Saudi deal with Iran worries Israel, shakes up Middle East

Saudi kingdom’s deal restoring relations with Tehran sends shockwaves through Israeli leadership, leading to finger-pointing and concerns over long-term reprecussions.

By The Associated Press

News of the rapprochement between long-time regional rivals Saudi Arabia and Iran sent shock waves through the Middle East on Saturday and dealt a symbolic blow to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who has made the threat posed by Tehran a public diplomacy priority and personal crusade.

The breakthrough — a culmination of more than a year of negotiations in Baghdad and more recent talks in China — also became ensnared in Israel’s internal politics, reflecting the country’s divisions at a moment of national turmoil.

The agreement, which gives Iran and Saudi Arabia two months to reopen their respective embassies and re-establish ties after seven years of rupture, more broadly represents one of the most striking shifts in Middle Eastern diplomacy over recent years. In countries like Yemen and Syria, long caught between the Sunni kingdom and the Shiite powerhouse, the announcement stirred cautious optimism.

In Israel, it caused disappointment — along with finger-pointing.

One of Netanyahu’s greatest foreign policy triumphs remains Israel’s U.S.-brokered normalization deals in 2020 with four Arab states, including Bahrain and the United Arab Emirates. They were part of a wider push to isolate and oppose Iran in the region.

He has portrayed himself as the only politician capable of protecting Israel from Tehran’s rapidly accelerating nuclear program and regional proxies, like Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in the Gaza Strip. Israel and Iran have also waged a regional shadow war that has led to suspected Iranian drone strikes on Israeli-linked ships ferrying goods in the Persian Gulf, among other attacks.

A normalization deal with Saudi Arabia, the most powerful and wealthy Arab state, would fulfill Netanyahu’s prized goal, reshaping the region and boosting Israel’s standing in historic ways. Even as backdoor relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia have grown, the kingdom has said it won’t officially recognize Israel before a resolution to the decadeslong Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Since returning to office late last year, Netanyahu and his allies have hinted that a deal with the kingdom could be approaching. In a speech to American Jewish leaders last month, Netanyahu described a peace agreement as “a goal that we are working on in parallel with the goal of stopping Iran.”

But experts say the Saudi-Iran deal that announced Friday has thrown cold water on those ambitions. Saudi Arabia’s decision to engage with its regional rival has left Israel largely alone as it leads the charge for diplomatic isolation of Iran and threats of a unilateral military strike against Iran’s nuclear facilities. The UAE also resumed formal relations with Iran last year.

“It’s a blow to Israel’s notion and efforts in recent years to try to form an anti-Iran bloc in the region,” said Yoel Guzansky, an expert on the Persian Gulf at the Institute for National Security Studies, an Israeli think tank. “If you see the Middle East as a zero-sum game, which Israel and Iran do, a diplomatic win for Iran is very bad news for Israel.”

Even Danny Danon, a Netanyahu ally and former Israeli ambassador to the U.N. who recently predicted a peace agreement with Saudi Arabia in 2023, seemed disconcerted.

“This is not supporting our efforts,” he said, when asked about whether the rapprochement hurt chances for the kingdom’s recognition of Israel.

In Yemen, where the rivalry between Saudi Arabia and Iran has played out with the most destructive consequences, both warring parties were guarded, but hopeful.

A Saudi-led military coalition intervened in Yemen’s conflict in 2015, months after the Iran-backed Houthi militias seized the capital of Sanaa in 2014, forcing the internationally recognized government into exile in Saudi Arabia.

The Houthi rebels welcomed the agreement as a modest but positive step.

“The region needs the return of normal relations between its countries, through which the Islamic society can regain security lost from foreign interventions,” said Houthi spokesman and chief negotiator Mohamed Abdulsalam.

The Saudi-backed Yemeni government expressed some optimism — and caveats.

“The Yemeni government’s position depends on actions and practices not words and claims,” it said, adding it would proceed cautiously “until observing a true change in (Iranian) behavior.”

