Saving Israel’s Arabs, despite themselves – analysis

Is all guilt to be a result of presumed “racists”?

By Yisrael Medad, JNS

Mossi Raz, a former Knesset member who represented the extreme-left Meretz Party and didn’t pass the electoral threshold, was asked in a Wall Street Journal story dated Dec. 6, 2022: What is “left-wing?”

He replied: “It’s about justice … and the main injustice in Israel today is toward the Palestinian citizens of Israel.”

There are many values the camp of the left assumes for itself, and Raz indicates that “justice” is one of them. Moreover, he slips in another prerogative—that of defining Israel Arabs deserving of justice as “Palestinian citizens”—that is, the Arabs of Israel. Yet Israel’s Arabs are a responsibility of the right as well.

The usage of “Palestinian citizens” or “Palestinian Arabs of Israel” is a fairly recent formulation. It stems from calls by academics and community activists that the Arab minority of Israel is part of a national grouping. As such, they have a right to demand that the state grant them fundamental recognition as an indigenous national minority, as well as autonomy and self-rule in many aspects of their ethnic-communal life in Israel.

The definition seeks a reordering of Israel, removing its definition as a Jewish state—a title even the United Nations recognized as legitimate and just. After all, its 1947 partition proposal called for an “Independent Jewish State” to “come into existence in Palestine,” and he employed the words “Jewish state” more than two-dozen times. The term “a Jew in the Arab State” was what was used in the proposal for those Jewish residents of Palestine who intended to remain in areas in which they resided, not taking into account that the Arabs were planning complete ethnic cleansing.

What is currently the preferred term is a “state of all its citizens” and, in the meantime, an intermediary stage would be “cultural autonomy” for the Arab community. These ideas enjoy firm and widespread support within the Arab public, as reflected in public opinion surveys that have been conducted in recent years, as well as among left-wing Jews. All these ideas evolved out of what has been termed the “Vision Documents.”

Those four position papers included plans and demands of the National Committee for the Heads of the Arab Local Authorities in Israel; the Mossawa Center; Adalah; and “The Haifa Declaration,” published by Mada al-Carmel. These all appeared in late 2006 and early 2007, though the propositions first entered public discourse in the mid-1989 when the idea of autonomy for Israeli Arabs was raised by two Israeli Arab intellectuals: Azmi Bishara and Said Zaidani.

Their outlook was that Israel is the product of a “colonialist process” that had imposed the state and its citizenship on an unwilling native population. Israel, they maintain, can no longer be defined only as the nation-state of the Jewish people and should assume responsibility for what they called the “historical injustice” it caused the “Palestinians,” in addition to providing compensation. Citizens, however, have duties as well as rights.

One of those duties is the maintenance of a sane semblance of internal social cohesion and consolidation, as well as a solid level of shared mutual responsibility. The statistics and news reports would indicate that that does not exist in the Arab community.

Statistics provided by the Abraham Initiatives NGO for 2021 reveal that 126 Arabs were killed by Arabs, 16 of them women. In 2022, 116 Arabs lost their lives to other Arabs. By the end of January, 13 Arabs have been murdered by other Arabs within the Arab sector in Israel. Over a 24-hour period in the first week of February, four Arabs had been killed within their community. It goes on.

This NGO, which terms these Arabs “Palestinian” rather than “Israeli,” sees a “certified racist” as being in charge of the police, and that the “root causes” of this situation are the need for “socioeconomic development of Arab society.” The New Israel Fund’s 2021 financial report reads: “The NIF redoubled our work to advance a genuinely shared society for Jewish and Palestinian citizens of Israel.” But who is to construct that development, and are there any internal root causes? For example, why is “honor killing” still an accepted and understood phenomenon?

An internal reality?

Is all guilt to be a result of presumed “racists”? Are we faced with external “racists” killing Arabs, or is it an internal reality? Is the problem a near-total breakdown of communal loyalty, whereby criminal elements have completely taken over? Is it, perhaps, the abandonment by communal leaders, elected officials, politicians, religious figures and educators of their duties to their community? Are Sharia court judges doing the best they can?

The Taub Center for Social Policy Studies published a report in June 2022 titled “A Picture of the Nation.” According to the findings, whereas between 2011 and 2021 the number of murders in the Jewish population declined (despite a population growth of 20%), in contrast, from 2016 to 2021 the number of murders within the Arab population doubled. Although Arabs represent 21% of Israel’s total population, 80% of all murders in Israel in the years 2020-21 occurred in the Arab population. Why is that?

The Taub Center sees as critical influential factors a “youth bulge” that is “socially disengaged.” These youth are “underemployed and not in higher education.” There is also a gender element involved with the Taub Center finding that in the 2020/21 academic year, 74% of all master’s degree students and 68% of those in a Ph.D. program are women among the Arab population.

