The Invasion of Iraq Wasn’t a “Mistake.” It Was a Crime.

Today is the 20th anniversary of the invasion of Iraq. We should never forget and never forgive the architects of that evil war.

The Iraq War was a calculated, premeditated crime perpetrated on a massive scale. (Jaime Razuri / AFP via Getty Images)

Twenty years ago today, US and allied ground troops invaded Iraq. The “shock and awe” bombing campaign had started the day before.

What happened on March 20, 2003 wasn’t a “mistake.” It wasn’t well-intentioned but “unwise.” It was a calculated, premeditated crime perpetrated on a massive scale. Thousands of Americans and hundreds of thousands of Iraqis died in a war premised on transparently nonsensical lies.

The Human Toll

By the time President George W. Bush ordered the invasion, I’d spent months marching in antiwar protests and sitting in organizing meetings in church basements. On February 15, 2003, the Greater Lansing Network Against the War in Iraq brought four thousand people out to the streets of my hometown, marching from the union building at Michigan State University (MSU) to the steps of the state capitol in Lansing. It was one small part of the largest coordinated protests in human history. Between six and ten million people turned out in six hundred cities around the world to tell the war planners “no.”

They didn’t listen. And in the coming months and years, more than four thousand Americans came home in flag-draped coffins. One of those coffins held the body of a kid with whom I went to high school. He was seventeen when he joined the Army. Four years too young to go to one of the bars crammed with MSU students on Friday and Saturday nights in East Lansing. Eight years too young to rent a car. And a year too young to be eligible to vote for any of the politicians who decided to throw his life away on a cruel and stupid “war of choice.”

We had friends in common, but he and I didn’t hang out, so I have no idea what his motives were for enlisting. But I have to imagine the recruiters told him the usual things about how the US military exists to “defend freedom.” Instead, he died on the other side of the world in the process of imposing an occupation bitterly resented by the vast majority of Iraqis.

The consequences for ordinary Iraqis dwarfed the “Coalition” casualties. According to an estimate published this month by the Watson Institute at Brown University, since the invasion between 550,000 and 580,000 people died in Iraq and then Syria when the chaos spread there — and “several times as many may have died due to indirect causes such as preventable diseases.” In addition, more than seven million people fled the two countries, and another eight million became “internal refugees.”

David Frum Rewrites History

In a speech the year before the invasion, Bush castigated Iraq, Iran, and North Korea as “the axis of evil.” The idea that Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and the Islamic Republic of Iran, which fought a long and bloody war through the 1980s, were part of an “axis” was already bizarre before you threw in North Korea — but this was the height of America’s post-9/11 jingoistic fervor, and Bush’s rhetoric didn’t have to make sense for a huge portion of the country to nod along.

The author of that speech, David Frum, might have slunk away from public life in shame after the catastrophic consequences of Bush’s wars in the Middle East became clear — if he were capable of shame. Instead, he’s the author of a piece released last week in the Atlantic under the jaw-dropping headline, “The Iraq War Reconsidered.”

In it, Frum admits that the war went badly and grants that it may perhaps have been pragmatically “unwise” — even as he insists the US didn’t act with “unprovoked aggression,” argues that it might have been worse to leave Hussein in power, and bristles at any comparison between Iraq and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Above all, he seems to regret that the debacle in Iraq dampened public enthusiasm for new wars elsewhere:

The belief that America could be a force for good in the world sadly and wrongly dimmed. Memories of Iraq became a powerful resource for extremists and authoritarians who wanted to push democracies aside and leave the world to the autocrats.

Frum says the Iraq invasion wasn’t “unprovoked aggression” because the first Gulf War in 1990–91 was “clearly legitimate” given Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait, and Iraq hadn’t complied with the conditions of the cease-fire. But if Frum were serious about this argument, he would also have to maintain that if some other power had bombed US cities after, say, the US invasion of Grenada or the US invasion of Panama, this would have been “clearly legitimate” — and any US violations of the subsequent cease-fire would been grounds for the cluster bombing, invasion, and long-term occupation of the entire country.

