U.S. Politics and the “Ugly Truth of 9/11”. Richard Gage Interviews Emanuel Pastreich, Independent Candidate for President of the U.S. (2000)

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate This Article button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe …

The post U.S. Politics and the “Ugly Truth of 9/11”. Richard Gage Interviews Emanuel Pastreich, Independent Candidate for President of the U.S. (2000) appeared first on Global Research.

Paul Vallas Gave Wall Street Massive Amounts of Money as Chicago Schools CEO

Chicago mayoral candidate Paul Vallas helped create a financial disaster as head of Chicago Public Schools, making bond deals worth $666 million — whose exorbitant interest payments to Wall Street are now robbing the city’s school system.

Paul Vallas, Democratic mayoral candidate for Chicago, during an interview in Chicago, Illinois, on March 16, 2023. (Christopher Dilts / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

When he led the Chicago school system, mayoral candidate Paul Vallas took actions that resulted in more than $1.5 billion being transferred out of the city’s budget-strapped public schools and to some of the wealthiest individuals and banks on the planet, a new report shows.

Now, Vallas is in an election runoff against Cook County Commissioner Brandon Johnson to lead the city of Chicago, with big support from wealthy investors and other corporate interests — including from executives at law firms and banks that benefited from the controversial financing methods Vallas used as CEO of Chicago Public Schools from 1995 to 2001.

With less than two weeks left before the April 4 election — which polls show is a tight race — Vallas has faced little scrutiny over his tenure as the Chicago Public Schools chief, even though he helped create a slow-moving financial disaster for America’s fourth-largest school system.

With Vallas at the helm, Chicago Public Schools issued $666 million worth of so-called payday loan bonds, according to a report from the Action Center on Race and the Economy (ACRE).

The interest payments on the bonds totaled $1.5 billion. A 2016 analysis from the Texas comptroller’s office found that the type of bonds Vallas issued can be three times more expensive than traditional bonds — meaning that Chicago Public Schools could have faced up to $1 billion in additional interest payments above a normal rate.

That $1 billion is almost exactly the budget shortfall that former Chicago mayor Rahm Emanuel, the current ambassador to Japan, cited as justification to shutter fifty Chicago public schools a decade ago. Some of Emanuel’s largest donors, like Citadel hedge fund CEO Ken Griffin and executives at private equity firm Madison Dearborn Partners, are currently backing Vallas.

“[Vallas] got Chicago Public Schools into really bad deals that we’re still paying for a quarter century after he left,” said Saqib Bhatti, the codirector of ACRE. “And the fact that his strongest base of support comes from Wall Street should in and of itself be a big red flag.”

“It Was a Gimmick”

The criticisms of Vallas’s budget management center on two opaque areas of municipal financing: “capital appreciation bonds” and “interest-rate swaps.”

Cities, states, and school districts routinely issue debt to pay for new infrastructure projects and to fund ongoing cash needs. For decades, municipal bonds were considered a plain vanilla sector of finance: municipalities would issue debt at a twenty- or thirty-year fixed interest rate, like a traditional mortgage. But starting in the 1990s, more exotic forms of financing came to the fore.

One example of those exotic forms of financing was capital appreciation bonds. Called “the school district equivalent of a payday loan” by former California state treasurer Bill Lockyer, these bonds don’t allow borrowers to make any principal or interest payments for many years — as long as fourteen years in the case of Chicago Public Schools — allowing governments to defer payments and investors to compound their interest and thus earn huge interest rate payments.

The report from ACRE found that Vallas issued $666 million in capital appreciation bonds during his tenure at Chicago Public Schools, resulting in $1.5 billion in interest payments — an effective interest rate of 223 percent on bonds issued to fund general operations of the school district.

Financial firms involved in the marketing of the capital appreciation bonds included Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, Lehman Brothers, and the Royal Bank of Canada.

“As a policy, I thought [capital appreciation bonds] was a bad idea,” Lockyer, who was California’s treasurer from 2007 to 2015, told us. “Bonds ought to pay for the project that’s contemplated. . . . Interest charges are fine. But building in capital appreciation bubbles seemed to me to be a bad idea.”

Capital appreciation bonds were routinely marketed on assumptions of higher property values in the future due to the improved public services funded by the bonds. That optimistic modeling, in theory, justified the years of delayed payments, which allowed the bondholders to capitalize interest.

“To tie it to some speculative increase in local property values just doesn’t make sense,” said Lockyer. “I do give [the municipal finance industry] credit for always figuring out a new clever scam, but that’s what I thought it was. It was a gimmick that allowed them to claim that the costs of the bond were going to be significantly less than the workout justified.”

Citing Lockyer’s concerns, California cracked down on capital appreciation bonds in 2013.

“They’re Unpredictable”

Vallas also oversaw bond deals that led to costly interest-rate swaps.

Interest-rate swaps involve a municipality initially issuing variable-rate debt, like a variable-rate mortgage, and then “swapping” the debt for a fixed interest rate in a transaction with a bank.

Under Vallas in 2000, Chicago Public Schools issued $303 million in variable-rate debt, some of which was later subject to interest rate swaps that cost the city’s schools $32 million, according to the ACRE report.

Interest-rate swaps have been a subject of enormous controversy in Chicago, with routine protests at banks and financial firms that profited from the deals. Those protests were often led by the Chicago Teachers Union (CTU), which is backing Johnson, a teacher and former CTU organizer, in the mayoral race. In total, all of the swap deals initiated by the school district — not just under Vallas’s watch — have cost the city’s schoolchildren $508 million, said Bhatti at ACRE.