Analysts did not expect an immediate settlement to the conflict, but said direct talks and better relations could create momentum for a separate agreement that may offer both countries an exit from a disastrous war.

“The ball now is in the court of the Yemeni domestic warring parties to prioritize Yemen’s national interest in reaching a peace deal and be inspired by this initial positive step,” said Afrah Nasser, a non-resident fellow at the Washington-based Arab Center.

Anna Jacobs, senior Gulf analyst with the International Crisis Group, said she believed the deal was tied to a de-escalation in Yemen.

“It is difficult to imagine a Saudi-Iran agreement to resume diplomatic relations and re-open embassies within a two-month period without some assurances from Iran to more seriously support conflict resolution efforts in Yemen,” she said.

War-scarred Syria similarly welcomed the agreement as a move toward easing tensions that have exacerbated the country’s conflict. Iran has been a main backer of Syrian President Bashar Assad’s government, while Saudi Arabia has supported opposition fighters trying to remove him from power.

The Syrian Foreign Ministry called it an “important step that will lead to strengthening security and stability in the region.”

In Israel, bitterly divided and gripped by mass protests over plans by Netanyahu’s government to overhaul the judiciary, politicians seized on the rapprochement between the kingdom and Israel’s archenemy as an opportunity to criticize Netanyahu, accusing him of focusing on his personal agenda at the expense of Israel’s international relations.

Yair Lapid, the former prime minister and head of Israel’s opposition, denounced the agreement between Riyadh and Tehran as “a full and dangerous failure of the Israeli government’s foreign policy.”

“This is what happens when you deal with legal madness all day instead of doing the job with Iran and strengthening relations with the U.S.,” he wrote on Twitter. Even Yuli Edelstein from Netanyahu’s Likud party blamed Israel’s “power struggles and head-butting” for distracting the country from its more pressing threats.

Another opposition lawmaker, Gideon Saar, mocked Netanyahu’s goal of formal ties with the kingdom. “Netanyahu promised peace with Saudi Arabia,” he wrote on social media. “In the end (Saudi Arabia) did it … with Iran.”

Netanyahu, on an official visit to Italy, declined a request for comment and issued no statement on the matter. But quotes to Israeli media by an anonymous senior official in the delegation sought to put blame on the previous government that ruled for a year and a half before Netanyahu returned to office. “It happened because of the impression that Israel and the U.S. were weak,” said the senior official, according to the Haaretz daily, which hinted that Netanyahu was the official.

Despite the fallout for Netanyahu’s reputation, experts doubted a detente would harm Israel. Saudi Arabia and Iran will remain regional rivals, even if they open embassies in each other’s capitals, said Guzansky. And like the UAE, Saudi Arabia could deepen relations with Israel even while maintaining a transactional relationship with Iran.

“The low-key arrangement that the Saudis have with Israel will continue,” said Umar Karim, an expert on Saudi politics at the University of Birmingham, noting that the Israeli presence in Judea and Samaria remained more of a barrier to Saudi recognition than differences over Iran. “The Saudi leadership is engaging in more than one way to secure its national security.”

The post Saudi deal with Iran worries Israel, shakes up Middle East appeared first on World Israel News.

EU Empties the Arsenals to Fill the Arsenals

Defense ministers of the 27 EU countries, meeting in Stockholm, approved the plan – presented by Josep Borrell, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy – for “joint procurement of large caliber munitions.”

The meeting was attended by …

The post EU Empties the Arsenals to Fill the Arsenals appeared first on Global Research.

Israel to mull bailing out tech companies hurt by US bank collapse

Silicon Valley Bank, which collapsed after a run on the institution, held some $160 billion in uninsured deposits.

By JNS

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said on Saturday night that he would consider bailing out Israeli companies affected by the collapse on Friday of the Silicon Valley Bank.

“I am closely monitoring the collapse of the American investment bank Silicon Valley Bank (SVB), which has led to a major crisis in the high-tech world. From Rome, I have held talks with senior high-tech figures in Israel. Upon my return to Israel, I will discuss the scope of the crisis with the finance and economy ministers and the governor of the Bank of Israel,” said Netanyahu.