Does David Frum really think that? Does anyone think that?

A War Based on Absurd Lies

At the time, Bush and his cronies didn’t say, “We’re going to invade Iraq because there were some cease-fire violations from the war that ended twelve years ago, and that’s all the justification we need.” They knew no one would have accepted such a rationale. Instead, they asserted that (a) Saddam Hussein had “Weapons of Mass Destruction” and (b) the Iraqi dictator, who’d long brutally repressed local Islamists, was going to magically decide to share these “WMDs” with his mortal enemies in al-Qaeda. Bush administration officials argued that this theoretical possibility of WMDs falling in al-Qaeda’s hands was too terrifying for anyone to wait for real evidence. The “smoking gun,” Vice President Dick Cheney infamously said, could be a “mushroom cloud” over a US city.

All of this is nonsensical in the same way as Vladimir Putin’s claim that he invaded Ukraine to “demilitarize and denazify” that country. Even if there had been any reason to believe (a), the absurdity of (b) would have made it irrelevant.

David Frum claims to have been shocked that there were no WMDs in Iraq. And it’s true that much of what the Bush administration said about WMDs later turned out to be based on deliberate distortion. But even at the time, the evidence presented to the public was paper thin.

I can remember arguing about this with the professor in my political science class in 2002. The professor — a fairly liberal Democrat — told us that Iraq had chemical and biological weapons and was at least working on nuclear weapons. When I asked how he could possibly know that, he referred to the president’s many confident statements. Surely all these assertions were based on information Bush was getting from the intelligence agencies.

I didn’t buy it. If definitive evidence existed, why weren’t they sharing it — the way that, for example, John F. Kennedy’s administration showed the whole world surveillance pictures of Soviet missile sites in Cuba in 1962?

The closest we got was Secretary of State Colin Powell waving around a vial of anthrax at the United Nations as he made wild claims about the Iraqi threat. I watched Powell’s speech with a group of antiwar students at my college, and I remember at one point he shared intercepted Iraqi communications that vaguely referred to “trucks” and Powell asserted as if it were the only possible interpretation that the trucks in question were mobile chemical weapons labs. I was amazed that anyone anywhere was taking this stuff seriously.

Never Forget

That skepticism didn’t make me unique. Again: six to ten million of us marched in antiwar protests that February. The global antiwar movement was absolutely correct — and no one who was on the wrong side in 2003 should be allowed to forget it. Not shameless ghouls like David Frum, not the politicians in both parties who voted for the war because they were afraid of looking weak, and not all the oh-so-clever centrist pundits who ran cover for the Bush administration on their blogs or in New York Times op-eds.

None of these people were making an innocent mistake. They were throwing in their lot with conspirators openly planning to destroy a society on the other side of the world — killing hundreds of thousands at minimum in the process — in a war that was based on barely coherent nonsense. A war that was very good for the shareholders at Halliburton and Raytheon and Lockheed Martin and bad for nearly everyone else.

This isn’t a “live-and-learn” situation.

The invasion of Iraq wasn’t a “mistake.”

It was a crime.

And it’s unforgivable.

Iran’s mission made clear: Wipe out America

As recently as November, Khamenei vowed, “Death to America will happen. In the new order I am talking about America will no longer have any important role.”

By Majid Rafizadeh, The Gatestone Institute

A radical regime, whose mission is to “Export the Revolution” and bring Islamist rule to the rest of the world, will not alter its aims through policies of appeasement.

The appeasement policies of the Obama Administration empowered and emboldened Iran’s ruling mullahs, and the Biden Administration seems determined to pursue the same path.

Recall when, upon reaching the JCPOA “nuclear deal” with Iran in 2105, then US President Barack Obama pointed out that he was “confident” that the deal, with its lifting of sanctions on Iran, would “meet the national security needs of the United States and our allies”? It was even outlined in the JCPOA preamble that all parties “anticipate that full implementation of this JCPOA will positively contribute to regional and international peace and security.”

