The Basics of Marxist Economics

The analysis of capitalism that Karl Marx presented in the three volumes of Capital remains vital to understanding our social world. A renowned Marxian economist talked to Jacobin to break down the key points of Marx’s economic theory.

A drawing of Karl Marx. (Heinrich Zille / Wikimedia Commons)

The name of Karl Marx is often associated with the revolutionary political movements of the nineteenth and twentieth century that called themselves “Marxist,” and Marx’s best-known work is probably the Communist Manifesto, the political pamphlet that Marx cowrote with Friedrich Engels in 1848. Yet Marx’s crowning achievement was the in-depth, rigorous economic analysis of capitalism he spent his later years refining, which eventually became volumes I, II, and III of Capital.

Over 150 years since the first volume of Capital was published, Marx’s economic theories continue to be widely debated and discussed — and also maligned and misunderstood. Jacobin A/V spoke to University of Massachusetts Amherst economist Deepankar Basu, author of The Logic of Capital: An Introduction to Marxist Economics (Cambridge University Press, 2021), who summarized what is most distinctive and important in Marx’s economics. This transcript has been edited for length and clarity.

Cale Brooks

What’s distinctive about Marxist economics compared to other economic traditions?

Deepankar Basu

There are at least three distinctive elements. Marxist economics locates the study of capitalism in the broad flow of history. It understands capitalism as one form of organizing social production, and it sees capitalism as a class-divided society, just like feudalism and slave-based societies. Therefore, the first distinctive characteristic of Marxist economics is that it tries to understand how the class-divided society of capitalism gives rise to and is based on exploitation.

Second, Marxist economics looks at capitalism as a contradictory system. This comes from Marx’s work, where Marx highlights the positive aspects of capitalism in comparison to previous modes of production. These positive aspects create enormous wealth that can, if distributed properly, address the needs of the majority of the population — but that is not happening due to the way the relationships of capitalism are organized. There is that contradictory aspect: capitalism increases the productivity of labor and makes possible enormous wealth creation; but then, because it is motivated by generating profit and not satisfying need, it does not end up satisfying the social needs of the system.

The first distinctive characteristic of Marxist economics is that it tries to understand how the class-divided society of capitalism gives rise to and is based on exploitation.

The third distinctive element, which sets it apart from all other economic traditions, is the focus on crisis. Marx’s analysis of capitalism always highlighted that capitalism is a crisis-prone system. Even though there are periods when it seems to be doing ok, if we look underneath the surface, a crisis tendency matures, which will almost inevitably explode into a crisis. So if you look at the history of capitalism, every three or four decades it is caught in a deep crisis.

In Marx’s writing, you’ll never find something like a final demise of capitalism. There is a rich discussion of various tendencies that lead capitalism to a crisis, but how the crisis is resolved and what emerges from that is not predicted. The resolution can only emerge as the result of social action by large groups of people.

Cale Brooks

Your book is obviously not the first introduction to Marxist economics. But unlike other classic introductions to Marxist economics, you structure much of your book in the same logical progression that Marx used in Capital. Can you explain how Marx’s argument is structured?

Deepankar Basu

Between 1857–58, when he seriously started writing Capital, and 1865, when he had more or less completed some first drafts, we see Marx going through several different ways of organizing and presenting the work.

What finally emerged comes from two important ideas that Marx had. First, he realized, after his almost decade-long study of the capitalist system, that the focus of his work would be on capital. By “capital” he meant a system where sums of money come to the market, purchase commodities, produce some commodities with the purchased commodities — one of the important commodities being labor power — and then at the end sell those commodities that have been produced for more money. It is a system that is organized around the need to generate more money by investing money.

This process of what Marx calls “value begetting more value” or “value in motion” is what he understood by the word “capital.” Marx’s understanding was that capitalism is a representation of this dynamic, of this logic, of this need. Therefore, the central concept that he wanted to study in his book would be capital.

The second thing followed from his understanding that, if he wanted to present to his readers an analysis of the logic of capital, then it must not follow the historical trajectory by which capitalism emerged, but it must follow the logic of the concepts that are necessary to understand the social structure and dynamics of capitalism as it existed during Marx’s time. That’s why he did not present a historical narrative but instead presented a conceptual structure.

If Marx wanted to present to his readers an analysis of the logic of capital, then it must follow the logic of the concepts that are necessary to understand the social structure and dynamics of capitalism.

Moreover, the conceptual structure that he presented was organized into what Marx called “different levels of abstraction.” Just like any other science, social science also abstracts from various peripheral aspects of a phenomenon and tries to hone down and to come to the basic thing that comprises a system’s logic. That is what Marx wanted to do at the first level of abstraction, which he called “capital in general.”

There he wanted to understand the pure interaction between the two elements that comprise capital — on the one hand, capital or money, on the other hand labor — and how the interaction of the two gives rise to various tendencies that we see in capitalism.

Volumes I and II of Capital are organized at this high level of abstraction. What Marx abstracts from here are two things. The first is the fact of competition, which is the fact that in capitalism there is not one bloc of capital, but individual capitalists who compete among each other. The second is that in capitalism there is the phenomenon of credit, whereby banks can make credit available to capitalists, who can make credit available to households.

Then in volume III of Capital, he brings these things that he had abstracted from back into the analysis. So by the time we have reached the end of volume III, we have understood the logic of capital at a very abstract level, but then also have understood how it operates when it is brought down to lower levels of abstraction where competition between capitalists and the phenomenon of credit also play important roles.

Cale Brooks

One of the other distinctive features of Marx’s work is value theory. Could you explain the basics of Marx’s labor theory of value?

Deepankar Basu

The question of value is central to economic thinking, and it has been for a very long time. It starts with a simple phenomenon. If we observe the world of commodities where things are bought and sold, we realize that in the market, one commodity exchanges in a particular ratio for another commodity. For instance, let’s say the price of a table is forty dollars and the price of a shirt is twenty dollars. That effectively means that two shirts can be exchanged for a table.

Value is an answer to this question: What can account for the phenomenon of exchange?

This form of exchange of one commodity for another has been in existence for a very long time, and economic theorists have asked what underlies this phenomenon of exchange. Value is an answer to this question: What can account for the phenomenon of exchange? In the history of economic thinking, we see two broad approaches. One is the subjective approach — this is the approach of neoclassical economics. Then there is an older tradition going back to the writings of Adam Smith, David Ricardo, and Karl Marx, which provides a very different answer to this question.

The answer that is given by the classical economists Ricardo, Smith, and Marx is that what can explain the phenomenon of exchange and what can thereby account for the value of commodities is the amount of labor that has gone into producing commodities. That is that tradition’s answer, which emerged as the labor theory of value.

On the other hand, the neoclassical tradition, which started gaining prominence from about the 1870s, answers the same question by looking at what it calls “utility.” The answer it provides is that commodities exchange with one another in particular ratios because different commodities provide different levels of utility to the people who want to purchase them.

Now utility or usefulness was recognized by the classical thinkers as one aspect of a commodity. But they also realized that there is another aspect of the commodity, which is the fact that commodities can be exchanged for one another. When they see that what can account for the fact of exchange is not utility or usefulness, they want to give an objective theory of value. Therefore, they look at the process of production and at the relative amounts of labor that have gone into producing different commodities. Their answer is that the relative amount of labor that has gone into producing commodities can account for exchange, both its qualitative features and its quantitative features.