When Vallas was the superintendent of the School District of Philadelphia from 2002 until 2007, Vallas made $691 million in swap deals, with the total cost to the school district being $162 million, the ACRE report found.

Jack Wagner, a former auditor general of Pennsylvania who routinely audited swap deals, told us that the swaps were too risky and that they should be banned.

“With concern in the banking system again, there is greater potential that certain entities that are involved in interest rate swaps could be subjected to losses,” Wagner said. “The big issue there is they’re unpredictable. And unpredictable financial sources should not be part of public money because obviously you are gambling with public money. And it’s very difficult to understand swaps, let alone follow them.”

Those concerns were echoed by Joe Fichera, a former Wall Street executive who has studied interest-rate swaps.

“Most municipalities don’t have the in-house expertise to evaluate swaps, so they have a swap advisor who only gets paid if a deal gets done,” he noted.

“You’re taking on multiple risks that you may not be able to manage,” Fichera continued. “The unwinding of swaps creates enormous payments that you have to fund, which shows the kinds of risks you have. The structure is built for the bank, not the government, because the banks are smarter.”

Vallas has received $5,000 in campaign cash from Allan Muchin, whose firm Katten Muchin did legal work on some of the capital appreciation bonds, as well as $5,000 from Paul Crimmins, a partner at Mayer Brown, which also did legal work on the bonds.

Additionally, Vallas has received $1,000 from an executive at the Royal Bank of Canada, the bank that did the Chicago Public Schools swap deal which emerged from the variable-rate debt issuance overseen by Vallas.

“The absurdly complicated deals that were so ruinous for Chicago’s and Philadelphia’s public schools were the emperor’s new clothes of public finance,” said former Democratic representative Brad Miller of North Carolina, a critic of Wall Street municipal finance deals. “Vallas thought he was in the small circle of sophisticates who understood the deals and the emperor’s new clothes were beautiful. When the deals went to hell, the Wall Street banks told everybody that the deals were great but they just got unlucky, and Vallas believed that too.”

You can subscribe to David Sirota’s investigative journalism project, the Lever, here.

Peter Hitchens Is Wrong. The Nazis Weren’t “Left-Wing.”

Conservative commentator Peter Hitchens thinks the Nazis were leftists. His case doesn’t even begin to add up.

Members of the Nazi SA marching in Nuremberg, Germany, September 1934. (FPG / Archive Photos / Getty Images)

In a column earlier this month for the Daily Mail, conservative commentator Peter Hitchens lamented that “no one seems to know” that the Nazis were “very left-wing.” He cites evidence like the high taxes the German middle class had to pay to support the war effort and the fact that the Nazis and the Soviets held an “amicable prisoner swap” during their short-lived pact in 1939.

None of this comes within ten thousand miles of establishing his conclusion. It’s worth spelling out why not, given that Hitchens is arguing for a conclusion common on the Right. At least he’s trying to make a historical case, instead of replying on the usual semantic argument that the Nazis called themselves “National Socialists” so they must have been socialists. (To see what’s wrong with that one, ask yourself whether the German Democratic Republic was a democracy.)

The Nazis imposed strictly socially conservative values on German society. Under their rule, workers who tried to organize for better conditions on the job were brutally repressed while politically connected capitalists grew fabulously wealthy from state contracts. And the German left was exterminated en masse.

None of that means that mainstream conservatives are Nazis. But it does make it absurd to deny that Adolf Hitler belonged to the extreme right.

The History Hitchens Includes

A column announcing that “the Nazis were leftists, actually” is the kind of thing I’d expect from Ben Shapiro or Charlie Kirk, not Peter Hitchens. However alien I might find his deeply conservative worldview — Hitchens, the brother of former leftist Christopher, thinks atheism breeds immorality and worries about the dangers of legal cannabis — I expect someone as smart as him to do better than that.

But here’s a complete list of the facts he uses to bolster his case:

According to Julia Boyd’s book Travelers in the Third Reich, many affluent German professionals you’d expect to enthusiastically support a right-wing government bitterly complained about the Nazis in private conversations.
The Nazis were, “like all bad left-wing causes,” supported by many college students.
Many ex-Communists renounced the KPD (the German Communist Party) and became supporters of the new regime.
Hitler and Joseph Stalin were allies during the period between the 1939 Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact and the 1941 Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union.
When the pact was signed, the two sides held a joint parade and a prisoner swap.
Everyone in pictures from the prisoner swap looks happy.
The Nazis imposed high taxes on the middle class.
The Nazis imposed ideological indoctrination in the schools and encouraged children to turn against dissident — for example, socialist or communist — parents.

…and that’s it.

To state the painfully obvious: plenty of governments universally regarded as right-wing have been harshly criticized by a great many middle-class professionals. And every right-wing dictatorship that’s ever existed has been supported by pro-regime student groups.

The very first line of Martin Niemöller’s famous lamentation about not speaking out against the Nazi regime until it was too late was, “First, they came for the communists. . . .” Under those circumstances, of course many ex-Communists either got swept up in the patriotic hysteria or simply went over to the Nazis out of fear. The existence of such defectors isn’t remarkable. The remarkable part is that many Communists did keep their nerve.