What was actually the result? The international community witnessed even more rockets launched by Yemen’s Houthis at civilian targets, the deployment of Lebanese Hezbollah soldiers in Syria, and increasing attacks by the Iranian-funded Hamas on Israel. With billions of dollars of revenue pouring into the pockets of Iran’s Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei and the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), Tehran did not change its behavior for the better. Instead, it became even more empowered and emboldened to pursue its revolutionary ideals of anti-Americanism and anti-Semitism.

Iran became, in fact, according to the US State Department, “the world’s worst state sponsor of terrorism.”

Worse, at the peak of these appeasement policies towards the mullahs, Iran’s fundamentalist regime was emboldened to publicly harass the US Navy, detain US sailors and imprison American citizens. Khamenei has also repeatedly threatened “Death to America!” and “Death to Israel!” and made incendiary remarks about wiping Israel from the face of earth “in less than 8 minutes.”

Currently, thanks to the Biden Administration’s appeasement where it would not matter and inaction where it would, the Iran’s ruling mullahs are closer than ever to acquiring nuclear weapons. The Biden administration would do well to realize that a nuclear Iran is not just an existential threat to Israel; a nuclear Iran is major threat to the region, Europe, America, the world.

The regime has made its intentions clear. Especially now that it is aligned with Putin’s Russia and the Chinese Communist Party, it would like to conquer the US.

As recently as November, Khamenei vowed, “Death to America will happen. In the new order I am talking about America will no longer have any important role.”

The headline of a report by Iran’s state-controlled Afkar News read (in Farsi): “American Soil Is Now Within the Range of Iranian Bombs.” The report boasted about the damage that Iran could inflict, and claims that the Islamic Republic can use “a high-altitude electromagnetic bomb to attack the United States.”

“The U.S. Congress’ Electromagnetic Attack Commission has long warned that detonating just one nuclear bomb at high altitude [over the US] could take out the US power grid and, with it, all infrastructure. The report of March 28, 2017 of the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs in the US Senate also writes in a report to the 114th Congress: ‘A successful attack with an electromagnetic nuclear bomb against the United States could cause the death of approximately 90% of the American population.’”

The report adds:

“By sending a military satellite into space, Iran now has shown that it can target all American territory; the Iranian parliament had previously warned [the US] that an electromagnetic nuclear attack on the United States would likely kill 90 percent of Americans….. If the industrialized nations of the world cannot devise effective ways to defend themselves against dangerous electronic attacks, they will collapse within a few years… American soldiers will not be able to find food to eat or fire a shot.”

American politicians shortsightedly fail to harden America’s electric grid, probably because it will not show up as an accomplishment that donors will respond to, electorally or financially, during their election campaigns.

The European Union, which voted in favor of lifting the arms embargo against Iran, is also being threatened:

“The same type of ballistic missile technology used to launch the satellite could carry nuclear, chemical or even biological weapons to wipe Israel off the map, hit US bases and allies in the region and US facilities, and target NATO even in the far west of Europe….”

Tragically, through its appeasement policies and failure to take on the Free World’s adversaries in a serious and credible way, the Biden Administration has been empowering at least one predatory regime that is determined to accomplish its mission of Jihad to rule the world at any cost; even if that requires wiping out other states.

And now, thanks to the catastrophic policies of the Biden Administration — suppressing US fossil fuel production, thereby enriching Russia so it could launch a war against Ukraine; and by snubbing America’s historical ally, Saudi Arabia — it has brought US national security to the brink.

Dr. Majid Rafizadeh is a business strategist and advisor, Harvard-educated scholar, political scientist, board member of Harvard International Review, and president of the International American Council on the Middle East. He has authored several books on Islam and US Foreign Policy. He can be reached at Dr.Rafizadeh@Post.Harvard.Edu

 

The post Iran’s mission made clear: Wipe out America appeared first on World Israel News.

