Climate-Fueled Displacement Is Already Happening in the United States

Climate change–fueled displacement is often thought of as a future problem, or one that primarily affects people in developing countries. But natural disasters caused or exacerbated by the climate crisis are already frequently displacing people within the US.

Aerial view of damaged property in Fort Myers Beach, Florida after Hurricane Ian. (Jeffrey Greenberg / Universal Images Group via Getty Images)

Over the past few years, climate disasters have threatened and destroyed housing across the diverse landscapes of the United States. Wildfires have scorched through California, destroying more than fifteen thousand buildings since 2020. Hurricanes have battered Florida’s vulnerable coastlines, with Hurricane Ian alone claiming five thousand homes and damaging thirty thousand more. Severe drought has coincided with Arizona’s housing boom this past January, subjecting residents of a Scottsdale suburb to water shutoffs — a problem that will only intensify as long as both drought and incessant housing construction continue in the Southwest.

In The Great Displacement: Climate Change and the Next American Migration, Jake Bittle, a reporter covering climate impacts and adaptation, brings together eight stories of communities displaced from their land in the wake of natural disasters. He illustrates how a range of climate causes and effects have threatened communities across the country, from the government buyout of a historically black neighborhood in rural North Carolina to a housing crisis following wildfires in Santa Rosa, California. Sketching out the varied responses to climate disaster, Bittle emphasizes that climate displacement in the United States is not only a problem for the future, but a present and past reality.

Cal Turner and Sara Van Horn interviewed Bittle for Jacobin about what climate displacement looks like now: the crucial links between disasters and the US housing crisis, the government responses that could create housing stability in the face of increased precarity, and the broad spectrum of people impacted by climate disasters.

Sara Van Horn

Your book adjusts our understanding of the timescale of climate migration by emphasizing that climate-related displacement started at least a generation ago. Why is this temporal shift in perspective important? And why does the mainstream narrative of climate displacement so often focus exclusively on the future?

Jake Bittle

It’s difficult to make a categorical distinction between displacement caused by climate change and displacement caused by natural disasters that were not made more intense by global warming. In the book, I talked about displacement events that happened before we were at 1.1 degrees Celsius [above preindustrial levels], because what climate change does is make disasters more severe and more frequent. The patterns of displacement once climate disasters happen — they’re not a mystery. We already know because similar things have already happened. We can see future migration, present migration, and past migration as being on a continuum of housing instability and vulnerable construction.

A lot of people wonder: What will climate change be like? But it’s the wrong question. We can look at what’s already happening and say that this is the kind of thing that we can expect more of. “Here’s what happened before climate change, here’s what happened after it started” — a lot of mainstream journalism about this issue has not been able to avoid that binary.

For a while we just didn’t really talk about climate change. We talked about fires and hurricanes. And now a lot of publications and newspapers have the opposite, very well-intentioned reflex: every time that anything happens, they say, “This is the link to climate change.” But it leads people to think that some events can be categorized as climate-driven and some can be categorized as not having been. I’m trying to say that that’s not really true, but that you do see this gradual ratcheting up of severity.

Cal Turner

You highlight a broad range of ways that people relate to the land they live on: a lot of different communities, a lot of different kinds of work that bind people to their land, and a diverse set of ways that people respond when they lose that land. Why was it important to cast this wide net in terms of the stories you told about climate displacement?

Jake Bittle

From the start, I was pretty convinced that most people experience climate change through the lens of housing instability: the loss of access to housing, and housing becoming less affordable. But it looks so different in each place. All the patterns of displacement — and all the outcomes after these disasters — seemed informed so extensively not only by climate change, but also by the detailed history of how the built environment had taken shape in those places.

Each disaster was striking, because there are some commonalities, but there are also a lot of differences. And the differences turned out to be really important. The conclusion that I came away with is that climate change applies stress to specific social, economic, and architectural structures. Without knowing what those are, you can’t really understand what is happening.

A lot of people wonder: What will climate change be like? We can look at what’s already happening and say this is the kind of thing we can expect more of.

Cal Turner

Are there mainstream narratives of climate migration that you’re hoping to intervene in?

