The government is ‘confident’ in its decision to hand police new powers – despite scathing review of the Met Police
Author: admin
Biden administration pushing Arabs towards Iran – analysis
Thanks to the US administration’s fragility, the Iranian-led axis of evil has been significantly emboldened as America’s erstwhile Arab allies are rushing towards the open arms of the mullahs in Tehran.
By Khaled Abu Toameh, The Gatestone Institute
Many Arabs and Muslims are celebrating the Saudi-Iranian agreement to restore diplomatic relations as a devastating blow to the Biden Administration, a victory for Iran and China, and a sign of Washington’s failed policies in the Middle East.
According to these Arabs and Muslims, the Saudi-Iranian pact is the direct result of the Biden Administration’s antagonism towards America’s traditional Arab allies, especially Saudi Arabia, and the American policy of appeasement towards the mullahs in Iran.
Lebanese-born American scholar Walid Phares wrote that in the past two years he has been issuing warnings that the Biden administration’s dealings with the Arab allies “were neither at the required level nor with the necessary depth.”
From Obama to Biden
According to Phares, the Obama Administration “went too far in its partnership with Iran and the Muslim Brotherhood, while turning its back on the Arab countries, with the aim of establishing partnerships with Islamists in the region.”
Phares pointed out that this policy of the Obama administration led to the first crisis of confidence between Washington and the Arab countries. The Trump Administration, however, he noted, “embarked on an unprecedented alliance with the Arabs to isolate Iran and defeat the Islamic State (ISIS).”
“The Arab-American alliance lasted four years, and Saudi Arabia and its partners committed themselves to the shared agenda on all fronts, starting with confronting the [Iranian-backed] Houthis [in Yemen] and supporting those who confronted Iran, in addition to uprooting Al-Qaeda and ISIS and, most importantly, delegitimizing radical Islam… However, the fluctuation in US foreign policy after the end of the Trump administration and the arrival of President Joe Biden’s administration put the Saudis, and with them all the Arabs, in a difficult position. The Arabs continued with their commitment to the policy agreed upon with the Trump administration, but the administration of his successor turned against it. In 2021, the Arab coalition found itself headed towards war with Iran, while the Biden administration was going to make peace with Tehran!”
Phares noted that the Biden Administration has continued the policy of the Obama Administration by ignoring the Arab coalition and the concerns of the Arab countries about the expansionist and terrorist dangers of the radicals in the Middle East. The Arabs, he added, also saw how the Biden Administration handed over Afghanistan to the Taliban “and were shocked to see the West scrambling towards the negotiating table with the Iranians, while ignoring the Arab countries and their national interests.”
China’s role in the shift
Many Arabs have also taken to social media to praise the Chinese-brokered Saudi-Iranian agreement, hailing it as a major defeat for the policies of the Biden administration and a victory for China.
“China is coming with force and has defeated America politically,” read a comment posted by Saudi political activist Saeed Al-Mryti.
“China extracted full Arab recognition against America’s policies. Today, China is victorious by sponsoring the historic agreement between Saudi Arabia and Iran, while the US has a new president who comes to destroy agreements reached by his predecessor, and even brags about it during his election campaign and his presidency.”
Another Arab, Ahmed Al-Fifi, wrote on Twitter:
“Two earthquakes, unprecedented for nearly 70 years, have hit Washington, and their center is in Riyadh! The first occurred in 1986 when Saudi Arabia bought long-range strategic missiles from China. The second was when Saudi Arabia worked to restore its relationship with Iran under Chinese auspices.”
Prominent Iraqi author Iyad Al-Dalimi wrote that by choosing China as the sponsor of the agreement, the Saudis aimed to place the Biden administration in an embarrassing situation. The Saudi-Iranian agreement, Al-Dalimi stated, “came in response to Biden ignoring Saudi Arabia and the apathy that afflicted this relationship since he assumed power more than two years ago.”
American ‘escape’ from the Middle East
Commenting on the Saudi-Iranian agreement, Lebanese political analyst Jubran Al-Khoury wrote that “no matter how hard analysts try to beautify the situation for US policy, what Saudi Arabia has done today is a direct and successful blow to the Biden administration and its policy in the Middle East.”