For classical economists, the relative amount of labor that has gone into producing commodities can account for exchange, both its qualitative features and its quantitative features.

That’s why their answer is different from the answer of the neoclassical economists who rely on utility or usefulness, which is, after all, a subjective feature. Because how much usefulness or utility I derive from a particular commodity’s consumption depends on me. It depends on my surroundings, on my state of being, whether I’m happy, whether it’s raining. The same ice cream that I consume will give me different amounts of utility depending on whether it’s a very hot day or a cold day. So utility is really a subjective phenomenon, and therefore the theory of value that derives from utility is a subjective theory of value.

On the other hand, the theory of value that derives from the amount of labor that has gone into producing a commodity is an objective theory of value because production is an objective fact. Labor going into production and the amount of labor going into producing different commodities is an objective fact. How we measure that value is a different question, and it may be that in some cases measuring precisely the amount of labor that has gone into producing a commodity is difficult. But nonetheless, it’s an objective theory of value.

The labor theory of value, which asserts that commodities have value because and to the extent they have absorbed some productive labor of society, was something that Marx took from the classical economists. But he then brought in more nuances. He asked, “Can we say something more about the labor that has gone into producing commodities and that can thereby give rise to value?” There he brought in the concept of abstract labor, and he said that abstract labor rather than concrete labor gives rise to the value of a commodity.

He also brought in the concept of socially necessary labor. Marx says that at any given point in time, given the technology of production and the intensity of work, the amount of labor needed to produce one unit of any commodity will be more or less fixed. That is what he calls the “socially necessary labor” required to produce the commodity. So he says, when we think about value, we have to think about the social context, the given technology and intensity of work, which will then define how much labor is needed.

The labor theory of value, which asserts that commodities have value because and to the extent they have absorbed some productive labor of society, was something that Marx took from the classical economists.

Finally, Marx was aware that we cannot compare an hour of a skilled worker’s labor with an hour of an unskilled worker’s labor. He therefore pointed out that there must be a conceptual way to make sure that we convert units of complex labor into units of simple labor. So once we have worked out these three concepts of socially necessary labor, abstract labor, and the reduction of complex to simple labor, we have a very solid foundation coming from the writings of Marx for a labor theory of value.

Cale Brooks

Much of volume I of Capital is devoted to explaining the emergence of surplus value and its importance in the process of capital accumulation. Can you explain the significance of the concept of surplus value to Marx’s analysis?

Deepankar Basu

There are two ways in which the concept of surplus value is significant for Marx. The first is that Marx located his economic analysis in the broader understanding of history, what he calls the “materialist conception of history” or “historical materialism.” In the materialist conception of history, capitalism is understood as one form of class-divided society. Now, in class-divided society, there is the appropriation of labor effort of one class by another. That was the central way in which the phenomenon of exploitation was understood by Marx.

Marx wanted to clearly understand and explain to his readers how the phenomenon of exploitation operates in a class-divided society. Marx was juxtaposing the understanding of exploitation in feudalism, which was very easy to understand because it was transparent, to the much more complex way in which the same phenomenon operates in capitalism.

In feudalism, to give a very simple analysis, the law enforced that the serf would work for four days a week on the lord’s land and for three days the serf would work on his or her own land. So four-sevenths of the serf’s time was immediately appropriated by the lord. The fact of exploitation whereby the lord appropriated the fruits of labor of the serf was transparent.

Marx claimed that the same phenomenon was happening in capitalism. But what was obscuring this was the fact that it was all mediated through the market process and the fact of exchange. In capitalism, the working class sells its ability to work to a capitalist for a wage. Marx wanted to show that when the capitalist used the labor power that he or she had purchased, and produced a commodity and then sold it in the market, in that process the capitalist was able to appropriate more value than the capitalist paid to the worker in the form of the wage.

This difference, which was essentially what emerged as the profit of the whole capitalist class, is what Marx understood as surplus value. This was probably the most important aspect of the concept of surplus value, because by demonstrating in a rigorous way that a market-based exchange system can also give rise to the emergence and appropriation of surplus value of one class by another — appropriation of surplus value by the capitalist class from the working class — Marx demonstrated in a rigorous way that capitalism was also based on exploitation of one class by another, just like previous class-based societies were.

By demonstrating that a market-based exchange system can also give rise to the emergence and appropriation of surplus value of one class by another, Marx demonstrated that capitalism was also based on exploitation of one class by another.

The second point was that Marx understood that the generation, realization, and distribution of surplus value was the primary dynamic of the capitalist system looked at from a macro perspective. Capitalism is about making profits, and the source of profit is surplus value. That is why what the capitalist class does with the surplus value that it realizes as profit has a direct implication for how the system evolves over time. Marx also argued that crisis tendencies that emerge in the capitalist system are related to either the generation of surplus value or the realization of surplus value.

The concept of surplus value played both roles. One, it emphasized that capitalism was a class-divided society and therefore it rested on the exploitation of workers by the capitalists in the sense that part of the working classes’ value creation was taken away by the capitalist class without giving anything in return. Two, the dynamics of the system, including its crisis tendencies, emerge from these two domains, one where surplus value is generated and another where it is realized through the sale of commodities.

Cale Brooks

Volume I of Capital comes to this great crescendo toward the end, where Marx is describing the process of accumulation. This is the central dynamic of capitalist development and growth. Can you explain what capital accumulation means for Marx and, relatedly, what his theory of persistent unemployment is?

Deepankar Basu

An abstract way to understand a capitalist society is to start with a capitalist or the capitalist class entering the market with sums of money and using those sums of money to purchase two kinds of commodities: labor power — the ability to work — and all other nonlabor inputs that are used in production. Then we travel with the capitalist into the factory, where the capitalist brings these two elements together, and once they are brought together, the commodity is produced, and the capitalist returns to the market once again — now not as a buyer but as the seller, because he has the finished commodities with him. Then he sells them.

In the process, the capitalist ends up with more money than he started with, and this extra amount of money is the monetary expression of surplus value. That is the part of the unpaid labor time of the workers who actually produce the commodities. Once we understand this, then Marx asks the question: What does the capitalist do with this extra amount of money that he has managed to extract from the working class, the unpaid labor time of the working class?

Marx’s answer is that most of the surplus value that has been realized is plowed back into the production process to generate more surplus value. And at the end of another cycle, it will again be reinvested so as to generate more surplus value. The reinvestment of surplus value into the production process with the aim of generating more surplus value is what Marx calls the “accumulation of capital.”

The reinvestment of surplus value into the production process with the aim of generating more surplus value is what Marx calls the ‘accumulation of capital.’

The process of accumulation of capital gives rise to a seeming puzzle. Let’s say the capitalists invest all their profits back into production. In this case, what will happen is the scale of production will rise and the demand for labor power will rise. If this keeps happening over many quarters and years, the demand for labor will ultimately outstrip the supply of labor power. Once that happens, the real wage that is earned by the working class will start going up. And if that keeps going up, it will ultimately start eating into the profits. If this is not checked, then this will lead, in the extreme case, to profits becoming zero.