Parallel to that, between 2004 and 2019, there has been an increase of more than 50% in the divorce rate among Muslims and Druze (and more than doubled among Christians). Muslim marriages are becoming significantly destabilized, and half of all femicide cases in Israel’s Arab society remain unsolved.

Perhaps, oddly, TikTok has been reported to be an element in Israel’s Arab crime epidemic. The social-media site amplifies conflicts and crime in the Arab community, police confirm, with video clips glorifying illegal actions including shooting guns in the street, drug and weapons possession, high-speed driving and threats of murder.

The Baladna NGO now researches this aspect of promoting violent messages in the context of crime. The nationalist violence of May 2022 in mixed cities and neighborhoods was fed by this as well, as is the protection racket in the north and south.

Ze’ev Jabotinsky wrote in a 1926 pamphlet, “What the Zionist-Revisionists Want,” that after the establishment of the Jewish state, “a considerable Arab population always will remain … if things fare badly for this group of inhabitants, the entire country will fare badly. The political, economic and cultural welfare of the Arabs will thus always remain one of the main conditions for the well-being of the Land of Israel.”

This government is headed by the successors of the Jabotinsky legacy. It behooves it both to confront the attempts by Israel’s Arabs to obtain an out-of-state cultural and redefined political identity on the one hand, while on the other, assisting them more actively and efficiently to solve their internal social difficulties, even in spite of themselves.

Yisrael Medad is an analyst and opinion commentator on political, cultural and media issues.

The post Saving Israel’s Arabs, despite themselves – analysis appeared first on World Israel News.

GOP hawks say the only thing cut from the Pentagon will be ‘wokeness’

‘I can’t think of a worse time to cut defense spending than now,’ Rep. Mike Gallagher says.

By Adam Kredo, Washington Free Beacon

Congressional defense hawks say the only cuts to the defense budget that will be considered will be to “woke” programs, saying cuts to the Pentagon would be disastrous as the United States faces down a Russian war in Ukraine and Chinese threats to invade Taiwan.

“As Russia wages war on Ukraine and China eyes a similar move on Taiwan, I can’t think of a worse time to cut defense spending than now,” Rep. Mike Gallagher (R., Wis.), a member of the House Armed Services Committee, which oversees America’s $400 billion defense budget, told the Washington Free Beacon.

Gallagher and other Armed Services Committee leaders, including chairman Mike Rogers (R., Ala.), told the Washington Free Beacon there is zero appetite among the majority of House Republicans to roll back the Pentagon’s budget.

As part of concessions to a small group of Republican holdouts during the House speakership fight, Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R., Calif.) reportedly agreed to some $130 billion in spending cuts that are expected to impact even traditionally insulated agencies like the Defense Department. The agreement has given rise to concerns the Pentagon’s budget could be frozen in place, preventing it from expanding war-fighting priorities amid rising demands due to the war in Ukraine.

McCarthy has said he would only cut the Defense Department’s spending on “wokeism” and other projects not impacting war-fighting capabilities. Others, such as Rep. Jim Jordan (R., Ohio), said “everything has to be on the table” as the 2023 budget is made. But those with the most power over the Pentagon’s budget said they will prevent any cuts that negatively impact an already strained fighting force.

The Biden administration’s push to foster a more sensitive environment across the U.S. military has been under Republican scrutiny since the president took office. Hawks have pilloried the introduction of critical race theory books in the Navy as well as mandated gender identity trainings implemented by the Army and Navy.

Republican defense leaders who spoke to the Free Beacon said they see a pathway to compromise with far-right budget hawks. As McCarthy recently proposed, military programs seen as promoting a “woke” agenda, such as diversity and inclusion training, could provide a pathway to satiate members advocating defense cuts as well as those trying to keep the military well equipped to face down Russia, China, and Iran.

“On the House Armed Services Committee—we are laser-focused on the threats we face and the capabilities we need to defeat them,” Rogers told the Free Beacon. “We are examining programs to determine if they actually provide the capabilities we need to defeat the threats we face. If they don’t, they’ll be cut. However, maintaining overmatch with China requires modernizing our military, and we cannot shy away from that investment.”

Rep. Jim Banks (R., Ind.), also an Armed Services Committee member, offered a similar analysis. Banks, like other GOP hawks, said wide-ranging defense cuts will embolden China and other U.S. enemies.

Chinese leader Xi Jinping “is now planning a visit to Moscow,” Banks said, pointing to increased ties between China and Russia. U.S. president Joe Biden “has fomented chaos around the globe,” Banks said, “and House Republicans need to be laser-focused on investing in our military and disentangling our defense industrial base from our greatest adversary.”

Banks said he “will never vote to cut defense spending, and a large majority of Republicans are in the same boat.” But the congressman also said there “are plenty of budget cuts I support that would strengthen our military, like defunding Office of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion at the [Defense Department].”