Al-Khoury pointed out that the Biden administration tried to “escape” from the Middle East to confront China in its home in the Far East.
“Two years after this American decision, Saudi Arabia allowed China to enter directly into Middle East politics from the wide door… Since 2021, Saudi Arabia’s policy has changed due to a change in America’s policy, and Saudi Arabia has taken several measures, which include launching negotiations with Iran, expanding trade relations with China despite the declared trade war between the US and China, and developing Saudi relations with Russia…
“The Biden administration has become keenly aware that the new policy of Saudi Arabia is no longer as flexible towards American requests as it was previously… Indeed, Saudi Arabia, with its current performance, may have forced America to reconsider its policy in the Middle East.”
The Palestinians, who are opposed to peace between Israel and the Arab countries, also see the Saudi-Iranian accord as a severe blow to both the US and Israel. The Palestinians are voicing optimism that the agreement will stop Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries from joining the Abraham Accords, a series of treaties normalizing diplomatic relations between Israel, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Kosovo, Sudan and Morocco.
An end to the Abraham Accords?
By turning its back on Saudi Arabia, the Biden Administration has empowered the Arabs who oppose peace with Israel and destroyed any chance of expanding the Abraham Accords to include more Arab countries.
According to an editorial in the Palestinian newspaper Al-Quds:
“The Saudi-Iranian agreement dealt a strong blow not only to Israel, but also to America and many European countries that are imposing a blockade on Iran and stirring unrest within it… Likewise, the agreement will be a prelude to the Arab world’s exit from American control and hegemony, and support the international trend against America in order to end its domination of the world through unipolarity. This agreement will unite the Arabic and Islamic [worlds]; it will also end Israeli hopes of getting Saudi Arabia to join the Abraham Accords.”
It is thus no surprise that Iran and its terror proxies – Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad and Hezbollah – are expressing profound satisfaction over the Saudi-Iranian agreement. In their eyes, the agreement is an indication of the growing weakness of the US and the failed policy of the Biden administration in the Middle East.
Thanks to the US administration’s fragility, the Iranian-led axis of evil has been significantly emboldened as America’s erstwhile Arab allies are rushing towards the open arms of the mullahs in Tehran.
Khaled Abu Toameh is an award-winning journalist based in Jerusalem.
The post Biden administration pushing Arabs towards Iran – analysis appeared first on World Israel News.
WATCH: Israel’s defense minister warns the next war will be on multiple fronts
While Israel has fought limited operations in the past 50 years, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant is warning that the current escalation has the potential to ignite fighting simultaneously in Judea and Samaria, Gaza – and even the Lebanon border.
The post WATCH: Israel’s defense minister warns the next war will be on multiple fronts appeared first on World Israel News.
Mine blast on Lebanon border wounds three IDF soldiers
An Israeli army vehicle driving along the frontier reportedly set off the explosion.
By JNS
A mine explosion along the border with Lebanon injured three Israeli soldiers on Tuesday.
The blast was reportedly set off by an IDF vehicle driving along the frontier.
The IDF earlier Tuesday said that the terrorist who placed a roadside bomb along the Route 65 highway in northern Israel on March 13 infiltrated the country from Lebanon using a ladder to climb over the border fence.
The terrorist was not spotted by soldiers at lookout posts, nor did he set off the detection system, said the military.
The military has not named who it believes dispatched the terrorist, but it is suspected that Hezbollah was involved.
The bomb, which was placed behind a barrier near Megiddo Junction some 18 miles southeast of Haifa and 37 miles from the Lebanese border, detonated at around 6 a.m., seriously wounding Shareef ad-Din, 21, a resident of the Israeli Arab town of Salem.
After the blast, the IDF, Israel Security Agency (Shin Bet) and Israel Police launched an intensive search for the terrorist, including the establishment of roadblocks in northern Israel. The terrorist, who was equipped with a suicide vest and a rifle, was killed by security forces after being stopped at a checkpoint near the village of Ya’ara.
Security sources believe the suspect likely planned to carry out an additional attack before possibly seeking to return to Lebanon.
The post Mine blast on Lebanon border wounds three IDF soldiers appeared first on World Israel News.