Hitler and Stalin’s brief pact was widely regarded by leftists around the world as a shocking betrayal of socialist principles. If that agreement is evidence of Hitler’s left-wing credentials, surely the fact that Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union were mortal enemies for several years before the reversal is evidence that he wasn’t in fact left-wing. The same could be said of how Hitler used the lull of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact to prepare for an all-out invasion of the Soviet Union — and that the Soviet Union paid a greater sacrifice in lost lives than any of its allies to defeat Hitler and the Nazis.

Of course a government preparing for global war imposed high taxes. Taxes also went up under the wartime government of Winston Churchill in the UK. (Though perhaps Churchill was a closet leftist, too — after all, he also entered an alliance with Stalin in 1941!)

Hitchens apparently thinks governments indoctrinating schoolchildren is inherently left-wing. Historically, the proposition that education should teach students critical thinking skills so they can make up their own minds about controversial issues has found many of its most enthusiastic supporters on the Left. Even so, I could grant Hitchens that imposing ideological indoctrination would be evidence of leftism — if the ideology students were being indoctrinated into was left-wing. But the Nazis’ indoctrination was all about patriotism, nationalism, racial superiority, and conventional gender roles.

The History He Leaves Out

Perhaps knowing that these bits of information don’t add up to much, Hitchens offers up the far more dubious idea that the Nazis were fundamentally hostile to religion — and the outright falsehood that they were hostile to the family.

On religion, as Peter’s late brother, Christopher, liked to point out, there was quite a bit of collaboration between the Nazi regime and both the Catholic Church and major Protestant denominations. Prayers for the Führer were routinely said during church services, and Hitler often appealed to Christian imagery in his speeches. Nazi soldiers had “Gott Mitt Uns” (God With Us) emblazoned on their belt buckles.

It’s true the Nazis feared both Catholic and major Protestant churches as one of the only alternative centers of power remaining in an increasingly Nazified society, that they often sought to assert greater control over the churches, and that officially sanctioned versions of Christian theology were often Nazified to the point where any standard-issue Christian abroad would see them as heretical. But if a government is “anti-religion” if it engages in a power struggle with church officials and insists on beliefs that Christians elsewhere would regard as heretical, then King Henry VIII, who founded the Church of England, was also “anti-religion.”

And even when we turn from the policies of the Nazi regime to the beliefs of those high-ranking Nazis who preferred “Völkisch” paganism to Christianity, it’s hard to see what this has to do with the Nazis being “very left-wing.” Historically, various socialist and communist governments have taken attitudes toward religion ranging from disastrous attempts to impose atheism to a sensible adherence to the separation between church and state — but I’ve never heard of one that wanted to replace Christianity with the worship of Odin.

Finally, when it comes to the family, Peter Hitchens simply has no case. “Very left-wing” governments have no monopoly on the grotesque tactic of encouraging children to inform on anti-regime parents. And as for the Nazis’ attitude toward family relationships in general, they were so “left-wing” they revived a slogan from the era of Kaiser Wilhelm about the proper role of women — “Kinder, Küche, Kirche” (children, church, kitchen) — and systematically excluded women from public life. Gay people were sent to death camps.

Hitler and Stalin

Any time the Nazis did something that contemporary conservatives generally oppose — like increasing taxes — Hitchens takes this as evidence that they couldn’t have been right-wing. Oddly, he doesn’t apply this methodology in the other direction. The Left cares deeply about racial equality, but he argues that the Nazis’ fanatical embrace of an ideology of racial superiority — and indeed, the Third Reich’s outright extermination of Jewish and Roma people — doesn’t count as evidence that the Nazis weren’t left-wing. But why not?

Hitchens writes that Stalin was also an antisemite and that some of the purges against supposed counterrevolutionaries particularly targeted Jews. In the same spirit, he’s argued in exchanges with historians who objected to his Daily Mail article that the Nazis’ extermination of German Communists doesn’t substantiate the claim that the Nazis were “very left-wing” because Stalin also killed lots of Communists.

He also repeats two standard right-wing attempts to smear socialists more generally as antisemitic — he says that Marx was an antisemite, and he insinuates that leftists who speak out against Israel’s brutal oppression of the Palestinians are antisemitic. I’ve responded to these claims elsewhere. But what about the comparisons between Hitler and Stalin?

One obvious point is that killing Communists who were accused (often falsely) of opposition to Stalin is a far cry from Hitler killing people because they were Communists. The Spanish Inquisition killed many Spanish Christians, but Christianity wasn’t illegal in sixteenth-century Spain.

And a far more important point is that Stalin’s consolidation of power in the Soviet Union represented a conservative turn — at least by the standards of a state that had emerged from a successful socialist revolution. Leon Trotsky’s son, Leon Sedov, vividly summed up what this looked like:

Revolutionary internationalism gives way to the cult of the fatherland in the strictest sense. And the fatherland means, above all, the authorities. Ranks, decorations and titles have been reintroduced. The officer caste headed by the marshals has been reestablished. The old communist workers are pushed into the background; the working class is divided into different layers.

Commenting on this passage, Alex Skopic notes that if anything, Sedov is considerably understating the last point. The revolution had originally promised workers’ control of factories. By the 1930s, Stalin had enacted criminal penalties for “absenteeism.”

Along with autocratic workplaces, the Stalin era witnessed a revival of anti-Jewish prejudice (Stalin himself was a bigot) and the prohibition of abortion and homosexuality, both of which had been legalized in the immediate aftermath of the revolution. Would Peter Hitchens regard this as evidence that there’s nothing conservative about opposition to abortion or same-sex marriage? I seriously doubt it.