This leads to a puzzle because the capitalist system is geared toward generating profits. If the internal dynamic of the system is leading us to a situation where profits will become zero, then this shows up in a deeply contradictory dynamic hidden within capitalism. So Marx asks: Is there a mechanism available to capitalism to make sure that the demand for labor power does not rise to the extent that it starts eating into profits and, at the extreme, pushing down profits to zero? And Marx’s answer is yes. The mechanism that he talks about is what he calls the “reserve army of labor” or the “relative surplus population.”

The reserve army of labor is the fraction of the working class that is not currently employed by capitalist firms but that is potentially available to be employed when necessary. Marx says that we can understand the reserve army of labor as being composed of three parts. One, which he calls the “floating” reserve army of labor, is the part of the working class that moves between employment and unemployment. Sometimes they’re employed, and then when there is a recession or a firm closes down, they are laid off and they are unemployed.

There is a second big element of the reserve army of labor, which Marx calls the “latent” reserve army. This is the fragment of the working class that has not yet been tapped into by the capitalist system but that is potentially available. Here he has two important demographic segments in mind. The first is peasant producers who own small plots of land and who are able to generate enough income so as to not need to come all the way to the market to sell their ability to work. The second is domestic labor, largely women, who for a long period of time were outside the labor force. This segment can be drawn on by capital if needed.

The third segment is the “stagnant” reserve army of labor. This is the part of the working class that has really fallen out of the system: workers who have either lost their skills or have, for various reasons, stopped looking for work. All of these together comprise the reserve army of labor.

And in chapter twenty-five of volume I of Capital, Marx demonstrates that fluctuations in the reserve army of labor are the primary mechanism that keeps the real wage movement in check and makes sure that real wages do not rise to an extent that will completely wipe out profit. This was a very important and revolutionary concept because it highlighted that the fact of unemployment is built into the capitalist system.

Marx demonstrates that fluctuations in the reserve army of labor are the primary mechanism that keeps the real wage movement in check.

While it is possible for capitalism to solve the problem of unemployment for short periods of time, over long stretches of time, unemployment as a feature of capitalism is going to be there. Because if that mechanism is not available, then capitalism will be in jeopardy because there will be no way of ensuring that wages do not rise to the extent that profits fall to zero.

Cale Brooks

Politically minded people should recognize the implications of agreeing to this analysis, that unemployment is a persistent phenomenon in capitalism and that it’s derivative of accumulation. This is relevant for when we think about various social democratic proposals or the history of efforts to create full employment, and many of the walls that they ran into at key historical junctures; or when we think of the failure of Keynesianism in the 1970s to explain what was going on with stagflation. It’s critical that it is accumulation that is driving this process — and not, as you’ll sometimes hear, workers asking for too much — that ultimately leads to stagnation.

Marx was a lifelong political revolutionary who spent a lot of his later life contributing to working-class political movements. At the same time, he was saying there are built-in limits to pushing for higher wages. That doesn’t mean you don’t do it, but that you have to find a political solution to deal with these objective economic structures that are inextricable from capitalism.

For most people, that’s where the story ends because they don’t read past volume I. But I want to turn to volume II now. Could you explain the importance of the circulation and realization of surplus value, as well as how Marx understands economic growth within capitalism?

Deepankar Basu

In volume I of Capital, Marx’s question is to understand how surplus value is generated and what the capitalist class does with that surplus value. So one part is to explain how surplus value is generated. Another part is the accumulation of capital, which is what happens when that surplus value is reinvested.

In doing this analysis, Marx had abstracted from an important issue: surplus value can only be realized and become part of the capitalists’ pool of money when the commodities that have been produced with the labor are sold in the market at an adequate price. In volume II, he comes back to the question: How is it that the capitalist system is able to produce a lot of commodities and then to make sure that all those commodities are purchased at the prices that are necessary to realize all the value? Marx provides an answer to this at two levels.

At the aggregate level, the main thing he wants to point out is that, when we look at the bundle of commodities that have been produced in a capitalist country in a period of time, let’s say a year, we will realize that all those commodities will be purchased either by the capitalist class or by the working class (roughly speaking, if we abstract from the state and from international trade for the moment). So the capitalist class will purchase from each other parts of what they have produced as inputs that they will use in their production process.

It is the decision of capitalists of how much to invest, of how much commodities they want to produce, which ultimately will determine whether all the commodities that have been produced will be bought.

So part of that total bundle of commodities, the capitalists will directly purchase from one another. The other part, which will be purchased by the working class, is also ultimately driven by the purchases of the capitalist class. Why? Because the capitalist class decides how much labor to employ. When labor is employed, workers get wage income. With those wage incomes, the workers go out and purchase commodities for their consumption needs. So it is the decision of capitalists of how much to invest, of how much commodities they want to produce, which ultimately will determine whether all the commodities that have been produced will be bought.

In the aggregate, the capitalist economy will be able to purchase everything that it produces at the right price to generate and to realize all the surplus value, if the capitalist class is willing to make an adequate amount of investment. Therefore, from Marx’s perspective, it was crucial to develop a solid theory of capitalist investment. Marx did not complete that project in volume II, and I think Marxist scholars need to work on this.

The second perspective from which Marx tried to attack that same question was to understand what happens when we think of the economy as being divided into what he called “departments.” Let’s say there are two departments: one department produces machines, another department produces consumption goods. Once we think about it a little, it is obvious that the aggregate capitalist economy, divided into these two departments, will be able to produce and sell everything it produces only if there is a proportionality between how many machines are produced and how many consumer goods are produced.

You cannot produce too much of either, because otherwise there will be a glut. The reason is that a lot of the machines that are being produced will be purchased by the capitalists who are currently engaged in producing consumption goods. And a lot of the consumption goods that are being produced will be purchased not only by the workers in the consumption goods factories, but by workers in the machine goods factories.

There is an interdependence between the two sectors. That is why Marx emphasized, through what are known as the reproduction schemes, that if the capitalist system is to reproduce itself smoothly over time and get caught neither in a problem of too much demand or too little demand, it must produce consumption goods and producer goods in some proportionality. We can actually be more precise and work out the algebra and show that there is a specific ratio in which these two departments must produce for the system to smoothly reproduce itself over time.

Growth is understood by Marx as the size of the flow of value through the capitalist economy over time.

From that, we go directly to the question of growth. For Marx, capitalism is a system that is geared toward generating and realizing surplus value. That surplus value that has been realized is plowed back into the system, which increases the scale of the production process, and so growth is understood by Marx as the size of the flow of value through the capitalist economy over time.

Over time, year after year, the size of value increases. It increases for two reasons. First, more surplus value is extracted from the workers because the working-class population, which is employed by capital, increases. It becomes more productive. Second, because of technological change, commodities are sold more quickly. The speed with which value traverses the whole process and comes back in monetary form to the hands of the capitalists to be reinvested once again increases over time. As more surplus value is extracted and as it is realized in a speedy fashion, the system grows over time.

Marx understood capitalist growth as a deeply contradictory process, which had the possibility of being interrupted at various points. The interruption of this generation, circulation, and realization of surplus value is what Marx calls “the period of crisis.” A crisis can happen if a lot of surplus value has been produced and for some reason the commodities are not able to be sold, so all that surplus value that was produced is not being realized. If that happens, then in the next period capitalists will reduce their investment, a lot of workers will lose their jobs, and the demand for goods and services produced will fall further. The economy will then move into a crisis.