The Chinese Document, “US Hegemony and Its Perils”. The U.S. is a “Paper Tiger”. Geopolitical Analysis by Dr. Paul Craig Roberts
All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.
To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.
Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …
The post The Chinese Document, “US Hegemony and Its Perils”. The U.S. is a “Paper Tiger”. Geopolitical Analysis by Dr. Paul Craig Roberts appeared first on Global Research.
Breaking: “Second Russia Offensive” (SRO): Vladimir Sharpens the Cleaver; Volodymyr Fattens the Calf
All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate Website button below the author’s name.
To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.
Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe to …
The post Breaking: “Second Russia Offensive” (SRO): Vladimir Sharpens the Cleaver; Volodymyr Fattens the Calf appeared first on Global Research.
Security forces foil imminent terror attacks in Jerusalem
Terrorists from Gaza smuggled weapons to several activists they had recruited in Judea and Samaria.
By Batya Jerenberg, World Israel News
Israeli security forces have foiled a string of potentially large attacks in Jerusalem and other cities that were being planned by Palestinian cells recruited and armed by Gazan terrorists, the Shabak (Israel’s security agency) announced Tuesday. Several arrests were made in recent weeks.
The cell leaders are two residents of Rafiah in the southern Gaza Strip who are members of the Popular Resistance Committees (PRC), a coalition of Hezbollah-financed, armed Palestinian groups that originate from the Palestinian Authority’s main Fatah faction but oppose its supposed conciliatory approach towards Israel.
Tzabri Mahmoud Eram (40) and Ayman Youssef Khalil Zakkut (31) were under covert surveillance throughout the recruitment and planning process, according to the Shabak. They smuggled weapons to several Palestinians in Judea and Samaria, including a pair of brothers who were arrested last month on suspicion of planning a bombing attack in Israel.
Another two Palestinians who were arrested recently revealed under interrogation that they had been instructed to carry out a shooting attack in Jerusalem in the coming days. They turned over the weapon they had been given to use in the attack.
The IDF and Israeli Police worked together with the Shabak in uncovering the terror infrastructure over the last several weeks.
The PRC has been designated a terrorist organization by both Israel and the United States. Established in 2000, it took responsibility for several infamous attacks on civilians in the Gaza Strip prior to the 2005 ‘Disengagement‘ – when Jews living in the Gush Katif region of the Strip were forced out of their homes.
The attacks included the bombing of a school bus that claimed the lives of two adults and seriously injured several children.
The terrorists also shot and killed a pregnant woman, Tali Hatuel, along with her four daughters, ages 2-11, as she drove towards the Kissufim Junction in Gush Katif in 2004.
An unrelated spate of arrests was carried out overnight Monday-Tuesday by the IDF, Shabak and Border Police in Judea and Samaria; 16 suspected terrorists were taken into custody.
The post Security forces foil imminent terror attacks in Jerusalem appeared first on World Israel News.
Sinn Féin Leader Mary Lou McDonald: “We’ll Build a Truly United Ireland”
Sinn Féin has surged to a huge lead in Ireland’s opinion polls. In an interview, party president Mary Lou McDonald explains why building a successful united Ireland is about more than just stitching together north and south.
Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald at Leinster House in Dublin on December 15, 2022. (Brian Lawless / PA Images via Getty Images)
As Europe was ravaged by austerity policies in the past decade, numerous left-wing insurgencies emerged to challenge for government: Syriza in Greece, Podemos in Spain, La France Insoumise, and, from 2015 to 2019, the Labour Party under Jeremy Corbyn. Each came from outside the traditional center-left and learned, to some degree, from the others. They offered moments of hope for the international left in a time of deep social crisis.
By 2020, it seemed those moments had passed. The much-vaunted “new” parties and movements of Europe’s post-2008 landscape had been defeated, and the forces of the status quo had returned with a vengeance. But in the Irish general election, a far older movement made a breakthrough on more or less the same terms. Sinn Féin, which before the crash had been a party of 6–7 percent, rose to a historic 24.5 percent — and, in the process, defeated the two right-wing parties that had dominated Irish politics since the foundation of the southern state.