Christopher Hitchens’s Judgment

Even after his politics moved right, Christopher Hitchens was too intellectually honest to compare leftists to fascists.

In 2002, his close friend Martin Amis published a book about Stalin called Koba the Dread arguing that Stalin should be condemned just as severely as Hitler and that everyone in the West who supported the Russian Revolution deserved denunciation. Writing in an open letter to Amis published in the Guardian, Christopher Hitchens pointed out that this “attempted syllogism” would suggest that, for example, many of the “hard left” types who worked with Martin Luther King Jr were the moral equivalent of Nazis.

His response to Amis nicely doubles as a response to his brother’s attempt to transfer Hitler from the far right to the far left:

My provisional critique of this ahistorical reasoning would fit into three short italicised sentences. Don’t. Be. Silly.

The Problem With AI Is the Problem With Capitalism

Workers’ fear of new artificial intelligence technology makes sense: that technology has the potential to eliminate their jobs. But if we didn’t live under capitalism, AI could be used to liberate us from drudgery rather than hurl us into poverty.

We shouldn’t have to fear AI. Capitalism leaves us little other choice. (Getty Images)

Lately, I have been experimenting with artificial intelligence image-generating programs. Their power is astonishing. They’re not just good at the technical aspect of creating “art” but appear to be genuinely creative, producing works that not only match the competence of a highly skilled artist but that can be surprising, interesting, and even beautiful.

Of course, everything still depends on the human who is entering the prompt to tell the AI what to do. But nobody who sees these things in action can doubt that we’re entering a very strange new era in which a great deal that could be done by hand will soon be automated.

Many artists are up in arms about the new AI programs — and with good reason. Some are furious that their works have been used as training data without their permission. Others fear that corporate clients will simply turn to machines to do the work that used to be done by human hands. AI is causing the cost of image generation to plummet. In a capitalist economy, where everyone depends for survival on the value of their labor in the marketplace, a massive drop in the value of a skill will cause widespread suffering.

Art is far from the only domain about to be transformed by generative AI. Paralegals, programmers, market researchers, customer-service agents, financial analysts, and many other professions are at risk of seeing much of their work automated in the near future. OpenAI’s hugely successful ChatGPT not only writes bad jokes and slightly better poetry but is even helping to write published research papers. The models are only getting better, too. The newly released GPT4 is already being used to write whole books.

The powers of this new technology are frightening. Scammers are already using the ability to generate realistic “deepfakes” to fool people into thinking their relatives are asking them for money. Credible-looking misinformation can now be produced at lightning speed, an especially unfortunate development at a time when we lack trusted media institutions.

The problem is that new generative AI is being introduced into a capitalist society that is ill-equipped to handle it.

While Noam Chomsky, Gary Marcus, Erik J. Larson, and others have produced convincing arguments that the fear of artificial “superintelligence” coming in the near term is overstated, there are all kinds of ways in which the technology as it already exists can wreak havoc on society.

People are right to be terrified of the disruptions that AI might cause within our lifetimes. But when we think about what those disruptions actually are, it’s clear that the main problem is not actually the development of the technology itself. Introduced under a different economic and political system, few of the risks would be so grave.

The problem is that new generative AI is being introduced into a capitalist society that is ill-equipped to handle it.

Artists, for example, are mostly not afraid of AI because they fear having a machine be better at art. Chess players didn’t stop playing chess when the computer program Deep Blue beat grandmaster Garry Kasparov. And if art is made for pleasure and self-expression, it doesn’t matter what anyone else can do.

The problem is that, in our world, artists have to make a living through their art by selling it, and so they have to think about its market value. We’re introducing a technology that can utterly wreck people’s livelihoods, and in a free-market economic system, if your skills decline in value, you’re screwed.

We should be excited if legal documents can be written by a computer. Who wants to spend all day writing legal documents?

It’s interesting that we talk about jobs being “at risk” of being automated. Under a socialist economic system, automating many jobs would be a good thing: another step down the road to a world in which robots do the hard work and everyone enjoys abundance. We should be able to be excited if legal documents can be written by a computer. Who wants to spend all day writing legal documents? But we can’t be excited about it, because we live under capitalism, and we know that if paralegal work is automated, that’s over three hundred thousand people who face the prospect of trying to find work knowing their years of experience and training are economically useless.

Luddism is a rational approach to automation in a capitalist society. If machines threaten your job, fight the machines. Even a reactionary like Tucker Carlson has said that politicians should intervene to stop automation, for example, by banning self-driving trucks, because having millions of people thrown out of work would cause too much social disruption. But that solution is absurd: Why would we have people do needless labor that could be done by robots? Truck drivers have their health destroyed and don’t get to see their families for long stretches of time. Even when a machine could do the hard work instead, we’re going to make people do it?

We can expand our imagination far further than Carlson’s. What if finding out that your job could be automated was a thrill? What if it meant that a worker could be paid while the robot did the work? How about this: once the job that you train for is automated, you get an automation pension and get to relax for the rest of your life. Everyone will be praying their job is next on the list to go.

How about this: once your job is automated, you get an automation pension and get to relax for the rest of your life. Everyone will be praying their job is next.