A crisis can happen if a lot of surplus value has been produced and for some reason the commodities are not able to be sold, so all that surplus value that was produced is not being realized.

Another way a crisis can emerge is if there is conflict in the workplace, whereby the capitalist system is not able to generate enough surplus value, and that might then present itself or manifest itself as a fall in the rate of profit that is realized on investment.

Cale Brooks

Let’s turn to volume III of Capital, which is where Marx discusses how the capitalist class distributes the surplus once it’s generated, and the social relations that hold the ruling class together. Marx is not saying that every single capitalist is directly exploiting workers, but instead that many of them have to bargain with each other to secure their cut of the surplus. Could you briefly explain those divisions and how the surplus is distributed among the capitalist class?

Deepankar Basu

His argument moves in two steps. In the first step, he is looking at what he calls functioning capitalists: capitalists who are either directly involved in the production of commodities, or capitalists who are involved in ensuring that those commodities are sold. The first group of capitalists is what Marx calls “industrial” capital, and the second group of capitalists is what he calls “commercial” capital.

Industrial capital directly organizes the production of commodities and then hands it over to commercial capital, which then makes sure the commodities are sold to the final consumers. Let’s say you have General Motors making cars and then you have a group of shops that sell those cars. The first would be industrial capital, the second would be commercial capital.

Marx is very clear that surplus value can only be generated in production. All of the surplus value that is distributed and redistributed is generated in the capitalist production of commodities. That is the first place to start understanding how the surplus value will then gradually flow through society and end up as the income stream of different fragments of the nonworking class.

There is a process by which the total surplus value that has been generated in the production of commodities is redistributed between the different fragments of industrial capital.

Within the group of industrial capitalists, different types of producers have different capital intensities. Some production requires a lot of labor per machine, and some other commodities require the opposite. So there is a process by which the total surplus value that has been generated in the production of commodities is, in the first instance, redistributed between the different fragments of industrial capital.

Why is that necessary? It is necessary to make sure that every capitalist in the long run makes the same average rate of profit. Because if there is a segment of production that generates higher than the average rates of profit, then a lot of capitalists will come into that sector and the production and supply of that commodity will rise. Therefore its price will fall and the rate of profit will fall.

We can visualize this process working itself out over a long period to ensure that every capitalist who is engaged in the production of commodities — no matter which line of production he or she is involved in, whether producing cars or computers or shirts — gets the same rate of profit. The fact that production of cars might require many more machines per worker than production of shirts means that there is a first-round redistribution of surplus value among the industrial capitalists themselves. That’s the first step.

Then the commodities that have been produced are handed over to the firms that organize the sale of the commodities. Those firms do not produce anything; they just make sure that the commodities that have been produced are sold. This category of capital is what Marx calls commercial capital. So the second part of the argument is that what happens between industrial capital and commercial capital is a distribution of surplus value. If total surplus value generated was equal to $100, there is some process by which that $100 is distributed between the producer who actually organized the production and the firms that sell the commodities.

Surplus value was generated; part of it is realized by the capitalists who generated it, part of it is handed over to the commercial capital, because the commercial capital will ensure that the commodity is actually sold. Without the commodity being sold, the surplus value cannot be realized. That is why commercial capital is able to extract part of the surplus value.

The process does not end there, because all these firms need two things. First, they need to borrow money to finance their investments, because oftentimes they do not have all the money they need to expand their production, to introduce a new machine, or to expand the network of shops.

Part of the surplus value that has been realized as profit of the producing capitalists or the commercial capitalists has to be handed over to the money capitalists as interest income.

So capitalists end up borrowing from another group of nonworkers who specialize in lending money to the functioning capitalists, and this group is what Marx calls “money capital.” Now a process of bargaining happens between functioning capitalists and money capitalists. Part of the surplus value that has been realized as profit of the producing capitalists or the commercial capitalists has to be handed over to the money capitalists as interest income. That is necessary because functioning capitalists need to borrow money from the money capitalists.

The final cut comes from a group of nonworking people who have ownership of natural resources like land. Land is required for capitalist production — think of agriculture — but also think of mines, real estate, tourism, all of which require natural resources or access to natural resources. Owners of natural resources are able to bargain for a part of the surplus value from the functioning capitalists, who will use that natural resource for producing some commodity and selling it at a profit. The part of income that is taken by the owners of natural resources such as land is what Marx calls “ground rent,” or what we can just call “rent.”

So at the end of volume III, we have covered all the important segments of the nonworking class — the ruling class — and have understood how the income streams ultimately come from the unpaid labor of workers. The first cut goes to the industrial capitalist, the second to the commercial capitalist, the third to the money capitalist, the final to owners of natural resources. The first two groups get profit, the money capitalist gets interest, and the owners of natural resources get rent.

The first cut goes to the industrial capitalist, the second to the commercial capitalist, the third to the money capitalist, the final to owners of natural resources.

That is how Marx concludes the analysis: by showing how surplus value was generated in volume I, how it was realized in volume II, and then how it was distributed and ends up as the income stream of different fragments of the nonworking class in volume III of Capital.

Cale Brooks

The fact that everyone is dependent on markets for their survival in capitalism, either as workers in a labor market or capitalists trying to accumulate a profit within a limited commodity market, means that competition is generated from the class structure, and it’s something that must be dealt with in one way or another within capitalism.

The key thing that comes out of this process of competition is technical change, which is the addition of greater machines and laborsaving devices within the work process. How does a Marxist understand competition and technical change in contrast to other economic understandings of these phenomena?

Deepankar Basu

Marx always has the class structure in view when he’s theorizing capitalism, and he makes the following two points. First, there is the all-important contradictory relationship between capital and labor, but there is also the contradictory relationship between the individual capitalists or groups of capitalists within the capitalist class. The interaction between them is what we can understand as the process of competition.

Capitalists individually and as a group are interested in generating and realizing more and more surplus value. Since capitalism is not a planned system, each individual capitalist is not always trying to coordinate his or her action with other capitalists. In fact, the opposite is mostly the case. Individual capitalists within one industry, or different capitalists between industries, are always trying to outdo one another to generate more profit for themselves. The process of fierce, unrelenting, continuous competition is a fact of life under capitalism. Marx spends a lot of time describing and analyzing this phenomenon.

Since capitalism is not a planned system, each individual capitalist is not always trying to coordinate his or her action with other capitalists. In fact, the opposite is mostly the case.

In the competition between two capitalists, the capitalist who is able to reduce the cost of production will be able to win the competitive struggle. Why? Because the individual capitalist who produces the same commodity for a lower cost will, on selling at the going market price, be able to generate more surplus value and more profit. And by reinvesting that surplus value or profit into the production process, he will be able to increase the size of his capital base and to improve the techniques of production used.

So the capitalist who is able to reduce the cost of production is going to win the competitive struggle. Therefore, built into the logic of capitalism is a need for capitalists to continuously search for newer methods of production that can reduce the cost of production. Once we realize this, we also need to realize that one of the most important elements of cost for the capitalist producer is the wage cost, because labor is one of the most important elements of production.

