All of that depended on the crushing of Hitler’s “nozzie” Wehrmacht menace, and for that much, our alliance held; Churchill even had the satisfaction of walking over Hitler’s burned-out bunker at the Potsdam Summit that July. Even then, German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder in 2004 asked to be included in the regular celebration of D-Day because the Allies had freed the German people, too. 

Now, we need to seek peace with a passion. The Biden administration representative, Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, has said our goal in this war is to “weaken Russia.” No one in in the administration has contradicted the Secretary. That must not be our goal, stated or even implied. NATO is proving itself as the greatest defensive alliance in all history. But to succeed, it is not necessary to cripple Russia. It isn’t even desirable. 

President Biden is to be commended for the grave warnings he offered to NATO. He skillfully reunited NATO after years of disparagement by his predecessor. The Kremlin’s unjustified aggression against Ukraine proved the President’s words prophetic. The accession of Sweden and Finland to NATO, if it occurs, will be one of President Biden’s crowning achievements. 

Mr. Biden has also wisely refrained from sending U.S. or NATO ground troops into Ukraine. Additionally, he declined to provide Ukraine with a “no fly zone.” As urgently as Ukrainians sought such aid, the dangers of lethal engagement between NATO forces and the Russian military were unacceptable. 

A Russian attack on NATO forces could have brought into question the collective security guarantees of Article V of the North Atlantic Treaty. President Biden’s measured response can be seen in this week’s announcement that Ukrainian troops would be trained on the defensive Patriot Missile system here in the United States. Thus, we emphasize our determination not to make war on Russians.

This tragic war, however, might have been avoided altogether. President Biden could have persuaded our NATO allies to accept Ukraine as a member. That, and perhaps that alone, could have deterred the Kremlin from its disastrous course of invasion. Germans certainly feared all of NATO being dragged into a war that could escalate to nuclear exchange. 

We could have worked overtime to persuade the Russian people that NATO is not Russia’s enemy. We could communicate to the Russian people that NATO is their shield, citing Germany as the classic confirmation of this fact. In 1991, the USSR acceded to the reunion of Germany and its inclusion within NATO. The Soviets even agreed to withdraw their hundreds of thousands of troops from Eastern Germany. 

Since that historic rapprochement, Germany as a NATO member has posed no threat to Russia. Far from it. German politicians made every effort for thirty years to implement their wandel durch handel policy—trade will bring changes. 

We know that the Peacemakers are blessed. More than that, they are urgently needed now. Although Trump called Gospodin (Mister) Putin’s invasion “genius,” not even Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin thinks it was a good move. He knows it was a катастрофа (catastrophe). His problem is our problem: how to extricate himself from this crisis without winding up like Saddam or Gaddafi. Our peace offer could include a Russo-Ukrainian Treaty based on the Russo-Finnish Treaty of 1992: no territorial demands but guarantees to ethnic minorities of both countries of linguistic, cultural, religious, and civil rights. We might agree to a UN-supervised plebiscite in Crimea. 

The absence of any fierce resistance to Russian invasion in Crimea such as we’ve seen in Ukraine suggests that those people may in fact identify as Russians. We could press Ukraine to continue to supply vital water to Crimea. We could offer Russia a relaxation of economic sanctions, timed to coincide with the staged withdrawal of their troops from Ukraine. A liberated Ukraine should present NATO membership as a benefit to Russia; once peace is achieved, Russians could concentrate government funds on repairing their stricken economy and fractured health care system. 

America has never made war on Russia. We need to seek peace with strength, but we must have no goal of further humiliating Russians. A disintegrated Russia would plunge the world into nightmares of “loose nukes” in the hands of outlaws. Avoiding nuclear war is the best argument for Peace at Torgau. 

The post A New Peace Conference at Torgau appeared first on Providence.

What Whittaker Chambers Can Teach Biden on the True Meaning of Freedom

As war rages in Ukraine and Vladimir Putin grows more and more isolated from the West, President Biden has consistently defined the growing crisis as a “battle between democracy and autocracy.” Officials in Washington are increasingly eager to block Russian attempts to influence other parts of the world. Last month, for instance, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen traveled to several countries in Africa as part of an effort to strengthen ties with the continent. 