We shouldn’t have to fear AI. Frankly, I’d love it if a machine could edit magazine articles for me and I could sit on the beach. But I’m afraid of it, because I make a living editing magazine articles and need to keep a roof over my head. The same is true of everyone who works for a living in the present economic system. They have to be terrified by automation, because the value of labor matters a lot, and huge fluctuations in its value put all of one’s hopes and dreams in peril.

Most of the other problems AI could cause really boil down to problems of the way power and wealth are apportioned in our existing society. Because the world is organized into militarized nation-states, we have to worry that AI technology will be used in terrifying new superweapons. Because we let scams and fraud flourish in our Wild West economy, we will see a lot of people get rich using AI to prey on hapless consumers. The profit motive is already socially destructive, but AI will make it much worse, because it will allow companies to figure out how to more efficiently trick and exploit people. The new technologies are being developed by private corporations that have no incentive to ensure that a benefit to them is a benefit to all.

We need to be clear on the source of the problems with AI. They are real and will accelerate the crisis that socialists are devoted to helping humanity solve. But the problem is not technology itself. Technology should be a tool for liberation. Unless we transform the economic system, however, it will be a tool for ever greater exploitation and predation.

UK to Send Nuclear Weapon to Zelenskyy Regime

All Global Research articles can be read in 51 languages by activating the Translate This Article button below the author’s name.

To receive Global Research’s Daily Newsletter (selected articles), click here.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter and subscribe …

The post UK to Send Nuclear Weapon to Zelenskyy Regime appeared first on Global Research.

‘Conflict of interest’: Supreme Court says Netanyahu violated ruling with statement on judicial reform

“For our people, and for our country I will do everything to reach a solution,” the prime minister stated.

By World Israel News Staff

Attorney general Gali Baharav-Miara warned Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Friday that he has violated the Supreme Court’s ruling, which barred him from direct involvement in his government’s plans for a judicial overhaul, citing a “conflict of interest.”

Addressing the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations last month at Jerusalem’s Inbal hotel, the prime minister said he was given a gag order and could not elaborate on the topic of judicial reform.

“I’m not making this up. I’ve been given a gag order. After all, who am I? I’m just the Prime Minister of Israel. What have I got to say about this thing that is gripping  the nation? It is patently ridiculous,” he said.

On Thursday evening, however, Netanyahu spoke up. In a televised statement, he said that he had no plans to stop the judicial reform, beginning with the passage of a bill to reform the process of appointing judges.

“I’m taking the reins,” Netanyahu said, referring to the change in the law on removing a prime minister. Until now, his “hands were tied” over a conflict of interest, he said.

He went on to warn that the real danger to democracy was “an all-powerful court” and that stripping the attorney general of the power to remove him from office was necessary to clear the way for him to participate in the negotiations on the judicial overhaul, notwithstanding her instructions.

“The supporters of the reform are outraged that the balance between the authorities has been violated over the past decades. The court unjustifiably interfered with security considerations in the fight against terrorism, raising difficulties with the government’s policy,” he said.

“For our people, and for our country I will do everything to reach a solution,” he vowed.

Baharav-Miara blasted the premier in a letter sent to him.

“In your address that you made last night you discussed the initiatives relating to the judiciary, in particular the makeup of the judicial appointments committee, and you announced that you will be getting directly involved in these initiatives,” wrote Baharav-Miara.

“In so doing, you violated a Supreme Court ruling, according to which you, as a prime minister under criminal indictment, must not take actions which could raise reasonable fears of a conflict of interest between your personal interests related to your criminal proceedings and the interests related to your position as prime minister.”

The post ‘Conflict of interest’: Supreme Court says Netanyahu violated ruling with statement on judicial reform appeared first on World Israel News.

The EU’s Green Deal Industrial Plan Is a Windfall for Corporations

Responding to the Inflation Reduction Act, the EU has unveiled its own green industrial plan. It has little to do with real decarbonization — but hands public money to big business, fueling a global race among “clean-tech” oligopolies.

Rainer Hopp, foreman in the vehicle final inspection department at the Transparent Factory, demonstrates the final inspection of the car during a photo session on the occasion of the digital world premiere of the electric model of the Volkswagen ID.3. (Robert Michael / picture alliance via Getty Images)

A “man on the moon moment.” Speaking back in 2019, European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen used bold language to announce plans to make Europe the first carbon-neutral continent. Yet the Green Deal has turned out to be more of a “technocrats in Brussels moment” — and a fundamentally flawed one at that. Little fresh money was offered, and there was a strong bias toward the private and financial sector, with public funds directed to making projects profitable for investors. With only a slim budget to compensate for the impacts of decarbonization in fossil fuel—reliant regions, it was never going to usher into a just green transition.

Now, more than three years later, Von der Leyen has followed up on the Green Deal with the so-called “Green Deal Industrial Plan” (GDIP). Ostensibly, it’s meant to secure Europe a lead in a new “net-zero industrial age” by maximizing investment in the continent’s clean-tech manufacturing. If anyone still harbored hopes about the European Union developing a substantial green industrial policy, this plan — tellingly announced at the recent World Economic Forum in Davos — has definitively laid them to rest.

The EU’s plan is a direct reaction to the United States’ Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), a bill approving $370 billion in federal investments to build up the American clean-energy economy. Most of the money comes as tax credits for corporations, but grants and loans are also included. EU member states — already anxious about China’s lead in important parts of industrial sectors crucial for a low-carbon economy — see the IRA as a threat to the competitiveness of European industry. The latter are both upset at the IRA and being lured to move to the other side of the Atlantic to avoid high energy prices in Europe and benefit from US tax credits.