Jake Bittle

One thing that I’ve tried to press on is the difference between displacement and migration and the extent to which climate migration in the United States — and in a lot of other places as well — is primarily domestic, usually over short distances. And it’s very rarely a coherent, point-A-to-point-B single movement. One big problem that climate change creates is prolonged and generalized housing instability in a lot of places that makes it difficult for people to keep a solid grip on the traditional middle-class mortgage that rises in value and provides a solid investment and a lever for being upwardly mobile.

That specific idea of what home is and what housing looks like is going to be really destabilized over the next few decades. But I don’t feel like that gets much play. Instead, when people talk about climate migration, they’re usually talking about how to deal with an influx of people from developing countries who get displaced by massive disasters that are way worse than the ones in the United States. “How do we provide those people asylum?” is a really great question. But I was like: get your house in order, as well. We don’t do a good job with this domestically.

Sara Van Horn

Can you sketch out the relationship between climate change and the US housing crisis?

Sea-level rise, hurricane storm surges, wildfires, and water shortages all destroy housing in the places that are most vulnerable to climate disasters. They alter the balance between supply and demand for housing, but they also lead to restriction in insurance access and an increase in the cost of distributing risk for mortgage markets and insurance markets. Trying to deal with mounting risk is transferring a huge cost burden onto homeowners. It’s making it difficult for people to maintain their existing level of housing access. It’s certainly pushing a lot of people out of homeownership, and it’s exacerbating a crisis that was already there, which is a lack of affordable houses.

We have this pretty dire housing shortage in a lot of the places that are already vulnerable. Both by destroying physical housing and also by encouraging private actors to restrict access to credit and insurance coverage, climate change tends to make those pressures more significant, which hurts the lower end of the middle class and, of course, low-income people, who tend to rent in a lot of these places.

All the patterns of displacement seemed informed so extensively not only by climate change, but also by the detailed history of how the built environment had taken shape in those places.

There’s also a second-order thing: in less well-off places, these disasters damage access to public finance and municipal credit. For worse-off jurisdictions, there’s not enough money to recover from these disasters and to service infrastructure. As that happens, home values also fall. It’s a general loss of investment.

Sara Van Horn

How can the government support people who are displaced by climate change? What solutions are most important?

Jake Bittle

You have to start by taking the gloves off at FEMA [the Federal Emergency Management Agency]. It should be funded a lot better, but it should also have the ability to spend more money on preparing for disasters. It spends a very small proportion of its annual budget on anything that isn’t directly clearing debris or offering payments to people who just got their homes destroyed. If FEMA could be a little more flexible in terms of giving communities money to build a living shoreline on the water that they would like to protect from future flooding, or to elevate homes before a disaster happens, that could drastically reduce the total amount of displacement and the financial burden.

You also have to look at the housing crisis generally. It’s hard to imagine that you could smooth out the potential displacement toll of climate change unless you do a lot more to improve housing access in the country writ large. There are a lot of ideas about how to fix the housing crisis, but on the most basic level, we have a program, Section 8, that provides low-income people with housing vouchers so that they can rent. That program is funded at a quarter of total entitlement: only a quarter of people who are eligible for it can actually use it. Fixing a basic problem like that could go a long way toward easing people’s journey through this really turbulent market.

The issue with climate change is that a lot of times, people enter this market in surprising or awkward or painful ways as part of the process of relocation. But a lot of people are in that market all the time. It’s hard to imagine a total fix without fixing those fundamental inequities in the housing market itself.

It’s hard to imagine that you could smooth out the potential displacement toll of climate change unless you do a lot more to improve housing access in the country writ large.

Cal Turner

Why did you choose to focus mostly on the effects of climate change — such as housing insecurity, cultural loss, and large-scale migration — rather than root causes? Why was it important to look at the responses to catastrophe?

Jake Bittle

This has changed in the last three years, but when I started the book, there wasn’t a lot of awareness of the extent to which the climate crisis was already a present-tense phenomenon in the United States. Part of the reason is that the general level of infrastructure and housing — the general level of resources — in the United States is much larger than in other countries that had been hit really hard. The generally well-resourced nature of the United States and the existence of this gigantic middle class had made people believe it just wasn’t happening, when, in fact, it was happening. It just looked a little bit different because the infrastructure was so different.