The competitive struggle leads directly to the search for new techniques of production, which can reduce the amount of labor used to produce every unit of output. That is the secret to a tendency that we have observed for long periods of time, which is the emergence of laborsaving technical change whereby capitalist systems continuously improve on the methods of production by saving labor and increasing nonlabor inputs in place of labor.

The process of competition, which is inherent to capitalism, thereby leads to this particular feature of technical change. What is striking is that empirical evidence for long periods of time, and even today, has completely validated Marx’s understanding of the necessity of technical change and the pronounced tendency for labor-saving technical change coming into play over and over. This feature of Marx’s analysis is absolutely relevant to understanding the history of capitalist technology and also to understanding the current period of capitalism.

The Existential Crisis of Meaning and Human Significance Resulting from Global Capitalism and Corporatocracy

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post The Existential Crisis of Meaning and Human Significance Resulting from Global Capitalism and Corporatocracy appeared first on Global Research.

Must Watch: Man Accused of Murder Brazenly Escapes Courthouse

Recently released security footage reveals a 28-year-old murder suspect, Edi Villalobos, making an escape attempt at the Washington County Courthouse in Oregon on Monday, February 27th. Villalobos was standing trial for second-degree murder in the stabbing of 33-year-old Artemio Guzman-Olvera, alongside two counts of first-degree burglary, unlawful use of a weapon, reckless driving, and reckless endangerment.

The footage, which was made public by the Sheriff’s Office on Thursday, displays two deputies assigned to accompany Villalobos while his shackles were removed prior to jury selection. In a span of three minutes, the suspect leaps over a chair and sprints towards the exit, with the deputies chasing close behind. The video then shifts to the hallway, where Villalobos is seen leaving the building through a “staff only” door.

The ensuing two-hour manhunt involved several law enforcement agencies, canine units, and drones; a “reverse 911 message” was also issued to the local area, instructing residents to stay put. Villalobos was twice spotted during the pursuit but managed to elude officers. Finally, a community member in the 300 block of SE 4th Avenue reported a man attempting to break into an empty apartment underneath the caller’s dwelling. Villalobos was discovered hiding underneath a blanket inside a closet. He was immediately detained and transported back to the county jail.

The trial that was initially due to begin the week of February 27th was canceled and rescheduled for the end of September, with an additional three charges of first-degree burglary and one count of second-degree escape being added to Villalobos’s indictment. The Washington County Sheriff’s Office plans to address the escape through extra training.

EU-Russia’s “Unforgettable Divorce”

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post EU-Russia’s “Unforgettable Divorce” appeared first on Global Research.

‘FRIGHTENING’: Bias against ultra-Orthodox, judicial reform – journalist pleads for unity in Israel

One-of-a-kind investigative journalist, author, playwright and theater director Tovia Tenenbom warns against the deep divisions in Israeli society and media bias.

The post ‘FRIGHTENING’: Bias against ultra-Orthodox, judicial reform – journalist pleads for unity in Israel appeared first on World Israel News.

Father Kills Sex Offender with Moose Antler

Levi Axtell, a 27-year-old Minnesota father, has confessed to killing a sex offender he suspected of stalking his young daughter.

According to court documents that were obtained by Fox News, Axtell reportedly stated that he had beaten the offender, Lawrence V. Scully, 77, with a shovel and continued finishing him off with a moose antler.

Axtell turned himself in when he entered a police station on March 8th covered in blood, asking to be handcuffed. When the Cook County Sheriff’s Office arrived at Scully’s home in Grand Marias, they found him dead.

A witness reported seeing someone smashing a car in Scully’s driveway and then running into his home, followed by screaming.

Scully had been convicted in 1979 of molesting a 6-year-old in and had a history of conflict with Axtell.

In 2018, Axtell attempted to get a restraining order against Scully after believing he was stalking his daughter at her daycare center. This order was initially granted but was dismissed weeks later.

Axtell was arraigned Friday and was charged with second-degree murder. He is being held on a $1 million bond.

Authorities have stated that the recent allegations against Scully did not reveal anything and were mostly related to harassment. Axtell is next due in court on April 10th.

The Demise of Mesopotamia: The Geopolitics of Water. The Desertification of Iraq

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the “Translate Website” drop down menu on the top banner of our home page (Desktop version).

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Visit …

The post The Demise of Mesopotamia: The Geopolitics of Water. The Desertification of Iraq appeared first on Global Research.

Intellectual Property Killed the Movie Star

The lead actors in today’s blockbuster films are celebrities, not movie stars. That’s not their fault: the industry has reduced actors to stewards of profitable intellectual property, robbing them of the opportunity to connect with audiences and shine.

Bruce Willis as John McClane in Die Hard. (20th Century Fox, 1988)

At this point it’s hard to imagine Die Hard starring anyone but Bruce Willis. But when film producer Joel Silver was searching for the lead role of his 1988 summer blockbuster, the list included just about every leading man in Hollywood at the time. Clint Eastwood, Sylvester Stallone, Mel Gibson, and Arnold Schwarzenegger were among the prospects. The last two had worked with Silver in 1987 on Lethal Weapon and Predator respectively, both massive action hits.

Silver was contractually obligated to ask seventy-two-year-old Frank Sinatra first, since Sinatra had starred in a film that was legally considered a quasi-prequel. But after Sinatra turned down the role due to his age — a gesture that’s hard to imagine in 2023, with a new Indiana Jones starring eighty-year-old Harrison Ford currently in postproduction — Silver had a deep bench to choose from.

Hollywood didn’t just have actors then. It had movie stars. And everyone agreed on who they were, which is one of the category’s defining characteristics. We still have a few movie stars today — but the problem, as the Harrison Ford example shows, is that they’re the same ones Silver had to choose from thirty-five years ago. We’re running the old movie stars into the ground, and we aren’t making new ones.

Large action epics and superhero franchises routinely break box office records, but while their stars get massively rich, they seem to remain comparatively impotent. Today’s panoply of symmetrical muscle-bound actors who all quip in the same cool masculine tone may star in movies, but they’re not movie stars.

That the decline of the movie star has happened concurrently with the rise of comic-book films seems somewhat paradoxical, considering that comic books themselves provide the raw material for the making of great action heroes. Whether it’s an alternative interpretation or backstory or the introduction of new characters altogether into shared universes, comic-book fans welcome and even expect novelty and spontaneity when it comes to superhero protagonists. And yet today’s superheroes are dimensionless and lacking individuality, making it difficult for up-and-coming actors to truly endear themselves to audiences by playing leading roles.

Movie studios have achieved something useful for their bottom line and dull for the rest of us: intellectual property has replaced the need for movie stars.

This gulf between comic books and comic-book movies owes partly to how many more moving parts are in film production versus comic-book publishing. But it owes an even larger part to the matter of financial risk. Making movies is risky, and executives shy away from anything that seems unstable, including the differentiating features that give films and characters their individuality. The result is that every trace of human input in the art of acting, from unique physical characteristics to temperament, is minimized in order to maintain a homogeneity that fulfills studio-mandated near certainties. Financial backers like certainty, because they like to know ahead of time that their investment will be profitable.