The Israeli premier arrived in Italy on Friday for a three-day diplomatic visit.

“If necessary, out of responsibility to Israeli high-tech companies and employees, we will take steps to assist the Israeli companies whose center of activity is in Israel to weather the cash-flow crisis that has been created for them due to the turmoil,” he said.

SVB was the sixteenth largest bank in the United States, and its failure following a bank run is the country’s second-largest ever after the collapse of Washington Mutual during the 2008 global financial crisis.

It held an estimated $150 billion in uninsured deposits, according to the company’s financial statements from last month, and more than $200 billion in assets at the end of last year.

Regulators estimate that the bank had seen roughly $40 billion in outflows in a short period of time, leading to the bank’s collapse.

The U.S. Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation said that all customers with insured deposits—namely, accounts worth less than $250,000—would have full access to their money by Monday morning. The FDID said that uninsured depositors—those with accounts exceeding $250,000—would get some of their money back, but did not specify how much.

Bloomberg reported that 93 percent of SVB’s accounts were uninsured.

Companies that did business with SVB have warned that the bank’s failure may force thousands of layoffs, and prevent workers from receiving their next paycheck.

California Gov. Gavin Newsom said Saturday that he was in talks with the White House to help “stabilize the situation as quickly as possible, to protect jobs, people’s livelihoods, and the entire innovation ecosystem that has served as a tent pole for our economy.”

Federal officials were facing growing pressure on Sunday to bail out even huge customers of the failed bank.

Israeli Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich said that he was forming a special committee to investigate the potential consequences for Israel from the collapse.

“We promised to work for the Israeli economy so that it is an island of stability and certainty amid the world’s turbulent economic waters, and we will do so, with God’s help,” said Smotrich on Saturday.

“The State of Israel stands with the local high-tech industry and will help it get through the crisis so that it can continue its developmental momentum and success.”

Netanyahu stressed that the collapse did not threaten Israel’s economy, which he said was “strong and stable.”

The post Israel to mull bailing out tech companies hurt by US bank collapse appeared first on World Israel News.

Biggest Lie in World History: There Never Was A Pandemic. The Data Base is Flawed. The Covid Mandates including the Vaccine are Invalid

Fake science was supportive of this devastating agenda. The lies were sustained by a massive media disinformation campaign. The historic March 11, 2020 lockdown triggered economic and social chaos Worldwide. It was an act of “economic warfare”: a war against humanity.

The post Biggest Lie in World History: There Never Was A Pandemic. The Data Base is Flawed. The Covid Mandates including the Vaccine are Invalid appeared first on Global Research.

It’s Still Incredibly Common for Americans to Be Uninsured

The typical measure of Americans without health insurance underreports how many people are going without coverage. Examining how many people go without insurance in a given year reveals that over 20 percent of Americans have gone uninsured in recent years.

Three ambulances are parked in front of the emergency room at Childrens Health of Orange County in California, November 1, 2022. (Allen J. Schaben / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images)

People who write about health insurance in the United States frequently cite statistics about what percent of the population has insurance. These statistics typically use point-in-time (PIT) measurements that report what percent of the population is insured at any given moment. These PIT measures are useful but can also mislead people into thinking that health uninsurance is a much less common experience than it really is.

To illustrate this problem with PIT measures, I used the longitudinal Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP) to determine what percent of the population was uninsured in any given month between January 2017 and December 2020 and what percent of the population was uninsured at any point between January 2017 and December 2020.

The black line is the PIT measurement that is most commonly reported. It shows that in a typical month, around 7 percent of the population is uninsured. The red line is the longitudinal measure and it shows that, over these four years, around 21 percent of the population was uninsured for at least one month. New uninsurance spells are most common in January of each year, which is what you would expect as health insurance plan years typically end in December.

Here is the same graph but for non-elderly adults.

For non-elderly adults, around 27 percent were uninsured for at least one month between January 2017 and December 2020.