I wanted to make this corrective argument. So many other people had already hammered home the clear relationship between fossil fuels and global warming and the clear scientific basis for saying that global warming was already changing weather patterns and ambient temperatures. I wanted to take it one step further and say, “What does that actually mean for us in the United States? Can we shake ourselves out of this idea that it will happen one day, or that maybe it’s already happening in Fiji, but not here?”

Cal Turner

What do you think has changed in the last three years?

Jake Bittle

The 2020 wildfires in California. There was a really bad day when the sky turned red that brought it home for a lot of people. The media generally got a bit more enthusiastic about making that linkage any time there was a big disaster. The heatwave in 2021 in the Pacific Northwest was also a big change. I think hearing about this rigamarole of things that happen every summer convinced people — even people that I spoke to in parts of the country that were pretty reticent about believing that there was really anything wrong. With this drumbeat of disasters, people just said, “This doesn’t seem quite normal. Something’s up here.”

Political Insanity: The Real Face of the GOP’s “Non-interventionism”: Withdrawal of U.S. Troops from Syria Should be Redeployed to “Fight China”

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Political Insanity: The Real Face of the GOP’s “Non-interventionism”: Withdrawal of U.S. Troops from Syria Should be Redeployed to “Fight China” appeared first on Global Research.

Knesset passes Override Clause, limiting Supreme Court’s power, in first reading

Judicial reform bill, including the Override Clause and limits on Supreme Court’s judicial review, passes its first reading the in Knesset 61 to 52.

By World Israel News Staff

The Knesset voted to back two key provisions of the government’s judicial overhaul plan early Tuesday morning.

During a marathon session overnight which continued into Tuesday morning, the Knesset plenum voted 61 to 52 in favor of a bill which would both limit the Supreme Court’s ability to strike down laws and provide the Knesset with an override to veto such rulings.

Opposition lawmakers filibustered for hours, delaying the vote, which ultimately split entirely along Coalition-Opposition lines.

The two provisions were passed in their first reading, and will now be sent back to the Knesset’s Constitution, Law and Justice Committee, headed by MK Simcha Rothman (Religious Zionist Party), one of the architects of the judicial reform plan.

Once the committee has completed its hearings on the bill and finalized the details, the legislation will be sent back to the Knesset plenum for its second and third votes, after which it will become law.

If passed in its present form, the bill would bar the Supreme Court from exercising judicial review over any of Israel’s 13 Basic Laws or amendments to the Basic Laws.

Furthermore, the bill requires that in order to exercise judicial review over a standard law, the court must convene all 15 justices, with at least 80%, or twelve justices, voting to strike down the law.

Once struck down, however, the Knesset can vote to override the court and restore the law, with at least 61 MKs voting to override.

Yisrael Beitenu party chief MK Avidgor Liberman slammed the government after the vote, predicting it would lead to the restoration of the 2017 ultra-Orthodox draft law. “Override Clause IN – sharing the burden OUT,” Liberman tweeted.

“The passing of the Override Clause is a slap in the face of the IDF soldiers and reserve officers. This is another stage of this crazy government on the way to a deep rift among the people of Israel and splitting it in two. As Gafni said – between those who will go to the army and risk their lives and those who will go to yeshiva.”

“While the coalition is busy telling the reservists to go to hell, it promotes ruthless legislation that promotes the refusal of tens of thousands of young people to serve under the protection of the law,” he added.

“We will not allow the sacred values of ‘sharing of the burden’ and ‘the people’s army’ to be overrun and we will continue to fight to keep the State of Israel Jewish, Zionist and liberal.”

Hours earlier, on Monday night, the Knesset voted 61 to 51 to approve the first reading of the Incapacitation Law, which would bar the Attorney General from declaring a prime minister unfit to serve.

The post Knesset passes Override Clause, limiting Supreme Court’s power, in first reading appeared first on World Israel News.

Pro-Israel groups call for sanctions on Morningstar for blacklisting companies that aid the Jewish state

Groups say the ratings giant has not stamped out anti-Israel bias.

By Adam Kredo, The Washington Free Beacon

Advocacy groups are pressing state government officials to sanction financial ratings giant Morningstar for promoting divestment from companies that help the Israeli government combat Palestinian suicide bombers.