According to Biden’s narrative, authoritarian movements pose the gravest threat to global stability by countering the spread of democracy. Biden reiterated this belief in a speech to African leaders late last year in which he encouraged them to “strengthen democracy and the core values that unite our people — all our people, especially young people — freedom, opportunity, transparency, good governance.”

Although this dichotomy between “democracy” and “autocracy” captures an element of American strategic competition, it does not tell the whole story. And, more importantly, it fails to appeal to the leaders of nondemocratic countries that the United States needs as allies to succeed in outcompeting our rivals. Biden needs to develop a more compelling narrative about the meaning of freedom and how we can protect it.

In foreign affairs, America’s comparative advantage is our dedication to freedom. Our founding principles have inspired people all over the world to strive for freedom and throw off tyranny. But as Abraham Lincoln once said, “The world has never had a good definition of the word liberty.” Ideas like “democracy” or “freedom” are incredibly slippery, and we need to work hard to clearly define what we mean. 

During the Cold War, conservative thinkers and writers worked hard to recover the meaning of American freedom. They knew that the milquetoast defenses of “democracy” on offer from New Deal liberals could not withstand the ideological threat posed by the Soviet Union. The left-wing establishment had a natural tendency to accommodate and appease the Soviets because its egalitarian commitments and faith in centralized bureaucracy were simply too similar to communism.

One of the most vocal anticommunist voices was Whittaker Chambers. His memoir, Witness, is a neglected classic of American literature. It recounts his youthful embrace of communism, induction into the Soviet espionage underground, and eventual break with the Communist Party. 

Chambers was initially attracted to communism out of disgust for bourgeois society. He came to see revolution “as a reflex of human suffering and desperation, a perpetual insurgence of that instinct for justice and truth that lay within the human soul, from which a new vision of truth and justice was continually issuing to meet the new needs of the soul in new ages of the world.” He joined the Communist Party itself and, eventually, the Soviet underground in the hope that the world’s great Marxist-Leninist power would bring about a new birth of freedom.

He especially admired the apparent strength of communism. “The Communist Party presents itself as the one organization of the will to survive the crisis in a civilization where that will is elsewhere divided, wavering, or absent,” he said. “The revolution is never stronger than the failure of civilization. Communism is never stronger than the failure of other faiths.” 

In the end, though, two things convinced Chambers to break with the Party. 

The first was the screams. In the introduction to Witness, Chambers recounts an anecdote from a communist-sympathizing German diplomat walking through Moscow one night. In the cold air, “he heard screams.” For the first time, his eyes were opened to the immense human suffering caused by the Soviet regime. In their attempt to impose an abstract equality on all people, the communists carried out crime after crime against the concrete dignity of actual persons. For Chambers, this ideological commitment to revolution was embodied in the gulag camps and the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact – the political event which inspired him to begin informing on former Party associates.

The second was a quiet moment of contemplation. Sitting in a Baltimore apartment with his baby daughter, Chambers realized that her life was a miracle. Looking at the intricacies of her ear, he suddenly understood that human beings “could have been created only by immense design.” Communism, however, completely rejects the notion of God. Communists suppose that man is the measure of all things; therefore, man has a responsibility to revolutionize the world and remake it in his own image. In a world without God, man must become as gods. But in a world with God, such an attitude is foolish rebellion. 

In the agony of his break with the Party, Chambers discovered an important truth – perfect freedom can only be found in service to God:

“Freedom is a need of the soul, and nothing else. It is in striving toward God that the soul strives continually after a condition of freedom. God alone is the inciter and guarantor of freedom. He is the only guarantor. External freedom is only an aspect of interior freedom. Political freedom, as the Western world has known it, is only a political reading of the Bible. Religion and freedom are indivisible. Without freedom the soul dies. Without the soul there is no justification for freedom… A Communist breaks because he must choose at last between irreconcilable opposites — God or Man, Soul or Mind, Freedom or Communism.”

Chambers believed the New Deal liberalism which dominated Washington in the early days of the Cold War was a threat to this godly freedom. He came to despise the notion that certain “experts” have special knowledge which they can deploy through bureaucratic regulation. Chambers believed that the common people’s right to rule themselves was essential to the preservation of human dignity. The traditions of American self-government – divided sovereignty, constitutionalism, a virtuous citizenry – were, for Chambers, a great source of faith in the struggle against totalitarianism. 