With growing economic woes in Europe — from disrupted supply chains in the aftermath of the pandemic to the energy crisis that came with the war in Ukraine — the US initiative has pushed Brussels to act. EU authorities are now preparing what they see as the right conditions for a mass rollout of subsidies in the name of improving European clean-tech industry investments, decarbonizing industry, and accelerating “green growth.”

To this end, the European Commission’s new Net-Zero Industry Act proposal — one of the key pillars of the GDIP — aims to ease the permit-granting process now slowing down advancement of big clean-tech projects. The other pillars include faster access to funding, enhancing of skills (including a proposal for “Net-Zero Industry Academies”), and trade openness to develop new export markets for European green industry on the one hand and to secure access to raw materials on the other.

For now there’s a lack of fresh EU money on the table. So the commission is relying on facilitating easier and faster flows of state aid, from individual member states, to finance the GDIP. Normally, such aid — considered to be any state resources flowing to corporations in the form of grants, tax breaks, guarantees, or governmental shareholding — is limited by the bloc’s rules on competition within the internal market.

With only a slim budget to compensate for the impacts of decarbonization in fossil fuel–reliant regions, Europe’s Green Deal was never going to usher into a just green transition responding to social needs.

On top of that, governments can tap into already existing investment channels (such as InvestEU, REPowerEU, and the Innovation Funds). Proposals for an entirely new fund stumble over the disagreements between member states and an already overstretched EU budget. Heads of European banks and institutions are also urging the creation of a “Capital Markets Union” to unlock access to larger private finance for European businesses through a European bond market. Here the EU is clearly lagging behind the US — bank loans are currently the main source of corporate borrowing as opposed to bond markets, while the opposite is true in the US.

The GDIP claims that “the race to net-zero can be good for the planet and for business.” In reality, it can only deliver bad news for Europe’s decarbonization targets. It props up already huge corporate profits with public budgets: there will be a steady supply of carrots but without any sticks. And hungry to sustain hefty profits, big companies that are already benefiting from record state aid for hydrogen — such as Iberdrola, Shell, and Enel — still demand the aid top-up. So do industries feeling high energy prices as well as pressure to decarbonize and go green in time to get an early advantage in the global market. This includes corporate giants like multinational steel producer ArcelorMittal, and German chemicals manufacturer BASF who — with the rest of the European Chemical Industry Council — called for the EU to learn the lesson from the IRA’s tax breaks and let them have more state aid.

In short, the GDIP is a top-down policy of corporate handouts, instead of one based on a collective debate about social and ecological needs that could determine Europe’s strategic industrial interests.

Clean-Tech Oligopolies

The GDIP’s most likely outcome is a monopolized renewables market and an accelerated clean-tech oligopoly race. The plan is centered on products like batteries, solar, windmills, biofuels, and hydrogen or carbon capture, and storage technologies that are inefficient, costly, unrealistic at scale, and causing damaging social and environmental impacts, but which work well for increasing the profits of large corporations. And it is the biggest energy sector companies, including fossil fuel producers — the top five having made record profits of $195 billion in 2022 — that will keep demanding governments hand out state aid to scale up the hydrogen market and carbon capture, while backtracking on their already shabby renewables commitments.

The Green Deal Industrial Policy is a top-down approach based on corporate handouts, not one based on a collective debate about social and ecological needs.

The GDIP fails to come up with a plan for what Europe actually needs for a just transition — green industrial-policy planning that defines essential industrial sectors for decarbonization. What it proposes is financing the same kind of centralized, unsustainable, and market-sensitive energy system that is serving the interests of the corporate few rather than the majority of society. The amounts of energy and water needed for transport and production of green hydrogen (and those are only one of many problems) clearly make it an unviable solution.

Moreover, hydrogen is estimated to be more costly than fossil fuels even in the long run, which means that a fixed flow of public funds will be required to sustain its competitiveness. Public finance should not be feeding an expansion and retrofitting of gas infrastructure well beyond a limited number of the “hard-to-abate sectors” just to save the corporate giants’ investments.

Other European plans like the Hydrogen Strategy 2030 or REPowerEU suggest that investment outside the EU can deal with this inconvenience and make up for limited domestic hydrogen production capacity. The GDIP condenses this agenda of expanding the market for consumers of European clean tech in exchange for cheap hydrogen in the future — regardless of the negative socioeconomic impacts this might have locally. Apart from Africa’s hydrogen potential, another case in point is the EU’s new Strategic Partnership on Biomethane, Hydrogen and Other Synthetic Gases with Ukraine announced in early February 2023. Despite the destructive war over the year since Russia’s invasion and the obvious need to address local (and renewable) energy needs during Ukraine’s reconstruction, Europe sees an opportunity to secure hydrogen imports to the EU.

EVs for Whom?

Electric vehicles (EVs) — as well as batteries and charging stations — also play a central role in the GDIP. Unsurprisingly, socially just schemes benefiting the majority — like green public transport and publicly financed shared mobility — are irrelevant to the plan, despite the clear positive effects resulting from a shift from private to shared ownership.

Indeed, the shift toward electric vehicles is also becoming a social question. In both the EU and the United States, demand for cars is in decline. According to the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association, in 2023 sales are unlikely to match the pre-pandemic levels. Now leading car manufacturers are pledging to shift production to EVs only (Fiat from 2027, Mercedes from 2030, and Volkswagen from 2033) by targeting high-income households. Their lower-income counterparts, reliant on the cheaper secondhand car market, are left out.