Morningstar subsidiary Sustainalytics “treats Israel differently from all other nations,” according to two pro-Israel community organizations, Christians United for Israel and the Orthodox Union. The organizations are urging the State Financial Officers Foundation, which represents officials in charge of implementing state laws against the anti-Israel Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement, to cancel lucrative contracts and investments in Morningstar.

Morningstar has been battling accusations that it fuels the BDS movement by downgrading companies that work with Israel, particularly in its security sector, making them less attractive to potential investors.

The pro-Israel groups say the financial ratings giant has not made good on its promises to address those concerns and implement reforms, according to a copy of the letter obtained by the Washington Free Beacon.

The Free Beacon reported in February, for example, that the company is still blacklisting several firms that help Israel combat Palestinian terrorism.

Those actions, the groups say, “constitute a clear violation of state laws prohibiting contracts with and/or investment in firms that boycott Israel.”

“It’s time for Morningstar to choose boycotts of Israel or state investments and contracts,” the groups write.

The groups also want to ease concerns that Morningstar could retaliate against the states by using its ratings systems to downgrade 529 accounts, an investment portfolio used to help pay for college education.

“Given that Morningstar already uses its ratings to advance a political agenda, we recognize and respect the concern the company might retaliate against states that faithfully implement their anti-BDS laws. For instance, by downgrading the ratings of state 529 accounts,” the groups write.

“Rest assured, we will urge attorneys general around the country to hold Morningstar accountable should such underhanded tactics be employed.”

Richard Goldberg, a former Illinois gubernatorial chief of staff who helped craft the state’s anti-BDS legislation, said there is “a credible fear among state officials” that going after Morningstar for its alleged support of the BDS movement “could prompt retaliation.”

“If Morningstar tried to retaliate,” he said, “that would be an issue for the Justice Department and the [Securities and Exchange Commission] to investigate.”

At least 10 major Jewish groups—including the Jewish Federations of North America and the Anti-Defamation League—informed Morningstar in late December that after months of close work with the company, they were frustrated with the lack of progress at reining in Sustainalytics’s anti-Israel bias.

Morningstar has promised to remove several companies from its do-not-invest lists and reverse policies that blacklist a company for providing services to Israel’s security sector.

“It appears that Sustainalytics is failing to do its part to implement the commitments that Morningstar made to eliminate the pervasive anti-Israel bias in Sustainalytics’s [environmental, social, and corporate governance] ratings,” the organizations wrote at the time.

“We do not believe that Sustainalytics is engaging with us in the spirit of Morningstar’s October commitments and have found a number of the steps it has taken to be directly contrary to those commitments.”

Morningstar maintains it has made reforms. Information published on its website claims that ESG Risk Ratings have been assigned to 140 Israel-based companies out of more than 15,000. Just 0.2 percent of the companies reviewed were “flagged for involvement in an Israeli-Palestinian conflict area,” according to the company.

Derek Kreifels, the CEO of the State Financial Officers Foundation, said his organization will encourage its members to investigate Morningstar for potential violations of anti-BDS laws.

“Morningstar is engaging in economic warfare against the Jewish state using American retirement dollars to impose an anti-Semitic BDS movement on many companies in the name of ESG,” Kreifels said. “We look forward to the results of the continued investigation into Morningstar’s anti-Semitic activities.”

The post Pro-Israel groups call for sanctions on Morningstar for blacklisting companies that aid the Jewish state appeared first on World Israel News.

Iran, China and the Panama Canal: Is the US being encircled?

In a visible challenge to US dominance in the Western Hemisphere, Iranian ships will proceed to the Panama Canal, at both ends of which sits China.

By Lawrence A. Franklin, The Gatestone Institute

Iran and China are on the move again. Last Friday, to the apparent surprise of the Biden Administration, China asserted its influence in the Middle East by entering the vacuum created by US President Joe Biden, and brokering a deal between Iran and its threatened neighbor, Saudi Arabia, which Biden had vowed to make a “pariah,” and “end the sale of material” to it. The Saudis heard.