Chambers’s vision of freedom, stemming from his belief in the equal dignity of every human being, is far more attractive than President Biden’s simplistic dichotomy between “democracy” and “autocracy.” It nothing to do with faddish liberal notions of progress, but rather a fuller account of human nature’s truly universal aspects. And it can do far more to appeal to traditionalist societies in the Global South than any of the White House’s empty rhetoric.

The post What Whittaker Chambers Can Teach Biden on the True Meaning of Freedom appeared first on Providence.

St. Antonio and the Scholastics: Medieval Monks as Economists

When enumerating the images associated with capitalism, one such impression is of wealthy merchants exploiting the poor. Similarly, when moneylending is mentioned, visions of miserly Ebenezer Scrooge spring to mind. Yet surprisingly, the first thinker to produce a systematic treatise on what is today called the Science of Economics, and among the first to argue that earning profit and charging interest is not sinful, was Renaissance-era Dominican monk St. Antonio of Florence.1 

Contrary to modern notions of what it means to be a capitalist or a socialist, St. Antonio was a social economist who cared deeply for people. He realized that if unfair monopolies controlled by the rich were removed, free markets would give hard-working citizens the chance to improve their lives. In essence, he envisioned the system that, over 300 years later, would enable the United States of America to create the world’s largest middle class.

St. Antonio (1389–1459) was born Antonio Pierozzi in Florence. At age 16, he was admitted to the Dominican Order, ultimately serving as Archbishop of Florence from 1446 until his death. During this era, Florence was ruled by Cosimo de’ Medici and was one of the richest cities on Earth.2 Many economists regard Florence as the birthplace of capitalism, owing to its urbanization, industrialization, trade networks, and sizable banking sector.

St. Antonio was a member of the Scholastics, a philosophical tradition largely led by Catholic monks from Italy and Spain. From around 1150 to 1450, the Scholastics utilized a mix of Catholic, Jewish and Islamic religious principles combined with Aristotelian philosophy to conduct economic thought experiments3. The thinking of St. Antonio and similar philosophers, like St. Thomas Aquinas, was ahead of its time and broke with long-held traditions and beliefs.  

Early Christian scholars discouraged entrepreneurship because profit-seeking necessarily led to avarice. St. Antonio agreed that traders and entrepreneurs may be led to sin, but so could other professions.4 St. Antonio argued that, from a position of Christian faith, the acquisition of wealth was not intrinsically sinful so long as the money was earned honestly and not spent sinfully. To determine what constituted the honest acquisition of wealth, St. Antonio referred to the Ten Commandments and the Canonical law. Along with the Bible, he cited these two documents because they were the most widely accepted standards of morality. It was a sin to lie, steal, or cheat, and therefore contracts had to be legally enforced by the government. This would encourage people to invest money, he wrote. No one would invest in a business if they thought their investment could be stolen. What’s more, he regarded contract enforcement as one of the few areas where the government should involve itself in the economy. 

In 1776 Adam Smith, the father of modern economics, published An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, a work that changed the course of history. In it, Smith stated that the economy would work most efficiently if the government limited itself to protecting national borders, keeping public order, and upholding property rights. This is exactly what St. Antonio had outlined in his great work of 1477, Summa Theologica Moralis. 

Profits could be earned, in St. Antonio’s reckoning, if they were moderate and used to support families or help the poor5. His idea of moderate profits was that a “just price” should be charged for goods and services. But unlike modern socialists, who believe the government should decide what the just price is, St. Antonio regarded the just price as being whatever buyers and sellers arrive on without coercion. In effect, he was describing a free market where buyers and sellers are free to do business with whomever they choose.

One of his most innovative concepts was his theory of the economy as a system. Today, we call this the circular flow. In a simple yet brilliant observation, St. Antonio realized that there were two major players in the economy: firms and households. The former produces products and services, while the latter consumes them. This much had been known for centuries, but St. Antonio took this idea a step further by completing the circular flow. He recognized that firms bought inputs and raw materials to make goods and services, and that one of those inputs was labor, which is purchased from households. 

In the circular flow model, a worker receives a wage which is then used to buy groceries and clothing. The worker sells their labor to the firm, and the firm buys the labor to make goods and services, which the firm sells. The worker then receives a payment for selling their labor and uses that payment to buy other goods and services. This cycle repeats countless times per day across the world every day of human existence. This is our economy. 