In the pursuit of profit, studios have thus opted for safety and sameness. In the process, they have achieved something useful for their bottom line and dull for the rest of us: intellectual property has replaced the need for movie stars.

What Is a Movie Star?

An actor at work gives themselves to the project and inhabits the inner world of the character on the page. The craft has evolved as stage acting has given way to the Golden Era of Hollywood and on to New Hollywood, but that basic devotion to embodying the character has remained the same.

Changes in style and technique in acting owe largely to technology. For example, stage acting requires broader, more exaggerated mannerisms than film acting, since audiences aren’t able to see close-ups of actors’ faces. Similarly, early film, with its cumbersome cameras with film stocks that necessitated more light to even make an image visible, required less naturalistic acting and stage direction than the films that came later. As technology has brought cinematic images closer to reality, acting has transformed to become more naturalistic.

According to the film theorist André Bazin, an important component differentiating cinema from theater is the audience’s participation. In theater, there is a covenant between the actor and audience that what one is witnessing is a fabrication, and the audience in the presence of an actor must knowingly participate in the abstraction. When one views a film, there is a much less rigorous intellectual exercise underway, and thus audiences are able to more directly relate themselves to the characters they’re watching. A theater actor is the singular wellspring of drama on the stage, whereas in film drama derives from an actor’s presence and relationship to whatever else is on screen. It is through this relationality that film audiences come to personally identify with a film’s hero.

As film technology has evolved more, identifications have become more seamless and intense, creating perfect conditions for the rise of unique, beloved, universally recognized movie stars — actors who have the talent and presence to make the most of the medium and tap into that capacity for identification. But as intellectual property (IP) has come to dominate the film industry, it has also begun to interfere with the characteristics of acting that lend themselves to movie stardom. If an audience’s draw to films becomes ritual consumption of the IP instead of authentic attachment to the stars and the characters they portray, this delicate balance of personal resonance and intellectual connection is disrupted. Audiences become shareholders of a sort, members of a fandom tasked with keeping the franchise alive. As a result, audiences end up connecting with the business of film rather than the art of it.

The movie star is an actor whose presence strengthens that bond of identification through an immediate familiarity to the audience. In this relationship, a movie star’s value-add is their ability to join any project and confer not only a standard of quality but act as a guarantor of the audience’s connection. With franchise filmmaking, this is no longer necessary, and may even be considered a hindrance. Consequently, the rise of franchise IP-based filmmaking has seemed to reverse that process of ever-deeper identification in film acting, while also retaining nothing about what made stage acting so powerful.

When acting has been reduced to stewarding intellectual property, there’s little need for actors to have unique characteristics or styles. In fact, it’s better for investors if they function as empty vessels.

Audiences are not meant to connect with the new comic-book movie protagonists as imagined alternate selves. They’re meant to connect with intellectual property as members of a stable consumer base. Audiences are fickle, but fandoms are reliable, which mitigates risk and acts as a better indicator of future profits.

When acting has been reduced to stewarding IP, there’s little need for actors to have unique characteristics or styles. In fact, it’s better for investors if they function as empty vessels for stories much bigger than them, ones that can be endlessly iterated long after they’re out of the picture.

Method Acting and Celebrity

The advent of New Hollywood’s move to more realistic acting is often attributed in part to Lee Strasberg’s method, wherein the actor attempts to ground their character’s emotional state in their own personal experiences, and is trained to tap into them. This approach, called method acting, stands in direct contrast with the approach of more traditional theatrical actors, who built their characters through signature physicality rather than empathic emotionality.

The transition to method acting was the living embodiment of Bazin’s concept of the distinction between theater and film acting. Theater acting is an intellectual exercise for the actor and the audience, while film acting is a more instinctual means of identification. Strasberg’s approach provided a method for tapping into that instinct.

The rise of method acting in Hollywood occurred in tandem with the birth of the modern celebrity. This is no coincidence. Consumerism, marketization, and various industry strategies certainly played a major role in the rise of twentieth-century celebrities, but we can’t overlook the evolution of the craft itself. As method acting was based upon a much more personal connection between the actor and the character, audiences in turn felt stronger connections to characters and the actors who played them. This process naturally stoked curiosity, and mass media and celebrity gossip followed suit.

This balance of personal connection had to be tempered with a sense of separation. Just like a stage has a proscenium, films have the edges of the frame, and the conflict between the audience and these barriers is inherent to filmmaking. The tabloid press was the industry’s first strategy for making money off people’s frustration with those edges and the desire to trespass them. Another defining characteristic of the movie star exists in that in-between space: people desperately want to know about their personal lives, but some things are off-limits, no matter how hard the tabloids try to dig up the dirt.

Increasingly, however, nothing is off-limits. With the advent of social media, the industry has pivoted to a strategy of intentionally making actors more relatable and accessible outside of their performances. Actors are often required to have online personalities that encourage fandom cults, and blur the lines between their person and personae. That accessibility obliterates the mystique that is necessary for the creation of a movie star.

Female actors have always had to fight harder to maintain that mystique than their male counterparts. Marilyn Monroe, for example, was a particularly adept student of Lee Strasberg, who said in his his eulogy of her:

Others were as physically beautiful as she was, but there was obviously something more in her, something that people saw and recognized in her performances and with which they identified. She had a luminous quality — a combination of wistfulness, radiance, yearning — to set her apart and yet make everyone wish to be a part of it, to share in the childish naivete which was so shy and yet so vibrant.

Marilyn Monroe’s use of method acting, which drew on her personal experience, allowed audiences to connect with her vulnerability and feel close to her. But this only made them want more — and they felt entitled to it. Because she was a woman, the tabloid press was eager and able to exploit audiences’ “wish to be a part of it” in uniquely damaging ways. Female stars have always had to try harder than male stars to maintain the balance of relatability and mystique that elevates an actor into a movie star and keeps them in the category for life.

It has never been easier to become a celebrity — and this forecloses on the possibility of ever becoming a star.

Now actors of all genders are voluntarily tipping the scales themselves. As modern celebrities take to social media to integrate their personal lives into their brands, their fame increases, but the tension between relatability and exclusiveness that used to characterize movie stardom starts to disappear. It has never been easier to become a celebrity — and this forecloses on the possibility of ever becoming a star.

The Last Action Heroes

The action films of the 1980s were an expression of hypermasculinity in the wake of defeat in Vietnam. The Cold War, the beginning of the decline of the American working class’s share of power, and the introduction of austerity that would strip away the gains of the New Deal and the Great Society were all beginning to reshape America’s cultural sentiments about itself. So when the mid-to-late 1980s rolled around, producers like Joel Silver and Jerry Bruckheimer managed to read the moment and strike a chord with stars like Bruce Willis and Tom Cruise — two actors whose career paths chart the polar extremes of the remaining options for movie stars.

In the context of the release of Die Hard, the novelty of a character like John McClane was that he was an everyman thrust into an extraordinary situation that forged him as a hero. This stands in stark contrast to many tentpoles released today, especially superhero films in which characters — who we already know possess superior abilities — are made to feel relatable via their sense of humor or the fact that they have the same pop-culture sensibilities as their audience.