Finally, here is the same graph but for people who were on Medicaid in January 2017. Initially, this group has a 0 percent uninsurance rate because they are all on Medicaid. But over time, we can see that they also frequently experience uninsurance.

The Medicaid case is an interesting one because, in the health insurance discourse, you frequently hear people say that people on Medicaid are already covered and so various reform efforts would not be beneficial to them. But, as we can see above, this is not true. Today’s Medicaid recipient is tomorrow’s uninsured person. In fact, today’s Medicaid recipient goes on to hold all kinds of insurance statuses in the future.

In general, policy makers and policy commentators frequently fall into the trap of looking at cross-sectional data and assuming that population categories are much more static than they really are. Yesterday’s uninsured are not today’s uninsured and today’s uninsured are not tomorrow’s uninsured. The same is true for the unemployed, the poor, and many other similar groups.

When you patch up the overall system so as to reduce, eliminate, or ameliorate certain economic statuses, the number of people this helps is not the number of people who are in that status at any given point in time. It’s vastly larger than that.

The NHS Is Slowly Dying of Privatization

Britain’s NHS on its knees after decades of austerity. The British government is deliberately underfunding the system, raising the real question of whether or not the public health system can survive much longer.

A nurse arrives to join a picket line during strike action by the Royal College of Nursing outside the Northern General Hospital in Sheffield, UK, on Wednesday, January 18, 2023. (Dominic Lipinski / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

We are living under a deeply cruel, ideologically driven government. Since coming to power in 2010, the Conservative’s austerity program has caused over 330,000 deaths, and the mishandling of the pandemic saw a further two hundred thousand deaths, many of them avoidable. Currently, an estimated five hundred people are dying each week because of delays in emergency care, while countless more pass away on National Health Service (NHS) waiting lists.

The human cost of the government’s mismanagement of the NHS is difficult to overstate, but it results from an intentional policy to underfund health care and allow private interests to extract money from the system.

The UK now spends about a fifth less on health care than our European neighbors — a gap of over £40 billion each year. In fact, one of the first acts of the Cameron government was to cut costs by halting the expansion of medical school training for doctors and cutting four thousand nurses’ training places. The wages of NHS workers were the next target, resulting in more than a decade of below-inflation pay rises, causing the real-terms pay of staff to plummet — nurses are paid over £5,000 a year less than they were in 2010.

We are paying for these decisions today. There are 133,000 vacancies in the NHS, including fifty thousand nurses and seventeen thousand doctors, including GPs. Years of underfunding have resulted in a deadly shortage of hospital beds, GP surgeries and health centers in a state of decay, hospital buildings that are literally crumbling, and a burnt-out and frustrated workforce. In my years of practice, I have never seen staff morale so low.

All the while, money that should be spent improving services is being syphoned off by private companies. The government is pouring money into private contractors to cherry-pick NHS patients from waiting lists. As a result, private companies are now performing more hip replacements for the NHS than the NHS. The funding for these operations comes from the NHS, but privateers take a slice.

Year on year, more and more services are handed over to the private companies to deliver, including imaging, pharmacy, data collection, and IT services. Some of these contracts are for eye-watering amounts, such as the £2.25 billion contract to provide pathology services in South East London, awarded with no public consultation. The “public” element of our public services is being eroded.

It is bad enough that an increasing number of NHS services are farmed out to the private sector, but just as concerning is the impact of substandard public health care in driving patients toward privatized healthcare. With 7.3 million people on waiting lists, wealthier people are paying for private operations, normalizing a two-tier health service and devaluing the NHS.

Britain’s adult social care system is a cautionary tale of how a fully privatized system might look. Often owned by hedge funds based in tax havens, private providers take between 20 and 40 percent of their budget as profit, neglecting those in their care and underpaying staff. The poverty wages paid to carers are evidence of the type of exploitation that happens in a system where private companies are free to maximize profits.

Beyond the money that is wasted and taken out of the system as profit, privately provided health care is less effective, with research from Oxford revealing a link between outsourcing services and increased death rates.