Once St. Antonio completed the circle, he realized that if firms could set the price at which they sold goods and services, workers should be able to set the price at which they sold their labor. But, even more forward thinking, he believed that unions and syndicates, which forced employers to pay a certain wage, distort markets. He advocated for a free market for labor, just as there was a free market for shoes, bread or any other product. This way, workers who were more productive could command higher wages and thus get richer. It would be centuries until the circular flow diagram entered the lexicon of economics. 

St. Antonio’s philosophy regarding lending is a classic example of his melding of Christian ideals with economics. Early Christian and Islamic scholars believed that the charging of interest was prohibited by the Bible, specifically Deuteronomy 23:20. The Scholastics, however, also understood that compensation and profit were at the core of commerce. As for profit, the reason a worker does one job over another is so they can earn more. The reason a firm specializes in one product over another is so it can earn more by selling it. And that “more” is the profit. 

Consequently, if it is permissible in Christian ethics to earn a profit from working or to sell a product at profit, why would it be immoral to earn a profit on money? And here is where St. Antonio derived a whole slew of innovative economic concepts. He recognized that someone lending money had to be compensated for the risk. He also recognized that the lender has a choice, in a free market, to do what they wish with their money. Because they will invest their money into the most profitable activities, interest on a loan must be enough to compensate the lender for the next best use of his money. If you could invest your money for a 3% return or loan it out, you would have to charge at least 3% interest to compensate for the opportunity cost incurred. To this day, the concepts of opportunity cost and the time value of money are at the foundation of our modern economy. 

Today, we see a world where many wish to forget the wisdom of the past. In abandoning religious morality, they believe they will find more happiness or, in the case of socialism, more equitable outcomes. But it was by maintaining our moral values, rooted in scripture, that a system of guaranteed rights and laws which made America one of the richest and freest societies ever was established. 

When Adam Smith wrote The Wealth of Nations in 1776 and America’s Founding Fathers signed the Declaration of Independence, human beings lived in a world of limited upward mobility. Yet despite Smith’s reputation as the first expositor of economic freedom, capitalism’s theoretical underpinnings were first articulated hundreds of years earlier by St. Antonio and the Scholastics; it was these Renaissance scholars who recognized that the amelioration of poverty and creation of a fairer society could be accomplished through free markets. Though capitalism’s rise was not immediate, by the end of the 19th century, nations like the United States were so far ahead that there could be no contest. St. Antonio has been proven right beyond any shadow of a doubt.

(1)  Alexandrin, G., & Poulatis, S. S. (2001). “Social Economist: St Antonino, Bishop of Florence, 13841459.” International Journal of Social Economics, 28(5/6/7), 561–576. https://doi.org/10.1108/03068290110360830

(2)  Brown, J. A. (2019). St Antonin of Florence on Justice in Buying and Selling: Introduction, Critical Edition, and Translation [Doctoral dissertation, Centre for Medieval Studies, University of Toronto]. Toronto. 

(3) Langholm, O. (1998). The Legacy of Scholasticism in Economic Thought. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511528491

(4) Rothbard, M. N. (1975). “San Bernardino of Siena: Economics and the Entrepreneur.” Journal of Christian Reconstruction Symposium on Christian Economics, Vol. 2 (1).

(5) Caferro, W. (2020, April 30). “Premodern European capitalism, Christianity, and Florence.” Business History Review, Vol. 94, 39–72. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007680520000045

The post St. Antonio and the Scholastics: Medieval Monks as Economists appeared first on Providence.

All 5 aboard Care Flight plane killed in Nevada crash

Five people are dead, including a patient and medical personnel, after a Care Flight plane crashed late Friday in Nevada. The incident occurred at approximately 9:15 p.m. when the Lyon County Dispatch Center began receiving multiple calls regarding a possible plane crash near Stagecoach, Nevada — about 45 miles east of Reno, according to a statement from the Lyon County Sheriff’s Office. Care Flight, a service of REMSA Health, headquartered in Reno, Nevada and Guardian Flight, headquartered in

Measles outbreak that sickened 85 children declared over in Ohio

The measles outbreak in central Ohio that left 85 children infected has officially been declared over, Columbus Public Health announced Thursday. “CPH has received the last pending test result, which was negative for suspected measles cases,” the agency tweeted. “We have surpassed 42 days, or two incubation periods, since the last rash onset, which fits the CDC’s definition of the end of an outbreak.”