Iran, meanwhile, has not been shy about its mission to “export the revolution” to the Western hemisphere. Most recently, in February, two Iranian warships docked in Brazil, under its recently elected socialist President Luis Inácio Lula da Silva. From there, the ships will reportedly proceed to the Panama Canal, already controlled at both ends by Iran’s newish ally — the Chinese Communist Party (CCP).

The CCP officially declared a “people’s war” on the United States on May 14, 2019, in its flagship newspaper, the People’s Daily, as well as before that, on January 29, 2017, even if the US was not listening.

Iranian Infiltration of South America

Iran has been openly infiltrating South America for decades. In 1994, it famously blew up a Jewish community center in Buenos Aires, Argentina, killing 85 people. Recently, while the Biden Administration has been pursuing a “nuclear deal” with Iran — one that will enable it soon to have as many nuclear weapons as it likes — Iran has been expanding its already sizeable foothold south of the US border. The militant Islamic theocracy already has a significant presence — and presumably influence — in Venezuela, Bolivia, Ecuador and Nicaragua. It is now targeting Brazil and the Panama Canal.

Brazilian President da Silva has a history of welcoming Iran. In 2009, during his previous presidential term, he warmly greeted then Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad during his state visit to Brazil. Da Silva will decidedly shift from the pro-US and pro-Israel foreign policy of his predecessor, President Jair Bolsonaro, to one that favors friendly ties with Iran.

Da Silva, who served as Brazil’s president from 2003 to 2010, barely defeated Bolsonaro in a runoff election last October. A left-wing populist, da Silva drew support from Brazilians who benefited by his liberal welfare policies, particularly access to affordable health care, during his previous terms as president.

Iran and Da Silva

Under the Bolsonaro administration (2019-2022), diplomatic links between Iran and Brazil were chilly. His investigation of Hezbollah and its activities in the tri-border zone of Brazil, Paraguay and Argentina resulted in the 2018 arrest of the terrorist group’s regional financier Assad Ahmad Barakat. Bolsonaro’s support for Israel, on the other hand, was shown by the first visit ever by an Israeli Prime Minister to Brazil: Benjamin Netanyahu attended Bolsonaro’s inauguration in 2019.

Iran welcomed da Silva’s election and the warming of relations with Brazil it expects will ensue. Iran’s Foreign Ministry spokesman, Nasser Kanaani, was quick to congratulate da Silva on his election. The congratulatory message from Hamas politburo member Basir Naim, was, not surprisingly, that Hamas “looks forward to President Lula mitigating all the effects of the unlimited support [from Bolsonaro] for the Israeli Occupation State.”

Brazilians do not necessarily support da Silva’s shift to the left on foreign policy. A Pew poll conducted in 2015 revealed that the great majority of Brazilians had an unfavorable view of Iran. Brazil had warm relations with Iran during da Silva’s earlier terms. He visited Iran in 2010, following Ahmadinejad’s visit to Brazil in 2009. Brazil is also Iran’s largest trading partner in Latin America. Brazilians ship large amounts of meat (mostly beef), medicines and cars to Iran. Brazil’s oil giant Petrobras has invested heavily in Iran’s oil industry.

Da Silva’s turn away from the West was recently underscored by his granting permission for two Iranian warships to dock in Rio de Janeiro immediately after his visit to the White House late last month. The US Department of State and the US Ambassador to Brazil Elizabeth Bagley were unsuccessful in their efforts to persuade da Silva to deny Iran’s warships permission to dock.

Iran has high praise for da Silva. He has refused to join the US-led sanctions regime against Tehran, and has criticized Western suspicions of Iran’s intentions concerning nuclear weapons. Da Silva has stated repeatedly that Iran has the right to develop peaceful nuclear programs and that the Islamic Republic should be taken at its word until proven otherwise by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA). According to the IAEA, however, Iran seems to have been cheating the “whole time.”

In 2004, the IAEA accused Iran of violating the agency’s “Safeguards Agreement”: the regime failed to notify the IAEA of increased enrichment activities.

The IAEA also noted that Iran prematurely deployed advanced uranium enrichment centrifuges. In still another accusation leveled by the IAEA against Iran, the agency declared that Tehran processed uranium gas necessary for the production of the uranium metal needed for the core of a nuclear weapon. These are but a few of the violations which underscore Iran’s duplicity regarding its nuclear program.