North of the border, Sinn Féin had been growing steadily. In 2003, it eclipsed the Social Democratic and Labour Party as the leading nationalist party, and by 2007, Martin McGuinness was elected deputy first minister of Northern Ireland. But its progress in the south was slower. It wasn’t until 2014’s European election, around the time of the mass movement against water charges, that it threatened leading parties Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael for the first time. This cemented its position as the leading party of the Left and the fight against austerity in the southern Irish state.
In 2018, the party appointed a new leader, Mary Lou McDonald, replacing veteran republican Gerry Adams. While Sinn Féin briefly faltered in her first European elections — leading to many predictions of its demise — the 2020 general election that followed has fundamentally changed the Irish political landscape. While the party was locked out of government by a right-wing coalition, Sinn Féin has led in every poll since and currently sits at a scarcely believable 35 percent to Fine Gael’s 21 percent and Fianna Fáil’s 16 percent.
Added to this, the party secured twenty-seven seats in May’s assembly elections, making it the largest party in the north for the first time in its history — although Unionist obstructionism has prevented it from assuming this role in practice. With its longtime ambition of government north and south in Ireland firmly within view, Ronan Burtenshaw sat down with Sinn Féin president Mary Lou McDonald to discuss what this means for the party, the country, and left-wing politics more broadly.
Ronan Burtenshaw
It would have been unthinkable for most of my lifetime for Sinn Féin to be leading in the polls in the south of Ireland. Politics has been dominated by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael for the entire history of the state. How has this change come about?
Mary Lou McDonald
It has been an extraordinary journey. Not just in the south, but right across the island. You’re right to say few could have imagined it. I suppose it’s like every big development, every success in political life, it looks sudden. But the truth is Sinn Féin has been toiling away building capacity, strength, running in elections, winning, losing, sometimes succeeding, sometimes failing, but all the time learning. Our activists as well as our elected representatives.
It’s interesting when I look at the faces that we have here in the Dáil, but also colleagues up north in the assembly and the executive, lots of us have been active together for all of our political lifetime. We were the young cubs running for election when the party didn’t have a real prospect of getting elected, but we invested politically and personally. We are lucky to have a lot of talent that’s just crystallizing at this moment. We’ve had generations before us, like Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness, a golden generation of leaders, but now we have a new generation that’s just come of age.
Circumstances have contributed too. The bursting of the property bubble a decade ago was hugely traumatic and transformative in terms of people’s political thinking. Then you had Brexit, Boris Johnson, belligerent Toryism, that always impacts on the Irish political scene. None of that was any great surprise, I suppose, but it has been quite something. Just bear in mind, we’re certainly not finished yet. I’m conscious that you earn your political stripes, political progress, trust, and momentum. It sometimes happens spontaneously because of extraneous factors, but the truth, for the most part, is that progress is built, assiduously, laboriously, consistently. We’ve built this far, and we need to consolidate the progress that we’ve made nationally, north and south. We haven’t hit any ceilings yet.
What distinguishes us from the other political parties — Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, Labour, and so on — is that we have a big political project. All of this is about something; it’s not simply so that we can be elected members of the Dáil, it’s certainly not about building careers or platforms for people. Although ambition is a good thing; you want your people to be the best that they can, to succeed to the best of their abilities. But Sinn Féin’s project is about resolving a generations-long conflict. It’s about ridding Ireland of those tail ends of a colonial experience that was absolutely devastating, as you well know. We’ve had experiences of colonization, occupation, conflict, partition, and now a peace process and a settlement that will be twenty-five years old this year.
They say there is nothing more powerful than an idea that comes of age. I think our ideas about social justice, democracy, fairness, public goods and public services, the politics of equality are coming of age in this country. It’s an exciting time to be an activist. In my view, there’s never been a more important time to be an activist — wherever you live. Ireland is changing and has changed, but the world is changing too. It will change in ways that we have yet to imagine. It is important to be involved. At no stage should anybody fool themselves into thinking that success comes in a white puff of smoke, or that progress is something to be watched at a distance, or for others to do. This is now everybody’s business.
Ronan Burtenshaw
When I was back home during the last election, two things really stood out: Sinn Féin’s approach to dealing with the housing crisis and commitment to building a National Health Service in the south of Ireland. These things came up time and again when I asked people who were voting Sinn Féin for the first time. Why do you think your party’s approach to those two issues had such a transformative impact?