‘If they meet a Jew, they want to kill him,’ says German tourist attacked by Palestinian mob

“I really felt the hate in their eyes, and from the way they were acting…and they were throwing rocks, maybe double the size of my head.”

By Lauren Marcus, World Israel News

A German tourist who was attacked by a violent mob after driving into a Palestinian Authority-controlled city in a car with Israeli license plates said that the incident has dramatically changed his view of the Palestinians and Israel’s security concerns.

Speaking to Hebrew-language media outlets Channel 12 and Kan, Gerald Hetzel said that he survived a “very, very dangerous situation” and that he and his travel companion “really thought” local Palestinians from Nablus “wanted to kill us.”

During the attack, “I really felt the hate in their eyes, and from the way they were acting,” Hetzel said. “And they were throwing rocks, maybe double the size of my head.”

After Nablus residents noticed that Hetzel was driving in an Israeli car, “young men came from taxis around us … and started to knock on our windows, to scream at us in Arabic,” he said.

“They were bringing stones and a traffic sign and throwing everything against the car. After one or two minutes they pulled out a knife and stabbed the wheels of the car, and also threatened my friend.”

شبان يحطمون مركبة تحمل لوحات تسجيل “إسرائيلية” وسط #نابلس بعد الاشتباه بوجود مستوطنين بداخلها ووجود أعلام للاحتلال داخل المركبة. pic.twitter.com/N8dJVzwroJ

— وكالة شهاب للأنباء (@ShehabAgency) March 18, 2023

Hetzel said he was surprised that the Palestinians would target visitors with European appearances.

“I thought they were only targeting religious-looking Jews, not international tourists,” he said.

The incident “doesn’t change my entire view on Israel. I think Israel is a very friendly country,” he said.

However, the attack “definitely changes my view on the Palestinians and the Palestinian Authority areas in Judea and Samaria,” he said. He spoke about an interaction with Palestinian teenagers in Bethlehem on a previous visit to the region.

“They told me if they meet a Jew on the street, they want to kill him, just like that. And I think it’s a big problem, they have so much hate in their education.”

The German national also challenged the Palestinian Authority’s narrative about the event.

PA officials claimed that local security forces managed to hold back the violent mob. According to Hetzel, the Palestinian police were unable to control the attackers and simply told him to drive out of the city as fast as possible.

What really happened, Hetzel continued, is that an Arab-Israeli visiting Nablus recognized that he and his friend were tourists and helped guide them out of the city using side streets. He then gave them a ride back to Tel Aviv, as the tourists’ rental car was so damaged after the mob attack that they were unable to continue driving.

In a media statement, a senior PA official stated that “we clearly have zero hostility toward a country whose citizens visit our cities.” Notably, the official stressed that German tourists should be safe in Nablus, but he did not express those sentiments regarding Jewish or Israeli visitors.

“A mob attacking tourists because they don’t like their license plate is disgusting and cowardly,” wrote Germany’s ambassador to Israel, Steffen Seibert, on Twitter shortly after the incident.

The post ‘If they meet a Jew, they want to kill him,’ says German tourist attacked by Palestinian mob appeared first on World Israel News.

Israel’s NY Consul summoned over anti-judicial reform comments

Israeli diplomat Asaf Zamir tells Foreign Ministry officials that he “stands behind” his public remarks criticizing the judicial overhaul.

By Lauren Marcus, World Israel News

Israel’s Consul General in New York, Asaf Zamir, was summoned to Jerusalem by the Foreign Ministry after he made critical remarks regarding a planned overhaul of Israel’s judicial system.

Speaking at a fundraising event for the Anu Museum in New York last week, Zamir said he was “deeply concerned” about the judicial overhaul.

Zamir stressed his worry “about the direction the country is going in right now” and said that “if we want a national home and we want it to be everyone’s home, it has to be democratic.”