“Wokeness is weakness, and defunding these far-left ideologies will boost cohesion, retention, and morale and make our military stronger,” Banks said.

There are concerns that with a slim Republican majority in the House, Republican defectors could team up with dovish Democrats to force defense cuts. “There are places I may actually agree with Republicans on defense cuts,” Rep. Ro Khanna (D., Calif.) said last month. “If they’re going to look at that and make certain cuts, then let’s have that conversation.”

“What we saw in the speaker fight was that a relatively small number of Republicans are willing to hold the process hostage out of the desire to make dramatic cuts in the budget,” Rep. Adam Smith (D., Wash.), the Armed Services Committee’s former chairman, told the Hill last month. “So regardless of what McCarthy did or did not promise, that same group of people can do the same thing on the budget, on the appropriations bills, on the defense bill.”

It is unlikely that any Democrat would sign on to cuts that target liberal initiatives such as the DEI office Banks has in his sights, and Republicans think they have a better chance to bring the party together on redirecting funds toward war-fighting rather than making any cuts.

Military capability needed to counter China

Rep. Mike Waltz (R., Fla.), a combat veteran who serves on the Armed Services Committee, said all flanks of the Republican Party could unite to redirect Pentagon funding to critical war-fighting programs that increase America’s ability to confront China and other threats, such as those posed by Iran in the Middle East.

“I’m in favor of identifying wasteful programs within the [Defense Department] and redirecting those funds to urgent priorities, but we cannot propose broad spending cuts on the backs of our troops,” Waltz told the Free Beacon.

“We need to ensure our military has the capability to counter China’s massive military buildup, Iran’s growing nuclear capabilities, the emerging terrorist threat in Afghanistan, and much more.”

There are also concerns that potential defense cuts could interfere with efforts to modernize America’s military, which has lagged behind similar efforts undertaken by China and other nations in recent years. Military production lines in the United States also have been strained by the ongoing war in Ukraine, where America is supplying a great amount of hardware. Potential cuts to the defense budget could exacerbate these supply-line issues.

“A strong budget ensures that our military forces are always capable of safeguarding the homeland, protecting our national interests, strengthening foreign alliances and partnerships, rapidly modernizing our forces to counter emerging threats, and supporting service-member families and veterans,” Rep. Joe Wilson (R., S.C.), another Armed Services Committee member, told the Free Beacon.

Rebeccah Heinrichs, a national security analyst with the Hudson Institute think tank, said the American military needs hardware now more than ever, particularly if it is to engage in a showdown with China in the Pacific region.

“In an idyllic world at peace,” Heinrichs said, “we could do the hard acquisition reform and gut all of the butter out of a budget that’s supposed to be strictly guns, so to speak. But we are not in that world.”

The post GOP hawks say the only thing cut from the Pentagon will be ‘wokeness’ appeared first on World Israel News.

Terrorists who murdered Elan Ganeles captured

“Whoever tries to hurt us will pay the price,” Netanyahu said after terrorists who murdered a 26-year-old American man were apprehended.

By World Israel News Staff

Israeli forces operating outside of Jericho Wednesday afternoon captured two terrorists suspected in the murder earlier this week of an American-Israel visiting the country, an IDF spokesperson said.

IDF forces working in conjunction with Border Police officers and the Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet) surrounded a house in the Aqabat Jabr camp south of Jericho Wednesday afternoon, as part of the manhunt for two terrorists responsible for the deadly shooting attack Monday that left 26-year-old Connecticut-native Elan Ganeles dead.

Ganeles, a dual U.S.-Israeli citizen who served in the IDF before returning to the U.S. for college, was shot and critically wounded on Route 90 near the Dead Sea Monday during a trip to Israel for a wedding. He died shortly afterwards in hospital.

“A short while ago, in joint IDF, ISA, and Israel Border Police activity, the security forces operated in the Aqabat Jabr camp adjacent to the city of Jericho,” an army spokesperson said.

“Based off of ISA intelligence, the forces apprehended two terrorists suspected of carrying out the shooting attack (Monday) in which the late Elan Ganeles was murdered.”

The two terrorists were found holed up in a building in the Aqabat Jabr camp, and following a siege of the building, both terrorists were taken into custody and transferred for interrogation.

The army said a terrorist was shot during the operation, while the Palestinian Authority’s WAFA media outlet claimed three people were wounded.

Defense Minister Yoav Gallant (Likud) praised Israeli security personnel for the terrorists’ capture.

“I commend the IDF, ISA and Border Police forces for apprehending the two terrorists who murdered Elan Ganeles of blessed memory, during the attack conducted on route 90. Every terrorist should be aware of Israel’s defense establishment – we will get our hands on them.”

Following the arrests, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed that Israel would make any terrorists who attack Israeli targets “pay the price.”