It’s hard to see it now, post–Die Hard, but at the time Willis was considered a relatively physically diminutive actor, known primarily for his acerbic role in the television show Moonlighting. Casting him as an action hero was considered so risky that the studio initially advertised the film by not even featuring Willis on the posters. It wasn’t until the film was a hit that they included his face. But the director John McTiernan was confident that Willis had the “everyman” temperament to make audiences relate to his character, and that this process of identification would make for an even more powerful hero arc. They were right.

Two years before Die Hard, another action movie star was minted when Tom Cruise played the lead role in Top Gun. His character Maverick was a cocky, charismatic fighter pilot who embodied the United States’ confident late–Cold War posture. The movie was a fantasy of the end of history: Maverick’s character nearly caused what would in real life have amounted to World War III simply because he wanted to show off. In the movie, the United States is so ascendant that there are no geopolitical consequences to his hubris. This triumphant attitude became emblematic of action films from the late 1980s to the early 2000s — until 9/11 jump-started another wave of paranoid war propaganda.

Once an actor has reached star status, their star power is an asset that, like capital itself, must be reinvested or else risk atrophying.

The storytelling and acting methods of Top Gun and Die Hard tapped into something deep in the American psyche, and transformed Cruise and Willis into bona fide movie stars. But where are our movie stars now?

Once an actor has reached star status, their star power is an asset that, like capital itself, must be reinvested or else risk atrophying. Movie stars have always walked a fine line, careful to keep working while not attaching themselves to projects that will hurt their brand name. Many of them also hit on a clever strategy for maintaining income as they waited for acceptable projects to appear: they did advertisements overseas.

Before the widespread use of the internet, celebrities who were protective of their star power could do ads overseas for extra money without much risk of American audiences associating them with tawdry or low-rent acting work. But once it became impossible to do these ads covertly, the jig was up: movie stars had to come out of the closet as working actors who appear in advertisements, something they’d always done, but discreetly.

In time, more movie stars began to make lucrative deals with domestic brands as ambassadors. This, in addition to social media making movie stars more approachable, has begun to erode the last vestiges of a star’s mystique. Consider the transactional nature of the app Cameo, which allows users to spend hundreds of dollars to have a celebrity send them a personalized video. If a movie star is cemented by their ability to command a broad relatability while retaining some degree of separateness, then reducing them to sending customizable happy birthday videos is an indication of their winnowed utility. There can be no movie stars in the age of Cameo.

Like overseas ads, the phenomenon of direct-to-video action films was once an easy way for struggling stars to make money without risking a box office flop. The formula was simple: take a low-budget B film script, shoot in a country or state with low labor costs and/or tax credits, have a movie star shoot for only a couple days in order to get the film funded with foreign presales based off of their international appeal, and then release the film in theaters overseas — and into the bargain bin at Walmart domestically.

With the decline of the home video market, however, films had to evolve for streaming. Enter the modern so-called geezer teaser. The idea is that cheap, disposable films could be funded through questionable means by hiring an aging actor for a short time, using their face on the poster, and then using the money that would be generated with their star power to make the film. It’s almost unnecessary for these films to even turn a profit when released on streaming. Stars like Mel Gibson, Robert DeNiro, and Nicolas Cage have each taken a turn, but they must be careful not to overdo it and lose the credibility they spent a career developing. That is, unless they don’t plan on acting for much longer.

In March 2022, Bruce Willis suddenly announced his retirement from acting. In the following months, stories of his declining mental state trickled out to paint a picture of his being taken advantage of by producers for years. Since 2011, he’s had fifty-seven credits completed or pending, most of which are disposable films of the type described above. It’s not totally clear when the decline started, but it seems pretty obvious that with fewer and fewer choices afforded to stars who aren’t attached to franchise vehicles, Willis made a calculation to wring out as much as he could from his celebrity before retirement.

With fewer and fewer choices afforded to stars who aren’t attached to franchise vehicles, Willis made a calculation to wring out as much as he could from his celebrity before retirement.

The career of Alec Baldwin, which was recently put on ice after he shot Halyna Hutchins on the set of the low-budget Western film Rust, can also be understood through the lens of declining options for movie stars. BondIt Media Capital, which was a financier of both Rust and numerous Bruce Willis films of the last decade, helps finance low-budget films that don’t meet the criteria of the diminishing pool of acceptable studio films. It’s a smart business model, cashing in on aging movie stars’ remaining cultural capital while it lasts. It may not be glamorous, but it allows someone like Baldwin to turn a quick buck without much effort.

The problem is that BondIt Media Capital and others like it are interested in only one thing: maximum return on investment. That means they’re also chasing tax credits and relaxed labor laws. The result is not only poor-quality filmmaking but also chaotic, slapdash, and ultimately unsafe movie sets. The incentives of the film industry are not only devaluing the legacy of the remaining actors who neglected or failed to join a franchise, but they’re putting crews in harm’s way with smaller budgets and films headed by unscrupulous producers. As movie stars navigate the deteriorating prospects of the film industry, it’s becoming clear that the crews who make these films will bear the brunt of the decline.

It would seem that compared to Willis, Cruise has weathered worsening industry conditions quite well. Top Gun: Maverick revitalized a beleaguered theatrical film landscape by reminding people that movie theaters are where you can still see genuine spectacle. Like every actor of his pedigree, Cruise finally decided to reboot his most important role — and somehow, he managed to not only avoid the pitfalls of that task, but to build upon what made the original Top Gun work. The plot was well-worn, and the ending was telegraphed from a mile away, but Cruise is a genuine action star, and Top Gun: Maverick made it undeniable.

Watching Top Gun: Maverick, you get the sense that you really are watching one of the last great movie stars in action, and there’s no one lined up to take his place.

Cruise broke with tradition in a reboot like this, which typically allows the younger generation to shine in the third act. Instead Cruise stayed in the lead — just like his character Maverick, who knows he’s the only one who can complete the task because he’s the only pilot who’s been tested in this way. It made for thrilling filmmaking, but it was also bittersweet. Watching Top Gun: Maverick, you get the sense that you really are watching one of the last great movie stars in action, and there’s no one lined up to take his place.

The Rise of IP, the Downfall of Cinema

When Tim Burton’s Batman (1989) became a smash hit, Warner Bros. responded by giving more control and a bigger budget for its sequel, Batman Returns (1992). Its seems Warner Bros. forgot that it was working with the director of Beetlejuice, and was surprised when the sequel was darker and less family friendly. In reaction it ousted Burton from the franchise, a story that illustrates the process of exiling auteur filmmakers — and indeed all original and unique interpretations — from franchise filmmaking.

In order to market Batman Returns and offset how much more money it was costing the studio, Warner Bros. made a deal with McDonald’s, including Happy Meal merchandising. Once McDonald’s saw a rough cut of the film, however, it realized that it was marketing a film to children that had far more violent and sexual content than it had anticipated, and tried its best to create some distance from the film itself while still fulfilling its obligation.

McDonald’s made Batman-themed toys separate from Burton’s design in an effort to not seem as if it was drawing children to the more mature film. Its efforts weren’t enough — by the time the film came out, children had already collected toys and commemorative cups and were insistent on seeing the film. When their parents took them, they were shocked by the graphic violence and sexually suggestive content.

