Florida Republicans Are Reminding Us Again: The Right Doesn’t Care About Free Speech

The Right makes a big show of supporting free speech. But Republicans are advancing legislation in Florida that is doing the exact opposite, attempting to clamp down on the free speech rights of bloggers who criticize Gov. Ron DeSantis.

Florida governor Ron DeSantis speaking in early February, 2023. (@GovRonDeSantis / Twitter)

Earlier this month, Florida state senator Jason Brodeur proposed a piece of legislation that has to count among the most stupidly sinister in recent memory. SB 1316, which Brodeur has innocuously titled “An Act Relating to Information Dissemination,” would force bloggers who write about Ron DeSantis and other government officials to register with the state or face stiff financial penalties if they refuse.

The bill would further compel anyone who wants to write about “elected state officers” (defined in its text as “the Governor, the Lieutenant Governor, a Cabinet officer, or any member of the Legislature”) to disclose the source and amount of any compensation they receive, right down to the individual post: “If a blogger posts to a blog about an elected state officer and receives, or will receive, compensation for that post, the blogger must register.”

Brodeur has sought to frame the legislation using the language of openness and transparency. “Paid bloggers are lobbyists who write instead of talk,” he told Florida Politics. “They both are professional electioneers. If lobbyists have to register and report, why shouldn’t paid bloggers?”

Do you want to know the truth about the so-called “blogger” bill?

It brings the current pay-to-play scheme to light and gives voters clarity as to who is influencing their elected officials, JUST LIKE how we treat lobbyists. It’s an electioneering issue, not a free speech issue pic.twitter.com/XO6RKhrjZq

— Jason Brodeur (@jasonbrodeur) March 5, 2023

Mercifully, the bill is very unlikely to pass. The governor’s office is reportedly reviewing it, but a passively worded statement from DeSantis’s press secretary did not suggest it would receive his backing in present form. Newt Gingrich, for some reason, has come out strongly against it. It’s also met with a decidedly cool reception in the conservative media.

Taken on its own, SB 1316 is nonetheless a fascinating case study in how easily authoritarian ideas can be laundered through the language of openness and transparency. If a hypothetical liberal lawmaker had proposed anything even remotely resembling it, the conservative response would basically write itself: the idea of a blogger registry would be framed as a dystopian instance of state overreach against freedom of speech (and, for once, that framing would be entirely correct).

That a lawmaker sitting deep in DeSantis country apparently sees no contradiction between his own, oft-declared support for freedom of speech and forcing political bloggers to register with the state is instructive in itself. The conservative project is often understood in relation to concepts like property rights and the rhetorical constructs — free speech, states’ rights, etc. — invoked by conservatives themselves. In practice, however, supposedly cherished and foundational values like these can be subordinated to higher objectives whenever it becomes convenient.

The Right thinks all kinds of regulations on private companies — safety rules, minimum wage laws — are oppressive because the free market is sacrosanct, but is perfectly content to enforce stringent rules on those it deems excessively woke or decides are treating conservatives unfairly. The state should get off people’s backs and stop enforcing a rigid morality on private individuals — unless they’re transgender youth, drag performers, or academics teaching particular subjects.

The state should get off people’s backs and stop enforcing a rigid morality on private individuals — unless they’re transgender youth, drag performers, or academics.

Republican-controlled states like Florida and Texas are now regularly advancing initiatives along these lines under the neutral-sounding rhetoric of freedom and choice. In this context, it’s quite easy to see how the leap from free speech maximalism to a state blogger registry can actually be a very short one indeed. As the Atlantic’s Adam Serwer wrote in 2021:

Republicans cannot imagine labor relations as exploitative except in that someone might have to sit through a tedious video on race or gender sensitivity in the workplace. They do not perceive the concentration of corporate power as perilous unless companies’ desire to retain their customer base interferes with Republican schemes to entrench their own political dominance. They see freedom of speech as vital, unless it prevents them from using the state to sanction forms of political expression they oppose.

It’s in exactly this spirit that self-identified free speech champion DeSantis (and Brodeur, who is personally sponsoring it in the Florida Senate) are currently backing another bill that poses an existential threat to press freedom. By reforming the state’s defamation laws, the bill aims to eliminate a number of existing protections for journalists: making it harder for them to quote anonymous sources, curtailing anti–strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPP) rules designed to minimize frivolous lawsuits that can serve to chill free speech, and weakening the working definition of “actual malice” so that wealthy people and government officials alike can more easily sue and intimidate reporters. If realized, as the Freedom of the Press Foundation’s Trevor Timm argues in the Guardian, it could quite literally destroy independent media in Florida.