“A short time ago, we apprehended the three terrorists who were responsible for the murder of Elan Ganeles. I salute the IDF and ISA for quickly locating the terrorists and carrying out a precise operation. Whoever tries to hurt us will pay the price.”

The post Terrorists who murdered Elan Ganeles captured appeared first on World Israel News.

WATCH: Thousands mourn American-Israeli terror victim Elan Ganeles, 26

Thousands of people throughout Israel gathered in the city of Ra’anana, north of Tel Aviv, to attend the funeral of  Elan Ganeles, who was murdered Monday by a Palestinian terrorist near the Dead Sea.

“He was the biggest gift in our lives. He wanted so much to see the world and all its aspects,” his mother, Carolyn, told the crowd.

“He was so loved, he will be missed so much. We feel like a part of our being has been taken from us,” she said.

A native of Connecticut, Ganales had worked as a geospatial analyst at the university’s Center for International Earth Science Information Network. He also served in the IDF.

The mourners sang Hatikvah (Hebrew for ‘The Hope’), Israel’s national anthem.

People who attended the funeral of Elan Ganeles signing HaTikva together.#Israel pic.twitter.com/K7Z47BFX6u

— Agencia AJN (@AgenciaAJN) March 1, 2023

The post WATCH: Thousands mourn American-Israeli terror victim Elan Ganeles, 26 appeared first on World Israel News.

The Great Salt Lake in Utah is disappearing, leaving behind a toxic bowl of dust and potentially one of the greatest environmental disasters in US history

Scientists warned Utah lawmakers the state would face “unprecedented” danger if the Great Salt Lake doesn’t receive an influx of water by next year.

WATCH: Schools, medical facilities, transportation blocked in country-wide anti-gov’t protests

Tens of thousands of protesters against judicial reform have caused a standstill at major highways and train stations as well as disrupting schools on Wednesday.

Israel-based international human rights lawyer Arsen Ostrovsky tweeted, “Protest is a sacrosanct right in any democracy. But it is also not without limit. You can’t hold an entire country hostage, including those going to work, school and medical need.

כך זה נראה בצומת הכפר הירוק
צילום: שי קוריאנסקי pic.twitter.com/6gaNHFx3cj

— Bar Peleg (@bar_peleg) March 1, 2023

The post WATCH: Schools, medical facilities, transportation blocked in country-wide anti-gov’t protests appeared first on World Israel News.

In time for Purim: Inscription bearing name of King Ahasuerus’s father found in Israel

Persian King Darius the Great’s name was found on a 2,500-year-old potsherd in Tel Lachish.

By Batya Jerenberg, World Israel News

In an archaeological first, the name of King Darius the Great, father of King Ahasuerus of Purim holiday fame, has been discovered in Israel, the Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) announced Wednesday.

International Media adviser to President Isaac Herzog, Eylon Levy, was visiting the Tel Lachish National Park with a friend in December when they chanced upon a small inscribed potsherd adorned by a brief phrase.

They immediately reported it to the IAA, although they could not believe at first that they had made such an important discovery.

“When I picked up the ostracon and saw the inscription, my hands shook,” Levy said. “I looked left and right for the cameras, because I was sure someone was playing an elaborate prank on me.”

He was simply“walking around” and “turning over pieces of pottery and stones in my hand,” he said, when “suddenly, I found something that had letters on it, and I thought this was too good to be true.”

Two experts, Dr. Haggai Misgav of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and the IAA’s own Saar Ganor, determined with some help from the Authority’s analytical laboratory scanners that the words were in Aramaic and said “Year 24 of Darius.”

Historically speaking, this would mean that the original container was made in 498 BCE, over 2,500 years ago. This was in the midst of the period in which Israel existed as part of the Idumean (Edomite) province of the Persian Empire.

Lachish was then a major, fortified city, responsible for the all-important collection of local taxes for the king. The ostracon was found in the area of an elaborate administrative building from the Persian period that had been uncovered in a 1930s excavation by the British Archaeological Expedition.

The IAA announcement theorized that the potsherd “may have been an administrative note, akin to a receipt for goods or for their dispatchment.”

The IAA emphasized the importance of having finally found physical documentation in Israel of the existence of King Darius, who is called “the Great” for having expanded his empire’s boundaries tremendously during his 36-year reign.

His son, King Ahasuerus (Xerxes in Greek), is even more famous among Jews than his father, however, as he was the monarch who plotted with the evil Haman to murder all the Jews in his 127-country realm before the courageous Queen Esther overturned the plan and saved her people.

The holiday commemorating the miraculous turn of events, Purim, will be celebrated next week. IAA director Eli Escuzido summed up the find by saying that Ahasuerus “could never have imagined that we would find evidence of his father in Israel 2,500 years after the dramatic events in his royal court.”

The post In time for Purim: Inscription bearing name of King Ahasuerus’s father found in Israel appeared first on World Israel News.