Mary Lou McDonald
You’re right, but I’d add to that list the issue around the pension age. It is any workers’ right to retire with a decent pension at the age of sixty-five. We fought for that, and it really struck a chord, not just with older people, but with many young workers who function now in the gig economy. They face the prospect of insecure work for their entire working lives in some cases. For many people, it could mean working on and on, sixty-six, sixty-seven, sixty-eight, and beyond, before having any entitlement to a pension payment. It cuts to the core of the social contract between the government and the people.
The same was true with housing. There was a recent report from the ESRI [the Economic and Social Research Institute], one of the big think tanks here, as you know, and its findings were damning. It sets out very plainly that we now have a young generation locked out of any real prospect of home ownership, or even affordability in terms of rent. So what are those people supposed to do? What is the future? Projecting forward, they were forecasting that same generation would still be in an insecure state as they come of pension age. It’s a very depressing scenario. For so many people, the notion of having secure shelter is just beyond their reach. You’re right; that was, I would say, the core issue in the last election.
Those that went on to form the government to keep us out, Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, said that they had heard the people. They claimed that they accepted the housing had to be sorted. But I have to tell you, we are two years on, and far from anything getting sorted, the situation is worse. We’ve got record levels of homelessness. It’s not just individuals either, as it once was; it’s families with children. There is no sign, despite all the rhetoric, of affordability in terms of housing, much less any delivery in social housing stock. The right to a home is, in my view, a democratic right. It’s not a luxury. You’re not looking for the world by saying that you deserve a home. Having that right vindicated is central to the exercise of all other rights that we enjoy as citizens. Education, employment, relationships, family structures, all of those things rely to some degree on shelter.
We have a crisis, and it’s not something that’s limited to the poor, the marginalized, or the disadvantaged, although they’re feeling it most acutely. This is something that is reaching every layer of society. We are still dealing with a government that either cannot, or will not, own up to the fact that they have gotten it wrong, not just now but for a decade and more. The state retreated and left the provision of shelter and housing to the private developers. We see the consequences of that now, but they cannot fess up and say, “That was wrong.”
Ronan Burtenshaw
I agree with you on that, but it does raise a question. Sinn Féin’s agenda is bold on housing — doubling capital investment in social housing, a rent freeze, ending tax breaks for these big investment funds that are hoovering up properties. But the Irish housing sector has been dominated by private interests for decades. The developer lobby is not going to go away. How will you implement your program? And will you be able to do it if, for instance, you require a coalition government?
Mary Lou McDonald
Failure is not an option. There are some things in life that have to be done. Like if you are raising a family, you have to feed the kids, keep the lights on, you have to keep people warm. For us, there isn’t a question around “What if we can’t?”; the imperative is to do it. That’s a pressure on us because even with the right agenda, and the right policy direction, and the right priorities, and the right people in the right places at the right times, this is still a very big challenge. It is a crisis a generation or two in the making.
There’s no quick solution, but it has to be done. We need to be prepared for the opportunity of government. The front-bench team here in Dublin have essentially two tasks. One is to hold the government to account, keep their feet to the fire on the cost of living. And we’ve moved them in recent weeks on things like a back-to-school provision for families. We haven’t got them the whole way, but we have pushed them to make initial moves.
Then, running alongside that, is preparation for government. Eoin Ó Broin is our housing spokesperson. He is engaging with the people and organizations we will need to make a difference in the housing sector. When we enter government, there are certain things that you could do fairly quickly. One of the things that we’ve been raising, for example, is rent. We haven’t had a proper rent freeze. They introduced what they called “rent pressure zones,” but they aren’t real freezes, and they don’t work. We have a proposal to give back, by means of a refundable tax credit, a month’s rent into tenants’ pockets and to freeze rents for a three-year period.
There’s some argument from those who oppose our agenda that we can’t do it. They say it’s unconstitutional. But our legal advice is to the contrary, that you can do it as an emergency intervention. So with measures like that, which are emergencies, you move in, you stabilize and support people. That can be done quickly, but the rest is going to be very challenging. But not only do I believe that we can change Ireland, I believe that we will. It has to be done. I look around at what [Fianna Fáil minister for housing] Darragh O’Brien and his colleagues in government are saying, and they’re all culpable in this. They’re all defending the indefensible. Build to rent, buy to rent, these are not the answer. Selling more and more properties to big investment funds, that’s not the answer.