What is needed for peaceful nuclear use is uranium enriched to 3% to 20%. Iran has now enriched uranium to 84%, close to the 90% needed for use in nuclear bombs, and, according to reports, is just “days away” from being able to build its nuclear weapons, as the 2015 JCOA nuclear deal allows it to do, anyway.

The Biden Administration, like the Obama Administration, is most likely just trying to avoid having Iran going full nuclear “on my watch,” as Obama let slip in 2015.

Iran’s Atlantic Flotilla

The Iranian vessels that docked in Brazil, were the Iris Makran (the largest Iranian warship) and the Iris Dena, a frigate. They are part of Iran’s 86th Flotilla and its newly established Atlantic Ocean Command. In a visible challenge to US dominance in the Western Hemisphere, the ships will proceed to the Panama Canal.

This visit to Latin America is the second such naval deployment to the hemisphere since Iran’s Atlantic maritime tour in 2021. There is every reason to expect Tehran to attempt to expand its diplomatic and military profile in this region.

Brazil – The Linchpin of South America

As Brazil is the largest, most populous, and militarily strongest nation in South America, other Latin American countries might be emboldened to also seek better ties with adversaries of the US. How did “China Beat Out the U.S. to Dominate South America”? According to Bloomberg:

“China has bought up so much copper, pork, and soy—and constructed so many roads, trains, power grids, and bridges—that it’s surpassed the U.S. as South America’s largest trade partner and is now the single biggest trader with Brazil, Chile, and Peru.”

“It’s no secret that China has been pouring resources into South America this century, chipping away at the United States’ historic dominance,” noted the Buenos Aires Times.

Seven South American countries – Venezuela, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, Chile, Argentina and Uruguay — are already part of the China’s Belt and Road Initiative; the only country with diplomatic ties to Taiwan is Paraguay. Add to this that China is also apparently eager to increase its economic and military presence in the Caribbean.

Is the US being encircled?

Dr. Lawrence A. Franklin was the Iran Desk Officer for Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld. He also served on active duty with the U.S. Army and as a Colonel in the Air Force Reserve.

The post Iran, China and the Panama Canal: Is the US being encircled? appeared first on World Israel News.

Conspiracy Theories Become Conspiracy Facts

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Conspiracy Theories Become Conspiracy Facts appeared first on Global Research.

Inflation Is Set to Fall. The Fed Should Back Off.

Wage growth has been experiencing a historic slowdown. If that trend holds up, inflation is on track to get within half a percentage point of the Fed’s 2% target level by this time next year. But will inflation hawks be willing to take yes for an answer?

A man walks past price advertisements on windows of a grocery store in the Brooklyn borough of New York, the United States, on February 14, 2023. (Michael Nagle / Xinhua via Getty Images)

A little over a week ago, I tried to make the case for a more relaxed view of the current inflation situation than might be gleaned from the alarmist analyses emanating from top Fed officials and some prominent commentators — not least Jason Furman, former chief economist in the Obama administration and a notable voice of inflation hawkery. Responding to new data released late last month showing a sizable jump in the core inflation rate in January, Furman published an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal headlined “To Fight Inflation, Fed Tightening Should Go Faster and Further.”

My basic argument, as Eric Levitz of New York Magazine efficiently summed it up in a tweet, was that, “looking beyond a month-to-month time horizon, wage growth more or less determines price growth [and] wage growth is rapidly decelerating.”

I showed, first, that the correlation between wage growth and inflation, though not very impressive within a one-month or three-month timespan, becomes extremely strong at longer time horizons: the R-squared (i.e. the strength of the correlation) rises to 0.63 at a one-year horizon and 0.78 by four years.

Second, I showed that wages have indeed been rapidly decelerating — so rapidly, in fact, that in the forty-odd years since the massive disinflation engineered by former Fed chairman Paul Volcker in the early 1980s, only four months have seen faster wage deceleration (measured by the twelve-month change in the twelve-month growth rate) than what we experienced in January of this year. (And in three of those four other months, the data were clearly distorted by the pandemic shutdowns of spring 2020.)