While it might be tempting to accuse DeSantis of hypocrisy, there’s ultimately no inconsistency here beyond the level of rhetoric. As in so many areas, the Right is perfectly capable of invoking freedom of speech when it’s ideologically advantageous while, at the same time, trying to curtail dissent. And if you only support free expression that aligns with your own interests and worldview, you don’t really support it at all.

Video: January 6, 2021 Capitol Hill Event, See the Footage

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Video: January 6, 2021 Capitol Hill Event, See the Footage appeared first on Global Research.

Israel Air Force colonel sacked for telling pilots not to report for duty

IDF chief Herzi Halevi approved the decision after the air force officer encouraged others to skip training to protest judicial reforms.

By JNS

A commander in an elite Israel Air Forces reserves unit whose members threatened to skip combat training over the government’s judicial reforms plan has been relieved of his duties.

IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Herzi Halevi approved the decision to dismiss Col. Gilad Peled, citing a “crisis of trust.”

The move came after it was revealed that the officer was not only participating in the anti-reform protests but was actively encouraging other reserve pilots not to report for duty. The IAF’s 69th Fighter Squadron of which he is a member made headlines Sunday when 37 out of the unit’s 40 fighter pilots announced that they would be boycotting combat training.

These elite reserve pilots fly F-15I Ra’am (“Thunder” in Hebrew) fighter jets on important missions for the Jewish state out of Hatzerim Air Base, near Be’er Sheba.

The 37 pilots were to hold their protest on Wednesday. However ,on Tuesday, following intensive efforts behind the scenes, they announced that they would be showing up for work on Wednesday for discussions.

“We are responding to the call of our commanders and will report to the unit tomorrow to talk to the soldiers,” the pilots said, “We have full confidence in the commanders and will continue to serve the Jewish and democratic State of Israel as long as necessary.”

Meetings were set up for the pilots with Halevi, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and Air Force chief Maj. Gen. Tomer Bar. The pilots asked that Gallant urge Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Justice Minister Yariv Levin to stop pushing forward the legal overhaul bills and begin negotiations with the opposition over a compromise.

Netanyahu on Monday night described as an existential threat the refusal by reserve soldiers to show up for duty in protest of the government’s judicial reform program.

“Refusal to serve threatens the foundation of our existence, and it must have no place in our ranks,” the prime minister said after attending a Purim megillah reading at a Border Police base in the Jewish community of Beit Horon.

“Israeli society has always condemned those refusing to serve. This will not be allowed to gain a foothold,” he added.

The post Israel Air Force colonel sacked for telling pilots not to report for duty appeared first on World Israel News.

21-Year-Old Pregnant Woman Gunned Down in Robbery Attempt Gone Wrong

Genesis Escobar, a 21-year-old pregnant woman from Chicago, tragically died in a robbery attempt gone wrong in the Belmont Cragin neighborhood in Chicago on Monday afternoon.

Reports suggest that she had climbed into someone’s car and demanded money before the situation escalated and shots were fired from within and outside the car.

Escobar was hit multiple times and was thrown out of the car at an intersection, where her body was discovered with money covering her.

Those involved in the crime fled the scene.

Escobar had been eagerly looking forward to becoming a new mother, as relayed by friends.

As of right now, no arrests have been made. The investigation is still ongoing.

Netanyahu, US Defense Secretary Austin discuss ‘common agenda’ against Iran

“If anyone in Tehran thinks that Iran can make unhindered progress toward nuclear weapons, they are mistaken,” the prime minister said.

By World Israel News Staff

Ahead of his official visit to Rome Thursday, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin to discuss, among other issues, the Iranian threat.

Austin arrived on a one-day visit to Jerusalem after stopping in Jordan, Iraq and Egypt. The US official’s trip was truncated due to the anti-government protests across the country.

Ahead of the meeting, the two statesmen made statements to the press.

“We have a common agenda to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons and preventing Iran’s aggression, maintaining the security and prosperity of this region, seeking to expand the circle of peace,” Netanyahu said.

”You’ve heard us say over and over again: We are absolutely committed to the security of Israel,” Austin responded.

After the meeting, Netanyahu issued the following statement to the media, saying that he “very much appreciated his remarks on behalf of President Biden, as well as the US commitment to Israel’s security, also on behalf of the President.