The right approach is investment in public housing on public land; it is a mix of affordable housing for purchase, for families that wish to, affordable rents, and then social housing. We need to reconfigure in our mind’s eye in Ireland what social housing means. We’ve got a strange and almost discriminatory view, as you know, that social housing is only for a tiny minority of people who are disadvantaged or deprived. In other countries, people from all sorts of backgrounds access and live in quality publicly owned housing. So you asked me, can it be done? It has to be done, Ronan. It’s as simple as that.
Ronan Burtenshaw
On the question of changing Ireland, you recently said that you thought there was a prospect of a unity referendum within ten years. How do you see the path from here to there? Because sitting in London, it looks like the role of the secretary of state will be significant — and I can’t see an obvious way to overcome the fact that under the Good Friday Agreement they, in effect, set the conditions that must be achieved before a referendum could take place.
Mary Lou McDonald
The first thing to say is that the right to a referendum is established as a matter of law. We’re not petitioning anyone to grant us this opportunity out of the goodness of their heart. We have a right to self-determination under international law, and we have an agreed mechanism in the Good Friday Agreement set down almost twenty-five years ago. But you’re right — the issue looks to be, how, in the secretary of state’s view, would a triggering point be reached? I have raised it in my time as leader of Sinn Féin with any number of prime ministers and secretaries of state, I’ve lost count of the number of them, and we’ve never gotten a straight answer.
The truth is though, the secretary of state won’t really make this call. It will be made by whoever is residing at Number 10. The best way to encourage the thought process and the call for a referendum is to have a government in Dublin that is applying pressure and advancing the case. So I’m not going to speculate as to what those trigger points might be. But I will say this, it’s very clear that Boris Johnson’s government — far from having a positive impact on relations — was wholly negative. His government actually attacked the Good Friday Agreement. Parties walked away from north-south institutions, walked away from the executive, attacked the protocol, all with the assistance of Boris Johnson. The legacy legislation that they moved through the Parliament was clearly not Article Two compliant; it was clearly in breach of international law. They attacked the foundations, in fact, of the Good Friday Agreement.
So I’m not naive at all about the prospects. We are just going to have to navigate those woods. What that means is there has to be a level of initiative and energy from Dublin. Not in a way that’s confrontational or divisive, but to create the space by means of something like a citizens’ assembly where the question of reunification can be discussed and developed. It also must include those from a unionist perspective, for whom Irish unity would not be their first choice. There should be unionist farmers, haulers, businesspeople, community activists, trade unionists, and others; they should be part of the conversation around what kind of Ireland we want in ten years’ time, in twenty years’ time.
The conversation shouldn’t start from a position of negativity, it should start from a position of opportunity. I can see it happening already, ever since the last election in the north. My colleagues and I have been struck by the number of people who approach us randomly to say, look, it wouldn’t be my first choice, I come from a different political viewpoint, different cultural viewpoint, but let’s talk about it. What about my pension? What about the currency? What about investment opportunities? That is a big difference.
Ronan Burtenshaw
But how much of that change will reunification bring? Will it be the stitching together of two, in their own way, quite broken states with deep social problems? North and south, there are huge proportions of the population without what you describe as basic rights, to a decent job, to housing, to health care. How can you convince people that what we are talking about here is a fundamentally different society, the new republic that progressives have spoken about for so long?
Mary Lou McDonald
You’re absolutely right. The last thing I would want is to stitch those two reactionary, dysfunctional entities together. I mean, looking back now, on the centenary of the civil war, it’s remarkable how accurate James Connolly was when he predicted that partition would lead to “a carnival of reaction.” North of the border we ended up with a single-party state, a Protestant parliament for Protestant people, and decades of oppression. But as you have written about, the oppression didn’t only happen north of the border. For too many, let’s say it out loud, Home Rule meant Rome Rule, and women and the poor in particular suffered the consequences of that. The last thing that we want is to repeat these mistakes.