A clip of Zamir’s comments went viral in Hebrew-language media, attracting the attention of Israel’s Foreign Ministry.

Appointed by former prime minister Yair Lapid in 2021, Zamir is not expected to be immediately removed from his position, according to an Israel Hayom report.

However, as a diplomat representing the Jewish state, Zamir is expected to maintain a non-partisan position on Israeli government policies. Should Zamir continue to publicly express disapproval of internal legislative matters, he may be fired from his post.

David Roth, the deputy director of North America at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, contacted Zamir to inform him of his summons.

According to a Walla report, Zamir said that he “stands behind my words” and that he “said them from my heart.”

In 2018, Zamir challenged longtime Tel Aviv mayor Ron Huldai in municipal elections. Zamir was easily defeated by Huldai.

Zamir, a member of the Blue and White party headed by Benny Gantz, became a member of Knesset in 2019. He served as tourism minister in 2020.

Yitzhak Zamir, the diplomat’s uncle, served as Supreme Court judge from 1994 to 2001.

After the current coalition government headed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was sworn in, two Israeli diplomats resigned from their positions in protest.

Israeli Ambassador to France Yael German and Ambassador to Canada Ronen Hoffman immediately quit their posts, rather than serve under Netanyahu.

The post Israel’s NY Consul summoned over anti-judicial reform comments appeared first on World Israel News.

WATCH: First trans athlete case heads to US Supreme Court

West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey joins ‘America Reports’ to explain the state’s effort to keep ‘fairness’ in women’s sports after a court blocked a proposed ban on transgender athletes.

The post WATCH: First trans athlete case heads to US Supreme Court appeared first on World Israel News.

WATCH: Israel’s reps in the US ‘should be out of their offices every single day,’ presenting Israel’s case

Gideon Israel, founder and president of the Jerusalem Washington Center, discusses with ILTV the shift in the Democratic party towards the Palestinians in recent years and what he believes needs to be done.

The post WATCH: Israel’s reps in the US ‘should be out of their offices every single day,’ presenting Israel’s case appeared first on World Israel News.

‘Frank and candid’: Biden urges Netanyahu to seek compromise on judicial reform

Biden phones Netanyahu, expresses “concern” over judicial reforms, pressures him to pursue “broad compromise.”

By Lauren Marcus, World Israel News

U.S. President Joe Biden urged Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to pursue a compromise regarding a plan to overhaul Israel’s judicial system, in a phone conversation described as “frank and candid” by a senior American official.

“The President…underscored his belief that democratic values have always been, and must remain, a hallmark of the U.S.-Israel relationship, that democratic societies are strengthened by genuine checks and balances, and that fundamental changes should be pursued with the broadest possible base of popular support,” read a State Department read-out summarizing the call between Biden and Netanyahu.

“The President offered support for efforts underway to forge a compromise on proposed judicial reforms consistent with those core principles,” the statement added.

Netanyahu responded to Biden “that Israel was, and will remain, a strong and vibrant democracy,” according to an Israeli transcript of the conversation.

An American official who spoke to the media on the condition of anonymity said that Biden expressed concerns about the current judicial reform proposals and that he hoped a “broad consensus” around the issue could be found.

The read-out of the call noted that Biden “welcomed” Israel’s participation in a security summit on Sunday, which included Palestinian, Egyptian, and Jordanian officials. During the meeting, Israel agreed to freeze settlement planning and building for at least six months.

While the meeting was taking place, a Palestinian terrorist shot an American-Israeli in the head from point blank range in the town of Huwara, where two Israeli brothers were murdered by terrorists three weeks ago.

Notably, that shooting took place during an earlier security summit, where Israel also made concessions around settlement issues.

At a media conference on Sunday, American officials demurred when asked why Netanyahu has not yet been invited to visit the White House.

A spokesman said that Biden “looks forward to getting the two leaders together” but avoided mentioning a specific time frame for the meeting.