The state our NHS is in and the trajectory it is on is concerning, but there is room for optimism. Most Britons want a properly funded, publicly-owned NHS, with just one in ten supporting a wholly or substantially private service. And the large majority of voters, including 73 percent of Tory voters, rightly blame the government for the current crisis.

The NHS is in serious danger, but we know how to save it. That’s why this Saturday, March 11, we at SOS NHS will be demonstrating in London along with fifty-five supporting unions and campaigns. We will be demanding that all NHS workers get the pay rise they deserve, a commitment to end privatization in the NHS (including from Labour), and that our NHS receives the funding it needs. And we’ll be opposing the new laws attacking the right of health care workers to go on strike too.

If you share our aims and think a public NHS is worth fighting for, join us.

“Deconstructing the Obvious” – From My Lai to Nord Stream. Interview with Legendary Muckraker Sy Hersh

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the “Translate Website” drop down menu below the author’s name or on the top banner of our home page (Desktop version).

Visit and follow us on Instagram at …

The post “Deconstructing the Obvious” – From My Lai to Nord Stream. Interview with Legendary Muckraker Sy Hersh appeared first on Global Research.

Trump vs. DeSantis: Florida religious leaders mull conservative issues

With DeSantis expected to face Trump for next year’s Republican presidential nomination, conservative religious leaders in Florida consider which candidate to throw their support behind.

By The Associated Press

Several of Florida’s conservative faith leaders have the ear of two early frontrunners for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination – former President Donald Trump, who lives in Palm Beach, and Gov. Ron DeSantis.

The clergy’s top political priorities are thus likely to resonate in the national campaign for the religious vote, even as both men’s agendas are still being weighed from the pulpit.

The faith leaders’ key issues include education, especially about gender and sexuality, and immigration, a particularly relevant matter in Florida, which is a destination for hundreds of thousands of newcomers and home to politically powerful Latino diasporas.

Trump made reducing illegal immigration a strong focus of his previous campaigns, often with strident rhetoric, and has discussed building on his legacy in a second term. DeSantis, who isn’t yet a candidate but is widely expected to run, has taken a more careful approach with immigration developments in Florida, while spotlighting issues related to schools and family.

Several pastors, particularly in heavily Latino South Florida, argue for reforming immigration policy. They want a more orderly process at a time of historically high illegal border crossings, but also more help to regularize and integrate undocumented migrants who are contributing economically and socially in United States communities.

The faith leaders’ top priority, however, is defending their congregations, and youth in general, from what they see as efforts to impose — through public education – concepts of marriage, family and identity that run against their values.

Some LGBT advocates, teachers unions, and others argue that the issue of “parental rights” is being used to inject conservative politics into public schools.

But for pastors like Frank López of Jesus Worship Center in Doral, a Miami suburb, exposing children to certain types of sexually explicit materials in schools without their parents’ knowledge is a form of political indoctrination that “brings conflict to a family.”

“We don’t want any government ever to go above a father and mother,” said López, whose church has grown to more than 3,000 members from over 40 different nationalities since it was founded two decades ago with barely three dozen worshippers.

He cited as a counterweight a bill DeSantis signed last year to give parents a say in what books are available in school libraries, targeting the presence of sexually explicit volumes.

“I think that the government should not get involved in any religion, but yes I believe that religion should get involved in governing,” said López, whose church has hosted visits by Trump, DeSantis and other conservative politicians.

Tom Ascol, the senior pastor at Grace Baptist Church in Cape Coral who offered a prayer at DeSantis’ inauguration earlier this year, said he wants political leaders fighting “woke mobs” to restore “common-sense sanity” on issues like sexually explicit materials in public spaces with children.

“What Governor DeSantis did here in Florida, I’m grateful for,” Ascol said.

For Rabbi Avrohom Brashevitzky, executive director of Chabad Jewish Center of Doral, the top concern is similarly “the breakdown in morals and ethics,” which he believes leads to societal ills including antisemitism, a growing worry nationwide.

He attributes that breakdown to failures in education to imbue youth with the values of tolerance, kindness and a belief in a higher existence.