Socially just schemes benefiting the majority — like green public transport and publicly financed shared mobility — are irrelevant to the Green Deal Industrial Plan.

Subsidies such as the IRA’s consumer tax credits for EV purchases try to address this issue. But a similar German subsidies scheme has been criticized for leaving poorer households behind, leaving high earners alone to benefit. Indeed, a public subsidies scheme does not guarantee a sustainable solution — it can create a volatile system of private ownership dependent on public financing. This was illustrated by a 13.2 percent drop in EV sales in Germany after the government halved subsidies — also leading to a 3.5 percent increase in sales of new petrol vehicles. The turn to EVs seems to work above all for the well-off — and for satisfying the automotive industry’s hunger for profits with a constant flow of state aid.

This push for EVs is driven by the automotive industry’s desire to slowly “green” the status quo of its business model on the back of the public purse. While carmakers can already afford to make cleaner cars with existing technology, they would rather lobby against emissions standards — which, they insist, would reduce their investments in EVs — and demand more public funds. For instance, Volkswagen’s profits reached €22.5 billion in 2022, up 13 percent from the year before. Yet the German carmaker has been squeezing Eastern European governments for state aid to support the construction of battery gigafactories. The entire project is now on hold as Volkswagen waits to assess the benefits offered by the EU’s answer to the IRA. But in the Czech Republic, a proposed gigafactory soon met with protests over its negative impact on the environment, local jobs, and the economy.

Replacing petrol cars with EV in the hands of the same few corporate giants — ones reliant on the Eastern European periphery for lower production costs — without changing the fundamental structure of individualized transportation doesn’t do much for a just green transition. Public money would be better spent directly investing in public transport. In many countries, the price of a train ticket today exceeds the cost of a two-person car ride on some routes. Last summer, a three-month experiment in Germany in which monthly tickets for all local and regional public transportation cost just €9 demonstrated the appeal of affordable public infrastructure, in particular for lower-income groups. But the resulting overcrowding of trains also pointed to the shortfall in public investment to expand routes, frequency, and capacity.

Completely missing from the GDIP is any consideration of the implications of the extractivism that Europe’s green transition presupposes. Global demand for lithium — an essential component of EV batteries — is expected to rise forty times over by 2040. The race to secure raw minerals like lithium risks severe environmental damage, land grabs, depletion of water resources, deepening inequalities, and more emissions. The Critical Raw Materials Act — a part of the GDIP — sets targets to increase domestic mining projects. But given public opposition (ironically acknowledged in the legislative proposal), it relies on securing raw minerals supply outside the EU, externalizing the ecological and social costs of Europe’s “green growth” to the Global South.

De-Risking Without Conditions

The GDIP offers no democratic revamp of industrial policy able to meet societal needs like quality jobs, public transport and services, and access to affordable renewable energy. At its heart is the de-risking of big private businesses’ investments and leveraging private finance to deliver decarbonization.

A turn to electric vehicles seems to work for the well-off — and for satisfying the automotive industry’s hunger for profits with a constant flow of state aid.

Doubts about the commission’s ability to leverage billions were already raised by the European Court of Auditors in 2015, in relation to the commission’s €315-billion Juncker Plan. It stressed that EU’s leveraging ambitions based on public guarantees might be just “hopes and expectations.” Now its successor, InvestEU — which is supposed to help finance the Green Deal and GDIP — already shows signs of a questionable uptake. Economist Daniela Gabor has raised doubts over the ability of de-risking to deliver decarbonization in time and at the necessary scale.

The de-risking approach effectively means that what gets financed is not determined based on a collective debate about what kind of economy and industry is needed for a genuinely just transition, but by what yields the highest and quickest return on investment.

It’s not surprising that shareholders afraid of lower short-term profits — in itself harmful to healthy industries — want free state handouts to develop clean technologies. But public finance should help sustainable, effective, and socially just renewable energy projects that require patient capital and actually need concessional funding. Yet GDIP is silent on conditionality that would help weed out free riders and prevent “green” state aid from going to polluting corporations that can already fund themselves or easily access private finance.

For instance, Iberdrola’s CEO José Galán was paid €13.2 million in 2021 (the same year the Spanish High Court launched an investigation into his involvement in alleged cases of bribery, privacy breach, and fraud). Galán’s salary was 171 times the average of Iberdrola’s employees — which fell by 1.3 percent. Now in 2023, Iberdrola expects net profit to go up by 8–10 percent and plans to keep paying out hefty dividends. Yet this year the European Investment Bank has signed off on a €150-million concessional loan to Iberdrola for renewable energy plants in Italy, following up on at least €650 million in 2021 and a further €550 million in 2022. Companies like Iberdrola that demand more state aid and pay out massive dividends to shareholders are going to be the real beneficiaries of the GDIP.

European governments are desperately looking for ways to boost the bloc’s global industrial competitiveness in the net-zero industrial age. But so far, the proposed vision of the new EU clean-tech oligopoly — centered on false solutions like green hydrogen at scale, working well for increasing the profits of large corporations — falls entirely short of considering who and what the “net-zero” clean-tech race is good for.