The post ‘Frank and candid’: Biden urges Netanyahu to seek compromise on judicial reform appeared first on World Israel News.

Israeli finance minister denies existence of a Palestinian people in Paris speech

“We need to tell the truth without bowing to the lies and distortions of history,” says Bezalel Smotrich.

By JNS

Israel’s Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich on Sunday denied the existence of a Palestinian people, saying that it was Jews such as his own family that were the true Palestinians.

Speaking in Paris at a tribute to Likud activist Jacques Kupfer, who died of cancer in January 2021 at the age of 74, the leader of the Religious Zionist Party said, “Jacques’ truth must be told with all our might and without confusion: He said there is no such thing as Palestinians—because there is no such thing as a Palestinian people.”

He continued: “We need to tell the truth without bowing to the lies and distortions of history, and without succumbing to the hypocrisy of BDS and the pro-Palestinian organizations.”

Smotrich went on to say that he is a Palestinian.

“My grandfather, who was the 13th generation in Jerusalem, is the real Palestinian. My grandmother, who was born in Metula more than 100 years ago to a family of pioneers, is Palestinian.”

The Palestinians claim that they descend from the Canaanites–the Semitic civilization that inhabited the southern Levant region before it was called Israel. “The Palestinian Arab people have existed on this land since the history of their Canaanite ancestors,” Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh said recently in a speech.

“The Palestinian people are the real owners of the land and not the Jewish people,” Shtayyeh said, echoing what P.A. President Mahmoud Abbas has said on multiple occasions.

However, the Palestinian identity was applied to Jews who lived in pre-state Israel before 1948, and Palestinian Arab nationalism did not start until the establishment of the Palestine Liberation Organization in 1964.

Smotrich’s claim is not a new one: Former Israeli prime minister Golda Meir famously claimed in a 1969 interview that she was a Palestinian, and said that “there was no such as Palestinians.” She later clarified that she meant that “there never was a Palestinian nation.”

In his address on Sunday, Smotrich said that international law sets out five characteristics of a state: history, culture, language, currency and historical leadership.

“Who was the first Palestinian king? What language do the Palestinians have? Has there ever been a Palestinian currency? Is there a Palestinian history or culture? There isn’t any,” he said. “There are Arabs who are in the Middle East and who arrived in the Land of Israel at the same time as the Jewish aliyah and the early days of Zionism.”

The source of Arab Palestinian nationalism, he continued, is opposition to the existence of Israel.

“After 2,000 years of exile, the people of Israel are returning home, and there are Arabs around who do not like it. So what do they do? They invent a fictitious people and claim fictitious rights in the Land of Israel just to fight the Zionist movement,” he said.

“This truth should be heard here in the Elysee Palace. This truth should also be heard by the Jewish people in the State of Israel who are a little confused. This truth should be heard in the White House in Washington. The whole world needs to hear this truth, because it is the truth—and the truth will win.”

The post Israeli finance minister denies existence of a Palestinian people in Paris speech appeared first on World Israel News.

Woman Pulls Gun on McDonald’s Worker Over Meal Not on Menu

On the 16th of March, Quavi Young, aged 26, was apprehended by police in Cocoa, Florida, after officers claimed she had threatened a McDonald’s employee and brandished a gun at them. Consequently, Young was booked with three charges: aggravated assault with a weapon, openly carrying a weapon and operating a vehicle with a suspended license.

The arrest report stated that Young had driven to the drive-thru speaker and requested a meal that was not on the menu. After being told that her order could not be taken, she proceeded to the first window and insisted on her order. When the employee inquired her about her agitation, Young reportedly took out her gun and said she would “push her stuff back”, before moving to the next window.

When officers arrived on the scene, they discovered a black M&P gun with a 50-round drum-style magazine on the passenger seat of Young’s vehicle. Employees at McDonald’s informed police that this was her second visit to the restaurant that night, without providing any further information. Young confessed to officers that her license had been suspended.

Young is due to appear in court for her arraignment on April 13, 2023.