“Life doesn’t begin and end with your cheeseburger, you and your pleasures,” Brashevitzky said, praising DeSantis and the Florida legislature for passing a “moment of silence” in schools before the day’s start, where children can pray or reflect.

“We as a society, Christian or not, have a responsibility to protect the young ones,” echoed Abraham Rivera, senior pastor at La Puerta Life Center, a Brethren in Christ church with about 200 members in Miami.

The focus on freedom for conservative faith-based moral values, particularly for youth, is proving a winning argument among religious voters nationwide, experts say.

“I certainly see a lot of energy around what conservatives would call ‘parental rights’ … I don’t see that ending,” said Marie Griffith, the director of religion and politics studies at Washington University in St. Louis.

In Florida, conservative family values might have turned younger Latino voters toward DeSantis, helping to account for his nearly 20 percentage point reelection victory last year — “unheard of” according to Susan MacManus, a professor emerita of political science at the University of South Florida.

The state is almost evenly divided between Democrats and Republicans, she said. Trump won the prized battleground state by single digit percentage points in the last two presidential elections.

“The evangelical vote in Florida is too diverse to be a big force in politics,” she added, but many faithful across denominations like seeing DeSantis take charge of issues like sexually explicit materials available to children. “That resonates.”

The ability to stand up for more conservative values is also inextricably linked to the free exercise of religion for faith leaders like Rivera and his wife, Marilyn, who’s also a pastor and met with Trump when she led South Florida’s Association of Hispanic Ministers, which represents about 800 pastors from different Christian denominations.

“We never come at it from a hate perspective. As a pastor, I happen to believe what the Bible teaches about sexuality and marriage,” he said.

But he and other pastors fear holding on to those beliefs could put their churches at risk of being sued, for example when refusing to celebrate same-sex marriages, or that they might be forced to go against their conscience.

“The effort of some on the ‘progressive side’ to define religious freedom as freedom to worship but not necessarily the freedom to serve or the freedom to advocate” is also a top concern for Thomas Wenski, the Catholic Archbishop of Miami.

Wenski noted that “neither party will necessarily embrace the whole gamut of Catholic social thought,” which includes opposing abortion and capital punishment. Last year, Wenski’s strong advocacy for migrants and refugees put him publicly at odds with DeSantis, who’s Catholic.

Ultimately, faith leaders said that a candidate’s integrity and ability to address their concerns through policies outweighs a candidate’s likeability and other personal traits.

“The Christian church is not about looking for a perfect person or a charismatic person,” López said. “It wants a person who does what he says and a person who’s aligned with God’s values.”

The post Trump vs. DeSantis: Florida religious leaders mull conservative issues appeared first on World Israel News.

Is the Biden administration funding mass protests in Israel?

Media reports and senior Netanyahu officials claim that U.S. taxpayer money is bankrolling major organizer of anti-judicial reform protests.

By Lauren Marcus, World Israel News

A senior member of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s administration said that the mass protests against potential reforms to Israel’s judicial system are being partially funded by the American government.

Speaking on the condition of anonymity to Hebrew-language news outlet Zman Israel on Friday, the official said that “this protest is financed and organized with millions of dollars.”

He added that the protests, which have seen hundreds of thousands of demonstrators block traffic and march through Tel Aviv and Jerusalem on a weekly basis, are being funded from a central source.

“This is a very high-level organization. There is an organized center from which all the demonstrators branch out in an orderly manner,” the official said. “Who finances the transportation, the flags, the stages? It’s clear to us.”

Though the official did not explicitly name the Biden administration or the U.S. as the source of the funding, other senior figures have said they believe American money is fueling the protests.

Netanyahu’s son recently tweeted a link to a Breitbart article which linked the U.S. State Department with a major organizer of the protests.

That Breitbart article heavily referenced a Washington Free Beacon report which claimed that U.S. taxpayer funds are being provided to the Movement for Quality Government (MQG), an NGO that is promoting the demonstrations.