I think we already have a model for these big national conversations. I’m going to cite two examples, marriage equality and the issue of women’s reproductive rights. They were very sensitive, tricky terrain in Ireland. And yet that conversation about the rights of our LGBT community, marriage rights, women’s rights, took the country forward. So we can do this, but we need the structure and a government to take the initiative. Dublin is duty-bound to do this, to plan ahead, to have the wider horizon and the bigger vision. People are up for that.
I will argue against just stitching together these two states, and I will do everything I can as a political leader and as an activist to ensure that is not the outcome. A new Ireland with all that it brings and a true republic, that’s where we need to get. The next decade will be a very exciting time in political life here. Those questions will be put, and any political leader who thinks that there is anything to be gained by burying their head in the sand and pretending the change isn’t happening will ultimately fail.
Emmanuel Macron Is Using the 2024 Olympics to Make France a Surveillance State
A new security law from Emmanuel Macron’s government will roll out an AI-based biometric categorization system. The law is billed as a measure for the 2024 Paris Olympics — but also allows a vast expansion of intrusive surveillance.
LE ROVE, FRANCE – 2021/02/02: Surveillance cameras in Le Rove, France.
More and more French municipalities are using surveillance cameras to monitor motorists. (Photo by Gerard Bottino/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)
Guillermo Federico Ibarrola was waiting for a train in the Buenos Aires metro when he was picked up by two police officers, booked and detained for six days. Ibarrola hadn’t committed a crime, nor was he a witness to one. Rather, Ibarrola was the unfortunate victim of a glitch in the city’s newfangled, artificial intelligence–based facial recognition system, installed citywide in 2019 and now covering 75 percent of the Argentinian capital.
Even some years after such biometric systems were developed, most European capitals haven’t followed Argentina’s example. But now, this could change. As large swaths of France take to the streets in protest against a proposed rise in the pension age, the National Assembly has been quietly pushing forward a bill related to the upcoming 2024 Olympics that privacy experts say will drastically increase the state’s policing and surveillance capacities.
The so-called Olympics and Paralympics law is being fast-tracked through Parliament after being proposed by Emmanuel Macron’s ruling Renaissance party (formerly En Marche!) last December. If adopted, it will pave the way for the installation of a controversial, if “experimental” according to its proponents, AI-based biometric categorization system aimed at detecting “predetermined events,” such as crowd movements, terrorist attacks, or acts of violence. In short, the bill is named after the Olympics, but it’s about much more.
“The government’s intention through the bill is to increase the social acceptability in France of generalized surveillance,” Elisa Martin, a deputy from the left-wing New Ecological and Social Popular Union (NUPES) coalition, told Jacobin.
An “Experimental” System
At the heart of the controversy surrounding the proposed Olympics and Paralympics bill is Article 7. This article states that “images collected by means of video protection systems,” including surveillance cameras around stadiums, metros, and other areas, “may be subject to processing, including through an artificial intelligence system.”
The proposed AI-based system is “experimental,” the authors write, and was initially planned to last through June 2025 — well beyond the Olympic Games, which are slated for August 2024. (This was later amended to last through the end of December 2024.) According to the authors of the law, the system would not include facial or biometric identification, but rather would use AI to identify “atypical” or “risky” behavior, such as standing in place for long periods of time or loud voices.
Privacy advocates say that while these systems are billed as not including facial recognition, for all intents and purposes they can be used in the same way.
The bill is named after the Olympics, but it’s about much more.
“There’s a whole range of things you can do with that data,” including grouping people together by hair or skin color, recognizing emotions and making inferences about behavior based on these categories, Daniel Leufer, a senior policy analyst at Access Now, told me. “You’re capturing people’s behavior, the way they walk, the way that they’re shouting. The types of data that you’re gathering or processing about people will allow for them to be identified.”
In recent weeks, civil society groups have joined the chorus of mostly left-wing politicians opposing the law. On March 7, thirty-eight organizations, including Access Now, Amnesty International, and AlgorithmWatch, a Berlin-based AI watchdog group, signed an open letter asking for Article 7 to be removed from the law.
Katia Roux, who heads advocacy at Amnesty International France, told Jacobin that the law, in addition to infringing on antidiscrimination and privacy standards, “can have an extremely dissuasive effect on the freedom of expression, the freedom of peaceful assembly.” “When we know we’re being surveilled, or when we think we’re under surveillance obviously we don’t act the same way,” she said. “There can be a form of self-censorship.”