“Our conversation focused primarily on our joint efforts to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons. If anyone in Tehran thinks that Iran can make unhindered progress toward nuclear weapons, they are mistaken,” he said.

“I discern a change in the approach to Iran in recent months, both in the US and in the countries of Western Europe, and in the West in general, the premier continued. “I see a need and an obligation to try and strengthen a more assertive approach with Iran.

“Of course, this will be at the center of my meeting with the Italian prime minister, just as it was at the center of my meeting with [French] President Macron. I intend to hold similar talks with principal European leaders in the near future.”

The post Netanyahu, US Defense Secretary Austin discuss ‘common agenda’ against Iran appeared first on World Israel News.

‘Ambiguous loss is a trauma like no other’: The Director of MH370: The Plane that Disappeared on the Biggest Mystery in Aviation History

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post ‘Ambiguous loss is a trauma like no other’: The Director of MH370: The Plane that Disappeared on the Biggest Mystery in Aviation History appeared first on Global Research.

Huwwara: Israeli Settlers Release Song Celebrating the Burning of Palestinian Town

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Huwwara: Israeli Settlers Release Song Celebrating the Burning of Palestinian Town appeared first on Global Research.

Taiwan Family to be Compensated Over Pfizer Vaccine Death of Daughter

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …

The post Taiwan Family to be Compensated Over Pfizer Vaccine Death of Daughter appeared first on Global Research.

House Hawks Kill Bipartisan Effort to End War in Syria

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post House Hawks Kill Bipartisan Effort to End War in Syria appeared first on Global Research.

Protesters block entrance to conservative think tank offices with sandbags, barbed wire

“If this isn’t crossing a red line, I don’t know what is.” Six people were arrested.

By World Israel News Staff

Brothers in Arms, a protest group representing reservist soldiers and officers, blocked the entrance of the Kohelet Policy Forum offices in Jerusalem with bags of mortar and barbed wire on Thursday morning.

“The Kohelet Forum is a far-right, nationalist, and messianic organization. They push for a Jewish state that discriminates against women and shrinks democracy to realize their vision of a messianic dictatorship, a dark religious state with apartheid and annexation of the territories,” the protesters claim, as reported by Israel National News.

They shouted ‘Traitor” when Forum director Meir Rubin arrived at the scene.

According to journalist Sara Haetzni-Cohen, My Israel charity organization chairperson, blocking the Kohelet Forum’s offices crosses a red line, Israel National News reported.

“These violent barbarians came to Kohelet’s offices with their faces covered so that no one would recognize them, of course.

“At the Kohelet Forum this morning, there was a young woman working on a research project and as they yelled at her to leave (what were you thinking of doing to her, you bunch of anarchists?); they blocked the entrance with sacks of mortar and barbed wire.

“If this isn’t crossing a red line, I don’t know what is,” Haetzni-Cohen said.

Six people were arrested.

Thursday marked the second weekly “Day of Disruption” in Israel, with tens of thousands of protesters against the government’s planned reforms to Israel’s judicial system blocking major highways, thoroughfares and junctions. They also intended to block Ben-Gurion Airport to prevent Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu from flying out on a state visit to Italy, but the premier managed to reach the airport via helicopter.

Prof. Moshe Koppel, chairman of Kohelet, is one of the architects of the judicial reform program. In conversation with JNS last week, he explained that contrary to the claims of its opponents, who say that it will strip Israel of its checks and balances, judicial reform would restore the checks and balances that have been stripped away by a court system that has arrogated powers beyond its purview.

יום השיבוש: אנשי מחאת ׳אחים לנשק׳ חסמו את דלת הכניסה למשרדי פורום קהלת בירושלים בשקי מלט pic.twitter.com/3ZtsgI31RF

— חיים גולדברג (@haim_goldberg) March 9, 2023

In New York City, a group of protesters demonstrated in front of the offices of the conservative Tikvah Fund, yelling “Shame” because of its support for Kohelet.

Breaking! Today Israelis and American Jews protested outside the offices of the Tikvah Fund in NY for funding through the anti democracy lobby Kohelet Policy Forum the ongoing coup efforts in Israel. The crowd shouted “Shame! Shame! shame!” In Hebrew and English. pic.twitter.com/IXfmbQqp3P

— Gili Getz #SaveMasaferYatta (@giligetz) March 9, 2023

The post Protesters block entrance to conservative think tank offices with sandbags, barbed wire appeared first on World Israel News.