“The State Department, which confirmed the funding, calls the group a nonpartisan organization, but its work opposing Netanyahu raises questions about how the group was able to obtain U.S. funding,” the Washington Free Beacon report notes.

“The United States typically avoids funding foreign partisan groups to avoid claims of political meddling.”

Rep. Jim Banks (R – IN), a member of the House Armed Services Committee, told the Free Beacon that he was concerned about the funding to MQC.

“The State Department should never fund foreign partisan organizations in allied democracies,” he said.

“If the shoe was on the other foot, the Biden administration would accuse Israel of interfering in our elections. Congress should absolutely review the State Department’s potential funding of partisan politics in Israel.”

The post Is the Biden administration funding mass protests in Israel? appeared first on World Israel News.

Attorney-General shoots down immunity proposal for Israeli soldiers

In response, Knesset committee postpones discussion on the subject; Ben-Gvir says, “She thinks she’s the prime minister.”

By Batya Jerenberg, World Israel News

In a legal opinion publicized Sunday, Attorney-General Gali Baharav Miara opposed a bill giving immunity from prosecution to security personnel who act against terrorists, raising the ire of the Otzma Yehudit party that is pushing for it.

The proposed law was problematic in several ways, Baharav Miara wrote, not least of which that it could backfire on those it is trying to protect.

“The bill exposes those working on behalf of the state to the possibility that legal proceedings – criminal and civil – will be brought forward, both in international courts such as the ICC, and in foreign countries,” she noted. “In this sense, and contrary to its purpose, the proposal may actually harm the members of the security forces by exposing them to criminal or civil proceedings abroad.”

The logic behind this is that since Israeli courts, which are held in high standing abroad, currently put on trial soldiers or others who allegedly commit crimes while carrying out their anti-terror duties, judicial bodies abroad rely on their judgments. A blanket immunity would spur these outside bodies to take up the victims’ cause instead.

Baharav Miara upped the ante even further, stating without going into any detail that such immunity could even lead to “greater danger to the lives and bodies” of the soldiers and police who take part in the “operational activities.”

The law is also unnecessary, she wrote, because “Over the years, various mechanisms have been developed in the State of Israel that are designed to balance the challenges that characterize operational activity and the importance of the duty to investigate cases of illegal or improper use of force by the security forces.”

“The immunity as proposed fundamentally changes the point of balance, and thereby results in a violation of human rights and other vital interests,” she added.

While a government committee would also be anchored in the law, which could determine if immunity should be removed in cases where action was taken with “bad faith or with malice,” the attorney-general argued that the committee members would not have the requisite “professional expertise” to come to a proper decision because they would consist of “non-judicial elements.”

In response to Bahav Miara’s opinion, which came just hours before the Knesset Constitution, Law and Justice committee was set to begin its deliberations on the subject, the coalition decided to postpone the discussion until at least the end of the month.

National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, who had insisted on the passage of this law as part of his Otzma Yehudit party’s coalition agreement with the Likud, criticized the Attorney-General over her ruling.

The Attorney-General, he said, “essentially wants to be the ultimate prime minister” in opposing “everything we propose,” he told Ynet. “With all due respect, she is not the only jurist in Israel and some think otherwise, who are no less professional than she is.”

The right-wing minister has made this accusation before several times, such as when the judicial reform plans first started being aired in December. Baharav Miara had made a speech in which she said, “In a democratic state, it is inappropriate to change the relationship between the political echelon and the judicial system through lightning legislation.”

Ben-Gvir reacted by saying, “The attorney-general is making the error of thinking that she is the real prime minister of Israel. Every law that she doesn’t agree with becomes a danger to democracy.”

The immunity law is primarily meant to protect those soldiers, police officers, or even civilians doing their national duty who shoot terrorists during an attack or military operation. It specifically does not grant immunity when there is suspicion of theft, looting, destruction of equipment, taking bribes, abusing, humiliating or perpetrating violence against uninvolved bystanders.

 

The post Attorney-General shoots down immunity proposal for Israeli soldiers appeared first on World Israel News.