The GDIP doesn’t deal with the bigger issues European industry is facing. The most obvious are reinvestment requirements and limits on buybacks and dividend payouts — the sticks so despised by the corporations begging for state-funded carrots. But the deeper problem is the lack of a comprehensive industrial rethink, able to identify nonessential and polluting economic activity, and which is based on a collectively decided public investment strategy centered on the just transition.

Technocratic attempts to reconcile conflicting interests of “good for the planet” and “good for business” are failing. Democratic participation and fair multilateral cooperation are needed if the green transition is to surpass the zero-sum corporate game it is now.

This work has been made possible by the support of the Puffin Foundation.

Trump arrested? Putin jailed? Fake AI images spread online

Misinformation experts warn the images are harbingers of a new reality: waves of fake photos and videos flooding social media.

By Associated Press

Former President Donald Trump getting gang-tackled by riot-gear-clad New York City police officers. Russian President Vladimir Putin in prison grays behind the bars of a dimly lit concrete cell.

The highly detailed, sensational images have inundated Twitter and other platforms in recent days, amid news that Trump faces possible criminal charges and the International Criminal Court has issued an arrest warrant for Putin.

But neither visual is remotely real. The images — and scores of variations littering social media — were produced using increasingly sophisticated and widely accessible image generators powered by artificial intelligence.

Misinformation experts warn the images are harbingers of a new reality: waves of fake photos and videos flooding social media after major news events and further muddying fact and fiction at crucial times for society.

“It does add noise during crisis events. It also increases the cynicism level,” said Jevin West, a professor at the University of Washington in Seattle who focuses on the spread of misinformation. “You start to lose trust in the system and the information that you are getting.”

While the ability to manipulate photos and create fake images isn’t new, AI image generator tools by Midjourney, DALL-E and others are easier to use. They can quickly generate realistic images — complete with detailed backgrounds — on a mass scale with little more than a simple text prompt from users.

Some of the recent images have been driven by this month’s release of a new version of Midjourney’s text-to-image synthesis model, which can, among other things, now produce convincing images mimicking the style of news agency photos.

In one widely-circulating Twitter thread, Eliot Higgins, founder of Bellingcat, a Netherlands-based investigative journalism collective, used the latest version of the tool to conjure up scores of dramatic images of Trump’s fictional arrest.

The visuals, which have been shared and liked tens of thousands of times, showed a crowd of uniformed officers grabbing the Republican billionaire and violently pulling him down onto the pavement.

Higgins, who was also behind a set of images of Putin being arrested, put on trial and then imprisoned, says he posted the images with no ill intent. He even stated clearly in his Twitter thread that the images were AI-generated.

Still, the images were enough to get him locked out of the Midjourney server, according to Higgins. The San Francisco-based independent research lab didn’t respond to emails seeking comment.

“The Trump arrest image was really just casually showing both how good and bad Midjourney was at rendering real scenes,” Higgins wrote in an email. “The images started to form a sort of narrative as I plugged in prompts to Midjourney, so I strung them along into a narrative, and decided to finish off the story.”

He pointed out the images are far from perfect: in some, Trump is seen, oddly, wearing a police utility belt. In others, faces and hands are clearly distorted.

But it’s not enough that users like Higgins clearly state in their posts that the images are AI-generated and solely for entertainment, says Shirin Anlen, media technologist at Witness, a New York-based human rights organization that focuses on visual evidence.

Too often, the visuals are quickly reshared by others without that crucial context, she said. Indeed, an Instagram post sharing some of Higgins’ images of Trump as if they were genuine garnered more than 79,000 likes.

“You’re just seeing an image, and once you see something, you cannot unsee it,” Anlen said.

In another recent example, social media users shared a synthetic image supposedly capturing Putin kneeling and kissing the hand of Chinese leader Xi Jinping. The image, which circulated as the Russian president welcomed Xi to the Kremlin this week, quickly became a crude meme.

It’s not clear who created the image or what tool they used, but some clues gave the forgery away. The heads and shoes of the two leaders were slightly distorted, for example, and the room’s interior didn’t match the room where the actual meeting took place.

Deepfakes could start involving ordinary people

With synthetic images becoming increasingly difficult to discern from the real thing, the best way to combat visual misinformation is better public awareness and education, experts say.

“It’s just becoming so easy and it’s so cheap to make these images that we should do whatever we can to make the public aware of how good this technology has gotten,” West said.

Higgins suggests social media companies could focus on developing technology to detect AI-generated images and integrate that into their platforms.

Twitter has a policy banning “synthetic, manipulated, or out-of-context media” with the potential to deceive or harm. Annotations from Community Notes, Twitter’s crowd-sourced fact checking project, were attached to some tweets to include the context that the Trump images were AI-generated.

When reached for comment Thursday, the company emailed back only an automated response.

Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, declined to comment. Some of the fabricated Trump images were labeled as either “false” or “missing context” through its third-party fact-checking program, of which the AP is a participant.

Arthur Holland Michel, a fellow at the Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs in New York who is focused on emerging technologies, said he worries the world isn’t ready for the impending deluge.

He wonders how deepfakes involving ordinary people — harmful fake pictures of an ex-partner or a colleague, for example — will be regulated.

“From a policy perspective, I’m not sure we’re prepared to deal with this scale of disinformation at every level of society,” Michel wrote in an email. “My sense is that it’s going to take an as-yet-unimagined technical breakthrough to definitively put a stop to this.”

The post Trump arrested? Putin jailed? Fake AI images spread online appeared first on World Israel News.