That the system would be deployed in Saint-Denis, the largely minority, working-class suburb north of Paris where much of the Olympics infrastructure is being built, she added, only adds to the potential for misuse.
Martin, from NUPES, noted that Article 7 is not the only concerning element of the Olympics and Paralympics law. It also includes US Transportation Security Administration (TSA)–style body scanners at the entrance to stadiums and the deployment of tens of thousands of police during the upcoming Games.
The proposed law, she added, is one of several laws and directives passed in recent months that aim to criminalize dissent in France, including a directive passed by the Interior Ministry that greatly expands the scope of misdemeanor fines. “Who is this aimed at? It’s aimed at poor people, it’s aimed at activists,” she said. “It’s part of a civil liberty-threatening continuum that’s being slowly and steadily reinforced.”
Surveillance Shock Doctrine
This wouldn’t be the first time the Olympics are used to push through extensive security measures, Jules Boykoff, the author of the book Power Games: A Political History of the Olympics, told me.
“When it comes to policing and the Olympics, local and national police forces in the host city and country use the Olympics like their own private cash machine, getting all the funding, special weapons and even laws that it would be very difficult to get during normal political times,” Boykoff told Jacobin. “And so, what we’re seeing transpire in Paris is what we see transpire in numerous cities.”
The 2004 Summer Olympics in Athens were a case in point.
In France, activists worry that the ‘state of exception’ created by the Olympics will lead to a long-term build-up of surveillance technology.
Throughout those Games — the first to take place after 9/11 — a large blimp fitted with cameras surveilled Athens. Seventy-thousand police and military forces marauded the streets. In computer centers hidden from public view, security agents monitored thousands of surveillance cameras that had been set up to identify “suspicious behavior.”
The security was so intensive that one Greek scholar referred to that year’s Olympics as a “super-panopticon,” in reference to a nineteenth-century prison design that allowed one guard to simultaneously monitor all of a penitentiary’s inmates without them being able to tell if they’re being watched.
Rio de Janeiro and Tokyo, other host cities, saw similarly expansive security measures passed, Boykoff writes in Power Games.
In France, activists worry that the “state of exception” created by the Olympics will lead to a long-term buildup of surveillance technology, much as it did in Greece — which is currently in the midst of a spying scandal nicknamed Predator-gate, brought about by allegations that the ruling party used a spyware tool called Predator to spy on journalists and politicians.
“The Olympics are an accelerator of surveillance,” “Alouette,” a privacy activist at La Quadrature du Net, a digital rights group, who preferred to remain anonymous for security reasons, told Jacobin. “For the security industry, especially the French industry, they are a huge opportunity.” French, and international, surveillance companies “really see the Olympic Games as a security showcase that allows them to show off their know-how,” she added.
While it’s unclear which company would provide the technology for AI-based surveillance for the Olympics, one company, the Israeli firm BriefCam, already deploys video surveillance technologies in more than two hundred municipalities across France, La Quadrature has noted.
To Boykoff, the idea of using the Olympics to push through these types of measures is common because of the popular nature of the Games. “You get people kind of used to it in that happy face, celebration capitalism environment of the Olympics, and then that new technology that was injected during the Games in that state of exception becomes the norm for policing moving forward.”
A European Precedent
The French law also comes as the European Union is preparing to pass an AI Act that would regulate artificial intelligence. This legislation, proposed in April 2021, could be adopted as soon as next month, and would place significant restrictions on algorithmic video surveillance.
According to Roux, the passage of the Olympic law would position France as Europe’s “champion of surveillance” and could be used as a way to hack at the AI bill from below, weakening future surveillance legislation in the EU.
“The precedent that it creates and the signal it sends to member states is extremely dangerous,” she said.
Other security experts, meanwhile, questioned the effectiveness of algorithmic surveillance.
“You have an inherent problem if you’re using machine learning to predict rare events,” Leufer said. “If that’s what you’re doing with your system, that should be a red flag already. That’s precisely the type of thing that machine learning is not good at. The less data you have on the type of thing that you’re trying to predict, the worse the system is going to be at it.”