The children had purchased a family-friendly version of a toy based off of a film adaptation of a comic book that they were not technically supposed to watch. They had become unknowing participants in the struggle for intellectual property primacy in film, a struggle that has come to dominate the entire industry in the decades since.

Once it came time to think about the next film in the franchise, Burton was edged out, and Joel Schumacher’s campier, more marketable, child-friendly vision was arranged for production, alongside a host of Happy Meal toys. Michael Keaton, who had played Batman in the previous Burton films, backed out, citing creative differences with Schumacher’s vision. The franchise moved forward with Val Kilmer in Batman Forever (1995), and then recast Batman with George Clooney for Schumacher’s last Batman film, Batman & Robin (1997).

This evolution maps the development of the modern film franchise. Directors are now expected to make films that fulfill studios’ broader cross-platform marketing and merchandising goals. The role of the movie star, meanwhile, is reduced to providing the mere physical embodiment of a character for studios and parent companies who are solely concerned with acting as custodians of profitable intellectual property.

The previous generation’s smash hits are more or less passive income for a dwindling group of conglomerates trying to squeeze as much profit out of them as they can.

Try as they might to bring originality to the roles, actors are once again being compelled to change their craft under practical constraints. The previous generation’s smash hits are more or less passive income for a dwindling group of conglomerates trying to squeeze as much profit out of them as they can. Not only does this reduce opportunities to shine for young and aspiring actors, but it has begun to put pressure on a graduating class of senior citizens who still possess a star quality that can only be betrayed by the body it resides within.

The film Blade Runner 2049 provides a nice metaphor for the state of Hollywood movie stardom. Harrison Ford spent much of the last decade and a half being dragged back to reboot the roles that cemented his legacy as a movie star, only to half-heartedly upstage every actor to whom he was ostensibly passing the baton. Blade Runner 2049 avoids this trap by not making the mistake of trying to replace his character, Deckard, with Ryan Gosling’s. In fact, the film’s tension is built upon Gosling’s character, Joe, slowly realizing that he, a replicant, may be Deckard’s son born from a miracle human/replicant conception. This false delusion is fed by memories that Deckard’s actual child has imparted to Joe through a process of making replicants feel more human.

Toward the end of the film, Joe journeys to find Deckard alone in a casino in an irradiated Las Vegas. The two fight in a venue playing a hologram of Elvis, taken from his performance during the end of his life when the real Elvis was essentially forced by his management to perform in humiliating fashion until he withered away. It’s a perfect backdrop for a showdown between a genuine old movie star and an up-and-comer. The latter must come to terms with the fact that he’s just a simulation of a type of hero the world needs but no longer makes anymore.

Netanyahu: Opposition using judicial reforms as pretext to undo election

The repeated rejection of dialogue proves the opposition seeks “anarchy and the overthrow of the elected government,” said the premier.

By JNS

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday accused the opposition of trying to overthrow his government and vowed to continue pressing ahead with its judicial reform program.

“Only four months ago we held elections. The government I head received a clear mandate from the citizens of Israel. The fact that for two whole months our repeated calls for dialogue received no response from the opposition proves that what interests the opposition is not the judicial reforms, but the creation of anarchy and the overthrow of the elected government,” said Netanyahu.

“It is impossible to be in favor of the success of the Israeli economy and to encourage the flight of funds from Israel. It is impossible to be in favor of the rule of law and to encourage violations of the law. It is impossible to be in favor of the security of the state and to encourage insubordination that would collapse the security of the state.

“There is no conditional Zionism,” said the premier.

Nevertheless, Netanyahu expressed hope that “honest” and “patriotic” members of the opposition, “those who care about the country,” will step up and engage in talks.

“But in any case,” he continued, “let no one make a mistake: We received a mandate from the public, and we will fulfill it.”

The comments come after Israelis once again took to the streets on Saturday night to protest against the government’s proposed judicial reforms, with large turnouts in Tel Aviv, Haifa and Beersheva.

Opposition leader Yair Lapid told an estimated 10,000-strong crowd in Beersheva that “Israel is in the greatest crisis in its history.”

The Yesh Atid Party chairman continued: “A terrible wave of terrorism is hitting us, the economy is collapsing, money is fleeing the country. Here in the South, personal security is collapsing every day. Yesterday, the Iranians signed an agreement with Saudi Arabia that will inject billions of dollars into their nuclear program. These are huge, historic challenges, but the government has lost interest. The only thing the government is interested in is continuing to crush Israeli democracy and the unity of the Israeli people.”

National Unity Party leader Benny Gantz tweeted that the answer to the government’s “coup” was “protest,” as “we will not allow them to turn Israel into a dictatorship.”

Last week, Justice Minister Yariv Levin, one of the main architects of the reforms, met with several prominent public figures who drafted a reform compromise proposal. Levin responded favorably to the outline, with sources from his office reportedly calling it a “breakthrough” and the “first outline that goes outside the box.”

A day earlier, Levin and MK Simcha Rothman, another principal advocate of the reforms who chairs the Knesset Law Committee that is dealing with the legislation, accepted a proposal by the Israel Manufacturers Association, the Chambers of Commerce and groups representing tech companies and building contractors for talks starting at the President’s Residence without preconditions.

“From the very first day we said we were in favor of a dialogue in an attempt to reach an understanding on the reform and at least to reduce the controversy,” the leaders of the reform said in a joint statement. “We respond to the call for talks without preconditions and call on others in the opposition to respond to the initiate and attend talks with the president on Tuesday.”

Opposition leaders swiftly rejected the proposal.

Netanyahu, who has been barred by the attorney general from discussing the specifics of the reform program due to a possible conflict of interest with his ongoing criminal trial, called on the opposition to present its own proposal for judicial overhaul.

“For eight weeks we have been calling for negotiations. We are bringing the reform to the Knesset to decide,” he said last Sunday. “I call upon those in the opposition to do something simple: Present your alternative in an attempt to reach an agreement.”

The premier said that with goodwill, an agreement could be reached “within days.”

Lapid and Gantz rejected the overture and conditioned any negotiations on the government freezing the accompanying legislative process.

President Isaac Herzog last Monday told a gathering of some 100 municipal officials that a compromise judicial reform proposal was nearly complete, and called on lawmakers to find common ground.

“I have already said that it is absolutely legitimate to discuss reforming the judicial system, and aspects of the proposal are indeed advisable. In the last few weeks, I have done everything in my power to bring about discussion and enable the sides to reach an agreement,” said Herzog.

“We are closer than ever to the possibility of an outline. There are agreements behind the scenes on most things,” he continued. “Now it depends on our national leadership, the coalition and the opposition, who need to rise to the occasion and understand the terrible alternative and put the country and its citizens above everything else.”

Protesters on Thursday staged another day of disruptive demonstrations, on what was dubbed a “Day of Resistance to Dictatorship.” Demonstrators attempted to shut down Israel’s primary international gateway by driving back and forth between the entrance to Ben-Gurion Airport and Terminal 3, its main passenger facility.

National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir accused the opposition of “trying to blackmail us with threats, protests and blocked roads that will only be opened if there is no reform. It won’t matter,” he said. “The reform will pass by the end of the month.”

The post Netanyahu: Opposition using judicial reforms as pretext to undo election appeared first on World Israel News.