Essentially, I’m saying that wages are a kind of “super-core” inflation index. Economists and policy makers pay close attention to measures of “core” inflation, which, in different ways, strip out the more volatile or transitory components of the product basket. There are core indexes that exclude just food and energy prices; others that try to more systematically identify and exclude the most volatile product categories; and still others that exclude the outliers (i.e. the products with the highest and lowest inflation rates each month, rather than those with the most volatile rates).

But in all cases, the idea is that by abstracting from the random noise and fleeting shocks that cause “headline” inflation to fluctuate so much, these indexes can give a better gauge of the underlying inflationary forces at work — and therefore a better clue to what inflation might do in the near future. In practice, what I’m arguing is that the rate of wage growth is the “most core” price index, as Elon Musk might put it.

Furman, as a practical, policy-oriented economist, can hardly be said to lack awareness of the tight connection between wage growth and inflation. In fact, in an article he wrote for the Peterson Institute for International Economics last November, he carried out an interesting little statistical exercise that was premised on exactly this connection: he took five different measures of wage growth, and for each one, calculated the core Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) inflation rate “implied” (as he put it) by its current level. (Core PCE, the price index for household purchases excluding food and energy, is the measure to which the Fed tends to give the greatest weight when aiming to reach its 2 percent inflation target.)

According to Furman’s calculations, all five of the wage growth measures, as they stood in October 2022, were implying core inflation rates well above the Fed’s 2 percent target: they ranged from 2.9 percent to 5.1 percent, with a median of 4.2 percent. This finding, in his view, strengthens the case that the Fed needs to tighten even faster.

But surely if we want to judge whether monetary policy should be tightened further to stem inflation, we need to know not just the current rate of inflation but also its current trend. At the risk of stating the obvious: if the goal is disinflation, and if disinflation is already happening, then existing monetary conditions are already disinflationary. In that case, there’s no obvious reason to tighten further. The current level of inflation can’t tell you whether monetary policy is sufficiently disinflationary. For that you need to know the trend. This is where measures of core inflation can be useful: they can identify the underlying trend of inflation more clearly than it appears in the headline figure.

I thought it would be interesting to update Furman’s estimates of the inflation rates “implied” by the current rate of wage growth, but I couldn’t find an explanation of exactly how he had arrived at his results. So I just went ahead and used the simplest method that made sense to me: I ran a regression that used the rate of wage growth and the rate of trend labor productivity growth to predict the core PCE inflation rate. (Wages and labor productivity, taken jointly, are considered to be the main determinants of inflation in the theory of John Maynard Keynes, as I explained in an earlier article.) In the chart below, I compare this predicted core PCE inflation rate with the actual rate published by the Department of Commerce.

Three facts jump out from this exercise. First is the excellent fit of the data, which should be evident from the chart below: the lines showing actual versus predicted core inflation hug each other very closely. (The R-squared of the regression is a very respectable 0.64.) Once again, this shows that wages, jointly with productivity, have a preponderant influence on inflation.

 

 

The second point is that while actual core PCE inflation over the past year has bounced around its predicted trend quite a bit — including the spike in January that led Furman this month to all but declare inflation out of control — the core PCE inflation rate implied by wage and labor productivity growth has been falling month after month, with no spike in January at all.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, over the past year the core PCE inflation rate implied by the rate of wage growth fell rapidly — from 5.4 percent in February 2022 to 4 percent in February 2023. At that pace of disinflation, we will reach a level of wage growth historically consistent with the Fed’s 2 percent inflation target rate in less than eighteen months — without the need for any additional tightening by the Fed.

Geoengineering: Romanian General Emil Strainu on the Terrifying Possibilities of Geo-warfare

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Geoengineering: Romanian General Emil Strainu on the Terrifying Possibilities of Geo-warfare appeared first on Global Research.

Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin—Former Member of Raytheon Board of Directors—Has Awarded Over $30 Billion in Contracts to Raytheon Since His Confirmation in January 2021

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name (desktop version)

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and …

The post Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin—Former Member of Raytheon Board of Directors—Has Awarded Over $30 Billion in Contracts to Raytheon Since His Confirmation in January 2021 appeared first on Global Research.